Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child Carers

137 replies

prepared101 · 18/06/2022 09:28

I've named changed because I'm aware this is emotive and I'm prepared to be flamed by some who wholeheartedly disagree with me but...

I've just seen a post a large Facebook group where a poster talks about their 7 year old child who has been her carer since the age of 3. THREE.

My 4 nearly 5 year old has asked me a million things already this morning including could I make them a drink, make their breakfast, help them put their swimming costume on etc etc. How on Earth is a three year old a carer FFS. Even at 10/11/13 etc a child doesn't have the emotional resilience to take on someone else's struggles.

IMO it's stealing a childhood and should be illegal. I can't believe that in this day and age we think that's acceptable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
mokololo · 19/06/2022 15:47

I hate the stuff around "supporting" young carers. It's state grooming and enslavement. You're not helping young carers by getting them a hat or a coach to Blackpool - you're just helping to groom and trap them.

I think this because I was a young carer, sacrificed eagerly to the NHS budget as a teenager and didn't escape for nearly 20 years. I was worked almost to death (I survived near death agains the odds). The worst part is, I "chose" to do it.

It's not a moral victory to give disabled people "rights" by taking them from children. Everyone in this racket needs to walk away from Omelas.

jamimmi · 19/06/2022 15:35

@Peoniesandcream I would agree cooking a meal is a life skill but not most nights a week at 13 which is when she started nor is setting up insulin pumps and checking your Dad's glucose levels. I agree it could be much worse though.

Son changing his uni plans was partly as he though we wouldn't cope we did but he popped home often especially when I had planned surgery. He's a good lad .

Cameleongirl · 19/06/2022 15:25

@Peoniesandcream Thinking about changing educational plans due to a sick parent is very different to actually doing it though.

as I said, I considered dropping out of uni, but my Mum said absolutely not. She couldn’t help her illness, but she did her utmost to ensure that I was minimally affected by it. She was a great Mum. ❤️

Simonjt · 19/06/2022 15:20

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 14:59

@Simonjt so he can do it then, so that's not an example of needing the children to be carers...

You just said being unable to cook a meal means you can’t care for your children, so thats a back track. He’ll always need a certain amount of care as there are lots of things he can’t do, like put on his own socks, cut his nails, wash or brush his own hair, put a top on if it needs to go over his head. Fairly certain the little ones will survive putting the odd pair of socks on for him.

Cameleongirl · 19/06/2022 15:18

@Simonjt
The key difference between your husband’s situation and my Mum’s when I was growing up is that there’s another adult providing care and emotional support to both the sick parent and the children.

The child isn’t left to carry the load.
As @jamimmi says, families work as a team to make things work and what I find appalling is when the other parent doesn’t support their child. Even if the parents aren’t together, the healthy parent should support their children. I can’t imagine letting my DC care for DH without significant support even if we were no longer together, it’s failing as a parent.

@jamimmiI also considered dropping out of uni after my first year as my Mum was v. unwell, but she told me not to. I spent the summer looking after her, and years later, she told me that the doctors had told her they couldn’t do anymore and sent her home to die, but she refused to. She was v. strong-willed 😂

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 15:11

@jamimmi being able to prep food at aged 15 is a normal basic life skill though, many people live independently at 16yo. The 18yo not wanting to go to uni shows their feeling wrong guilty about doing something for themselves/ getting on with their own life which is sad.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 19/06/2022 15:05

I have a relative who has become disabled since having DC. They are classed as young carers. They do less than my dc do. (Ie they wash up occasionally but that's all. Mine cook, do laundry, wash up etc)
But because they live with their disabled parent they are automatically classed as carers.

jamimmi · 19/06/2022 15:01

Young carer is an emotive term but it's happening everywhere. My kids were taught from 2 or 3 to find daddy orange juice , sugar and his blood testing kit and pen if he went funny. If he wasn't talking to call an ambulance. My 5 yr old.did need to do this once. He lost his sight 2 yrs ago and the attempts.to save it were grueling. The 17 yr old is was registered as one of his carers as he drives him to clinics collects meds etc. Hadn't thought about the 15 yr old untill she told.me she'd filled in a general questionnaire at school about home life and stresses and realised she too was a carer, she cooks , chops food checks meds ect.He has no he has no help as he's seen to have it in me but I need to work to pay the mortgage so I'm not around all day. We work as a team and if anything it's made us all much closer. I di have to force the 18 yr old not to alter his uni plans though.

Toddlerteaplease · 19/06/2022 14:59

@Peoniesandcream I have MS and it's the reason I've ruled out adoption or IVF. As hell would freeze over before a child became my carer.

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 14:59

@Simonjt so he can do it then, so that's not an example of needing the children to be carers...

Simonjt · 19/06/2022 14:50

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 14:40

Being unable to cook a meal ie feed yourself and children, yes that's unable to care for them, being unable to clean/ help your child if they're hurt/ choking etc. There are hundreds of examples.

My husband is unable to cook, he is more than capable of feeding himself, the children and caring for them, be that bath time, bed time, gettinf our daughter dressed.

worriedaboutmoney2022 · 19/06/2022 14:44

There was a situation like this but the child was older the single mum had Parkinson's and got very poorly very quickly
It was a case of them just not knowing to ask for help so me and another neighbour helped them and got her a GP appointment and got them some support but she was embarrassed to ask for help it was very sad her daughter was about 6/7

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 14:40

Being unable to cook a meal ie feed yourself and children, yes that's unable to care for them, being unable to clean/ help your child if they're hurt/ choking etc. There are hundreds of examples.

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 14:38

@OneEyedPenguin no my family member will have help from her husband and our family, her children won't go into care. By alternatives I mean if there is no care for you and you can't care for yourself then you yourself would need to go into care/supported housing.

OneEyedPenguin · 19/06/2022 14:16

If you're unable to care for your children properly, disability or not, in general, yes someone else should be caring for them

But some people would say a child parent unable to cook a meal is unable to look after their child properly. I'm asking what you count as unable because people have different views.

My family member with MS has 3 DC and will exhaust all options and still never use her DC as carers and I would do the same

So your family member would put her children in care? Children in care have dire outcomes, the care they receive from the state is way below what most parents would find acceptable. It's used as a last resort for children that are at extreme risk of harm.

As I've stated in my previous posts I'm talking about children being considered actual carers. It's wrong I will always disagree with it and that's that. People need to find suitable alternatives

And if there are no alternatives?

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 14:08

@OneEyedPenguin What do you think it means? If you're unable to care for your children properly, disability or not, in general, yes someone else should be caring for them. Common sense really. The recent examples of children learning to help wash up or assist with cooking isn't the Same thing as being a carer. Many families teach the children to do those things at a suitable age which is part of growing up. As I've stated in my previous posts I'm talking about children being considered actual carers. It's wrong I will always disagree with it and that's that. People need to find suitable alternatives. My family member with MS has 3 DC and will exhaust all options and still never use her DC as carers and I would do the same.

MargaretThursday · 19/06/2022 14:01

Teaching a child what to do if their parent has a seizure or similar is not unfair on the child. It's actually empowering the child if they know what to do, and taking away some of the fear, and certainly is less dangerous even for a young child. If there's a real danger that one morning you might not wake up, wouldn't you rather that your young child knew what to do? if they don't then they don't know how to get help, which is far worse both mentally and physically for them.

Caring can mean different things. I think people are assuming at 3yo the child did everything. But at 3yo mine used to love to have little jobs like load the washing machine, I'm not needing them to do it as I'm not disabled, but I can imagine that if I had been, I could have easily made a game of it so they thought they were having fun while doing something valuable for me. Like when I gave dd1 the "task" of being in charge of the wipes for #2's nappy changes. She was terribly proud of having such an important job and it meant she didn't feel left out while I was dealing with dd2.

But also young children are capable of more than we let them do. Dd1 "did" some shopping and cooking when she was 2.5yo. I was very sick when pregnant with dd2. So sick I couldn't go near food without vomiting. Even going into the kitchen or the supermarket was a problem.
So dd1 learnt to do a few things. She "cooked dinner" a couple of times a week. By this I mean she went into the kitchen, chose a couple of potatoes from the bag. Brought them out to me where we carefully pricked them with a fork. She walked back into the kitchen, put them in the oven and closed the door and switched the oven on. Sometimes dh put something in the oven before he left for work and she'd put it on at the right time. Then when dh came home he'd do everything else and get the cooked food out of the oven. Was that an unfair burden on her? I don't think so. She glowed with pride at eating the dinner "she'd cooked" and wanted to do it more often than we wanted baked potatoes, even if it was one of the few things I could eat without vomiting.
Shopping-yes she did that too. Normally dh made her a packed lunch before he went to work, but occasionally things fell through, or we needed something urgently from the shop. So we walked down to the local Sainsbury's together. She went in clutching the money. The shop has a full length window along one edge so I could watch her all the way round. She'd pick up what was needed, and go and pay. The staff knew her, any questions she'd come back to the door and call through. There is only one door so she couldn't go anywhere else. Again she loved doing it. I remember one time her looking at her packed lunch and announcing she thought she needed a packet of crisps because she knew that meant she could go shopping. The staff were great about it-mind you they were probably thankful I wasn't in there because they aren't keen on cleaning up vomit.
She's in her 20s now and still enjoys food shopping and cooking, so it clearly didn't put her off too much.

OneEyedPenguin · 19/06/2022 13:28

For*

OneEyedPenguin · 19/06/2022 13:27

Only if they're unable to care for their children

What do you count as being "unable to care of their children" though?

Timeforabiscuit · 19/06/2022 13:24

@Peoniesandcream I don't think you understand, there is no help from councils, let me just reiterate that again THERE IS NO HELP FROM COUNCILS.

Charities maybe, passenger transport to hospital appointments, maybe.

But if there is a working adult in the home, you are well and truly fucked and on your own.

But it's OK, I'll just drop my kids off at the poor house coz their dad has Cancer and they might need to be able to dial 999 if he has a seizure.

I don't think you understand how different families work, at all, mine need to do the washing up by way of pitching in, when we were doing daily 3 hrs round trips for radiology, every week day for 6 weeks, they needed to make their own dinner.

By your lights, my kids should be removed from my care - what do you think actually happens? An army of nannies just falls from the sky nanny mcphee style? Our income dropped overnight by 75%, statutory sick pay is £99.35 per week, that doesnt even cover petrol to get to radiology! (You get free parking at least).

It's terrible there are child carers, so write to your mp and say so, but you can get in the sea if you start laying into me and mine for making the best of limited choices.

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 13:08

@OneEyedPenguin Only if they're unable to care for their children

lollipoprainbow · 19/06/2022 13:04

I think it's appalling that children should have to care for their parents. These poor kids don't get any kind of recognition either just have to get on with it. Akin to sending kids up the chimney.

Discovereads · 19/06/2022 13:01

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:45

@Discovereads you should have been provided with carers to help you dress then shouldn't you if there's no suitable adult around.

I agree there should be more support for disabled, but this support simply does not exist. And frankly, disability benefits are poverty level. The highest % in poverty of any segment of the population are the disabled. We barely have the money to survive and certainly none left over to hire carers.

Discovereads · 19/06/2022 12:55

Peoniesandcream · 19/06/2022 12:36

If you can't afford private care, go through GP/ council/ charities/ social services. It still should never fall to children.

Did that. Got some help, but no caring help per se beyond volunteers driving me and helping me attend all the medical appointments which if my DH had taken me to, he would have been sacked for nonattendance at work as these were several times a week every week for years.

OneEyedPenguin · 19/06/2022 12:55

you should have been provided with carers to help you dress then shouldn't you if there's no suitable adult around

But adult social care, local councils etc won't provide carers in most cases.

What should disabled people that can't access carers or have enough adult help do? Put their children in care?