Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rent and bills. Doesn't seem fair. AIBU?

444 replies

Perfectworld · 18/06/2022 22:17

How would you split bills / rent in this scenario?

Both of us have 1x child each from previous relationships, both late 30s. Fiancé earns £120k, I earn £28k. I currently get child benefit and UC top up, which will cease when we move in together. He has suggested we pay half the rent each, plus he covers all joint utility bills, meaning I still have all non 'joint' bills e.g. my mobile phone, my car payment. Due to this, I will probably be left with less that I currently have spare each month (which is already very little). The rent I pay will be the same as I pay currently, due to needing a bigger house to support both of our DC. I will be worse off some months, and others about the same financially because I cannot claim UC or child benefit. On more expensive months, for instance, the months when DC's school dinner fee is due, I will be worse off than I am now. He will be saving approx £2k per month in this scenario, which he has said will be put towards joint savings.

What do you think is reasonable for each person, how would you split finances?

OP posts:
FlippityFlapperty · 19/06/2022 11:52

Ps also agree with you about his debt - he shouldn’t be saving the left over thousands into a ‘shared savings’ pot - he should be clearing all that debt. Savings obviously don’t exist if he has debt! Everything saved is already owed elsewhere and probably incurring interest so there’s no logic to him not tackling the debt first before saving. Sounds like you are quite a lot more realistic about finances than he is from what you say. You also sound smart and practical so listen to your gut.

FlippityFlapperty · 19/06/2022 11:44

This was identical to our finances when I met my DH. We were engaged and living together, but no kids. We worked out the cost of all the bills and then split the payments 80:20 so we paid a proportion equal to our incomes. He would never have wanted me to have been worse off or struggling while he had thousands and thousands spare, and nor should your partner. It’s very selfish. Can understand him wanting to retain some while you aren’t married, but not to this ridiculous extent that you are more skint living with him than you would be living singly. Why on earth would you agree to be worse off for pooling your resources and him be the only one to benefit?

I’d worry that this is the start of an ‘I’m the main wage earner so I get to control the money’ attitude which might spill over when you get married. It can happen so fast. He won’t see it as control, but it will be. The messages will be that you earn less so your job is less important, so you’ll do all the chores to help support him while he brings in the money, and he’ll get the final say on all purchases as it’s his money. It won’t be equal. It won’t be shared family money. Then you’ll find yourself running purchases past him, having your spending scrutinised and that will be the moment you’ll be utterly reliant on him.

So don’t let that happen!

Luxembourgmama · 19/06/2022 11:37

Fair would be paying the same % of your salary each into a common account to cover everything. So you 30% of £28k and him 30% of his salary

Nothappyatwork · 19/06/2022 11:34

@5128gap well currently the taxpayer is subsidising it via universal credits so it’s not unusual or unreasonable to ask that ends the question is who’s picking up the slack ?

slowcookerforone · 19/06/2022 11:31

This guy doesn't sound like he loves you or your child and he certainly doesn't give a shit about you.

I would definitely not move in with him, he's got his agenda and it's definitely not with you in mind.

I just didn't think anyone who cared about you would try and set you up for financial hardship while they used you to save money.

I suspect he sees you as the gravy train.

5128gap · 19/06/2022 11:26

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/06/2022 10:13

Red flag

I'd be asking him why he expects you to pay a far greater percentage than he does.

Because that's how paying for things works? No other aspect of life is costed as a percentage of income, and is cheaper for you if your income is lower, so why should the living costs of someone with a high earning partner?
This is not a young couple starting out together, supporting and helping to build each others success. This is two established adults with their own means and liabilities. If the wealthier is happy to subsidise the other, fair enough, but there is no justifiable reason to expect it.

Fulbe · 19/06/2022 11:12

Given that you're engaged and about to move in together, I would think it's reasonable to start thinking of your finances as joint. You need a plan for him to pay off his debt, which should be achievable within 1 year if he can save 2k per month. If it's a difference of £100 per month, then negotiate the rent payments so you're not worse off.

By the way, how much does he spend if he only has 2k spare every month from a salary that size? Perhaps he needs to cut back on his spending a bit otherwise you could find yourself in hot water once your assets are joined when you're married. I found Alvin Hall's What not to spend was a useful book.

CaptSkippy · 19/06/2022 11:11

Testina · 19/06/2022 10:53

@CaptSkippy “A partnership should be a partnership, meaning you pool your money and pay the household expenses from that. After what's left you each get 50/50 off of that.”

So in my case, I should work a high pressure job that I made sacrifices for, for years, but when it comes to choosing to give my child a house deposit (not obligatory but not unusual to want to) I have given away my money to my second husband?

I put some numbers behind thar earlier… I’ve got £3000 after bills, him £1200.

So if I’m to have £2100 not £3000, then £900 a month for 10 years is £108K.

He’s £400 a month better off living with me anyway. So he’s already £48K up over 10 years. That’s not all directly money I have earned and am paying out “for him” - some of it is forgoing a contribution as I earn more. A good example is council tax. I’m paying £200 when without him it would be £150. So he directly costs me £50. But I’m actually saving him £150 as he’s paying nothing, and I’m “giving up” the possibility of getting a £100 equal share from him.

So is it only a partnership if in 10 years time he has “made” £48K from the situation and not £108K? And I’ve lost the chance to give my child a house deposit?

I’m using language like “costing me” to illustrate clearly the financial impact. To be clear: that is not how either of us feel.

It is how I’d feel if I was £108K down over 10 years though 🤷🏻‍♀️

Is your partner's job not "high pressure"? Does he just laze around the hours he in not working?

Testina · 19/06/2022 11:02

“I think if we are not at the stage where we can be equal partners in love and money, I'd rather just stay as we are now.“

Forget love and money… the first issue is to be equal partners in communication!

Testina · 19/06/2022 10:53

@CaptSkippy “A partnership should be a partnership, meaning you pool your money and pay the household expenses from that. After what's left you each get 50/50 off of that.”

So in my case, I should work a high pressure job that I made sacrifices for, for years, but when it comes to choosing to give my child a house deposit (not obligatory but not unusual to want to) I have given away my money to my second husband?

I put some numbers behind thar earlier… I’ve got £3000 after bills, him £1200.

So if I’m to have £2100 not £3000, then £900 a month for 10 years is £108K.

He’s £400 a month better off living with me anyway. So he’s already £48K up over 10 years. That’s not all directly money I have earned and am paying out “for him” - some of it is forgoing a contribution as I earn more. A good example is council tax. I’m paying £200 when without him it would be £150. So he directly costs me £50. But I’m actually saving him £150 as he’s paying nothing, and I’m “giving up” the possibility of getting a £100 equal share from him.

So is it only a partnership if in 10 years time he has “made” £48K from the situation and not £108K? And I’ve lost the chance to give my child a house deposit?

I’m using language like “costing me” to illustrate clearly the financial impact. To be clear: that is not how either of us feel.

It is how I’d feel if I was £108K down over 10 years though 🤷🏻‍♀️

ConsuelaHammock · 19/06/2022 10:50

Wait until you’re married to move in together? Do you have a date for the wedding? If not why not?

Have an honest conversation about finances. If he genuinely loves you and sees a future together, he won’t want you to feel so anxious about money. Good luck!

Minimalme · 19/06/2022 10:45

Perfectworld · 18/06/2022 22:36

@bigkoalacliphug Approx £25k debt. Previously a homeowner and had spent a lot on costly renovations that weren't recouped in the house sale after he split with ex.

This doesn't stack up-home improvements should be done via savings or through extending the mortgage.

If he really did rack up £25k in personal debt on a joint asset then he is an absolute plonker.

Avoid.

ItWillBeOkHonestly · 19/06/2022 10:34

This doesn't seem fair and to be honest, I would make a bet that 'joint savings' are meaningless if you are not married.

There are other things to consider too. As a higher earner, he's possibly going to want really nice holidays or really nice meals out. Does that have to be 50/50 too?

I think you need to have a proper talk with him and explain you're not looking to financially benefit from being with him but you are also not prepared to be worse off. I think his reaction to this will tell you a lot about him. If he's understanding and immediately looks to compromise, that's a good sign! If he's defensive, angry etc, then this is a sign that you've got bigger problems on your hands. How a person reacts in this scenario will tell you a LOT! Watch his reaction carefully.

CaptSkippy · 19/06/2022 10:33

OP, don't do this. You'll be at his mercy. He'll hold the different in income over your head forever. A partnership should be a partnership, meaning you pool your money and pay the household expenses from that. After what's left you each get 50/50 off of that.

I mean, does he plan on doing 50/50 childcare duties? 50/50 household duties? I am willing to bet he is "far too important" for that. You'll be stuck with it all and paying for the privelege of being his live-in mommy bangmaid, supplementing his income and lifestyle to boot. And he'll expect you to be "grateful" for being "allowed" to live in such a fine house you could never afford on your own.

Nothappyatwork · 19/06/2022 10:23

Catcrazy83 · 19/06/2022 10:19

It was student finance who said the stepdads income meant they couldn’t get maintenance loan, and that the family were required to support the kid, but the step dad wouldn’t pay towards what the kid lost out on because of his income

We are in the same boat ex cannot stand up to new wife who has done the university thing and supported her 2 to get good degrees but apparently the same rules don’t apply when it comes to mine. We don’t even actually want her money, what I want is for him to pay his half of maintenance towards mine so that I don’t have to pay literally nine grand a term to cover all of them.

The youngest is living at home and working at the same time as Uni and he’s actually taking keep money off her. While step mummy keeps all of her pennies to herself.

Eeksteek · 19/06/2022 10:20

@Midlifemusings I can see your point. And obviously, ideally partners would earn a similar amount. But life isn’t like that. I also wouldn’t want to split my money the way I suggested, so I wouldn’t commit to blending a family unless and until I was.

If one child can go to uni and it’s off the table for another, or one adult can swan about treating themselves or the family on a whim and the other can’t, it’s not really a family. There’s an expectation of communal resources, and inequality of wealth could breed enormous resentment . If you aren’t ready to throw in your lot, you aren’t ready to move in together. Which is 100 percent valid and something in wouldn’t consider.

I would possibly agree, on a temporary basis, to ringfence assets or savings previously acquired while you have a trial. But they should be not part of the picture at all for the duration, and everyone’s spending should reflect that. It might even work to keep personal savings previously built up separate for good (I’m thinking of a running away fund! I’d always want one of those!). But going forward, the family income should be, well, for the family, especially with children involved.

Catcrazy83 · 19/06/2022 10:19

@Midlifemusings

Catcrazy83 · 19/06/2022 10:19

It was student finance who said the stepdads income meant they couldn’t get maintenance loan, and that the family were required to support the kid, but the step dad wouldn’t pay towards what the kid lost out on because of his income

Testina · 19/06/2022 10:14

@Nothappyatwork I’m with you. There is every chance that someone on £128K, with no reason to know about UC would have no idea how much UC get on £28K.

I mean - that’s half as much again as NMW. I bet loads of MNers wouldn’t know you can even get UC with that income. I’ve certainly seen posts on here with people saying, “do you really get it at £x?” and the number of times people have to point out it’s an in-work benefit.

This guy might be an arsehole, I’m not ruling it out. But what I see here is someone hoping to get half his money who might be called a cocklodger on another thread, who appears not to have had a proper discussion with him yet.

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/06/2022 10:13

Red flag

I'd be asking him why he expects you to pay a far greater percentage than he does.

britneyisfree · 19/06/2022 10:12

Good for you op. Why does he want you to move in anyway! Selfish imo.

Booklover3 · 19/06/2022 10:10

You need to talk to him about you being financially worse off moving in with him.

I don’t think it should be one pot. You shouldn’t however be out of pocket this significantly. It’s really not fair. Maybe he doesn’t realise how much worse off you will be… I don’t know. You will know though by his reaction when you talk to him.

Testina · 19/06/2022 10:07

This isn’t an arranged marriage to a man you haven’t met before though. You’ve decided to marry him! (although, you didn’t answer what “fiancé” means - plenty of people seem to say that without a wedding in sight…)

The first “family day out” that my second husband and I did - when he was my boyfriend of 9 months - was a theatre trip to London. Not only did I buy all the tickets, when we arrived I pulled out surprise envelopes for the planned “look around the shops”. He had 2 late teens, me 1 primary aged - all got £50. He bought dinner for us all.

I’ve already posted that he doesn’t get half my money. But he knew, long before we married, what my attitude to money and sharing and differences and the children was.

So this “will he buy his kids an ice cream and not mine?” question is odd to me.

I wouldn’t be engaged to someone that I couldn’t already answer that question about 🤷🏻‍♀️

newnamethanks · 19/06/2022 10:06

Is he so wonderful that you're prepared to pay for the privilege of living with him? If you think he's worth the financial loss then may the good lord help you. NEVER put your financial security in the hands of someone else, you're a mother. You may think he's fabulous, he's not. He's a pig for even suggesting such an unfair division of funds. You'd be well advised to take a long hard look at him. One person would benefit from such an arrangement and it wouldn't be you.

Fireflygal · 19/06/2022 10:06

Op, how long have you been together? How old are the children?

The number one reason for conflict in a relationship is money...you are starting out in with financial conflict (you will be definitely feel resentful).

It looks like he has worked out a proposal which feels fair to HIM. If he doesn't have empathy for your situation then it's a red flag. Especially if you believe you are a generous person (selfish people exploit that trait)

Don't make any assumption on his willingness to split household chores, given his attitude to money. It's easy to sleep walk in losing your home!