Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rent and bills. Doesn't seem fair. AIBU?

444 replies

Perfectworld · 18/06/2022 22:17

How would you split bills / rent in this scenario?

Both of us have 1x child each from previous relationships, both late 30s. Fiancé earns £120k, I earn £28k. I currently get child benefit and UC top up, which will cease when we move in together. He has suggested we pay half the rent each, plus he covers all joint utility bills, meaning I still have all non 'joint' bills e.g. my mobile phone, my car payment. Due to this, I will probably be left with less that I currently have spare each month (which is already very little). The rent I pay will be the same as I pay currently, due to needing a bigger house to support both of our DC. I will be worse off some months, and others about the same financially because I cannot claim UC or child benefit. On more expensive months, for instance, the months when DC's school dinner fee is due, I will be worse off than I am now. He will be saving approx £2k per month in this scenario, which he has said will be put towards joint savings.

What do you think is reasonable for each person, how would you split finances?

OP posts:
Perfectworld · 21/06/2022 13:00

@LondonLawyer After tax on both of us (subtracting benefits once we start living together), his take home is 3.5x my own. That's why I think a proportional split of 70/30 is about fair, if we are going down the split route.

OP posts:
LondonLawyer · 21/06/2022 12:42

Lou98 · 18/06/2022 23:28

I agree with others that the fairest way is to pay proportionate to your wages (so approx 80/20) on all household bills and then you both pay your own/your own child's other outgoings.

It sounds like he has high outgoings so you would be better off both paying your own personal bills and just splitting the house costs

It needs to be proportionate to wages after tax, though - he will be paying a lot more tax so his take home pay won't be anything like 80%

Crikeyalmighty · 21/06/2022 12:40

@Perfectworld yes OP, I'm sure there's a compromise in there somewhere and no, I don't remotely think you are a gold digger, just concerned about if this is the way now, what's the future going to be like. You should be put into a position where you are no worse off than you are now

Perfectworld · 21/06/2022 12:16

He does know about the benefits. I really do need to talk to him properly, which I am planning on doing, to express myself properly.

I'm torn between suggesting a joint pot - which feels most natural to me - and splitting proportionally (me 30%, him 70% seems about right). I think if we are moving in together, it should be because we are joining our families as a partnership. We're engaged and we've also discussed having more children. I want someone who views me as their equal. I hand on heart have always shared everything I have with all my ex-partners, even when I've been the higher earner. It comes naturally to me to be very generous. I don't see how our mindsets will work when it's splitting hairs over who pays for family days out, I will end up being resentful and upset, I already feel that and we are not even to the point of living together yet! And for those who have suggested I may be after his money or saw him as a 'gravy train', I couldn't care less about his money, if I was looking for someone with money I wouldn't be with someone who has debts and massive child maintenance payments (I don't have either of those)! If he wanted to leave his job tomorrow and be earning £30k I wouldn't care less, in fact, it would make this conversation a lot easier! I've already said we need to make sure that any money or assets we have up to this point (savings, cars) should be kept ring fenced for ourselves / our children. Pretty rubbish gold digger I am!

OP posts:
P205 · 21/06/2022 11:50

luxxlisbon · 21/06/2022 11:13

You realise that would probably mean OP paying more than his proposal?
Her contribution to rent he is suggesting is the same as she pays now and then he pays joins bills. OP would have to cover her own personal expenses as would he.

The only issue really is the amount OP would lose in benefits and making sure that is addressed in the financial split between them but OP hasn’t even answered the questions on that so we don’t even know if she has told him that.

But now the OP has to pay everything for her own child by herself. They also split groceries and the OP pays for things like her own phone, school dinners, car payments. I think all these kinds of things should come out of the joint account.

Yes, the OP would be paying in more but at least she wouldn’t have to worry about being able to pay for new school shoes or not being able to afford groceries because she had to pay school dinners.

LaDamaDeElche · 21/06/2022 11:36

That reply was to @BadNomad

LaDamaDeElche · 21/06/2022 11:35

Or perhaps what people are saying is that they are engaged (I assume people still do this with the intention of actually getting married) and the money should go into one pot as money for them as one family, otherwise, perhaps they’re better off staying as they are and no one loses out. If this was a wife saying this about her husband, he would be considered to be being financially abusive.

Nothappyatwork · 21/06/2022 11:18

I’ve concluded with this thread that she hasn’t told him about the benefits because she’s embarrassed so he thinks currently she is living her life on the £28,000 and that’s all that needs to be considered in the financial splitting of bills.

It’s the only logical conclusion

Nothappyatwork · 21/06/2022 11:17

Bollindger · 21/06/2022 11:07

If he loves you. ask him to do this.
Tell him to pay all his extra bills. Child support and debts.
Ask him to transfer everything out of his account so you both have the same amount in your accounts. Then ask him to just do a month on that amount, so he can see what it feels like. Then explain that you don;t want his money, but you do need to change the split, so it represents your incomes,

@Bollindger Is this like some sort of reality TV show where he goes on the dole for a month to see how the other half live. I mean what the fuck ?
Im not on 120 grand a year but I’ve worked hard To be on more than £28k plus benefits. I don’t think I would be impressed if somebody asked me to continue with the same level of output on a weekly basis but to receive around a third of the income just to make a point.

is he allowed to tell her to buck her ideas up and go and try and maintain 128K salary to prove a point ? Or would that be mean-spirited

luxxlisbon · 21/06/2022 11:13

P205 · 21/06/2022 05:42

I think in reality, he will benefit in many ways by having the OP there. She will probably end up helping with childcare, helping with housework, helping with cooking, laundry, etc.

Personally, I would both put half our income into a joint account and that account is used to pay for rent, bills, children, holidays, shopping, etc. The other half can be used for personal expenditures and personal savings.

You realise that would probably mean OP paying more than his proposal?
Her contribution to rent he is suggesting is the same as she pays now and then he pays joins bills. OP would have to cover her own personal expenses as would he.

The only issue really is the amount OP would lose in benefits and making sure that is addressed in the financial split between them but OP hasn’t even answered the questions on that so we don’t even know if she has told him that.

Bollindger · 21/06/2022 11:07

If he loves you. ask him to do this.
Tell him to pay all his extra bills. Child support and debts.
Ask him to transfer everything out of his account so you both have the same amount in your accounts. Then ask him to just do a month on that amount, so he can see what it feels like. Then explain that you don;t want his money, but you do need to change the split, so it represents your incomes,

Crikeyalmighty · 21/06/2022 11:02

@BadNomad Where did it say she only has to contribute £500?? I must have totally missed that- if that is indeed the case then Indeed I don't get what she's moaning at . Even losing the benefits , OP must clear £1800, that's a lot of money to yourself if only paying out£500

RachaelN · 21/06/2022 10:04

This sounds like financial control. He should pay a bit more due to his salary. Yes you should contribute, but 50/50 seems to out you in a worse position. Please think about this carefully.

Ortega888 · 21/06/2022 08:54

Please do not move in with this man. He’s on a much higher wage and he’s expecting you to contribute. I think it’s awful especially as you have a child. Just state your better off financially to stop where you are. He sounds very controlling could he be a narcissist as they are so good at manipulation. Huge red flag is he quite mean with money if so run. Let us know how you go. xx

gottogonow · 21/06/2022 08:34

Sorry haven’t read all the thread but I think if you make it proportional to your income for house and household running costs, then you could each put for instance £75 a month into a separate account to use for ice creams etc when you go out. Then it feels joint funded rather than either of you worrying about it. Important to get it sorted before moving forwards as needs to be fair to you both.

BarneyW · 21/06/2022 08:29

My DH and I have a similar income split (I work part time) - all our money goes into one bank account and we spend from there. We used to have an 'allowance' transferred into our own bank accounts each month for buying each other presents and our own treats but after a while this just seemed pointless. As everyone else says, once you are married I would expect everything to be joint. I think it is dangerous ground if you see income as 'yours' and 'his'. I do quite a bit more around the house because I am only part time and looking at things holistically (eg adding earning work to non-earning work) I think our contributions are pretty balanced, basically we both work damn hard keeping money coming in, the house running and the family going. You need to have a calm conversation with him x

P205 · 21/06/2022 05:42

I think in reality, he will benefit in many ways by having the OP there. She will probably end up helping with childcare, helping with housework, helping with cooking, laundry, etc.

Personally, I would both put half our income into a joint account and that account is used to pay for rent, bills, children, holidays, shopping, etc. The other half can be used for personal expenditures and personal savings.

qtpa2t · 21/06/2022 05:38

i don't want to presume things about other oriole's relationships but when our income disparity was this big my partner was paying all the rent and bills and I would send him what I could.

now I'm a SAHM he sends me monthly spending money and also pays all the rent and bills.
i would struggle to agree to what your partner is suggesting.

BadNomad · 21/06/2022 03:07

Crikeyalmighty · 21/06/2022 02:36

@Harmonypuss but we are talking a massive income difference here , not just an odd 3k and they are engaged. Unless he's prepared to consider his income family money - I for one wouldn't move in and be worse off- will he be like this if they are married?

But the OP's money isn't being used as "family money". She's being asked to contribute just £500 and gets to keep the rest for herself and her child. Out of £28k a year she only has to contribute £6k to the house. The other £22k she will spend on herself. Kid, cars, phones, whatever.

Not in any scenario does he benefit from living with her. If she moves in, their joint income will be less and he will be paying out more. He is not making money from her. He is losing money because he will be housing and feeding extra people.

What the OP actually wants (and most of MN it seems) is for her wealthier boyfriend to cover every joint expense AND pay for her child to have the same lifestyle as his child AND be give her spending money WHILE she keeps all her own money for cars, phones, herself etc.

Crikeyalmighty · 21/06/2022 02:36

@Harmonypuss but we are talking a massive income difference here , not just an odd 3k and they are engaged. Unless he's prepared to consider his income family money - I for one wouldn't move in and be worse off- will he be like this if they are married?

Harmonypuss · 21/06/2022 01:02

@Crikeyalmighty

Of course he wants a decent lifestyle, that's why he earns that much but at the end of the day if the OP doesn't like what's on offer, she doesn't have to move in with him.
I'm my situation, my extra £3k/yr meant absolutely nothing coz I paid 2/3 of all joint household stuff but I still paid for my own car, clothing, everything to do with my kids, so all in all if I added everything we both paid together it turned out that I was paying over 80% of our overall costs and he was just putting the majority of his cash into HIS savings (not a joint account), then he was doing cash in hand work on top which gave him another at least £10k/yr, so he was actually earning a decent amount more than me but I was paying the lion's share of our costs.
This was all because I AGREED to pay more coz the kids were mine but if the situation was such that one was mine and the other his, I would have insisted on 50:50, regardless of our individual incomes. Just because one earns more than the other, unless they're married, one should not be expected to financially carry the other!

Borisisafecklesstoad · 21/06/2022 00:18

Set up a joint account. Work out what complete total for expenses is (everything other than spending moneys) and then make a budget including amounts for days out with kids etc. Say 4000 a month

Proportionally from both salaries. If he makes 3x what you earn you pay 1k he pays 3k
And

I would include in the budget his debt/maintenance as well as your current childcare costs.

This may leave him with more than you at the end of the month but that would happen if you didn't live together?

If you love him and can afford this go enjoy. Being able to have this conversation should be a good indicator of your ability to communicate.good luck xxx

Crikeyalmighty · 20/06/2022 23:48

@Harmonypuss of course income has to come into it- if he is on that kind of income then chances are he will want a relatively good lifestyle too and will have plenty of cash , whereas OP will have next to no spare cash as she will be at least £200 a month down . I appreciate he might not want to fund 100% of everything -- but in my opinion he's taking the piss

Dinoteeth · 20/06/2022 23:32

@Harmonypuss of course income needs to come into the equation of who pays what, esp when she looses income by moving in with a much higher earner.
And in a few years the household income is what will be taken into account if her DS was to go to uni.

She cannot move in as the lower earner when he isn't prepared to support both her and her DS.

Harmonypuss · 20/06/2022 23:16

Salaries shouldn't come into it. 2 adults, 2 kids, half each.

I was in situation where I had 2 kids, OH had none, I earned £3k/yr more than him but he wanted me to pay 75% of everything, ie, I pay for me and my kids but as they were exactly that, kids, I agreed to 2/3.