Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is my husband re my nephew?

134 replies

TurtleDucks · 17/06/2022 21:58

I am married to a Muslim Arab, very happily married and there are no issues around us being different religions as he’s not that religious.

DSis is also married. Her husband is a racist bastard and wants nothing to do with us because I married a Muslim. Took a while for the truth to come out but when I started dating my husband, I realised BIL was less friendly and slowly pulling away, but I didn’t realise there was an issue until DSis finally told me. He justifies his racism saying he has his reasons for not liking Muslims and not liking Arabs and wants nothing to do with us. I think DSis knows more about his views than she lets on, but that’s for her.

It does mean DSis is in a tricky position. We don’t live anywhere near each other so only visit my hometown 3-4 times a year, and each time he makes it really difficult for her to see us, going as far as threatening divorce. DSis recognises she’s in a controlling and emotionally abusive relationship, but she keeps hope that he will change so she has no interest in leaving him.

They’ve reached a compromise of sorts that when we visit my parents, DSis can visit us, but their son, my nephew, can’t. He realises he can’t stop DSis from seeing us, but can stop their son.

Now on to the AIBU. This really upsets me. I want to see my nephew and want him to be close to my daughter. I know they won’t grow up together as we live too far apart, but I want them to be close as cousins. DH on the other hand feels that DD shouldn’t have a relationship with my nephew on the back of all this. He says his feelings for my nephew has changed, as he used to really adore him when he was first born, but is now indifferent to him because of the issues with his dad. He says he feels no love or warmth for him anymore.

I keep getting upset at the whole situation and want us to find a solution but DH says that this is all their doing and we need to protect DD from any potential negative behaviour from my nephew. He has already told us his dad doesn’t like us, so there is a possibility his dad is feeding him more stories and as DD is mixed race, we need to protect her. He isn’t stopping me from finding ways for DD to see my nephew, just thinks we shouldn’t force it. But to me, family is so so important and it breaks my heart that DH isn’t being proactive in building a relationship between DD and my nephew.

I do think DH is more hurt by the whole situation than he makes out, but it’s DSis that is in the difficult position as it’s her marriage that’s affected by this.

OP posts:
Summersolargirl · 18/06/2022 08:57

I really don’t comprehend why you are pushing this, they’d see each other three to four times a year, the “cousin relationship” is not more important than your daughter, let it go. Your husband is right.

lunar1 · 18/06/2022 08:54

I don't know what autocorrect did there!

lunar1 · 18/06/2022 08:53

@Glitternails1 the D-D doesn't have a close relationship with the op's family because there is a racist divide.

It's also not the job of the DH or DD to help prevent the DN becoming racist.

If I had racists in my family they wouldn't get anywhere near my husband or children.

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 08:45

TheLadyDIdGood · 18/06/2022 08:35

Glitternails1 are you sure you're not projecting here because the op mentioned her dh is Arab Muslim? How is he being abusive and isolating the op from her family?

The Op's bil is the one who prevents his son, the op 's nephew, from seeing the op and her family. Her racist bil is also isolating his wife, the Op's sister, from the op and the op can only see her sister at her mum's house.

Why are you not saying anything about this but just focus g in the Op's husband because he's an Arab Muslim?

Why are you focusing on the fact he’s Arab Muslim? Very odd. I didn’t even mention Muslim or Arab. No, I just thought it was sad that OP is upset that her Dd has relationships with her dad’s family, but not her mum’s. I’m not sure if she means her entire family or just her sister and nephew (maybe OP could clarify). It is rather controlling to tell someone they can’t see their sister/auntie.

Racism is learned. You’re not born with it. Hopefully the nephew (not sure how old he is) will learn that his dad is wrong. Maybe he’ll form a positive relationship with his mixed race cousin. It’s worth a try and hopefully OP and her family can encourage her sister to leave her abusive husband. Of course, if nephew’s behaviour is abusive then by all means stop the cousins meeting up in future.

TheLadyDIdGood · 18/06/2022 08:35

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 03:02

@TurtleDucks As a mixed race woman, I agree with you and not your DH (despite most posters agreeing with your DH). If you encourage a positive relationship between the cousins then your nephew will learn that his father is wrong about other cultures because he will have a good relationship with his mixed race cousin.

I also see how close DD is to DH’s family and I do feel some sadness that she doesn’t have the same relationship with mine.

I think this is worrying. Your DH is trying to isolate you and your Dd from your family. Your Dd needs to form bonds with her 2 families - 2 races and 2 religious backgrounds. He is so so wrong to deny you both a relationship with your sister and nephew on the basis that your sister is married to an abusive man (also, your DH is bordering on abusive but in a different way).

Glitternails1 are you sure you're not projecting here because the op mentioned her dh is Arab Muslim? How is he being abusive and isolating the op from her family?

The Op's bil is the one who prevents his son, the op 's nephew, from seeing the op and her family. Her racist bil is also isolating his wife, the Op's sister, from the op and the op can only see her sister at her mum's house.

Why are you not saying anything about this but just focus g in the Op's husband because he's an Arab Muslim?

Bednobsbroomsticks · 18/06/2022 07:53

Zeus44 · 17/06/2022 23:14

You made your choices, they’ve made theirs. Live with the consequences of your actions.

What is this supposed to mean?

lunar1 · 18/06/2022 07:49

I think your husband should be protecting his child from your sister, she shouldn't be anywhere near your dd.

Racists raise racists, it's in no way your husband or child's job to educate them. I think you are minimising your sisters behaviour.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 18/06/2022 07:49

Yes I couldn't have contact with my sister in this situation. It's really sad for the kids. But I'd def have no contact. If that cuts her off to stay with the abuser so be it. My family would come first. Feel for you OP.

Tentpegsandtantrums · 18/06/2022 07:31

You do realize that your sister is enabling this, don’t you? I’d be cutting her off too.

balalake · 18/06/2022 07:26

I'm saddened for the nephew having a racist dad. You don't say how old your nephew is, but certainly should be having regular contact once he is old enough to make his own decisions.

I think minimal contact with your sister who has married a racist meanwhile.

Knowbodysphool · 18/06/2022 07:21

I'm with your husband too

Herejustforthisone · 18/06/2022 07:17

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 03:02

@TurtleDucks As a mixed race woman, I agree with you and not your DH (despite most posters agreeing with your DH). If you encourage a positive relationship between the cousins then your nephew will learn that his father is wrong about other cultures because he will have a good relationship with his mixed race cousin.

I also see how close DD is to DH’s family and I do feel some sadness that she doesn’t have the same relationship with mine.

I think this is worrying. Your DH is trying to isolate you and your Dd from your family. Your Dd needs to form bonds with her 2 families - 2 races and 2 religious backgrounds. He is so so wrong to deny you both a relationship with your sister and nephew on the basis that your sister is married to an abusive man (also, your DH is bordering on abusive but in a different way).

What TF are you talking about?

Also, by forcing her daughter to see the nephew, she’s putting her daughter in the firing line of a racist viewpoint and comments because with someone as overt as the BIL there’s no way the nephew won’t be massively influenced by him already.

I’d say to my sister that I was ready to support her when she chose to leave the abusive, racist cunt she married. In the meantime, there would be no relationship.

ChocolateHippo · 18/06/2022 06:58

Your poor husband! He probably feels a lot more hurt by this than he is making out.

I wouldn't push the issue with your nephew, as your DH has already told you that he is happy to let the relationship play out but just doesn't want to be 'proactive' (and what can he really do?). I would remind your DH that nephew is an innocent child who has no choice in who his father is but, apart from that, I agree that your priority should be your DD. Maybe she could make her cousin a card or picture for his mum to give him or some other indirect contact which isn't going to put her at risk of being subjected to racist views? Other that that, nothing can really be done until your sister steps up and leaves BIL.

girlmom21 · 18/06/2022 06:26

Your nephew is already telling you his dad doesn't like your DH and, presumably, by extension your DD because she'll be mixed race. Why would you knowingly force your child to have a relationship with a family of racists?

Your sister needs to draw the line somewhere. I understand if she's in an abusive relationship it's hard but her sons going to grow up like his scummy father if she doesn't step up now.

drpet49 · 18/06/2022 06:22

@Glitternails1 your post is laughable. Now her DH is the bad guy? Dream on.

Butchyrestingface · 18/06/2022 06:04

YABSU it's hard to put into words.

SpringBadger · 18/06/2022 05:24

TurtleDucks · 18/06/2022 02:10

Thank you for the responses.

I do get that this is difficult for my husband, honestly I do. And I’m so thankful he hasn’t asked me to choose. But my sister is also a victim here as she is in a controlling relationship and needs my support. She doesn’t have many people she can rely on.

I think I’m keen on the cousins relationship because it’s what I had and it was great. I also see how close DD is to DH’s family and I do feel some sadness that she doesn’t have the same relationship with mine. I just hope they’re close when they get older.

I really feel for all of you (except the BIL, obviously). I'm a bit shocked at the blanket condemnation of your sister, who is in an abusive relationship, and even some PPs suggesting your beloved nephew is probably just a mini-BIL. He's a child for goodness' sake and has done nothing wrong. It would break my heart too for my child to be kept away from their cousin, especially if they're an only child. None of that is to detract from the awfulness of BIL and I have no solution, I only hope your sister can escape this man and start to rebuild family relationships.

autienotnaughty · 18/06/2022 05:08

Maybe it's just how it reads but it seems you are colluding with your sister and extended family. Your dh and dc should not be around this vile situation and out of loyalty neither should you. I would cut those family members off but be open to reconciliation should dsis leave her husband.

Luckingfovely · 18/06/2022 04:20

@Glitternails1 there are so many ridiculous assumptions in your post that I don't even know where to start.

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 03:02

@TurtleDucks As a mixed race woman, I agree with you and not your DH (despite most posters agreeing with your DH). If you encourage a positive relationship between the cousins then your nephew will learn that his father is wrong about other cultures because he will have a good relationship with his mixed race cousin.

I also see how close DD is to DH’s family and I do feel some sadness that she doesn’t have the same relationship with mine.

I think this is worrying. Your DH is trying to isolate you and your Dd from your family. Your Dd needs to form bonds with her 2 families - 2 races and 2 religious backgrounds. He is so so wrong to deny you both a relationship with your sister and nephew on the basis that your sister is married to an abusive man (also, your DH is bordering on abusive but in a different way).

TurtleDucks · 18/06/2022 02:10

Thank you for the responses.

I do get that this is difficult for my husband, honestly I do. And I’m so thankful he hasn’t asked me to choose. But my sister is also a victim here as she is in a controlling relationship and needs my support. She doesn’t have many people she can rely on.

I think I’m keen on the cousins relationship because it’s what I had and it was great. I also see how close DD is to DH’s family and I do feel some sadness that she doesn’t have the same relationship with mine. I just hope they’re close when they get older.

OP posts:
RunningFromInsanity · 18/06/2022 00:49

I do think DH is more hurt by the whole situation than he makes out, but it’s DSis that is in the difficult position as it’s her marriage that’s affected by this

Bull. Your sister is enabling a racist and therefore is a racist herself. Against your own husband. And yet you are concerned about her marriage?
Sort your priorities out.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 18/06/2022 00:43

He isn’t stopping me from finding ways for DD to see my nephew, just thinks we shouldn’t force it.
Your DH is being accommodating here. He could justifiably be shutting down the exposure of his half Arab Muslim dd to her potentially racist cousin but he's willing to let it play out.

StaunchMomma · 18/06/2022 00:41

The one being unreasonable, apart from your obvious utter twunt of a BIL, is your sister for putting up with his shit and being in a relationship with a racist.

Your husband is right. Your BIL will be in his son's ear and that bile will be passed directly onto your DD. You don't know what that feels like but you can guarantee he does, unfortunately, and he's bound to want to protect her from that.

I can't believe people like you're BIL exist in 2022. It's literally pathetic.

BadNomad · 18/06/2022 00:30

I feel terrible for your daughter, actually. She's half-Arab and you want her to have a relationship with your racist family. Stand up for your daughter please.