Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child Carers

137 replies

prepared101 · 18/06/2022 09:28

I've named changed because I'm aware this is emotive and I'm prepared to be flamed by some who wholeheartedly disagree with me but...

I've just seen a post a large Facebook group where a poster talks about their 7 year old child who has been her carer since the age of 3. THREE.

My 4 nearly 5 year old has asked me a million things already this morning including could I make them a drink, make their breakfast, help them put their swimming costume on etc etc. How on Earth is a three year old a carer FFS. Even at 10/11/13 etc a child doesn't have the emotional resilience to take on someone else's struggles.

IMO it's stealing a childhood and should be illegal. I can't believe that in this day and age we think that's acceptable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SpaceJamtart · 18/06/2022 15:56

Peoniesandcream · 18/06/2022 15:47

I really disagree with child carers. It's neglectful, selfish and shouldn't be allowed. Let children have childhoods fgs.

These attitudes are the ones that really sucked when I was growing up.

People who don't understand, look down at your parents for being "neglectful" just for daring to have a disability and also raise children.

You are not the authority on what constitutes having a good childhood.

lovelychops · 18/06/2022 15:53

Peoniesandcream · 18/06/2022 15:47

I really disagree with child carers. It's neglectful, selfish and shouldn't be allowed. Let children have childhoods fgs.

It's rarely a choice!!!!!! No one knows what the future holds and circumstances can change.
My daughter is classed as a child carer to her brother who has special needs. It doesn't mean we sit back and let her do everything!! It means she helps out in ways her peers probably don't have to and his condition effects us as a whole. For example he doesn't sleep well at all = it effects us all the next day.
Good god. The ignorance on this thread

Comedycook · 18/06/2022 15:53

It's appalling really. They must save the government an absolute fortune at the expense of their own childhood. Terrible.

ChagSameachDoreen · 18/06/2022 15:52

I'm heavily opposed to child carers. It's child labour.

Simonjt · 18/06/2022 15:51

Young carer covers a huge spectrum, my son would technically be classed as a young carer because he sometimes helps with little things like putting on some socks, or helping to get a jacket onto properly.

Even when a younger carer is doing quite a lot, it doesn’t mean their childhood is ruined, it also doesn’t mean they should be removed from their care or their parents should have forced abortions, which is what would be happening if being a young carer was illegal.

Peoniesandcream · 18/06/2022 15:47

I really disagree with child carers. It's neglectful, selfish and shouldn't be allowed. Let children have childhoods fgs.

lovelychops · 18/06/2022 15:39

Often these situations don't rise out of nowhere or choice. I think it's incredibly naive to assume so much about a families circumstances.
Child carers can be classified as such for caring for siblings with special needs, or elderly grandparents. It doesn't happen because parents don't give a shit and leave all the caring to the child - more often than not it comes through circumstances you have no control over. It's certainly not something a parent wants for their child.

SpaceJamtart · 18/06/2022 15:33

YABU

You don't get to decide whose childhood is ruined because you know there is disability involved.

I was a young carer, for a disabled parent and several disabled siblings.
It is hard it can be very hard but when I was growing up in the 90s and 2000s there was government support and support from my schools that lessened the effects of the practical side of being a carer as a child.I had opportunities given to me that gave me time to be a kid.

On the emotional side I had present, loving, caring parents and a big family of people who despite having severe disabilities, loved me.
I knew I was loved, i was still cared for.
I had a good and happy childhood, sometimes more so than my friends who were not carers. Because my family was around me and always at home. My disabled parent still taught me to read and read me bedtime stories. It doesn't ruin a childhood to also care for other people.

Its harder when there is less government support like there is now and its harder when nobody knows or cares.
But I grew up well, I grew up happy and knowing where I belonged. I may have not had the same chances as some of my peers and some things were much harder. But there are positives to childhoods like mine.

Young carers dont need your pity or to have their homelife be declared illegal. We needed support, (specifically the government schemes from the early 2000s that were brilliant), we needed adequate benefits and housing.
we needed people to not make assumptions about ours and our parents lives that do not help, but just further demonise disabled people and those who claim benefits. As honestly it was people with those attitudes that caused me more harm than my disabled family ever did.

Thelnebriati · 18/06/2022 14:34

@Yesitsmeagainhey Direct your comments to the OP. Maybe the two of you can work out a solution to the 'problem' of disabled parents needing carers.

Prokupatuscrakedatus · 18/06/2022 14:33

In other countries most of the activities mentioned would be classed as "the expected help with the running of a household within the limits posed by age and abilities."

Yesitsmeagainhey · 18/06/2022 14:13

@Thelnebriati

What exactly do you mean by “sterilise the disabled women”?

That’s a very generalised sweeping statement that:

a) all women are fertile
b) all disabled women are able and willing to reproduce using their own eggs

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 18/06/2022 14:01

My dc are technically carers for me. DH does most of what I need help with but if he's busy or away, the dc help. I can't carry things up or down the stairs for example so one of them will carry my water bottle up before bed or they might unload the washing machine or one of them might accompany me somewhere to help carry things.

Thelnebriati · 18/06/2022 13:55

IMO it's stealing a childhood and should be illegal.

Many disabled adults would agree with you; but you let the Govt cut services to the bone because you fell for the line that people were claiming benefits for imaginary illnesses.

So what are you going to do about it? There are only two options; sterilise disabled women and take their children away, or campaign for better services. Pick one and do it.

JustLyra · 18/06/2022 13:52

Carer has a very wide ranging meaning though.

My DN is 4 and knows that if his Mummy has a seizure he should press the button on the phone that rings a specific person and tell them where she is.

He’s classes as a young carer, but he isn’t losing his childhood or anything else.

My kids are classed as young carers because they have a severely disabled sibling. They don’t actually do any caring activities as such, but as a family their life is dictated by her health so their opportunities are sometimes limited which classes them as such.

The scale is wide ranging and when you don’t remotely know what the child does it’s daft to get so OTT when it may be very little. And if it’s not very little the ire should be directed at those who’ve slashed services repeatedly so that people have to rely on their children as they’ve no other access to help.

Yesitsmeagainhey · 18/06/2022 13:40

When she was 3, she was putting my socks and shoes on me in winter. She was helping me pull up my trousers & getting my crutches for me.

At 5 she had a list of names and numbers on the fridge door and illustrations of how to use the phone (in case she had forgotten when in panic mode) on who to call in case of emergency. These people are all within a 3 minute drive and reliable and know of my health situation.

At age 7 she can use the front door key and God forbid if she ever needed to, knows which doors (safe place) to go to in our hamlet. She cuts my food up and can turn the hob on and off, she can do the online food shop as we discuss it together and she can make her own (healthy or unhealthy, depends on the day and mood!) packed lunches.

Her school report was amazing. She is thriving, loves challenges, is high-achieving, is well rounded and we have a laugh when things go wrong at home. It’s about balance and proportion here for us. I’m lucky to have the support in place to enable her to attend the extra curriculum activities she wishes.

A lot of it is about being pro-active and the government are decades behind on this. I can’t begin to explain where they have failed us both.

Isaidnoalready · 18/06/2022 13:14

Honestly at three my sister was told where nanny kept her meds in case of an angina attack when I was younger I knew where dad kept his blue inhaler and when to get it how many puffs we were l taught how to dial 999 and our home address if we couldn't wake out adult up right from a young age even as young as three on a rotary phone it's easy you don't even need to "know" the number just the position and give your address to the lady on the phone tell them daddy/nanny won't wake up etc etc it was classed as basic life skills in first school (nine and under) we were taught lifesaving skills basic mouth to mouth the recovery position how to rescue someone from a river it didn't feel like a stolen childhood rather the expectation of a life well lived

JessicaPeach · 18/06/2022 13:08

I saw this post too and was surprised.

Testina · 18/06/2022 13:05

“Well the detail was that he had was described as her carer and she suffered seizures and exhaustion so if say more than fetching a blanket occasionally”

No need for the eye roll, thanks.

So no detail at all of what he was doing to provide care at 3 years old then?

OneEyedPenguin · 18/06/2022 12:43

Yes, there are. Hard choices but there are choices

What are these hard choices?

ChickenGotLegs · 18/06/2022 12:33

prepared101 · 18/06/2022 09:28

I've named changed because I'm aware this is emotive and I'm prepared to be flamed by some who wholeheartedly disagree with me but...

I've just seen a post a large Facebook group where a poster talks about their 7 year old child who has been her carer since the age of 3. THREE.

My 4 nearly 5 year old has asked me a million things already this morning including could I make them a drink, make their breakfast, help them put their swimming costume on etc etc. How on Earth is a three year old a carer FFS. Even at 10/11/13 etc a child doesn't have the emotional resilience to take on someone else's struggles.

IMO it's stealing a childhood and should be illegal. I can't believe that in this day and age we think that's acceptable.

AIBU?

I seen this exact post too... About the bedroom.

Must admit I was also surprised at their kid being a carer since 3...what on earth could they have been doing at 3yo!

ghostyslovesheets · 18/06/2022 12:29

I'm interested in that these 'hard choices' are OP - can you elaborate?

OneFrenchEgg · 18/06/2022 12:13

Having a disabled child takes far more away from their siblings than just being in a small or large family.

OneFrenchEgg · 18/06/2022 12:11

In a family with two children if one is disabled, the other is classed as a young carer, yet they will get far more attention than a child in a family with four children when none of them has a disability

I have four children. One became disabled and I can assure you the others have far less attention and support then when none of them were disabled.

prepared101 · 18/06/2022 12:02

Testina · 18/06/2022 10:58

Right, but do you actually have any detail?

This 3yo was not shopping and cooking for her mother, or taking her to appointments.

So most likely the poster was meaning that the pre-schooler had done some activity for her mother. Which could be nothing more than fetching a blanket for her, on occasions.

I don’t want to minimise the huge burden that is put on young carers and the amazing work they do, but I think you’re over reacting to something with no actual information 🤷🏻‍♀️

Well the detail was that he had was described as her carer and she suffered seizures and exhaustion so if say more than fetching a blanket occasionally Hmm

Regardless, I worry that these children will never live independent and fulfilled lives and that's sad.

OP posts:
idontevenknowanyonecalledblurb · 18/06/2022 11:31

I saw this post this morning and wondered the same- what a life for that poor child