Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is my husband re my nephew?

134 replies

TurtleDucks · 17/06/2022 21:58

I am married to a Muslim Arab, very happily married and there are no issues around us being different religions as he’s not that religious.

DSis is also married. Her husband is a racist bastard and wants nothing to do with us because I married a Muslim. Took a while for the truth to come out but when I started dating my husband, I realised BIL was less friendly and slowly pulling away, but I didn’t realise there was an issue until DSis finally told me. He justifies his racism saying he has his reasons for not liking Muslims and not liking Arabs and wants nothing to do with us. I think DSis knows more about his views than she lets on, but that’s for her.

It does mean DSis is in a tricky position. We don’t live anywhere near each other so only visit my hometown 3-4 times a year, and each time he makes it really difficult for her to see us, going as far as threatening divorce. DSis recognises she’s in a controlling and emotionally abusive relationship, but she keeps hope that he will change so she has no interest in leaving him.

They’ve reached a compromise of sorts that when we visit my parents, DSis can visit us, but their son, my nephew, can’t. He realises he can’t stop DSis from seeing us, but can stop their son.

Now on to the AIBU. This really upsets me. I want to see my nephew and want him to be close to my daughter. I know they won’t grow up together as we live too far apart, but I want them to be close as cousins. DH on the other hand feels that DD shouldn’t have a relationship with my nephew on the back of all this. He says his feelings for my nephew has changed, as he used to really adore him when he was first born, but is now indifferent to him because of the issues with his dad. He says he feels no love or warmth for him anymore.

I keep getting upset at the whole situation and want us to find a solution but DH says that this is all their doing and we need to protect DD from any potential negative behaviour from my nephew. He has already told us his dad doesn’t like us, so there is a possibility his dad is feeding him more stories and as DD is mixed race, we need to protect her. He isn’t stopping me from finding ways for DD to see my nephew, just thinks we shouldn’t force it. But to me, family is so so important and it breaks my heart that DH isn’t being proactive in building a relationship between DD and my nephew.

I do think DH is more hurt by the whole situation than he makes out, but it’s DSis that is in the difficult position as it’s her marriage that’s affected by this.

OP posts:
TurtleDucks · 18/06/2022 10:26

Sally872 · 18/06/2022 10:14

Your sister is staying with him because day to day his racism isn't a problem for her only 3-4 times a year when you visit and the cousins or aunt/newphew relationship is not a priority for her. I know that must be hard to hear but your sister is not innocent by standing by her racisit husband at the expense of her family.

I would focus on family relationship with your parents and brother and wife and keep sister to a minimum. It is going to be a very difficult conversation when your dd eventually asks about uncle or cousin so aunt being very much in the background would be my preference.

It is a horrible situation you are in. Hopefully your sister sees sense one day.

You know, this never occurred to me. That it isn’t an issue for her for the majority of the year. That is some food for thought.

OP posts:
moose62 · 18/06/2022 10:25

Flip things around and think how you would feel if DH family treated you the way your BIL and sister him. You would expect him to protect and stand up for you. My DH and DD would come first. Your sister has chosen her bed, and as she is continuing to lie in it you would be better to go LC until things change. This must be so hurtful to your DH that you gave such a racist in the family and no one is ostracising him because of it.

worriedaboutmoney2022 · 18/06/2022 10:19

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 17/06/2022 22:00

Your husband is completely right. Protecting your family from racists is more important than a cousin relationship. Hopefully your sister will come to her senses and then you can reassess.

I agree with this
Wait for your sister to see sense and leave him then you can hopefully sort things out

Pbbananabagel · 18/06/2022 10:16

You ever hear the phrase ‘blood is thicker than water’?
the full quote is actually ‘the blood of the covenant is thicker than the water of the womb’. It means the bonds you CHOOSE to make are more important than the ones you have by chance of birth. You chose your husband and to have a child together so your allegiance should be to them, your sister is making her choice.

Sally872 · 18/06/2022 10:14

Your sister is staying with him because day to day his racism isn't a problem for her only 3-4 times a year when you visit and the cousins or aunt/newphew relationship is not a priority for her. I know that must be hard to hear but your sister is not innocent by standing by her racisit husband at the expense of her family.

I would focus on family relationship with your parents and brother and wife and keep sister to a minimum. It is going to be a very difficult conversation when your dd eventually asks about uncle or cousin so aunt being very much in the background would be my preference.

It is a horrible situation you are in. Hopefully your sister sees sense one day.

lunar1 · 18/06/2022 10:09

It isn't the job of people from an ethnic minority to educate racists.

I've had someone suggest this about my sons, that they could help educate the twats. The politest response I could come up with was fuck off.

TurtleDucks · 18/06/2022 10:07

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 09:49

You said you Dd doesn’t have a relationship with your family and that you were sad about it. You said your dh didn’t want you to see your sister and nephew. If this isn’t the case then sorry. That’s how I read it and it can be tricky to know unless everyone involved.

However, it is not on that you accused me of racism when I literally didn’t mention your dh’s race or religion or any stereotypes. As a half Asian, that really upset me.

Tbh it doesn’t matter you’re half Asian. DH has been on the receiving end of Asians who don’t like Muslims. I have also had comments by Asians about DH. People of all races can be racist and prejudiced. I’m not saying you are but saying you’re half Asian doesn’t excuse you from such prejudices.

I never said DD doesn’t have ANY relationship with my family. I said she doesn’t have the SAME relationship with my family than she does DH’s family. You took from that my husband is controlling…

For clarity, we see DH’s family much more often as we live in the same city and MIL helps with childcare when we want to go out or DD is sick. So DD adores DH’s family, but she doesn’t have the same attachment to my family because she sees them less. But tbh, and I don’t know if this is a cultural thing as Brits tend to be more reserved or if it’s my family, they show so much more love and affection to her than my family so she has a close bond with them. My SIL and my BIL (DH’s siblings) each call at least twice a week just to have a video call with DD, who is only 2, just because they want to see her. My siblings have never done that. So naturally she is closer to them, and I wish DD was attached to my family and she isn’t, and not seeing her cousin just makes that worse.

OP posts:
catandcoffee · 18/06/2022 10:02

OP, tell your sister her racist husband was always racist,he just didn't need to speak about it.....until YOU married 'outside' .

SherbertLemonDrop · 18/06/2022 10:01

She downplays how awful racism is and excuses it. Wouldn't be my sister anymore.

SherbertLemonDrop · 18/06/2022 09:57

Your DH is a right. How dare your sister and her racist family. I'd cut her out too.

tempester28 · 18/06/2022 09:50

I would be annoyed with your dsis that she doesn't have enough influence over your nephew to prevent him from growing up with the same views as his father. You obviously need to shield your daughter from that, although you might find they get on really well and that it is just the adults that are behaving badly - well maybe just your brother-in-law.

As others have said, if your dsis is in an abusive relationship, while I would be annoyed with her - I wouldn't cut her out of your life as that is very like what her husband wants.

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 09:49

*unless you know everyone involved

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 09:49

TurtleDucks · 18/06/2022 09:45

Then please tell me how my husband is trying to isolate me from my family and denying me a relationship with my sister and nephew. Because those are some assumptions you made there.

My issue is that he isn’t that keen for DD to see DN, that’s what I posted about. He has never ever got in the way of me and my family and encourages me to visit them when it’s been too long since a visit. Yet somehow you concluded he is keeping me away from them.

You said you Dd doesn’t have a relationship with your family and that you were sad about it. You said your dh didn’t want you to see your sister and nephew. If this isn’t the case then sorry. That’s how I read it and it can be tricky to know unless everyone involved.

However, it is not on that you accused me of racism when I literally didn’t mention your dh’s race or religion or any stereotypes. As a half Asian, that really upset me.

catandcoffee · 18/06/2022 09:45

Your Husband is correct in his view.

OP you need to face facts...your sister chooses to be with this racist arsehole.

You can make all the excuses in the world, for her, but she's stays with him.

Protect your daughter from all racists...even the blood relatives

TurtleDucks · 18/06/2022 09:45

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 09:41

@TurtleDucks Please do not project whatever assumptions you have against Arab Muslims on to my DH.

I didn’t mention Arabs or Muslims. All I did was agree with you that it might be nice for your Dd and dn to play with each other on the rare occasions they see each other. That it will be nice for her to experience both cultures. If your Dd is the victim of racial abuse then end contact.

I think you and @TheLadyDIdGood are mistaking me for another poster. I never mentioned any stereotypes. I am half Asian.

Then please tell me how my husband is trying to isolate me from my family and denying me a relationship with my sister and nephew. Because those are some assumptions you made there.

My issue is that he isn’t that keen for DD to see DN, that’s what I posted about. He has never ever got in the way of me and my family and encourages me to visit them when it’s been too long since a visit. Yet somehow you concluded he is keeping me away from them.

OP posts:
Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 09:41

@TurtleDucks Please do not project whatever assumptions you have against Arab Muslims on to my DH.

I didn’t mention Arabs or Muslims. All I did was agree with you that it might be nice for your Dd and dn to play with each other on the rare occasions they see each other. That it will be nice for her to experience both cultures. If your Dd is the victim of racial abuse then end contact.

I think you and @TheLadyDIdGood are mistaking me for another poster. I never mentioned any stereotypes. I am half Asian.

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 09:37

TheLadyDIdGood · 18/06/2022 09:09

That's right, you didn't mention that he's Arab but I wonder if the OP didn't mention it either whether your answer would be the same. The husband is trying to protect his dd from vile racists, who unfortunately happen to be her family. He behaviour is a reaction to the racism he's suffered from them. The op still visits her mum and her dh doesn't stop these visits. Her bil is the one who is isolating the Op's sister from the op & her family

I’m half Asian. I have been the victim of racism.

TheViscountessBridgerton · 18/06/2022 09:35

Your husband is a victim of racism perpetrated by your sisters husband. You are also a victim of his horrible views, as you can see how he's damaged your relationships with your family. Your daughter will be treated just as badly as your husband. Please listen to your husband on the topic of racism and xenophobia. He will have experienced this many times, he knows what it looks like. Don't assume that the nephew will be able to make his own mind up. Racism is taught. By racists. And his dad is one.

THisbackwithavengeance · 18/06/2022 09:32

AmandaHoldensLips · 17/06/2022 22:25

That's so shit. Racist parents raise racist kids. The cycle perpetuates with another generation of racists.

I cut my racist brother out of my life years ago. His attitude and behaviour is abhorrent.

Yea, that's true but I actually think that the cycle can be broken here.

So I disagree with the general consensus on here. It's not the nephew's fault his dad is racist and he deserves a relationship with his aunt, uncle and cousins.

And when he's older and hears his father spouting racist rhetoric, maybe he will have the knowledge to think, actually that's not right. My dad says Muslims are bad but my uncle is a really nice person and he will hopefully start to challenge his dad. Racism is caused by fear and ignorance and you cure ignorance by education.

TurtleDucks · 18/06/2022 09:23

Why won’t she leave him?

Couple of reasons. Because she loves him and hopes he will change. He wasn’t like this when they met and got married so she thinks it’s just stress and it will pass. But they live in an area where there is no one who isn’t white so it probably never came up until DH came along. But is holding on to that hope.

I also think she doesn’t want to uproot her and DN’s lives by leaving him and starting afresh somewhere.

We’re the only ones with children as my brother and his wife don’t want any. Her husband is Dutch so all is family there, so it also means that DN has no cousins apart from DD.

OP posts:
TurtleDucks · 18/06/2022 09:14

Glitternails1 · 18/06/2022 03:02

@TurtleDucks As a mixed race woman, I agree with you and not your DH (despite most posters agreeing with your DH). If you encourage a positive relationship between the cousins then your nephew will learn that his father is wrong about other cultures because he will have a good relationship with his mixed race cousin.

I also see how close DD is to DH’s family and I do feel some sadness that she doesn’t have the same relationship with mine.

I think this is worrying. Your DH is trying to isolate you and your Dd from your family. Your Dd needs to form bonds with her 2 families - 2 races and 2 religious backgrounds. He is so so wrong to deny you both a relationship with your sister and nephew on the basis that your sister is married to an abusive man (also, your DH is bordering on abusive but in a different way).

No. DH is an amazing man. This situation hurts him and he blames himself, has even apologised for causing a rift in my family when he’s done nothing wrong.

Please do not project whatever assumptions you have against Arab Muslims on to my DH. He has never once stopped me from visiting my family, and happily comes along and stays when I suggest a trip, and often tries to come up with ways for me to see my sister when we’re at my parents. Admittedly he doesn’t suggest coming along or joining us, but he has never stopped me.

OP posts:
TheLadyDIdGood · 18/06/2022 09:10

Sorry my reply was to @Glitternails1

ImustLearn2Cook · 18/06/2022 09:10

@TurtleDucks I understand both you and your husband’s perspective.

I voted yabu because you and your husband are not dn’s parents and as wrong as your bil is, he and your sister are his parents.

For now, focus on helping and supporting your sister in a respectful way. Stand by and support your husband and protect and support your daughter.

You don’t know what the future holds. Maybe when dn is older he will make the decision to not follow in his father’s racism. If that is the case and he is old enough to choose his own relationships then your daughter and cousin might get to know each other, if they both want to.

TheLadyDIdGood · 18/06/2022 09:09

That's right, you didn't mention that he's Arab but I wonder if the OP didn't mention it either whether your answer would be the same. The husband is trying to protect his dd from vile racists, who unfortunately happen to be her family. He behaviour is a reaction to the racism he's suffered from them. The op still visits her mum and her dh doesn't stop these visits. Her bil is the one who is isolating the Op's sister from the op & her family

Sswhinesthebest · 18/06/2022 09:06

It could help DN to see how bad his fathers views are, if he has a normal oving relationship with you all - however I do see your dh’s point.

I think a lot depends on how sis counteracts her husbands views when she speaks to dn. If she doesn’t directly speak about the issue and contradict her husbands views to her son, then absolutely no direct contact between the cousins.

It think your dsis needs support. Her situation is very dysfunctional. Why won’t she leave him?