Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rent and bills. Doesn't seem fair. AIBU?

444 replies

Perfectworld · 18/06/2022 22:17

How would you split bills / rent in this scenario?

Both of us have 1x child each from previous relationships, both late 30s. Fiancé earns £120k, I earn £28k. I currently get child benefit and UC top up, which will cease when we move in together. He has suggested we pay half the rent each, plus he covers all joint utility bills, meaning I still have all non 'joint' bills e.g. my mobile phone, my car payment. Due to this, I will probably be left with less that I currently have spare each month (which is already very little). The rent I pay will be the same as I pay currently, due to needing a bigger house to support both of our DC. I will be worse off some months, and others about the same financially because I cannot claim UC or child benefit. On more expensive months, for instance, the months when DC's school dinner fee is due, I will be worse off than I am now. He will be saving approx £2k per month in this scenario, which he has said will be put towards joint savings.

What do you think is reasonable for each person, how would you split finances?

OP posts:
wellhelloitsme · 19/06/2022 13:14

If he's earning that and saving, why hasn't he paid off his debt?

whowhatwerewhy · 19/06/2022 13:13

So you go to him and say you will be £200 down. He might not realise how much UC you will lose .

wellhelloitsme · 19/06/2022 13:12

@CoffeeDeprivation

He has been able to save thousands. I have over 15k debt. He cannot understand how I got there.

I'm surprised that if he has a decent job he's able to hold down, he's not smart enough to understand that if someone earns much less and has more outgoings proportionally to their salary, they get into debt while the other party can save. Especially when you've presumably explained the following to him:

Food costs have increased over the last 5 years, my salary was reduced during maternity significantly, we have been booking kids on more clubs, there's more uniform more often, in lockdown I paid for takeaways because it was a way of giving me a break and I found the whole year exhausting...

He doesn't sound very nice. Especially if they are joint kids.

He's continued an arrangement that benefits him financially versus putting you into debt.

He could have offered a compromise even if temporary e.g. during mat leave / lockdown.

That's what you do when you're a team.

What a dick.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 19/06/2022 13:03

Put it on a spreadsheet and show him.
The amount you need to save each month needs to be non negotiable

Testina · 19/06/2022 13:01

@Portiasparty “What do you mean she's not worse off yet?”

I mean that she’s not in this situation yet.

They’re talking about moving in together. He’s made a proposal. She hasn’t told him that it leaves her worse off! (at least, she hasn’t said that she has told him that, hasn’t replied to any of the people asking if she has, and has posted nothing about his reaction to her saying that).

No-one on this thread thinks it’s fair for her to be worse off.

But it’s unfair to him, all the people saying how awful he is. Maybe he’s an arsehole. Or maybe she just needs to say, “actually that proposal leaves me £200 worse off” and he’ll say, “well that’s not fair, what should we do instead?”

Mincingfuckdragon · 19/06/2022 12:59

OP, you say: "I think if we are not at the stage where we can be equal partners in love and money, I'd rather just stay as we are now".

You won't be equal partners in money if he won't enthusiastically and voluntarily agree to a one pot arrangement. And he won't - because of he was going to then he'd have done so already.

So stay as you are now.

(If you move in together, it sounds as though you'll have less money and less time for your child, more childcare and housework, more stress and more worry. Seriously, why would you do it when you can avoid all of that by not moving in??).

Portiasparty · 19/06/2022 12:54

Testina · 19/06/2022 12:32

@Portiasparty the reason I keep posting is this, OP’s opening questing:

”How would you split bills / rent in this scenario?”

OP appears to only be considering 2 options - one pot, and his proposal that leaves her worse off.

She actually isn’t in a different situation to me - yet. She’s NOT worse off. She’s just had a proposal from him that leaves him worse off, and 13 pages in still hasn’t answered multiple people asking if she’s even pointed that out to him yet.

She could go for my scenario - that’s why I don’t think it’s irrelevant, and that’s why I’m still on the thread. Hoping it helps her to see that a higher earner not sharing all their money in a second marriage with no shared children doesn’t necessarily mean they’re an arsehole.

Of course she can hold out for one pot and decide he’s not for her - that’s her choice. But there are other proposals for her to consider which might also be fair.

What do you mean she's not worse off yet? We're all talking about the situation the DP has proposed, in which she would be worse off and he would be better off. How would that be fair when he's better off than her anyway?

Fair enough they should be able to talk about it but you banging on about how much you earn (yes we get how successful you are), doesn't really help the Op and reads more like you're justifying it to yourself and everyone on the thread (you haven't just mentioned it once!!!).

And where has she said she wants to share all his money? Other people may have proposed that but my reading of her posts just suggests she doesn't want to be worse off.

KosherDill · 19/06/2022 12:51

greatblueheron · 19/06/2022 12:15

So you will be worse off financially AND doing childcare for him AND doing more of the heavy lifting at home because he works longer hours? And he gets to benefit from all that while you're penalized?

I really think you're putting your DC into a more vulnerable position if your relationship fails and you have stopped saving and have propped him up by being there. No economic cushion will be there for you.

Exactly. The focus needs to be on long-range security for OP and DC, not short term gratification.

This man is willing to gain at your expense and your kids expense. Think about it.

Testina · 19/06/2022 12:48

@Perfectworld you don’t need to give us the breakdown, you need to give it to him.

We believe you! You say you’ll be worse off, we believe you’ll be worse off.

Whether he’s taking the piss or not depends on whether he knows you’ll be worse off.

But you haven’t answered that question!

honeylulu · 19/06/2022 12:45

It's taken quite a few posts but the simple maths emerged in the end. If you go ahead as suggested:

  1. You will be £200 a month worse off and will bear increased domestic labour and childcare duties.
  2. He will be £2000 better off and will gain the benefit of your domestic labour and childcare duties.

If these are the only terms he will agree then of course you can't move in together. That would be insane!

The proportionate contributions need to be adjusted to accommodate the saving and deficit. In short you should EACH end up £900 a month better off.

If his answer is that he doesn't want to share the £2k saving he will make I would not only refuse to move in, I would dump his tightwad arse pronto!

Testina · 19/06/2022 12:32

@Portiasparty the reason I keep posting is this, OP’s opening questing:

”How would you split bills / rent in this scenario?”

OP appears to only be considering 2 options - one pot, and his proposal that leaves her worse off.

She actually isn’t in a different situation to me - yet. She’s NOT worse off. She’s just had a proposal from him that leaves him worse off, and 13 pages in still hasn’t answered multiple people asking if she’s even pointed that out to him yet.

She could go for my scenario - that’s why I don’t think it’s irrelevant, and that’s why I’m still on the thread. Hoping it helps her to see that a higher earner not sharing all their money in a second marriage with no shared children doesn’t necessarily mean they’re an arsehole.

Of course she can hold out for one pot and decide he’s not for her - that’s her choice. But there are other proposals for her to consider which might also be fair.

DamnUserName21 · 19/06/2022 12:31

And what if the relationship doesn't work out after moving in? You'll be scrambling to find somewhere else to live for you and DC on 28, 000 income. Where I live, a lot of places want income to be 2.5-3x the rent!

Put yourself and your child first.

AlarmF1reTestDate · 19/06/2022 12:27

If you don't claim the money for child benefit

You should still claim the child benefit, without the money
This is because, the National Insurance contributions will get paid while you have children. These contributions go towards your state pension & other benefits.

You can look up your individual National Insurance record on www.gov.uk

You can look up your individual state pension forecast on www.gov.uk

Suggest, do not rely on a man for your finances & future. Ensure that you keep an eye on your own finances

CaptSkippy · 19/06/2022 12:22

Testina · 19/06/2022 12:19

“more. I would be expected to do most of the childcare for my DC, a lot more for his too I imagine, and most of the household chores, cleaning, cooking, washing because his job is much longer hours and more demanding so it makes sense that I would do those things”

uh… no.

I’m posting a lot here because I’m the high earner not sharing everything and I don’t think that’s unfair at all.

I’ve literally just posted in answer to someone else that I have longer hours and more pressure.

My husband doesn’t do more cooking and cleaning because of that!! These are our choices.

I mean sure, when I’m working into the evening he’ll call up, “I’ll cook tonight!” and when I go to wash up after he’ll tell me not to. Because it is a loving partnership. But overall? House “stuff” is equal.

All our children are beyond the period of very hands on time consuming care, but when mine was younger I didn’t expect him to pick up my parenting.

So no, it doesn’t “make sense” AT ALL to me that you’re just deciding that you have to do his stuff for him a that he’s perfectly capable of fitting around his job now. Isn’t then that really just you being paid to be his housekeeper? If you “give” you domestic labour and he “gives” you money?

Let him keep his money. Let him keep his domestic labour.

Works for us!

The more I read your posts the more dismayed I get. You say it works for you and I am sure it does for him.

Seems to me you let yourself get taken for a ride.

DamnUserName21 · 19/06/2022 12:21

Look at the long-term picture...as someone posted above..uni costs.
Will he subsidise your child at uni when they can't get a maintenance loan?
OP, you will lose your financial independence as it will become limited whilst his won't.
He will benefit a lot more than you in this. He will also be able to reduce his child maintenance bill just because your child lives with him. (No idea if he will do this or not though!)
You'll likely end up subsidising his ability to pay off his loan and increase his savings.

As a single parent, there is no way in hell I would do this.

Testina · 19/06/2022 12:19

“more. I would be expected to do most of the childcare for my DC, a lot more for his too I imagine, and most of the household chores, cleaning, cooking, washing because his job is much longer hours and more demanding so it makes sense that I would do those things”

uh… no.

I’m posting a lot here because I’m the high earner not sharing everything and I don’t think that’s unfair at all.

I’ve literally just posted in answer to someone else that I have longer hours and more pressure.

My husband doesn’t do more cooking and cleaning because of that!! These are our choices.

I mean sure, when I’m working into the evening he’ll call up, “I’ll cook tonight!” and when I go to wash up after he’ll tell me not to. Because it is a loving partnership. But overall? House “stuff” is equal.

All our children are beyond the period of very hands on time consuming care, but when mine was younger I didn’t expect him to pick up my parenting.

So no, it doesn’t “make sense” AT ALL to me that you’re just deciding that you have to do his stuff for him a that he’s perfectly capable of fitting around his job now. Isn’t then that really just you being paid to be his housekeeper? If you “give” you domestic labour and he “gives” you money?

Let him keep his money. Let him keep his domestic labour.

Works for us!

Perfectworld · 19/06/2022 12:18

And in terms of a breakdown of financials - I would be paying the same rent as I do now, his rent would be halved. He would pay all joint bills, but the benefits I get, totalling around £600 would be gone. My bills which wouldn't be considered personal - council tax, water, gas + electric, equal £400. Leaving me with a deficit each month of around £200 if we moved in.

So I'd be paying the same amount of rent, plus all my personal expenses, but the CB and UC is gone, meaning I am -£200 per month. Does that make sense? I would be able to scrape by being £-200 that amount, but I wouldn't be able to save, and I'd have to be constantly looking ahead to the following months and considering how I am going to afford to do things in the summer holidays, or for new school uniform, or for after school club fees. The £100 I manage to scrape and save each month would be gone. My savings would quickly deplete and I'd not be able to afford holidays and the like at all.

OP posts:
greatblueheron · 19/06/2022 12:15

So you will be worse off financially AND doing childcare for him AND doing more of the heavy lifting at home because he works longer hours? And he gets to benefit from all that while you're penalized?

I really think you're putting your DC into a more vulnerable position if your relationship fails and you have stopped saving and have propped him up by being there. No economic cushion will be there for you.

Portiasparty · 19/06/2022 12:15

Testina · 19/06/2022 10:53

@CaptSkippy “A partnership should be a partnership, meaning you pool your money and pay the household expenses from that. After what's left you each get 50/50 off of that.”

So in my case, I should work a high pressure job that I made sacrifices for, for years, but when it comes to choosing to give my child a house deposit (not obligatory but not unusual to want to) I have given away my money to my second husband?

I put some numbers behind thar earlier… I’ve got £3000 after bills, him £1200.

So if I’m to have £2100 not £3000, then £900 a month for 10 years is £108K.

He’s £400 a month better off living with me anyway. So he’s already £48K up over 10 years. That’s not all directly money I have earned and am paying out “for him” - some of it is forgoing a contribution as I earn more. A good example is council tax. I’m paying £200 when without him it would be £150. So he directly costs me £50. But I’m actually saving him £150 as he’s paying nothing, and I’m “giving up” the possibility of getting a £100 equal share from him.

So is it only a partnership if in 10 years time he has “made” £48K from the situation and not £108K? And I’ve lost the chance to give my child a house deposit?

I’m using language like “costing me” to illustrate clearly the financial impact. To be clear: that is not how either of us feel.

It is how I’d feel if I was £108K down over 10 years though 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don't understand why you keep posting about your situation which isn't the same as the OPs. If the OP was better off by moving in with her partner (like your partner is by living with you), then I don't think anyone would have a problem with it. The issue is that she'll be worse off, when she hasn't got that much anyway* *and her partner will be better off and he doesn't seem to care about that.

My husband earns massively more than me. I don't expect him to give me half his salary. But equally I wouldn't expect him to see me destitute, while he had way more than he could ever spend (I've done all the childcare, and the vast majority of the domestic responsibilities and house maintenance as well). Equally there have been times when he hasn't worked and he's shared my income without quibbling. There are other issues in our relationship but this isn't one of them.

If you could see you partner scrabbling to pay for any kind of social life, clothes, phone bill etc while you had buckets of savings plus could afford all those things, then I'd probably think that we have different views on what constitutes a relationship. But your relationship doesn't sound like that, so is irrelevant to the OP.

CaptSkippy · 19/06/2022 12:13

Testina · 19/06/2022 12:05

“Is your partner's job not "high pressure"? Does he just laze around the hours he in not working“

No, it isn’t. He works in a job that he loves in an industry that is poorly paid. He works for himself. It’s a practical job, there’s nothing to think about after he finishes, nothing to take home. He works 4 days a week. Next year he’s taking a month off to do a bucket list motorcycle trip. Earlier in his working life, he took a full year off to travel. Twice.
He has literally never worked late in his life - even when not self employed. It just isn’t a feature of his industry.

All great choices.

By contrast, I’ve worked really long hours to reach my salary level, and still do sometimes. Not an issue - I love my job! I’ve also worked away from home. I needed a degree to get into it, so I had debt from that. I have a team to manage, which I love, but comes with stress. I have targets to deliver and if I don’t - my team is at risk as well as me. Don’t get me wrong - these are also my choices, and I’m happy with them, and love my job. But he’d be the first to say that he has an easy worklife, and mine is far harder.

When we’re not working? We both do an equal share of lazing about! 🤣 He’s an equal partner in the home - cooking, cleaning etc… he gets off a little lighter on life admin. I pay all the bills, so I get all the admin on that!

The key thing for us is that we are really open about it. He simply wouldn’t take half a joint pot because he’d feel like he was taking the piss. But, because we love each other he doesn’t feel the same way about me paying for all our holidays, for example. I pay the maintenance for stepson’s uni because my income impacted it. I also pay for him to come on our family holidays, and plenty of other things.

What I don’t do, is give exactly half the pot.

If that works for you, good! But it doesn't look like it will work for OP. She'll and her child will be severaly disadvantaged by such an arrangement.

And going by statistics, it's likely she'll do more life-admin stuff, household chores, child rearing (plus paying for everything her child needs) and living in a house she literally can't even afford half of.

In her situation the benefit is all for him. Even if they were to do as I suggested earlier, pooling their money, he would likely benefit in ways that would make his life a lot easier than it is now. So in this case her partner is taking the piss.

JaceLancs · 19/06/2022 12:12

I was in this situation a few years ago but on working and child tax credit - which dropped when partner moved in
we agreed he gave me monthly the exact amount that I lost in benefits
then we split all the bills
He still had more disposable income than me so he paid for all the extras such as holidays, meals out etc
I was better off than before he moved in as he shared the bills that previously I had been paying on my own
maybe that would work for you?

greatblueheron · 19/06/2022 12:11

Perfectworld · 19/06/2022 09:14

I think I would rather just go into things as equal partners from the off, I've been fretting over this a lot. I have visions of family days out in the future, such as quibbling over who buys ice creams on days out because I'm skint and really won't be able to afford it. Does he buy for him and his DC only, do I never get to treat his DC (which I love doing now), does he just pay for us all and grumble that he pays for all ice creams, days out, holidays and presents? I think if we are not at the stage where we can be equal partners in love and money, I'd rather just stay as we are now.

I think you should stay as you are now as otw, this is clearly where are you headed. You, and by extension your DC, will be worse off financially if you move in and he doesn't make up directly to you the money you will lose by moving in together.

Perfectworld · 19/06/2022 12:10

I think we are both cautious and worried as we have both been burned in the past. Not necessarily financially, but relationships not working out and ending very bitterly. I struggle to discuss the financials as I don't want him to think I am a gold digger or looking for a gravy train, although on the flip side people could say the same about him with his debt etc. Having such a wage disparity is hard. If I was the high earner, I can hand on heart say any relationship I enter into where my DC or theirs are involved, I would want us to be a family in all aspects. I have supported those on less income in the past, not only one ex who had a period of unemployment, but also an ex who earned significantly less than me so I paid for most dinners out, days out, dates etc. I'm not a shirker when it comes to money. I am a single parent with no support from my child's father, that's why I cannot work and earn more. I would be expected to do most of the childcare for my DC, a lot more for his too I imagine, and most of the household chores, cleaning, cooking, washing because his job is much longer hours and more demanding so it makes sense that I would do those things. I think one pot or a percentage split is the best way to go about things, but I am so conscious of being viewed as money grabbing which is so far from the reality.

OP posts:
Testina · 19/06/2022 12:05

“Is your partner's job not "high pressure"? Does he just laze around the hours he in not working“

No, it isn’t. He works in a job that he loves in an industry that is poorly paid. He works for himself. It’s a practical job, there’s nothing to think about after he finishes, nothing to take home. He works 4 days a week. Next year he’s taking a month off to do a bucket list motorcycle trip. Earlier in his working life, he took a full year off to travel. Twice.
He has literally never worked late in his life - even when not self employed. It just isn’t a feature of his industry.

All great choices.

By contrast, I’ve worked really long hours to reach my salary level, and still do sometimes. Not an issue - I love my job! I’ve also worked away from home. I needed a degree to get into it, so I had debt from that. I have a team to manage, which I love, but comes with stress. I have targets to deliver and if I don’t - my team is at risk as well as me. Don’t get me wrong - these are also my choices, and I’m happy with them, and love my job. But he’d be the first to say that he has an easy worklife, and mine is far harder.

When we’re not working? We both do an equal share of lazing about! 🤣 He’s an equal partner in the home - cooking, cleaning etc… he gets off a little lighter on life admin. I pay all the bills, so I get all the admin on that!

The key thing for us is that we are really open about it. He simply wouldn’t take half a joint pot because he’d feel like he was taking the piss. But, because we love each other he doesn’t feel the same way about me paying for all our holidays, for example. I pay the maintenance for stepson’s uni because my income impacted it. I also pay for him to come on our family holidays, and plenty of other things.

What I don’t do, is give exactly half the pot.

stephvdb · 19/06/2022 11:54

Run!

Not only is he being unfair and stingy, he's clearly a twat. He earns 4 times more than you! Not only should you not be splitting the bills, he should not even be letting you pay for anything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread