Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is my husband re my nephew?

134 replies

TurtleDucks · 17/06/2022 21:58

I am married to a Muslim Arab, very happily married and there are no issues around us being different religions as he’s not that religious.

DSis is also married. Her husband is a racist bastard and wants nothing to do with us because I married a Muslim. Took a while for the truth to come out but when I started dating my husband, I realised BIL was less friendly and slowly pulling away, but I didn’t realise there was an issue until DSis finally told me. He justifies his racism saying he has his reasons for not liking Muslims and not liking Arabs and wants nothing to do with us. I think DSis knows more about his views than she lets on, but that’s for her.

It does mean DSis is in a tricky position. We don’t live anywhere near each other so only visit my hometown 3-4 times a year, and each time he makes it really difficult for her to see us, going as far as threatening divorce. DSis recognises she’s in a controlling and emotionally abusive relationship, but she keeps hope that he will change so she has no interest in leaving him.

They’ve reached a compromise of sorts that when we visit my parents, DSis can visit us, but their son, my nephew, can’t. He realises he can’t stop DSis from seeing us, but can stop their son.

Now on to the AIBU. This really upsets me. I want to see my nephew and want him to be close to my daughter. I know they won’t grow up together as we live too far apart, but I want them to be close as cousins. DH on the other hand feels that DD shouldn’t have a relationship with my nephew on the back of all this. He says his feelings for my nephew has changed, as he used to really adore him when he was first born, but is now indifferent to him because of the issues with his dad. He says he feels no love or warmth for him anymore.

I keep getting upset at the whole situation and want us to find a solution but DH says that this is all their doing and we need to protect DD from any potential negative behaviour from my nephew. He has already told us his dad doesn’t like us, so there is a possibility his dad is feeding him more stories and as DD is mixed race, we need to protect her. He isn’t stopping me from finding ways for DD to see my nephew, just thinks we shouldn’t force it. But to me, family is so so important and it breaks my heart that DH isn’t being proactive in building a relationship between DD and my nephew.

I do think DH is more hurt by the whole situation than he makes out, but it’s DSis that is in the difficult position as it’s her marriage that’s affected by this.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 17/06/2022 23:55

it breaks my heart that DH isn’t being proactive in building a relationship between DD and my nephew it isn't his job to do this!! Even if this wasn't caused by the BIL being racist against your DH, it wouldn't be DH's job to build a relationship between his child and his wife's sisters child. She's your sister!!
And frankly I'm with DH in that Dad is out and out racist, Mom is at best ignoring it, it seems unlikely DNeph won't unwittingly pick up those attitudes unless he's challenged at school etc so your DD is going to get the full run of how awful her Dad is and by assoc her.

Your DSis has picked between you and she didn't pick you. Sorry.

whumpthereitis · 17/06/2022 23:51

You have the luxury of being ‘tolerant’ to their racism because you’re not subjected to it. Your husband on the other hand is subject to it, and so is your daughter. You don’t get to ask him to put up with it, I’m amazed you think it’s reasonable that he should. I’m also amazed that you think it reasonable to expose your husband and child to it tbh.

your nephew is almost certainly being raised with the attitudes of his parents. I say parents plural, because your sister is complicit.

Grandmum1 · 17/06/2022 23:50

In your situation I would cut myself off from your sister too so I think your husband is being very tolerant under the circumstances
I couldn’t have any relationship with someone with your sisters husbands vile beliefs or her if she supports them in any way

Your loyalty lies with your DH here

TheLadyDIdGood · 17/06/2022 23:39

Your title should be 'or is my bil towards my dd?' not 'Or is my husband towards my nephew?'
You've minimised the impact of racism on your dh and dd and are mistakenly concerned about your nephew instead of your dd.

I hate to say it but your nephew is probably not that different to his dad, the apple doesn't fall far from the tree. What will you do when your nephew starts to racially abuse your dd? Don't minimise the issue and face up to the situation which is that your sister's family hate your dh & dd because they're not white.

You are victim blaming your dh for not focusing on your nephew and negating the impact of racism on him. Because you haven't directly experienced racism yourself, you're refusing to acknowledge how dangerous it is.

itsnotmeitisactuallyyou · 17/06/2022 23:30

This

420Bruh · 17/06/2022 23:22

No way should you push the relationship, he's probably been horribly indoctrinated by his father.

I'd also not be seeing my sister if she was married to a racist but I guess that's your call. Clearly she tolerates his views to some extent which would make me worry for my child.

Zeus44 · 17/06/2022 23:14

You made your choices, they’ve made theirs. Live with the consequences of your actions.

MamaSquealus · 17/06/2022 23:10

This is a horrible situation, and you do have my sympathies, but have you ever sat down with your DH and discussed the racism he's no doubt experienced in his life? Until I met my husband (who is a Pakistani Muslim) I really didn't understand the full extent of the problem, but some of the things that go on are horrific, let alone unfair. What's also horrified me is that sometimes I've noticed someone is quite clearly speaking to him disrespectfully and he doesn't even notice, because he's so used to being disrespected and treated like shit. Racism is deeply scaring and traumatising for the victims, and as such, asking someone who has more than likely been affected by racism to have anything to do with the family of a racist is very unfair, no matter how much you love and miss your sister and nephew.

The fact your sister can be with someone with such disgusting views is beyond me. She values him above your family, and that's her choice, but your DH and DD really need to come first here.
Hopefully, one day your sister will leave that pig of a man, and be able to teach her son how disgusting and wrong his father's views are, but as things stand that seems unlikely, and as such, your DD needs to be protected.

I'm sorry this is so painful for you, but you really should let this go. Your family is your DH and DD, they're what's important here. Good luck 💐

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 17/06/2022 23:07

This is such a sad situation.

You need to protect your child from the racist BIL and have nothing to do with him. I feel so sad for the kids and you though for having to miss out on the cousin/nephew relationship.

Hopefully your nephew will one day be able to teach your BIL that racism of any sort is not acceptable in Britain today. One can hope anyway 🤞

Littleraindrop15 · 17/06/2022 23:02

agree with your husband you need to prioritise him and your daughter over dn and dsis

Ottersmith · 17/06/2022 22:58

I don't think any of this should be taken out on the nephew. It isn't his fault and he should be allowed to see his cousin. Your sister needs a wake up call though. Can you write her a letter or something saying the impact this has had? Dou think she would ever leave him? She really needs to leave him for the sake of her son.

BadNomad · 17/06/2022 22:53

I don't understand why this is being discussed. Your nephew isn't allowed to see your family, so why does it matter if your husband agrees with the cousins having a relationship when it's not even possible?

And what possible solutions is your sister proposing? I would leave it up to her, really. It's her family. She is the one supporting and enabling the racist.

Maurepas · 17/06/2022 22:50

Your DH is correct for multiple reasons.

Aquamarine1029 · 17/06/2022 22:49

Your sister is every bit as reprehensible as her husband. You don't seem to realise this.

RoaryLion1 · 17/06/2022 22:49

Agree with PPs. I understand you want to preserve family relationships but I think you are really minimising the impact this must be having on your DH. It’s not like DH and BIL don’t get on or just have a bad relationship - BIL is making judgements on your DH and DD purely on basis of their race. I’d find that incredibly upsetting and I think you need to consider your DH’s feelings when you push him to facilitate a relationship with DN/DSis.

also - minor point but if BIL doesn’t want DN to see your DD, what are you expecting your DH to do about it?

Blanketpolicy · 17/06/2022 22:43

For the sake of everyone it is time to accept the reality. There will be no close cousin relationship, your dh is not being unreasonable to say he doesn't have a bond with a nephew he barely knows. For the sake of your own family consider LC with your sister too.

Unless your BIL gets a brain transplant or your dsis leaves him it is out of your control, so let it go.

SemperIdem · 17/06/2022 22:37

I agree with your husband.

You must put your daughter first - I wouldn’t want her anywhere near your sister, her husband or their son, in your shoes.

Your poor husband has tolerated open racism for years and just wants to protect his daughter from it.

Why don’t you?

Anothernamechangeplease · 17/06/2022 22:35

Thinking about this more, OP, I'm surprised that your DH is not more upset about your own attitude towards all of this. You seem to be really minimising the racism.

My DH is not white. If my BIL was racist towards him and my sister condoned it, I would cut contact with all of them. Forget the cousins or the family relationships.

Family means nothing if family members cannot show basic respect towards one another.

CatherinedeBourgh · 17/06/2022 22:33

By not only continuing your relationship with your sister and nephew but also expecting your dh to do so you are being complicit in their racism.

You need to start standing up for your dh, and not indulging your sister's (racist) behaviour.

Merryoldgoat · 17/06/2022 22:29

I’m black and my DH white. If any of his family reacted negatively towards me he’d put a stop to it immediately (although I probably would first).

Your sister is complicit whilst she stays and reliant on a family bond being more important than your principles.

leavethewallalone · 17/06/2022 22:27

I completely agree with your DH. He sounds like a very patient man and he is looking our for your DD who is the priority here. I wouldn't want my mixed race child to have any relationship with DN if they were being raised by a racist IMO. And I feel like your sister is condoning it.

How is your sister even with this vile man?

AmandaHoldensLips · 17/06/2022 22:25

That's so shit. Racist parents raise racist kids. The cycle perpetuates with another generation of racists.

I cut my racist brother out of my life years ago. His attitude and behaviour is abhorrent.

Anothernamechangeplease · 17/06/2022 22:22

So your BIL is a shameless racist, your sister doesn't seem too bothered by his racism, and your nephew is almost certainly being raised a racist. And you think that your DH is being unreasonable because he doesn't want his mixed race dd to be exposed to that.

Seriously?

Your DH is the target of horrible racism from within his own extended family. Your DSis is choosing to stay in her marriage for whatever reason. How is this affecting her life now more than his?

Snoken · 17/06/2022 22:21

I am quite impressed your DH can even tolerate your sister. I also wouldn’t encourage a relationship between my mixed race DD and her racist aunt, because in my opinion you condone racism if you don’t stand up to it. I can’t even imagine what that does to your DD emotionally.

AlsoknownasOther · 17/06/2022 22:14

Yeah, I really wouldn't agree with it being your sister in the worst position.

Your sister's decision to stay with her husband is negatively impacting on your nephew, your daughter, your husband, you ...

She's pretty complicit.

I don't agree with your husband taking it out on your nephew though. Your nephew didn't choose his dad.