Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rent and bills. Doesn't seem fair. AIBU?

444 replies

Perfectworld · 18/06/2022 22:17

How would you split bills / rent in this scenario?

Both of us have 1x child each from previous relationships, both late 30s. Fiancé earns £120k, I earn £28k. I currently get child benefit and UC top up, which will cease when we move in together. He has suggested we pay half the rent each, plus he covers all joint utility bills, meaning I still have all non 'joint' bills e.g. my mobile phone, my car payment. Due to this, I will probably be left with less that I currently have spare each month (which is already very little). The rent I pay will be the same as I pay currently, due to needing a bigger house to support both of our DC. I will be worse off some months, and others about the same financially because I cannot claim UC or child benefit. On more expensive months, for instance, the months when DC's school dinner fee is due, I will be worse off than I am now. He will be saving approx £2k per month in this scenario, which he has said will be put towards joint savings.

What do you think is reasonable for each person, how would you split finances?

OP posts:
BadNomad · 19/06/2022 09:17

Yes, she would effectively lose child benefit. Not sure why people keep saying she won't? If they live together and share rental costs, they would classify as partners? Theoretically, yes, you can claim it and get it... but because your partner earns more than 50k a year, it will be taxed at 100%, which means you have to give it all back through taxes.

The DP would have to pay it back. Not the OP. This benefits her.

Perfectworld · 19/06/2022 09:14

I think I would rather just go into things as equal partners from the off, I've been fretting over this a lot. I have visions of family days out in the future, such as quibbling over who buys ice creams on days out because I'm skint and really won't be able to afford it. Does he buy for him and his DC only, do I never get to treat his DC (which I love doing now), does he just pay for us all and grumble that he pays for all ice creams, days out, holidays and presents? I think if we are not at the stage where we can be equal partners in love and money, I'd rather just stay as we are now.

OP posts:
CoffeeDeprivation · 19/06/2022 09:13

OP, whatever agreement you make now, it's likely to stay with very little changes afterwards. So agree only what you can afford long term and won't create tension.

I have a similar arrangement with DH, who earns more than twice what I earn. He pays all housebills including mortgage, I pay all childcare, food, clubs, bday presents, anything related to kids, kids shows and days out, etc. Each pay their own personal expenses. Food costs have increased over the last 5 years, my salary was reduced during maternity significantly, we have been booking kids on more clubs, there's more uniform more often, in lockdown I paid for takeaways because it was a way of giving me a break and I found the whole year exhausting... He has been able to save thousands. I have over 15k debt. He cannot understand how I got there. It's not exactly the same but my point is that it's extremely easy to build on debt when you are just a tiny bit worse off and something changes that makes you an extra bit worse off again.

things to consider:

  • Holidays, who pays, and will you consider what you can afford? 20% of a holiday to New York is not the same as 20% to a Haven caravan park.
  • Restaurants, takeaways, etc. - same point as above. Set a budget. You could pay for the cheaper ones (McDonald's, fish and chips, whatever), he could pay for sit down meals and more expensive ones.
  • You should always have an emergency fund to allow you to move out and pay three months rent (which in some places is the deposit for new rentals).

Yes, she would effectively lose child benefit. Not sure why people keep saying she won't? If they live together and share rental costs, they would classify as partners? Theoretically, yes, you can claim it and get it... but because your partner earns more than 50k a year, it will be taxed at 100%, which means you have to give it all back through taxes. Completely pointless and if you don't realise you get a huge HMRC bill all of a sudden. It happened to us. We signed the forms as usually because they came in the pregnancy pack (the one that is about £80/first child). I got the payments, all was in my name. Four years down the line, HMRC sent my husband a bill, he had to give back about 3k and it messed up his tax for another two years. Not sure why they never contacted me, though.

MarryMeTomHardy · 19/06/2022 09:12

Testina · 18/06/2022 22:39

I’m a minority on MN but I don’t think there’s anything wrong with a higher earning partner (either gender) not subsidising the other when they haven’t chosen marriage. I don’t think you should be worse off though. So fair to you would be, as an absolute minimum, you end up with the same disposable income that you have now. That might well mean you pay far less into the household to balance losing UC.

With marriage, I think first time round with joint children and joint decisions around them (like part time working for example) - all in one pot. As a principle, fine to manage it via separate accounts.

But marriage second time round, with each having children (my situation) I think it’s fine not to be “one pot”. Different needs, different responsibilities. Still the minimum should be no-one being worse off than they were before. But, because of marriage I’d expect the lower earner to be better off than they were. Just not necessarily one pot.

So:


  • in what way is he your fiancé? These days, that word doesn’t seem to have a certainty of marriage about it

  • what is his proposal for finances after marriage?


I think it’s fine to have different proposals here initially. What matters most is how he reacts when yours is different. Does he listen to you, consider why you think yours fair, compromise? (which doesn’t mean capitulate)

Agree with this

Washermother33 · 19/06/2022 09:09

OP you need to sit down and show him the figures so he can see he’s putting you in a worse financial position than you are now . If he isn’t happy to move responsibilities to accommodate that then it’s either too early for him to commit fully or he just isn’t committed enough to being in a partnership with you

Spidey66 · 19/06/2022 09:07

I think you should both pay a % of your salary into the pot....say 30% each. I think that's a fair compromise.

Dinoteeth · 19/06/2022 08:59

Op you are absolutely right it would get complicated and messy. And very stressful to be watching every penny while he has £2k spare every month.

Financially you just aren't compatible.
Enjoy his company but don't move in together. Won't be the first couple to decide that they get on better living apart than together.

TolkiensFallow · 19/06/2022 08:58

OP I think you seem quite reasonable. Your latest post spells it out, you are already worrying about gifts and days out.

Sit down with him and explain that you are going to be worse if each month due to universal credit and child benefit stopping and it’s going to put you on the breadline, worrying about school dinner moment. Perhaps show your partner and spreadsheet of your own finances and they’ll see where that money would make a huge difference to you.

He’ll be saving £2k per month and you’ll be worryingly about dinner money for DC. It’s not right yet but hopefully you can get there.

Luredbyapomegranate · 19/06/2022 08:55

Don't move in with this bloke till this is sorted fairly. He doesn't sound like he actually wants a partnership, and if you are moving in with kids a partnership is what is has to be.

The only workable thing is one pot, with contributions based on your salaries. You set up a joint account and pay in what is needed for bills, mortgage, food (separate account for holidays perhaps) - you pay 30% and he pays 70% or whatever reflects your earnings, obviously taking into account any debt repayments.

If he doesn't want to to this don't move in. It's either too early or he's not a keeper.

5128gap · 19/06/2022 08:55

Living together isn't feasible OP. The gulf between your incomes is too great for you to have a shared lifestyle without him financially subsidising you. Some people are fine to do that, he clearly isn't, and realistically you simply don't earn enough to 'pay your way' in this relationship.

Dailymenu · 19/06/2022 08:55

Do not move in and do not mix finances.🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩

Ahgoonyegirlye · 19/06/2022 08:52

I wouldn’t move in with him. You need the UC and he is in massive debt that he needs to deals with first.
DW and I have a similar difference in earnings. We pay proportionally in to a joint acct - or she contributes 4 x more . But we have kids together and are married.

whowhatwerewhy · 19/06/2022 08:51

I would sit and make a list of your current income and outgoing. Then the same for should you move in with him .
You can take if from there .
I think you should be responsible for your own car payment and phone , just as he's responsible for his debts.

I think the problem is you losing your UC and child benefits, that maybe he hasn't factored in .

Not sure how old your DC is but at some point you will lose the benefits once they become adults.

It might be you put off moving in together until he's paid off his debt and you have paid off your car .

Perfectworld · 19/06/2022 08:49

The comments that I am a gold digger or thought I'd found my ''gravy train' are funny. I have subsidised partners in the past (though I hate that word as I have always entered into long term relationships with the view that we will be partners). Life happens, and quickly, the person on £28k ends up being the sole provider, that is what happened with my last relationship. Thankfully, he found a new job within a couple of months but I never felt resentful for helping him (us) out. We were partners.

I'm in no debt, I never have been because I live within my means. I can afford to save a small amount a month at the moment, £100. I wouldn't be able to save anything living with him, because with everything taken into account (my contribution, paying everything for my DC, my own personal bills plus loss of child benefit and universal credit, I'd be worse off). So, while some months I would be 'okay', I would need to constantly be planning again for when DC's school dinner money was due etc. My fiancé's debt panics me as I have never been in debt in my life, and if I ever were to be in debt, I would pay it off as soon as possible. He has much more of a casual attitude to it.

I have been thinking about holidays/Christmas/days out etc. a lot. I really do not know how that would work or how we would budget. I've always gone feet first into things and treated things like a partnership or equal. I need to think about what to propose next, whether its we split everything 75/25, or 'one pot'. I think the current proposal could get very complicated and messy.

OP posts:
Walkaround · 19/06/2022 08:47

Ah yes, I see I misread the OP. He is not saving an extra £2,000 per month under the new arrangement, he is probably saving less than before. Nevertheless, I would never embark on a long term relationship with someone who happily envisaged different qualities of life for themselves and the other people they lived with - that’s just a houseshare, not a loving relationship. If he isn’t ready to pool incomes and isn’t even ready to help make up for the fact you lose income and are thus made much more financially vulnerable than he is if you move in together, then he is not worth moving in with, or being engaged to, as an engagement is not a legal commitment, it’s just an invitation for you to let your guard down and put yourself at financial risk with no recourse if it all goes tits up.

icelollycraving · 19/06/2022 08:46

Plus he could pay off the debt if he can save every month. All seems off. Are you sure it’s what he’s told you and not more?

icelollycraving · 19/06/2022 08:44

Why are you considering moving in? It doesn’t sound a fair set up.
If you have less money, you’ll become resentful surely? I bet he’s thinking it is a great idea, that he’s protecting himself after his ex.
Protect yourself and your family’s budget.

saleorbouy · 19/06/2022 08:43

I don't follow why he's saving when he has debt, he could be paying it off faster and reduce the interest costs especially if it's on credit card and interest rates are on the up.

On the main question, you can't afford to move in together with the current financial arrangements.
Personally I think he's right that you're responsible for your own finances for car, phone etc.
Perhaps you could split the rent differently to take into account the loss of UC and Child benefit. ( yours is a good example of why the £51k rule is no really fair)
You should discuss how you're intending to manage finances after you marry, saving for the wedding and mat leave provisions if you're planning more DC. I think from these you will get a better picture of his vision of 'sharing' the family financial burden.

Nothappyatwork · 19/06/2022 08:42

daisychain01 · 19/06/2022 08:38

He has the financial advantage.

He will know that the OP will lose all her benefits but has done nothing to rebalance that loss.

nothing you can say to me will convince me he isn't a squeaky tightwad and the OP is setting herself up for worse to come with someone who wants to ringfence their finances to that extent yet claim to care about the OP as supposedly their life partner.

So to flip that on its head what exactly is he getting out of this relationship financially (im sure you’re lovely op) ? Presumably they have chosen the house together so they’re both happy with the standard that that is. They both have similar tastes in food not like one was previously shopping in Lidl whilst the other was trotting around Waitrose if they’re splitting it 50-50 so which ever supermarket they using I presume will remain the same.

he’s covering all of the utilities which will increase.

if he was such a tight wad surely just stay where he was ?

daisychain01 · 19/06/2022 08:38

luxxlisbon · 19/06/2022 08:28

Yeah how dare he pay towards the utilities and food for OP’s child and then have the nerve to save money for his own. What a horrible father 🙄

If OP was the higher earner and saved 2k a month for her child’s future she would be to to NOT spend it subsiding his children instead.

He has the financial advantage.

He will know that the OP will lose all her benefits but has done nothing to rebalance that loss.

nothing you can say to me will convince me he isn't a squeaky tightwad and the OP is setting herself up for worse to come with someone who wants to ringfence their finances to that extent yet claim to care about the OP as supposedly their life partner.

Dervel · 19/06/2022 08:36

Why isn’t your ex paying any child support? I’d be inclined to pursue that avenue if that hadn’t been exhausted already.

MayBeee · 19/06/2022 08:36

Look to the future here , you will be less better off .
So Christmas / birthdays , he can afford to buy the best , high end presents for his child all wrapped up under the tree , whilst yours still have presents , obviously , but will they look the same as the other child's . Will they be lavished in gifts , designer trainers , hoodies whilst yours are High St ? Children will notice this sort of thing . How will holidays / days out work ?

daisychain01 · 19/06/2022 08:33

Midlifemusings · 19/06/2022 06:12

This is a good thread ot save though for the next time a woman posts that she is hte higher earner and her new partner is moving in with the expectsation that she will now take over the majorityof all his expenses and his kids expenses. I wonder if she will get called all the same names if she doesn't take over his expenses and immediately create joint accounts and divert her savings to him.

But threads like that are as rare as rocking horse shit.

it is very uncommon for a man to have to sacrifice their career when they have kids, because it is invariably the woman who takes the hit. High flying women with big pay packets of the £120k variety won't come on here with that dilemma. Far more frequent for a working mum to have been left with 1+ children while the man swans off Scot free and maybe sees his child/ren at weekend, so get to continue progressing and getting promoted

Grawlix · 19/06/2022 08:29

Well, the defenders of the poor 120K-earning DP have certainly arrived en masse, haven’t they?

@Perfectworld I would start a thread in Relationships setting out why you feel so very unsure about this proposed move, quite apart from the financial aspect (which is clearly causing you significant worry, and rightly so in my view).

Even from the little you’ve said it feels to me as though there’s more to this story and you might find advice away from AIBU helpful.

TolkiensFallow · 19/06/2022 08:28

I’m with the “one pot” brigade.

If you are moving in together, with children involved and planning to get married then you need the same concept of family.

It’s his choice to be with someone of substantially lower income and live with them so there can’t be a constant disparity whereby OP and her kid are the “poor relations”.

OP don’t do this in this way, you will resent it and you will be constantly scraping together money for clothes and birthday/Christmas presents for your child - resenting your high earning partner.

I do understand that he may be feeling self protecting of his high salary but he needs to make his peace with the lifestyle change before you make it and someone gets hurt.

Swipe left for the next trending thread