Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child Carers

137 replies

prepared101 · 18/06/2022 09:28

I've named changed because I'm aware this is emotive and I'm prepared to be flamed by some who wholeheartedly disagree with me but...

I've just seen a post a large Facebook group where a poster talks about their 7 year old child who has been her carer since the age of 3. THREE.

My 4 nearly 5 year old has asked me a million things already this morning including could I make them a drink, make their breakfast, help them put their swimming costume on etc etc. How on Earth is a three year old a carer FFS. Even at 10/11/13 etc a child doesn't have the emotional resilience to take on someone else's struggles.

IMO it's stealing a childhood and should be illegal. I can't believe that in this day and age we think that's acceptable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:45

@Discovereads you should have been provided with carers to help you dress then shouldn't you if there's no suitable adult around.

Discovereads · 19/06/2022 12:41

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:08

@lovelychops I'm not implying anything. But people who can't look after a child shouldn't have them, no. If you can't look after yourself, you can't look after a child properly. If you need care after having children, hire carers. UK councils also offer care for people, don't use your children.

Oh, so as a mother of 4 DC once working FT and being the primary breadwinner. After being disabled by a neglectful driver running me over, such that I lost my ability to work, which then meant we could not pay the mortgage and so were forced to sell our home and go back to renting. And then the year long battle for disability benefits meaning we literally had to sell most of our possessions so we could buy food because my DHs wages only covered rent and bills.

Good to know we should have simply “hired some carers” in that situation. That we are so horrible for “using our children” to help my DH care for me by doing age appropriate household tasks and things like help me dress or bring me a tray of food, or help me learn to read again.

PashunFroot · 19/06/2022 12:40

I saw this post, it was very sad. 3 is very young to be dealing with seizures.

Simonjt · 19/06/2022 12:38

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:37

@Simonjt were you unable to provide care in that case? Any other adult family/ friends?

What care do you think councils, charties, gps or SS will provide?

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:38

They should supply support, that's my point.

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:37

@Simonjt were you unable to provide care in that case? Any other adult family/ friends?

Simonjt · 19/06/2022 12:37

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:36

If you can't afford private care, go through GP/ council/ charities/ social services. It still should never fall to children.

And what exactly do you think councils, charities or social services will supply?

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:36

If you can't afford private care, go through GP/ council/ charities/ social services. It still should never fall to children.

Simonjt · 19/06/2022 12:29

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:08

@lovelychops I'm not implying anything. But people who can't look after a child shouldn't have them, no. If you can't look after yourself, you can't look after a child properly. If you need care after having children, hire carers. UK councils also offer care for people, don't use your children.

Which council provided care do you access?

My husband needed care a few years ago, he has arthrogryposis and was undergoing surgery which would mean he essentially couldn’t do anything for himself for a good 10-16 weeks.

Despite not being able to do anything at all for himself, he couldn’t even feed himself, he was entitled to 0 help.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/06/2022 12:28

Sorry that was in response to peonies.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/06/2022 12:26

Usually the care offered turns out in practice to be very, very limited. As for hire carers.... If you need a carer or are a carer for DC you're highly unlikely to have any spare money to hire anyone. I know quite a few disabled mums, who all work very very hard to make sure their disabilities don't impact their children. I know many mums with DC with SEN who also work very very hard to meet the needs of all their DC and wear themselves to the bone trying to do it all. I wish I was naive enough to think that the care offered to disabled/ill parents and to parents of high needs children was actually enough to meet their needs, you really have no idea.

x2boys · 19/06/2022 12:20

orbitalcrisis · 18/06/2022 11:15

The term young carer is also used to describe a child who, although has no caring responsibilities themselves, do lose out on some of the care and attention that a child without a disabled family member could expect. If you are the sibling of a disabled child your parents will typically not be able to give you as much attention as your disabled sibling, it does not mean they are in any way neglected.

In a family with two children if one is disabled, the other is classed as a young carer, yet they will get far more attention than a child in a family with four children when none of them has a disability. We do not see the second child as being neglected though, do we?

It's nuanced. But more help from the government is definitely needed. Charities should not be supporting families, that should be done by the NHS and social services and funded through taxes, not the generosity of a few good people.

This is very true my 12 year old has severe non verbal autism and learning disabilities, I am his full time carer,his older brother ho is 15, misses out on quite a lot ie family days out etc ,he also helps me out by watching his brother if I nip to the shops etc ,but he's in no way a full time carer he understands I have to spend more time with his brother due to his needs.

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:08

@lovelychops I'm not implying anything. But people who can't look after a child shouldn't have them, no. If you can't look after yourself, you can't look after a child properly. If you need care after having children, hire carers. UK councils also offer care for people, don't use your children.

Immaterialatthispoint · 19/06/2022 07:21

@SpaceJamtart

I am upset and offended by some of the comments here too. I was a child carer, in the technical sense, and I loved my childhood.

@prepared101 if your 15 year old can’t load a dishwasher, that’s rather a failing on your part. Presumably a proportion of the crockery in it was used by him?

it’s a massive spectrum, and it’s rarely something the parents happily chose. Yes, there may be the occasional parent who wanted it like that- but that’s not the norm.

As a child, from about 6, I would cook dinner when my dad was away. I’d turn the shower on and off and help my mum into her clothes. I’d open the medicine packets, under supervision. I’d do the tidying away after dinner. I would reach and fetch things.

I still had friends over, I did after school activities, my mum taught me to cook, to sew for practicality and pleasure, to paint. She taught me languages, she made up stories with me, we played our own games.

and as for whoever it was who said that they worried that child carers never had independent lives…. You’ll no doubt be glad to know what my mum died when I was just 19. And since I’d learnt all those skills, I transitioned easily into independent life. That’s the thing, isn’t it? My experience is not the same as every other child cater. It’s a huge broad term- some children absolutely are placed in positions that shouldn’t be allowed, many others not so much. Don’t lump us all together and decide our childhoods are ruined.

Rinatinabina · 19/06/2022 06:36

To be brutally honest I would never knowingly have a child if I was aware I would need a carer. It’s unfair, even if with the best will in the world you try to minimise the impact on them they always have to worry about you. It’s a parents job to worry not a child’s.

Many families don’t see it coming, illness, disability , these things happen and you already have a family and there is no choice.

autienotnaughty · 19/06/2022 06:09

If you are blaming a disabled person because he/she has no choice but to take support from their children YABU
If you are blaming a broken welfare system that leaves children vulnerable to being carers then YANBU

People saying it's wrong and put the blame at the family door need to look at what it's like in the real world . A world with no money, disability, no support network, no back up. We don't all have the same 24 hours🙄 some people are just doing the best they can with what they have got. And those judging should try to walk in their shoes for a while.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/06/2022 05:16

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/06/2022 05:04

I was a child carer, disabled siblings, MH issues, sole mother who struggled mentally. I learnt way to much to soon, given way to much responsibility. I didn't realise any of this till I was an adult in an abusive marriage. I would never put my DC through that. There is a point past which it is abusive to the child, but we don't know enough about the person in the OP to say. She could mean anything by it.

My youngest DC's life has been impacted since he was a year old by his brother's Autism. So you could say he was a child carer at 1. He didn't get to do playgroups and he had to come to therapy sessions with us. Our life is more limited because of my own disabilities, we do less than many families, but we would have to anyway because that's what my Autistic DC need. They're all ND. It's a very different scenario from my childhood.

I'm not discounting the impact on my DC of my disability or the impacts they have on each other, I know it's impacted them, but I will never put them through what I went through.

They've all at various times impacted each other, their always seems to be one that urgently needs my focus, panic attacks, Autistic burnout, medical issues, the youngest developed a physical disability that's had a big impact on his siblings lives.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/06/2022 05:04

I was a child carer, disabled siblings, MH issues, sole mother who struggled mentally. I learnt way to much to soon, given way to much responsibility. I didn't realise any of this till I was an adult in an abusive marriage. I would never put my DC through that. There is a point past which it is abusive to the child, but we don't know enough about the person in the OP to say. She could mean anything by it.

My youngest DC's life has been impacted since he was a year old by his brother's Autism. So you could say he was a child carer at 1. He didn't get to do playgroups and he had to come to therapy sessions with us. Our life is more limited because of my own disabilities, we do less than many families, but we would have to anyway because that's what my Autistic DC need. They're all ND. It's a very different scenario from my childhood.

Mally100 · 19/06/2022 05:04

Plinkyplankyplonk · 18/06/2022 23:11

My daughter is a young carer, this doesn't mean she does any of the physical caring, from age 5 she has done things like tell me when the younger one needed changing, fetched me things, made simple foods for them like a sandwich, reminded me of things I'd forgotten. She goes to a young carer group because it allows her to be a normal child, they take them on days out and doing activities, she loves it

You make this sound as if it's normal...it's not. What type of cater is she? For a sibling or yourself?

LeafHunter · 19/06/2022 03:26

Like others I was a young carer and although I often didn’t enjoy the physical side (ie helping parent to move around, cooking meals, making drinks etc) it was the emotional impact that was much stronger. It was simple things like hiding my emotions from my parents as I knew they didn’t have capacity for it and feelings like embarrassment or shame when I couldn’t access things in the way others could (parents evening for example, I remember having to ask a teacher to use a different room as my mum couldn’t get a wheelchair in the allocated room).

Although I think the government fails disabled people and their families I think some parents also don’t, or aren’t able to fully meet their child’s needs and that fails the child which can become a systemic family issue. I think this is especially a bigger issue when a parent cannot emotionally meet their child’s needs, or when the physical distress they are in impacts their emotional capacity.

Although a family can put in other adults as support, SO much relies on the very, very early attachments that if the foundations of them not being stable aren’t there it can be hard to build healthy attachments later.

LolaButt · 19/06/2022 02:27

Sibling is disabled. Was a child carer from a young age. I think it’s awful and shouldn’t be allowed.

My parents basically brainwashed us into thinking that it was totally normal for us to never and I mean never, see friends after school etc because we had to go home and look after the sibling while they “had a break”.

If anyone thinks that their child is ok with taking on such adult responsibility, you’re right they probably are ok as a child because they don’t know any different. Sadly when they get older and realise the burden that was placed on them, they won’t like you for it.

Toddlerteaplease · 19/06/2022 01:00

AllHailKingLouis · 18/06/2022 09:37

YANBU - I hate seeing child carers. A child’s life should be largely responsibility free, it should be about learning and having fun. Not caring for someone else.

I agree, the burdens some children have to carry are enormous. Particularly when they are a carer for a parent with mental health issues.

Plinkyplankyplonk · 18/06/2022 23:11

My daughter is a young carer, this doesn't mean she does any of the physical caring, from age 5 she has done things like tell me when the younger one needed changing, fetched me things, made simple foods for them like a sandwich, reminded me of things I'd forgotten. She goes to a young carer group because it allows her to be a normal child, they take them on days out and doing activities, she loves it

SammyScrounge · 18/06/2022 22:11

Geneviev · 18/06/2022 16:49

Well…I mean you shouldn’t be having a child on the basis that that child is going to be your carer, no.

my mum works with child carers, and this situation is more common than I would have liked to believe.

no one is saying sterilise they disabled. But having a child in the full knowledge that they will need to care for you is wrong. You need a new plan.

Sometimes people are perfectly healthy when they are pregnant. Disability of some kind can happen later. Would you take the child away in those circumstances?
At what level of disability would you disapprove or even forbid pregnancy?.Blindness? Minus a limb?etc etc
You sound like a eugenicist.

Cameleongirl · 18/06/2022 18:02

@Artwodeetoo Ah, that sounds like a very difficult situation, your poor friend.