Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child Carers

137 replies

prepared101 · 18/06/2022 09:28

I've named changed because I'm aware this is emotive and I'm prepared to be flamed by some who wholeheartedly disagree with me but...

I've just seen a post a large Facebook group where a poster talks about their 7 year old child who has been her carer since the age of 3. THREE.

My 4 nearly 5 year old has asked me a million things already this morning including could I make them a drink, make their breakfast, help them put their swimming costume on etc etc. How on Earth is a three year old a carer FFS. Even at 10/11/13 etc a child doesn't have the emotional resilience to take on someone else's struggles.

IMO it's stealing a childhood and should be illegal. I can't believe that in this day and age we think that's acceptable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
BadNomad · 18/06/2022 17:47

That is not that uncommon, sadly. Me and the couple of friends I had as a child were what you call young carers now. One girl's mother was in a wheelchair after she had a stroke during a tonsillectomy, so with her it was a lot of practical help.

Me and my best friend had mothers with severe mental health problems who didn't even get out of bed some days. So we did everything for our brothers (who both have autism), left sandwiches for other mothers, then took ourselves to school to sit and worry about what was going on at home in our absence.

There was no help. It was just life. You got on with it. Only looking back as an adult do we see how sad and fucked-up it was. I think this is the reality for a lot of children. People pity you, but no one cares really.

Sparklybutold · 18/06/2022 17:30

Only now as an adult do I recognise that I was a carer. I cared for my dad, the home and my older brothers. I cooked, cleaned, shopped, booked doc app, etc. My mum died when I was 2. I distinctly remember ironing mine and my dads stuff at the age of 5. I would wake at 6am at primary school age to start chores, cooking breakfast, ensuring my dads work stuff was ready, and then the same after school. My dad was a narcassist and an alcoholic. I had an awful childhood.

Artwodeetoo · 18/06/2022 17:23

Cameleongirl · 18/06/2022 17:06

@Artwodeetoo It sounds as if your friend was hugely let down by the other adults ( not her Mum) in her life. What did her other parent do to support her, for example?

She doesn't know who her father is. Her mother was very much us against the world at the detriment to her daughters education, chance to enjoy being a child with no responsibilities, social life (yes I believe that's important growing up). I met her when she was a teen and my parents would help her mum out so she could have a break and she eventually moved in with us at 16. I'm not suggesting at all everyone is like this, i would guess probably the tiny minority are. There's a difference between doing groceries, helping with siblings (although you don't choose to have them so shouldn't be a child's responsibility imo), helping occasionally and a parent relying on their child for a lot to their detriment.

jamoncrumpets · 18/06/2022 17:15

My 4yo DD is classed as a child carer. She has an autistic sibling and loses out on attention and some experiences that her peers do, despite our best efforts. It's an umbrella term for siblings of disabled children, or children of disabled parents.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 18/06/2022 17:06

@Yesitsmeagainhey I read the post about sterilising disabled women as the poster saying the choices are to do something extraordinary unpalatable or support them, and the only choice therefore is to support them. I really don't think she was advocating it.

Cameleongirl · 18/06/2022 17:06

@Artwodeetoo It sounds as if your friend was hugely let down by the other adults ( not her Mum) in her life. What did her other parent do to support her, for example?

Sleepingsatellite1 · 18/06/2022 17:02

ghostyslovesheets · 18/06/2022 16:50

But then no one should have children in case they get ill? Disabilities and conditions requiring care happen at all stages of life - MS, depression, CFS, FM , cancer, accidents - all things that can mean people need help.
My onw child has an acquired brain injury because of illness

As I said I was presuming this is what the OP meant not that it was my opinion

Geneviev · 18/06/2022 17:00

And for what it’s worth I’m not talking about kids who sometimes need to help with the shopping etc. the ones my mum works with are the ones who eventually stop attending school. Because they are running the household, caring for the parent and sometimes younger siblings.

Yesitsmeagainhey · 18/06/2022 16:56

This level of narrow-mindedness & discrimination on threads like this make me so grateful and appreciative that my DD is so open to seeing people for their flaws and weaknesses and embracing someone as a whole complete person for the good in them 🥰

Artwodeetoo · 18/06/2022 16:53

The biggest issue is that there isn't sufficient support for people to access carers and other services that would enable them to carry out day to day tasks. This means that family are the only choice, it someone doesn't have a partner and other family members who can help it invariably does fall on children. The alternative is of course very unpalatable and in a civilised country shouldn't be the case; but I also think its unfair. My best friend was a carer for her mum, she's pretty fucked up because of it to be honest and missed out on a lot of things growing up because she had to be at home. It's an unfair expectation to put on a child tbh as they won't have any actual choice or any escape- there's also the emotional element of course that they feel they have to help as they don't want a parent to suffer- but there's a price for that.

Yesitsmeagainhey · 18/06/2022 16:53

@Thelnebriati I’m asking YOU the question because it was YOUR comment 🙄😵‍💫 If you feel you can’t provide a legitimate response, maybe don’t insult with a nonsense piece of waffle.

Do YOU think “disabled” ie people with limited mobility should be sterilised? Would you same the same for those with mental health impairments?

Geneviev · 18/06/2022 16:52

No obviously no one can predict the future and that’s an entirely different kettle of fish. But that’s where we need the powers that be, to step in. It shouldn’t ever fall to a child.

ghostyslovesheets · 18/06/2022 16:50

Sleepingsatellite1 · 18/06/2022 16:45

I’m presuming here but is it a reference to not choosing to have children?

But then no one should have children in case they get ill? Disabilities and conditions requiring care happen at all stages of life - MS, depression, CFS, FM , cancer, accidents - all things that can mean people need help.
My onw child has an acquired brain injury because of illness

Geneviev · 18/06/2022 16:49

Well…I mean you shouldn’t be having a child on the basis that that child is going to be your carer, no.

my mum works with child carers, and this situation is more common than I would have liked to believe.

no one is saying sterilise they disabled. But having a child in the full knowledge that they will need to care for you is wrong. You need a new plan.

Sleepingsatellite1 · 18/06/2022 16:45

ghostyslovesheets · 18/06/2022 12:29

I'm interested in that these 'hard choices' are OP - can you elaborate?

I’m presuming here but is it a reference to not choosing to have children?

prepared101 · 18/06/2022 16:42

UnbeatenMum · 18/06/2022 16:18

At 3 it could just be passing the parent things though or helping to put shopping away or knowing what to do if the parent had a seizure. My 2yo can empty the dishwasher and put almost everything away in the right place, the difference is that I don't need him to because I'm not disabled, he just enjoys doing it. But I don't see why a 3yo couldn't do some basic tasks like that.

Really?

My 15 year old son still struggles to do this without moaning or being nagged

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 18/06/2022 16:18

While I agree that the government is partly responsible for these situations, I still think that it’s partly a societal problem if the other adults in the child’s life don’t step up to help them. Their other parent and relatives should do what they can to help the child, for example. If they don’t, they’re failing them, tbh.

UnbeatenMum · 18/06/2022 16:18

At 3 it could just be passing the parent things though or helping to put shopping away or knowing what to do if the parent had a seizure. My 2yo can empty the dishwasher and put almost everything away in the right place, the difference is that I don't need him to because I'm not disabled, he just enjoys doing it. But I don't see why a 3yo couldn't do some basic tasks like that.

Cameleongirl · 18/06/2022 16:11

My main question would be where are the other adults in the child’s life? How is the other parent supporting their child? Are other relatives supporting them too?

The disabled parent can’t help their condition, but other adults can assist and do their best to ensure that the child has sone relief from their caring responsibilities.

My Mum had a chronic condition that meant that she was physically unable to care for me at times. I did a lot for her when she had a flare-up, but my parents were together so my Dad did as well and sone of their friends pitched in. Family members were a bit useless, tbh.

She was an amazing Mum ❤️

JustLyra · 18/06/2022 16:02

ChagSameachDoreen · 18/06/2022 15:52

I'm heavily opposed to child carers. It's child labour.

And yet people have stood by and watched governments successively decimate the people welfare system and support systems that would minimise the weight on the children and siblings of the ill and disabled.

i mean, you could report any situations you feel are really bad to social services, but since they’ve also been decimated it’s unlikely to get anywhere.

SpaceJamtart · 18/06/2022 16:02

ChagSameachDoreen · 18/06/2022 15:52

I'm heavily opposed to child carers. It's child labour.

It's not it's really not

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 18/06/2022 16:00

My Dd was my Carer from age 8, not much choice in it really.
If you think I was ok with it, you are wrong.

lovelychops · 18/06/2022 16:00

Peoniesandcream · 18/06/2022 15:57

@lovelychops it's not ignorance, me ex SIL had 2 children classed as carers, her disability was there before she had them...

So you're implying that disabled adults should not have children ?
I was also referring to the ignorance this thread as there seems to be a large misunderstanding about what the criteria for being a child carer is. Eg siblings as previously mentioned

Peoniesandcream · 18/06/2022 15:57

@lovelychops it's not ignorance, me ex SIL had 2 children classed as carers, her disability was there before she had them...

hulahooper2 · 18/06/2022 15:56

I’m in the same fb group , I know there are lots of young carers , but my mind boggles at a 3 year old , do you think it’s true