Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave my kind and dependable DP

115 replies

Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 10:47

Currently living with DP of four years, we're both mid 30s. He's a lovely, loyal, demands nothing, kind, caring, hardworking, intelligent, funny, cheerful. I'm happy with him. However. I'm quite adventurous and like travel, trying new things, would like to live abroad again etc etc. We do go out hiking and cycling together a lot, but he is more of a sit at home watching TV type. Picky eater, eats the same food every day. Wants to go on same UK holidays every year. Wants to stay living in the same area he grew up in and where he plays in a sports team. I wonder if these differences are a sign I should leave? Or is it normal to have to compromise on something like this?

To be honest it's my first proper relationship and I always had a fear of ending up with someone like my father (physically and verbally abusive). I feel like I've lucked out simply finding someone who doesn't have an angry or aggressive bone in his body, genuinely cares for me, who I have interests and a moral compass in common with, and who I can be myself with. There's no perfect partner right?

OP posts:
D0lphine · 18/06/2022 14:47

I think you have to have a long hard think about what you want.

Personally I think you're very lucky to be in a relationship with someone kind and dependable, who shares hobbies with you and is respectful. Many people would kill for this. But if you aren't happy that's all there is to it!

Next thing to consider is do you want kids. If you want to try for kids, stay with mr dependable IMO. Does he want a family?

Of course, you can travel / work abroad with children but it does somewhat restrict you/ require more thought. But lots of people do it! So it might not be so polar opposite as you think!

Tell him where your head is at!

ComputerQueen · 18/06/2022 14:42

SleepingStandingUp · 18/06/2022 14:27

Probably going to come across harsh but I don't mean it to.

Your living in a one bed flat and can't afford anything else atm.. This lifestyle of travelling the world, living in different places, is that realistic if you weren't with him and having to live where you do, or is it a bit of a pipe dream based on you suddenly getting a better job and a cheaper house?

So if you dump him, will all your dreams come true or will you just be single and still dreaming of hawaii?

You don't need money to travel. Fruit picking, working in hostels etc. There are also jobs that pay you to do so like being a nanny, teaching English, housesitting...
Of course with the whole 'remote work' there are also people working from different countries, and certain in-demand professionals can always move countries but as the OP can't afford more than a one-bed flat in her mid-30's I'm somewhat safe in assuming that she's not that qualified.

Topseyt123 · 18/06/2022 14:36

coffeecupsandfairylights · 18/06/2022 12:31

I mean this in the kindest way, but if you can't afford to rent or buy a bigger place, can you afford to travel and live abroad in the way you want?

What I mean is - are you going to leave a lovely, kind dependable man for what is just a pipe-dream due to financial restraints?

I have to say that I agree with this.

You are considering leaving a nice, kind and dependable man for some dream that could turn out to be pie in the sky.

I think that would be mad, personally. You can always go on the occasional holiday by yourself if it is something that you want to do and he doesn't. Organise the odd thing that you want. He might tag along and enjoy it, or he might just be happy for you to go by yourself. It doesn't have to be such a huge issue.

DH and I do like going on similar types of holiday, but on some days will want to do different things while we are there. So we do. No issues and it works for us.

PlanetNormal · 18/06/2022 14:32

He sounds like a lovely guy who would be an absolute dream partner for so many women who have had their fingers badly burned by being in chaotic, abusive or even violent relationships with arseholes.

But you are not one of those women, and it’s possIble that while you & him are both good people, you are incompatible as life partners because you want different things. In my experience, there is no such thing as ‘soulmates’, all relationships require significant compromises from both parties, but some issues are dealbreakers (eg whether to have children) and the grass is definitely not always greener. Only you can decide if he is the right person for you. Whatever you do, do not have children with him until you are sure what you want.

Good luck.

dreamingbohemian · 18/06/2022 14:29

It sounds like you can never live more than an hour away from his family? That would feel so stifling to me.

I was in a similar situation at 30 and ended it, for me it worked out great as I moved abroad and found my amazing husband. He is even lovelier than the other guy and so much more curious about the world, after 15 years we are still having so much fun.

But it could easily have gone the other way, it's a big risk.

Herejustforthisone · 18/06/2022 14:28

MRex · 18/06/2022 10:57

You don't love him, clearly. So is better that you separate now than once you have kids. I suspect you'll leave him and regret it, but if you aren't compatible then you aren't and you need to hold onto that in future when you start second guessing yourself. You deserve to enjoy your life and he deserves to be with someone who loves him.

This is a unnecessarily snipey.

Trogbog · 18/06/2022 14:27

I guess everyone answers from how their own life turned out. I married a guy I was very compatible with in so many ways, but he turned out to be a fucking awful, defective human being.
Someone kind and dependable is now my dream! So I’d stick with a guy like that and find mates to do the exciting stuff with. ( though I don’t n’t like travel so easy for me to say!)

SleepingStandingUp · 18/06/2022 14:27

Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 12:21

We're both undecided about kids, it's not a decision either of us take lightly, plus housing is a big factor. We currently live in a one bed flat on a high street and can't afford to rent/buy anything bigger than a small flat within an hour or so of his family. I'm likely to have fertility problems so have always been open minded about having a family. And in all honesty, I'd feel a bit sad bringing kids into the world at the moment.

Probably going to come across harsh but I don't mean it to.

Your living in a one bed flat and can't afford anything else atm.. This lifestyle of travelling the world, living in different places, is that realistic if you weren't with him and having to live where you do, or is it a bit of a pipe dream based on you suddenly getting a better job and a cheaper house?

So if you dump him, will all your dreams come true or will you just be single and still dreaming of hawaii?

Thelnebriati · 18/06/2022 14:23

I was in your position, went off to do my own thing occasionally, and the relationship didn't last. I think that was a better way to find out he wasn't Mr Right than after having kids.

RealBecca · 18/06/2022 14:20

You say you're undecided about kids so what's stopping you up and doing that stuff now? Like actually deciding and following through.

PyongyangKipperbang · 18/06/2022 14:20

Have you actually told him any of this?

I suggest you sit down and lay it out, as you have here, and say that you are worried that without some compromise on his part, you dont have a future.

If you havent told him, how can he consider alternatives? He doesnt want to live abroad, ok but the compromise is that you travel to other countries instead of holidaying in the UK. He wants to be near his family? Ok, but your housing is expensive so you cant afford anything bigger, so the the compromise is you stay nearish but far enough away to be able to afford to better your accomodation.

Talk talk talk and if you dont agree to compromise (BOTH OF YOU) then yes I would say you should leave, but give him a chance to see your POV first.

Furrbabymama1987 · 18/06/2022 14:17

I think some compromise is normal if you love them and want to be with them. No one is 100% perfect. If you love them enough then those little things don't matter as much. But if you're not happy and not feeling fulfilled then that could be a sign it's time to move on. I left a partner I was never in love with, it was more a convenience and I'm now married to a man who satisfies me.

Sunnytwobridges · 18/06/2022 14:15

I feel like if you’re already having doubts like this there a seed planted and it will never go away.

i am a lot like your DP and I had a bf like you. He always was on the go and wanting to do things. I became too boring for him as he wanted someone just like him. Although I was devastated at the break up over time I know it was probably for the best as I know he would never be happy with someone less adventurous like me.

Funny, he tried to “come back” a few times since things ended but I wasn’t having any of it. He’s still single (seen him actively on dating apps) ten years later.

saying that I still think you should leave your dp so he can find a better match and it frees you up to find yours too.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/06/2022 13:21

You’re not joined at the hip - is it not possible to travel and do other things on your own? I do often wonder at couples who always do everything together - my parents were like this so my DM was doubly devastated and lost when my DF died.

Especially if you want children at some point, kind and dependable are IMO worth a great deal
And as a pp pointed out, adventurous, more risk-taking types of men are IMO rather less likely to be dependable. You see enough posts on MN about dh’s/DPs who prioritise their very time consuming hobbies - whether cycling or rock climbing - over family life.
Never mind the risk-taking aspect of affairs…..

You’re still young, but it’s worth bearing in mind that with every year that passes, more of the nice, kind, dependable fish in the sea will have been snapped up.

Dacquoise · 18/06/2022 13:16

Staynow · 18/06/2022 11:05

Why don't you travel on your own? Or work abroad for a year and have a long distance relationship for that time? If he's open to you doing those things even though he doesn't want to then I don't see why it couldn't work. Who knows when you keep telling him about the amazing things you've done he might start to feel he's missing out and decide to join in.

Great idea!

AnnaMagnani · 18/06/2022 13:12

A big thing about relationships is compromise - do you love your DP? Do you feel he has your back?

When I got married to my DH it was a massive shock that I was stuck with him and had to acknowledge his opinions which frankly, were not mine. I felt like I spent 2 years just dropping my standards - my DM says I would moan on the phone and she would smile and say 'Yes dear' - wise woman.

But he is kind, caring, consistent, always has my back and we have interests in common. I had a bit of counselling which helped me put across my views, and given your history of abuse may be helpful to you.

Are we doing what I dreamed of - honestly no. Is that the fault of my DH - also no. We made shared life decisions, sometimes life bit us on the bum and we had to do things we didn't want but after many years we did forge a team.

However most days he still irritates me so much I could bury him under the patio. But I daresay he could say the same about me.

If your DP is kind and supports you in the tough times, that is worth it's weight in gold.

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 18/06/2022 13:05

I'll go against the grain and say I'd totally stay with him. He sounds great!
You'll never be happy in a relationship if you won't accept someone who's 90% perfect and 10% not quite right.
You could meet 'Mr Adventurous' and he could be a cheating shit bag.
I've been with DH for 17 years and during that time I've wanted a couple of things that he's not - so I've gone out and done them! One of those things was working abroad for 3 months - he was supportive and it meant I could scratch that itch. I've also holidayed without him and will do again.

Sandinmyknickers · 18/06/2022 12:58

I left someone when I was 30 for similar reasons and was so worried I was asking a mistake because he was kind and lovely and there was nothing "wrong" as such.
Best decision I ever made
I now have a DP who is also kind and lovely but more on my wavelength and even after the "honeymoon period" has passed and we're settled into life, he still gives me butterflies and I want to not only travel and adventure but want him to be there with me. I look forward to seeing him at the end of the work day. If I'm honest with myself, I never was excited to spend time with my ex and often pursued my interests without him and didn't miss him not being there

beachcomber70 · 18/06/2022 12:54

Be very careful, and the grass is definitely not greener on the other side. Not all life is pleasant and a breeze, full of happiness and fulfilment, it can be dire and extremely unhappy even when you chase your dreams, things can backfire. Or you work with what you have and thank your lucky stars.

You could pursue your travelling and other interests with friends/a group of people interested in the same, you don't have to live life joined at the hip.

He sounds a keeper to me, you don't want the alternative. You have a chance of being happy but I don't think he deserves you and your critique. Sorry but you sound selfish and I don't think a relationship is for you. Relationships don't suit everyone. Maybe let him go, someone else would appreciate his good nature.

theworldhas · 18/06/2022 12:51

i think you need to resolve whether want to have children and where you want to live (IE do you want to live abroad/for how long etc). Once you have an answer to those questions you can then ponder your relationship/discuss with him and make decisions based on that.

ComputerQueen · 18/06/2022 12:42

Do you even 'want' a proper relationship?
Some people don't care either way. They meet someone, and like and get on with them, but can happily be single otherwise.
The majority of people do, but that's probably because of children and finances.
If you've already lived abroad, and want to do so again in your mid-30's settling is probably not for you. Break up with him and go your own way.

GetThatHelmetOn · 18/06/2022 12:37

I'm quite adventurous and like travel

Truth is, if you have got the curse or blessing of being a jumping bean, you will keep changing and desiring other things so… you are not going to find some one who can perfectly keep pace with you because even if that someone is as adventurous as you. His own personal growth will take him somewhere else while you do the same.

My advice, if you love this man and have a good relationship with him, is to work on the “periphery”: cultivate a bit of independence so you can follow your dreams while he is doing his own thing. The best trips we had as a couple were those were we did our own thing during the day and met for dinner at night to tell each other about our own adventures.

Now, moving abroad is a completely different thing, if you change the context the relationship changes and the fact he is not keen on getting out of his cocoon, makes me think he won’t enjoy the adventure and neither would you.

Konstantine8364 · 18/06/2022 12:33

Really tricky one! Ultimately you don't know what the future holds, you are with a good man who you have a reasonable amount in common with. You could leave and end up with your absolute perfect partner who is up for all your travel and adventure and live happily ever after or you could leave and end up single for a long time as you can't find a man who is exciting/adventurous AND a good person or you could have your heart broken by the exciting/adventurous bloke, when they leave for the next shiny exciting girlfriend. I think the suggestions of doing exciting things on your own are sensible, I'd also give it 6 months of trying to make it work; talking to him, trying different things etc before you decide to leave, as then you are less likely to have regrets as you've given it your best shot.

rainyskylight · 18/06/2022 12:32

What about your family, OP? Where do you want to live?

coffeecupsandfairylights · 18/06/2022 12:31

Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 12:21

We're both undecided about kids, it's not a decision either of us take lightly, plus housing is a big factor. We currently live in a one bed flat on a high street and can't afford to rent/buy anything bigger than a small flat within an hour or so of his family. I'm likely to have fertility problems so have always been open minded about having a family. And in all honesty, I'd feel a bit sad bringing kids into the world at the moment.

I mean this in the kindest way, but if you can't afford to rent or buy a bigger place, can you afford to travel and live abroad in the way you want?

What I mean is - are you going to leave a lovely, kind dependable man for what is just a pipe-dream due to financial restraints?