Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave my kind and dependable DP

115 replies

Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 10:47

Currently living with DP of four years, we're both mid 30s. He's a lovely, loyal, demands nothing, kind, caring, hardworking, intelligent, funny, cheerful. I'm happy with him. However. I'm quite adventurous and like travel, trying new things, would like to live abroad again etc etc. We do go out hiking and cycling together a lot, but he is more of a sit at home watching TV type. Picky eater, eats the same food every day. Wants to go on same UK holidays every year. Wants to stay living in the same area he grew up in and where he plays in a sports team. I wonder if these differences are a sign I should leave? Or is it normal to have to compromise on something like this?

To be honest it's my first proper relationship and I always had a fear of ending up with someone like my father (physically and verbally abusive). I feel like I've lucked out simply finding someone who doesn't have an angry or aggressive bone in his body, genuinely cares for me, who I have interests and a moral compass in common with, and who I can be myself with. There's no perfect partner right?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dreamingbohemian · 19/06/2022 23:33

Rotherweird · 19/06/2022 15:58

OP, to me it seems like you are actually in a really strong position: you have an DP who is kind and loving and that you enjoy spending time with. But you also know that you would be ok - more than ok! - on your own.

Why not take the problem to your DP - tell him that you have a strong need to move to a new area, where housing is more affordable, life is more exciting, and there are more chances to meet like minded people. You'd love to do this with him, but if he feels that he must stay in the area you are currently in, that's a deal breaker for you.

Either he is willing to take a risk and move away from his family/area - or he's not and you can go ahead and do it alone. Either seems like a much better outcome than your current situation, which is really limiting you.

I agree with this

OP you are still so young. Way too young to be bored stiff in commuterville! You could live anywhere, and have such an interesting life.

I was your age when I moved countries and started a whole new life. It's actually a great time to make major changes, you're still young but wiser than your youth.

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 22:15

Having RTFT it’s abundantly clear that this isn’t working.
Is he expecting to spend your whole life in a tiny rented flat?

AryaStarkWolf · 19/06/2022 16:51

SamBeckettslastleap · 18/06/2022 11:05

I married in my 20's and I didn't know who I was, by my 30's I had found out but was already enmeshed with mortgage and children.

my dh is a very decent guy but I'm waiting to leave, I want to fly and he wants to nest. I wouldn't choose to live this life if I'd known what I wanted.

You deserve more than just a non violent man.

That's pretty unfair on your DH, if you're planning to leave in the future why not leave now and give him the option of finding someone who actually wants to be with him now?

WalkingOnTheCracks · 19/06/2022 16:17

My OH loves to travel. Me, I'm happy with a couple of weeks in Italy every year. I mean, I've travelled a lot - but I just don't really want to any more.

Apparently we're not the only couple who have this mismatch of aspirations. So the OH sods off for a week at a time with people who like want to go to Miami or Morocco, and I stay at home with the kids and make pasta and slouch about, which I enjoy.

Works for us.

Rotherweird · 19/06/2022 15:58

OP, to me it seems like you are actually in a really strong position: you have an DP who is kind and loving and that you enjoy spending time with. But you also know that you would be ok - more than ok! - on your own.

Why not take the problem to your DP - tell him that you have a strong need to move to a new area, where housing is more affordable, life is more exciting, and there are more chances to meet like minded people. You'd love to do this with him, but if he feels that he must stay in the area you are currently in, that's a deal breaker for you.

Either he is willing to take a risk and move away from his family/area - or he's not and you can go ahead and do it alone. Either seems like a much better outcome than your current situation, which is really limiting you.

goldfinchonthelawn · 19/06/2022 15:37

OP, did you post a few months ago about being bored rigid working from home in a tiny flat in a dull area and wishing you could move but partner won't? Sounds like a similar set up. If it was you I think you need to accept that you are seriously and pretty permanently unhappy with your current lot in life and make some changes.

billy1966 · 19/06/2022 15:29

pixie5121 · 19/06/2022 12:02

But he IS holding you back.

Insisting on living within an hour of his parents, in an expensive, high COL area is holding you back. He's getting everything he wants and you're not.

I was in your exact position and it ended, not through choice, but I am now glad it ended, even though I'm 37 and single now. He got married and had a kid but I'm not jealous of him. If anything, I feel like I dodged a bullet. I realised after we broke up that he was controlling in his own way. His insistence on conforming, on only doing 'normal' things was stifling, and it was only getting worse the older he got. He's still working in the exact same place, with only a slight promotion in a decade. Still hanging out with the exact same people. He seems to take pride in never changing and staying the same. I can't fathom not growing and changing and I struggle to understand people who have no interest in considering a life beyond what they've always known. The lack of curiosity and ambition bothers me, and you sound the same.

You're living in a cramped flat in boring commuterville because of him. Is he even aware you're making such a sacrifice? My ex wasn't. He tried to write a narrative where I was demanding and selfish for asking for a few small things, like taking 2 weeks off and going hiking in the Pyrenees, completely oblivious to the sacrifices I made every single day to be in the relationship. If it wasn't for your partner, you could be living in a detached cottage in rural Wales, going for countryside walks every lunchtime, or living in a lower COL city like Sheffield, with much more disposable income for travel and adventure.

It seems like the question to ask is, which is more important, settling down and having a family or having the adventurous, exciting life you want? You can't have both with this man.

Until you realise that your relationship is ALL about HIS needs, you are never going to find yourself in a position where you can move forward.

You are stuck.
He is not moving anywhere.
You are compromising on so much for this man who wants everything his own way.

pixie5121 · 19/06/2022 12:02

Daisyinchains · 19/06/2022 10:15

No he's not holding me back - the location/place we live in is stifling me. I want to be with him but I don't want us to be isolated together in a tiny flat in a commuter belt island any more. Remote work means we don't need to be tied to this area any more!

His parents live on the south coast and he doesn't want to be any more than an hour from them, and he wants to continue playing for a sports team he loves and has played with for 10 years. But we can't afford to move anywhere bigger/more practical in the vicinity. We could afford an actual house in a nice area with enough room for us both to work from home, if we moved further away in literally any other direction. But he doesn't want that. I think he's only ever known London/surrounding area and can't broaden his horizons.

But he IS holding you back.

Insisting on living within an hour of his parents, in an expensive, high COL area is holding you back. He's getting everything he wants and you're not.

I was in your exact position and it ended, not through choice, but I am now glad it ended, even though I'm 37 and single now. He got married and had a kid but I'm not jealous of him. If anything, I feel like I dodged a bullet. I realised after we broke up that he was controlling in his own way. His insistence on conforming, on only doing 'normal' things was stifling, and it was only getting worse the older he got. He's still working in the exact same place, with only a slight promotion in a decade. Still hanging out with the exact same people. He seems to take pride in never changing and staying the same. I can't fathom not growing and changing and I struggle to understand people who have no interest in considering a life beyond what they've always known. The lack of curiosity and ambition bothers me, and you sound the same.

You're living in a cramped flat in boring commuterville because of him. Is he even aware you're making such a sacrifice? My ex wasn't. He tried to write a narrative where I was demanding and selfish for asking for a few small things, like taking 2 weeks off and going hiking in the Pyrenees, completely oblivious to the sacrifices I made every single day to be in the relationship. If it wasn't for your partner, you could be living in a detached cottage in rural Wales, going for countryside walks every lunchtime, or living in a lower COL city like Sheffield, with much more disposable income for travel and adventure.

It seems like the question to ask is, which is more important, settling down and having a family or having the adventurous, exciting life you want? You can't have both with this man.

Daisyinchains · 19/06/2022 10:15

Merryclaire · 18/06/2022 22:39

You say you are adventurous and he isn’t, but is he actually holding you back or are you just blaming him for feeling like you’re not doing enough with your life?

You don’t need to share every adventure with him - if you really wanted to go to interesting places and eat exotic food you’d do it. And you just might find he would follow your lead.

Point is, you control how you live your life, not him. So if you’re not enjoying yourself enough, then you are responsible for that.

If you love him then he sounds like a great partner and you should focus on why you really aren’t doing the things you want. But if you don’t love him then let him be with someone else.

No he's not holding me back - the location/place we live in is stifling me. I want to be with him but I don't want us to be isolated together in a tiny flat in a commuter belt island any more. Remote work means we don't need to be tied to this area any more!

His parents live on the south coast and he doesn't want to be any more than an hour from them, and he wants to continue playing for a sports team he loves and has played with for 10 years. But we can't afford to move anywhere bigger/more practical in the vicinity. We could afford an actual house in a nice area with enough room for us both to work from home, if we moved further away in literally any other direction. But he doesn't want that. I think he's only ever known London/surrounding area and can't broaden his horizons.

OP posts:
Merryclaire · 18/06/2022 22:39

You say you are adventurous and he isn’t, but is he actually holding you back or are you just blaming him for feeling like you’re not doing enough with your life?

You don’t need to share every adventure with him - if you really wanted to go to interesting places and eat exotic food you’d do it. And you just might find he would follow your lead.

Point is, you control how you live your life, not him. So if you’re not enjoying yourself enough, then you are responsible for that.

If you love him then he sounds like a great partner and you should focus on why you really aren’t doing the things you want. But if you don’t love him then let him be with someone else.

qpmz · 18/06/2022 21:47

Are you in love with him? Does he make you laugh? Do you want the same things when it comes to the future?

TheWayoftheLeaf · 18/06/2022 21:34

AnnaMagnani · 18/06/2022 18:24

There is not much anywhere for young women without kids!

The only way forwards is to pick out interest groups (or not actually that interested groups) and be determined. And not be put of if the first one or six you try are damp squibs.

In terms of cooking, I'd recommend Delia or Mary Berry to get away from beige oven food. A gentle expansion on the world of meat and potatoes. From there you can drift to Italian, Spanish, French... He may never make it to eating a curry for pleasure but you have already moved his horizons enormously.

My MIL was shocked when she discovered DH was having vegetarian food for dinner and looking forward to it! Definitely a home where meat, potatoes and veg boiled to a pulp were the norm.

Lol. Bars, cafes, libraries, clubs. Do you think childless young women just sit at home?

Rheia1983 · 18/06/2022 21:27

OP, you say your partner understands you, you can be yourself with him and that you enjoy spending time with him. If this is so, why do you want to leave?

Could it be that you have more of an issue with being open to intimacy and relationships due to your childhood experiences?

Speaking for myself, I have a great DP and we have been together for three years. Yet, my mind constantly is trying to find reasons to leave.

Why? I have a highly ambivalent attitude to realtionships. The reason is childhood abuse and abandonment. So I am dealing with stubborn belief that I'll be abandoned and I prefer being alone because that feels safer. My wanting to leave despite loving my DP is actually an self protective yet unproductive thought process.

Do you love your DP?

pixie5121 · 18/06/2022 21:06

Feel free to drop me a PM if you leave him and he wants another girlfriend 😂

IsThePopeCatholic · 18/06/2022 20:43

He sounds great. I think you’d be mad to leave him.

GetThatHelmetOn · 18/06/2022 20:32

He's very supportive and would be totally fine with me going away for a few months travelling or working overseas. He'd never stop me doing anything. I think secretly he'd be a bit sad though

That sounds great. I wouldn’t leave a man who is generous enough to respect your freedom.

Now, if you are bored and no longer love him, it is better to leave no matter how good he is.

Daisyinchains · 18/06/2022 20:07

I likely won't have kids in all honesty, for many reasons, and I'm fine with that.

@psychomath I've also assumed my whole life I would always be single, and was pretty content with it. I've never bothered with dating or anything. DP is pretty much the only guy who gets me and who I enjoy spending every day with. If we split I'd fully expect to be single forever. (I'm not afraid of that though).

OP posts:
m00rfarm · 18/06/2022 18:55

Why not tell him that you are about to end the relationship due to these reasons. I am sure he does not think you are perfect either! Alternatively, if he is happy for you to go on adventures without him, maybe that would also work.

SleepingStandingUp · 18/06/2022 18:53

There is not much anywhere for young women without kids! bar day time play groups surely there's everything there is for women with kids but without childcare issues

AnnaMagnani · 18/06/2022 18:24

There is not much anywhere for young women without kids!

The only way forwards is to pick out interest groups (or not actually that interested groups) and be determined. And not be put of if the first one or six you try are damp squibs.

In terms of cooking, I'd recommend Delia or Mary Berry to get away from beige oven food. A gentle expansion on the world of meat and potatoes. From there you can drift to Italian, Spanish, French... He may never make it to eating a curry for pleasure but you have already moved his horizons enormously.

My MIL was shocked when she discovered DH was having vegetarian food for dinner and looking forward to it! Definitely a home where meat, potatoes and veg boiled to a pulp were the norm.

IRunbecauseILikeCake · 18/06/2022 18:13

I think these threads are always tough because we are just a bunch of strangers on the Internet and our own experiences and desires will all colour what we say.
This is your life. Will you be happy with this man or will you always have a little feeling in the back of your mind that you're not fully happy?
He sounds like a great man, and if beige oven food as you put it was how he was raised, maybe he doesn't know how to really cook, and that can be worked on. I grew up a beige oven food person but now aged 30, having been with my DH for nearly 11 years, I have become a massive foodie. He was very unadventurous when it came to travel and going to gigs and we have seen lots of places together and love a good concert.
Sometimes we can bring the best out in eschother in relationships if we are both open minded, but you know you and him and what's going on deep down and whether you can happily compromise on things.

larkstar · 18/06/2022 18:08

@Daisyinchains "It's just very limiting."

It has to be a compromise - I think - you shouldn't start living your life as their carers now - that's what it might be in a good few years time - now more than ever is your chance to live your own life - the feeling of the need to be close might be a lot stronger and more justified when his parents are older, infirm, possibly suffering from dementia/Alzheimers etc - you shouldn't let this excuse - that he needs to be near his parents - limit what you do in life as a couple - extend that argument and he may as well move back in with them.

psychomath · 18/06/2022 17:58

I didn't pursue a serious relationship with a guy who sounds a lot like your partner, even though he would have been perfect in every other way and everyone who knew us was convinced we'd end up together, because I knew that years down the line I'd find myself in the same position. I also knew that if I ever did meet someone more 'exciting' I'd be tempted to stray, and thought it would be better for all concerned not even to allow that scenario to arise in the first place. Years later we're still best friends, with occasional benefits when he's single, and I have no regrets whatsoever - trying to convince myself I could compromise when I couldn't would only have led to heartache for both of us. I realise it's not the same as when you're already in a relationship, but that's the perspective I'm coming from.

In my case I think the key was that I was already sure I didn't want children, and I also knew I'd rather be single forever than in a relationship where I felt constrained. To be honest I'd always sort of assumed I wouldn't ever meet someone who'd be compatible with me, and if a person came along who was then that would be a bonus rather than an expectation. That's what you need to consider, I think. The world is overflowing with men who love novelty, travel and adventure and would probably be thrilled to meet a woman with similar interests, but as PPs have said, in my experience very few of them make good long term partners or are willing to settle down if and when you decide that's what you do want after all. So if you leave your current partner, it's best to do so on the assumption that you won't have a family and you'll end up long term single or in serial short term relationships rather than the traditional marriage til death us do part scenario, and a lot depends on how you feel about that.

Another thing to consider is how you'd feel about the worst case scenarios if you did break up. Would you be alright if he decided he never wanted any contact with you again? What if he moved on really quickly, or five years down the line you hadn't met anyone and he'd married someone else and had kids with them? If any of that would eat you up inside then you need to think carefully, because none of those situations are especially unlikely. And if none of it would then it doesn't sound like the relationship has much of a future anyway.

(As a side point, I expect you've already thought about this but as you haven't explicitly mentioned it, everything you've said is also something to factor into your decision as to whether you do want children. They are almost certainly going to place a lot more limits on your freedom than your choice of partner!)

balalake · 18/06/2022 17:44

I think were you to leave you should be prepared for never meeting another man who is at least as pleasant as your DP. So assume were you to leave that you could be single for your whole remaining life. That is no crime if you would be happy with that.

SomewhereEast · 18/06/2022 17:33

I do think he needs to meet you half way on this, because that's part of being in a relationship. To take a trivial-ish example, why should you both only holiday in the UK because that's what he wants? My DH was quite unadventurous about stuff like travel & food when we first met, but to his credit he actually listened & engaged when I said that I felt our life together felt a bit constrained. Fifteen years on he now actually enjoys travel well the travel we now get to do anyway & trying a wider range of stuff, and would say his early reluctance to try new things was lack of self-confidence + habit based on upbringing (his parents are very staid & stay at home).