Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave my kind and dependable DP

115 replies

Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 10:47

Currently living with DP of four years, we're both mid 30s. He's a lovely, loyal, demands nothing, kind, caring, hardworking, intelligent, funny, cheerful. I'm happy with him. However. I'm quite adventurous and like travel, trying new things, would like to live abroad again etc etc. We do go out hiking and cycling together a lot, but he is more of a sit at home watching TV type. Picky eater, eats the same food every day. Wants to go on same UK holidays every year. Wants to stay living in the same area he grew up in and where he plays in a sports team. I wonder if these differences are a sign I should leave? Or is it normal to have to compromise on something like this?

To be honest it's my first proper relationship and I always had a fear of ending up with someone like my father (physically and verbally abusive). I feel like I've lucked out simply finding someone who doesn't have an angry or aggressive bone in his body, genuinely cares for me, who I have interests and a moral compass in common with, and who I can be myself with. There's no perfect partner right?

OP posts:
Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 17:32

Also to clear up a few things:

He's very supportive and would be totally fine with me going away for a few months travelling or working overseas. He'd never stop me doing anything. I think secretly he'd be a bit sad though.

He cooks, does all his share of the chores etc. He grew up in a house where beige oven food was the norm and eating was very functional, and he's never broadened his horizons. He's a meat and potatoes man. I'm a massive foodie, love spicy, strong flavours, veggie and vegan, but to be fair I have a couple of friends I eat out with a lot.

True, @AnnaMagnani I have no friends locally. Pandemic hasn't helped with that, although theres not much here for women my age without kids. My best friends live hours away and my nearest friend is over an hour away (although we usually meet up in the city).

OP posts:
ComputerQueen · 18/06/2022 17:17

So, you’re in a ‘dull as dishwater’ area. Which are usually quite cheap, but you can only afford a small, cramped, one-bed flat between both of you?
I presume he also works full time?

Very strange.

There’s no such thing as the ‘inevitable monotony’ of life you know. There’s so much to do and see, new people to meet, new experiences, new hobbies, I can never imagine ever getting bored! And that’s just in Manchester (where I live). In fact I don’t have time for all the things I want to do!

AnnaMagnani · 18/06/2022 17:11

You sound as if you have got yourself in a rut. Apart from DH and his family have you made any links in the area to make it feel a bit less dull?

Hiking or cycling groups? Anything else you are interested in?

He has his social life with his sport but what about YOU? There will be people out there, just in some areas you need to look a bit harder.

I have approx nothing in common with most of the people in my village but after turning up religiously to every village event however tedious and ignoring a lot of political opinions I've got good friends and it's not so dull anymore.

billy1966 · 18/06/2022 16:58

OP,
You sound bored and restless.

He is NOT "demands nothing" if he dictates where you live, how you live and what you eat.

That's actually a lot of demands IMO.

Have you sat down and talked about how his comforts appear to be ahead of yours?

What about middle ground?

Does he cook his picky food or are YOU doing it?

Is he stopping you having a decent joint social life together by his love of a night in?

Are his hobbies enough for him socially?

He may be a nice man but he sounds as if he likes a lot of things his own way.

I'd be wary of that as it has regret written all over it, especially if you don't care to have children.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 18/06/2022 16:51

Personally I would hang onto him and do the adventurous stuff with friends. Obviously if he sulks and tries to stop you you should sack him but if not, for me, his positives would outweigh the negatives. Mind you I'm 10 years older and possibly value different things!

pixie5121 · 18/06/2022 16:51

Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 16:42

Thanks for all your responses so far, really interesting things to think about.

Maybe it's also be the realisation that I'm in my mid 30s, and I'm bored, and stuck in a tiny cramped flat in a dull as dishwater area. But honestly, I couldn't do any better if I went it alone. I never imagined this would be my life in my 30s. I have an interesting and meaningful career (but not well paid), lived abroad for some time, and did a lot of travelling and socialising in my 20s and early 30s. Maybe I'm trying to fight the inevitable monotony of life. But then again I don't want the turbulence of my parents' marriage either.

Also just to note, living near my parents isn't important to me as we're not close. I have no other family, and my friends are all over the place. I'd give a limb for a close, loving family, so I can't really begrudge him wanting to stay within visiting distance of his I guess. It's just very limiting.

Why couldn't you do better if you went it alone? I think you could. You could rent a one-bed on your own for a reasonable price in loads of cities/countries. You can live a digital nomad type life for a pittance if you're prepared to rough it a little bit. Is that what you want, though?

I was living your life in my late twenties. Steady relationship, one-bed flat, life fine but dull, frustrated about not travelling as much as I wanted or doing the things I wanted to do. The relationship ended because he turned into a dick (started holding my neurodiversity against me, being abusive, calling me pathetic for not being able to cope as well as he could) and so after a year or so of feeling miserable, I packed my bags and went travelling alone at 30. I did more in those few years than in the previous ten.

I've got itchy feet again, not least because things are turning to complete shit in the UK. I do have ties here (niece, nephew, support from friends) but if I didn't I'd be off like a shot.

Anonymouseposter · 18/06/2022 16:48

I think it really depends what you want in the future.
If you want children and a settled life it sounds like he would be a very good father and you could build on your relationship by communicating and making compromises. Reading posts on here shows how many poor excuses for fathers are out there.
On the other hand if travel and adventure is more important to you and you don't mind insecurity and being self sufficient, then leave.
There is no guarantee that you will find a better relationship if you leave, you may or you may not.

Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 16:42

Thanks for all your responses so far, really interesting things to think about.

Maybe it's also be the realisation that I'm in my mid 30s, and I'm bored, and stuck in a tiny cramped flat in a dull as dishwater area. But honestly, I couldn't do any better if I went it alone. I never imagined this would be my life in my 30s. I have an interesting and meaningful career (but not well paid), lived abroad for some time, and did a lot of travelling and socialising in my 20s and early 30s. Maybe I'm trying to fight the inevitable monotony of life. But then again I don't want the turbulence of my parents' marriage either.

Also just to note, living near my parents isn't important to me as we're not close. I have no other family, and my friends are all over the place. I'd give a limb for a close, loving family, so I can't really begrudge him wanting to stay within visiting distance of his I guess. It's just very limiting.

OP posts:
EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 18/06/2022 16:28

I've not taken to it but a book that is often recommended for women in the OP's position is Untamed: Stop Pleasing, Start Living. (Or, how to stop settling for an unsatisfactory life.)

www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B082K7QXRQ/?

I take what PP are saying about the difficulty of finding someone with whom you're compatible and shares your view of an enjoyable life but:


  • you can't meet someone when you're coupled-up and in a way from restricted from meeting the sort of people with whom you'd share interests.

  • you might discover that you'd sooner live alone than rub along in companionship.

Cameleongirl · 18/06/2022 16:25

I agree, @goldfinchonthelawn . One of my friends is married to someone like that-nice guy, but totally self-absorbed and obsessive about his hobbies. She decided not to have children with him, even though he initially said he wanted them….she actually said to me that she realized that she’d end up doing all the work!

Luckily having children wasn’t a huge priority for her so it’s worked out. I couldn’t live with someone like that though!

goldfinchonthelawn · 18/06/2022 16:21

Burgoo · 18/06/2022 11:51

Oops forgot this!

Does he flatly refuse to go away to different places etc? Have you asked him directly and he said no?

Whilst "adventurous" guys are fun, I often find that in the long term with that risky streak comes impulsivity. I find it tends to happen that people go for the "risky" and "adventurous" types and then realise that they aren't reliable and things fall apart.

I agree with this. I remember a friend coping with two DC who had severe measles with complications while she was in her third trimester, and her wonderful 'adventurous' DH was off climbing mountains that could kill him.

Not my idea of fun.

Cameleongirl · 18/06/2022 15:55

Haven’t RTFT so sorry if someone has already mentioned this. Have you sat down with him and explained that you’d like to travel and do some more exciting things? If so, what was his reaction? That’s really the key to this. My DH has travelled far more than he otherwise would have, because he’s married to me. Similarly, he’s encouraged me to explore some career opportunities that I’d never have considered.

Talk to him about it and if he’s encouraging and says that he’ll at least give some new adventures a try, because it’s important to you, it means he really loves you.

If he won’t even consider it, you may not be compatible. What you’re asking isn’t unreasonable or unrealistic ( relocating to the other side of the world, for example, might be at this stage!), so there should be room for compromise. He could try a few more exciting holidays.

WhatNoRaisins · 18/06/2022 15:53

If he was willing to consider living further away from his family would you potentially have more disposable income? I mean maybe not a jetsetter lifestyle but there's a whole spectrum between that and being stuck with a one bed flat because he's not open to moving.

pixie5121 · 18/06/2022 15:47

dottypotter · 18/06/2022 15:37

There are alot of abusive people around today, youve only got to look at relationship problems on boards like this. So yes its fortunate if you find someone kind and caring.

You dont ever find happiness or stability if you keep chasing the perfect person they dont exist.

I agree.

I think at least half of men are abusive in some way, not necessarily physical abuse, but negging, criticising, bringing you down. It really is quite rare to meet a heterosexual single man who isn't an arsehole. And I don't mean the ones I date, I mean the ones I encounter at work, at meetup groups, etc.

I think if you're not fortunate enough to meet someone decent in your twenties or very early thirties and stay together, it really is slim pickings. This idea that OP, in her mid thirties, can leave a lovely man and find someone who is somehow more compatible....I just don't think it's likely. I left my last partner at 35 because I realised during lockdown that he was an abusive arsehole and I had no choice. I don't think I'd have left a decent guy just because he was a bit boring.

Arucanafeather · 18/06/2022 15:46

I agree with all you’ve said. I had a traumatic childhood and inside I thought I couldn’t trust anyone. I would be interested in someone until they showed interest back. My lovely DH told me straight away he like me. I told him I wasn’t interested for 6 months until someone else sent him a valentine’s card! He had spent the 6 months being the loveliest friend I had ever had and I realised I hated the thought of him being with someone else!

Arucanafeather · 18/06/2022 15:43

I always think a good way to start determining this is to think how you would feel if he was with someone else.
equally toss a coin : heads you stay, tails you leave. See how you feel when the coin lands. You will already know what you want to do somewhere inside I suspect.

Chooksnroses · 18/06/2022 15:42

Good relationships thrive on communication and compromise. You need to talk and make some agreements. For example He could agree to travel with you for one holiday if you agree to go with his choice the next time. Talking is the key!

DancinOnTheCeiling · 18/06/2022 15:41

@Daisyinchains
you say you’re 4 years into your first proper relationship and you’re mid 30s - IMO that’s fairly ‘old’ to have a first proper relationship. I don’t mean this in a judgmental way (I was not unsimilar); just wondering if you might have a fear of commitment which would be completely understandable given your history.

It’s very common for people with commitment problems to try to ‘find fault’ in their caring and stable partner, and it’s usually about things that aren’t that important. (I know as I was one of them - the ‘faults’ I found in DH were really unimportant things like the clothes he wore.. basically out of fear to get close to him I was looking for reasons why I couldn’t date him. I had to work very hard at allowing myself to fall for him, and my friends talked sense into me too). So for me, the question is, are things like he doesn’t love travelling and he’s a picky eater really important/deal breaker type things for you (and if they are that’s fair enough), or are they your ‘excuses’ for rejecting someone who is a great partner, out of commitment fear?

One other thing to consider is the flip side: commitment phobes often find normal/stable relationships boring and seek out partners who seem exciting/thrilling/adventurous (when often the partner only seems that way because they’re actually unavailable/game playing), ie the reason that partner seems so thrilling isn’t that they’re that amazing as a person but it’s more the fact that they’re not really truly available/committed that’s exciting …because that in turn means the commitment phobe doesn’t have to face their fear of commitment as they know with this super exciting person it’ll never really work out anyway. Again, thinking back, a number of the men I dated in the past seemed so exciting but it was more their non commital actions that seemed a ‘thrill’ (eg never quite knew when you’d hear from them type thing) which I now know was all to do with me being too scared to commit one of the ‘stable’ people that I classed as boring at the time.

Just something to consider..

dottypotter · 18/06/2022 15:38

D0lphine · 18/06/2022 14:47

I think you have to have a long hard think about what you want.

Personally I think you're very lucky to be in a relationship with someone kind and dependable, who shares hobbies with you and is respectful. Many people would kill for this. But if you aren't happy that's all there is to it!

Next thing to consider is do you want kids. If you want to try for kids, stay with mr dependable IMO. Does he want a family?

Of course, you can travel / work abroad with children but it does somewhat restrict you/ require more thought. But lots of people do it! So it might not be so polar opposite as you think!

Tell him where your head is at!

If you arent happy.

when do you become happy then.

dottypotter · 18/06/2022 15:37

Palmtreechacha · 18/06/2022 14:58

Thinking you are lucky because he’s not abusive is so sad to me. That’s the most basic requirement of what any decent man should be like! That’s not a reason to stay if you know deep down you aren’t in love with him. My concern for you would be you stay with him out of comfort and familiarity and all is fine until you meet someone who you have massive compatibility and fireworks with. Then what? You either dump him or continue in mediocrity full of regret that you let someone amazing slip away. Don’t let that happen - both of you deserve to be with someone who adores you and whom you adore back.

There are alot of abusive people around today, youve only got to look at relationship problems on boards like this. So yes its fortunate if you find someone kind and caring.

You dont ever find happiness or stability if you keep chasing the perfect person they dont exist.

dottypotter · 18/06/2022 15:35

Why do some people keep thinking the grass is greener on the other side.

If you have a great bloke hang onto him. So many horrible people around with issues, moving around dosent bring happiness or stability, the perfect person dosent exist.

Thelnebriati · 18/06/2022 15:02

@Daisyinchains You say he demands nothing, but also your choices about where you live are constrained because you have to live within an hour of his family.
Have you ever said 'no' about something that matters to him?

Palmtreechacha · 18/06/2022 14:58

Thinking you are lucky because he’s not abusive is so sad to me. That’s the most basic requirement of what any decent man should be like! That’s not a reason to stay if you know deep down you aren’t in love with him. My concern for you would be you stay with him out of comfort and familiarity and all is fine until you meet someone who you have massive compatibility and fireworks with. Then what? You either dump him or continue in mediocrity full of regret that you let someone amazing slip away. Don’t let that happen - both of you deserve to be with someone who adores you and whom you adore back.

pixie5121 · 18/06/2022 14:54

coffeecupsandfairylights · 18/06/2022 12:31

I mean this in the kindest way, but if you can't afford to rent or buy a bigger place, can you afford to travel and live abroad in the way you want?

What I mean is - are you going to leave a lovely, kind dependable man for what is just a pipe-dream due to financial restraints?

Not a very relevant point.

The cost of living vs salary ratio in the UK is appalling. You can have a much, much better life elsewhere on the same kind of salary. It's one of the things that does my head in about being here...I spend so much money and get so little back in terms of quality of life.

larkstar · 18/06/2022 14:53

Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater - you see some good positives in him and what you have so you need an on going dialogue - you have to put your points across to him and make sure he "gets" that these aims/dreams of yours are important - well - they seem important ATM. I tend to think that any relationship that is not in a constant state of tension - with each partner wanting to use the relationship as a secure anchor point from which to branch off from and try new things in life - is a bit dead. You should be having these exploratory conversations all through your life and relationship - you go off and try X and discover it's not everything you thought it would be but OTOH you and/or your partner might discover something you/they enjoy. Likewise - you might be able to support and encourage him to follow up on or even discover some ideas/dreams/ambitions he might have. More than anything - don't be afraid of these deep conversations about what you both want out of life - honesty is everything - if you can't be honest how can you trust or be trusted in a relationship - that feeling of trust and security that comes from it is better than anything in a relationship IMHO. Don't be afraid of these conversations being part of an on going dialogue - sometimes it takes time to win your partner over to something new. Try and remain optimistic that you can win him over and get him to try new things with you.

You're right IMHO - there is no perfect partner - and in any event you will both be changing during your relationship anyway due to mixing with different people at work and doing different jobs etc.. and because we change anyway so any relationship is constantly in a state of flux - that's why you need this on going deep dialogue, this constant negotiation to keep the pair of you roughly in synch - it's impossible top be perfectly in synch all the time but having a relationship where you can be open and totally honest with your partner really gives you the best chance of having a good life together. You've got to talk - don't give up in that. Ever.