Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is my husband re my nephew?

134 replies

TurtleDucks · 17/06/2022 21:58

I am married to a Muslim Arab, very happily married and there are no issues around us being different religions as he’s not that religious.

DSis is also married. Her husband is a racist bastard and wants nothing to do with us because I married a Muslim. Took a while for the truth to come out but when I started dating my husband, I realised BIL was less friendly and slowly pulling away, but I didn’t realise there was an issue until DSis finally told me. He justifies his racism saying he has his reasons for not liking Muslims and not liking Arabs and wants nothing to do with us. I think DSis knows more about his views than she lets on, but that’s for her.

It does mean DSis is in a tricky position. We don’t live anywhere near each other so only visit my hometown 3-4 times a year, and each time he makes it really difficult for her to see us, going as far as threatening divorce. DSis recognises she’s in a controlling and emotionally abusive relationship, but she keeps hope that he will change so she has no interest in leaving him.

They’ve reached a compromise of sorts that when we visit my parents, DSis can visit us, but their son, my nephew, can’t. He realises he can’t stop DSis from seeing us, but can stop their son.

Now on to the AIBU. This really upsets me. I want to see my nephew and want him to be close to my daughter. I know they won’t grow up together as we live too far apart, but I want them to be close as cousins. DH on the other hand feels that DD shouldn’t have a relationship with my nephew on the back of all this. He says his feelings for my nephew has changed, as he used to really adore him when he was first born, but is now indifferent to him because of the issues with his dad. He says he feels no love or warmth for him anymore.

I keep getting upset at the whole situation and want us to find a solution but DH says that this is all their doing and we need to protect DD from any potential negative behaviour from my nephew. He has already told us his dad doesn’t like us, so there is a possibility his dad is feeding him more stories and as DD is mixed race, we need to protect her. He isn’t stopping me from finding ways for DD to see my nephew, just thinks we shouldn’t force it. But to me, family is so so important and it breaks my heart that DH isn’t being proactive in building a relationship between DD and my nephew.

I do think DH is more hurt by the whole situation than he makes out, but it’s DSis that is in the difficult position as it’s her marriage that’s affected by this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rheia1983 · 20/06/2022 15:46

I feel for both the OP's husband and @VeryGratefull. So many people do not understand how painful it is (i) to be the target of racism and (ii) being expected to be the "better person" and ignore mean and hurtful behaviour because the racist people are "family".

@TurtleDucks: You are being unreasonable. It is not your husband's responsibility to be proactive in building a relationship between your nephew and your daughter, and doubly so considering he's the actual victim in all of the drama.

SmartCarDriver · 20/06/2022 15:09

Your DH is right

passport123 · 20/06/2022 15:00

My SIL has lots in common with your BIL, though it's not about race, she's just toxic and unpleasant. So the set of cousins aren't close (my kids and theirs). Neither will yours be. Sorry, but you'd be crazy to expose your family to anyone in that family, other than being there for your Sis if she finally sees the light.

billy1966 · 20/06/2022 14:57

VeryGratefull · 20/06/2022 13:43

Hi everyone,

A friend of mine sent this thread to me as I am in the exact same situation. And I mean the exact same situation. Except I am the Muslim Arab and it’s my husband that is white British, and it’s his brother in law (his sister’s husband) who is racist and won’t let their son see us. And we have a son instead of a daughter. He also makes life difficult for her when she tries to see us without their son.

My husband isn’t trying to force a relationship between our son and his nephew, so that’s not an issue for us, but he does feel sad that I’m not close to his sister as he really wants us to be. But I really struggle because of the situation around her husband. I feel like no one on my husband’s side understands how painful this is for me and everyone is focussed on my sister on law being in a difficult situation instead of the hate that is targeted at me because of my existence. Even my husband doesn’t get it as when I get upset he asks me what I want him to do.

And one of my reservations is that I feel that my sister in law does tolerate and turn a blind to the racism, which is why I can’t get close to her, but my husband won’t even hear that.

But anyways, I wanted to say thank you to all the strangers for helping me see that my feelings are valid, and that I have been very tolerant towards my husband and his family about the situation. I sometimes worry that I’m causing problems so I don’t say much about it. I understand that with my in laws it’s their daughter (my husband’s sister) that matters to them more, but I have felt very alone with all this, so reading your comments has honestly made me cry.

Just like I feel sorry for the OP's husband, I feel sorry for you.

Your husband is not a good man if he cannot understand how you feel.

His family are awful too, tolerating this.

Why are you still with him?

The OP's husband must look at the OP with such disappointment for her lack of basic loyalty.

Her sister is no better for tolerating her husband like your SIL.

Do you really want to live your life among such awful people?....and raise a precious child with a man who tolerates racism and expects you to suck it up?

Favouritefruits · 20/06/2022 14:25

Your daughter is half of her Dad so if your BIL hates your DH she will begin to feel that the BIL must hate her too. I agree with your husband.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/06/2022 13:58

VeryGratefull Flowers I'm glad you feel less alone.

Bear in mind there are some posts here that sympathise with the original poster's sister, but only because she's in an abusive relationship, where she may not be safe to stand up for herself and her principles. There's absolutely no excuse for your sister-in-law to put up with her husband's racism unless she agrees with it.

VeryGratefull · 20/06/2022 13:43

Hi everyone,

A friend of mine sent this thread to me as I am in the exact same situation. And I mean the exact same situation. Except I am the Muslim Arab and it’s my husband that is white British, and it’s his brother in law (his sister’s husband) who is racist and won’t let their son see us. And we have a son instead of a daughter. He also makes life difficult for her when she tries to see us without their son.

My husband isn’t trying to force a relationship between our son and his nephew, so that’s not an issue for us, but he does feel sad that I’m not close to his sister as he really wants us to be. But I really struggle because of the situation around her husband. I feel like no one on my husband’s side understands how painful this is for me and everyone is focussed on my sister on law being in a difficult situation instead of the hate that is targeted at me because of my existence. Even my husband doesn’t get it as when I get upset he asks me what I want him to do.

And one of my reservations is that I feel that my sister in law does tolerate and turn a blind to the racism, which is why I can’t get close to her, but my husband won’t even hear that.

But anyways, I wanted to say thank you to all the strangers for helping me see that my feelings are valid, and that I have been very tolerant towards my husband and his family about the situation. I sometimes worry that I’m causing problems so I don’t say much about it. I understand that with my in laws it’s their daughter (my husband’s sister) that matters to them more, but I have felt very alone with all this, so reading your comments has honestly made me cry.

whumpthereitis · 20/06/2022 13:23

I would say*

whumpthereitis · 20/06/2022 13:21

RedHelenB · 20/06/2022 08:53

OK then, we'll just carry on as we are, a great plan.

Yes, I would call continuing to not expose the DH or their child to racist family members does indeed constitute a great plan.

10HailMarys · 20/06/2022 13:09

It still seems sad that he's disconnected from DN. As far as I can see DN hasn't said anything but he's being blamed just because of who his dad is.

Why would you expect him to stay 'connected' to a child he is only related to by marriage and whom never sees and has no relationship with?

He's not blaming the child for anything - the child's parents have literally banned him from seeing the child and therefore he's not going to actively facilitate additional contact between his mixed-race daughter and a family who have already made it clear that they are racist.

Would you expect him to encourage a play date with the child of a pair of racists if those racists were just some old friends of his wife's, rather than her sister and brother in law? I certainly wouldn't. The fact that the child happens to be a cousin is neither here nor there. His daughter isn't losing out by not seeing her cousin.

Rosebel · 20/06/2022 12:48

True but at the moment the cousins aren't meeting. No child or adult should be exposed to racism and it's even worse that it's coming from family.
I can totally see her DHs point and why he doesn't want his DS mixing with DN. I'm sure I'd feel the same.
It still seems sad that he's disconnected from DN. As far as I can see DN hasn't said anything but he's being blamed just because of who his dad is.
Absolutely the most important thing is to protect your DD and not expose her to racist comments but having racist parents doesn't always equal having racist children. If it did you wouldn't hear about parents disowning their children for marrying someone of a different race.
Without knowing what DN has said it's hard to say if it's right keeping the children apart.

eldora · 20/06/2022 11:20

Rosebel · 19/06/2022 21:47

OP said in her first post the cousins weren't seeing each other because her BIL won't allow it.
So in that case how will her DD be affected by DN? They don't see each other so DN won't be saying anything.

Because OP is actively looking for ways her dd can meet her nephew and getting upset that her DH won't help her.

SemperIdem · 20/06/2022 11:12

He wasn’t like this when they met and got married so she thinks it’s just stress

Stress related racism? That’s a new one!

There was a point in my life where I was so stressed at work that I was vomiting before, during and after shifts, absolutely out of my mind stressed. I didn’t suddenly become a racist twat however.

If “stress is making him racist” then he always was racist. Nobody becomes racist overnight.

Your sister agrees with him or she wouldn’t still be with him. You are yourself condoning the behaviour - you seem to care more about your sister and nephew than you do your own child and husband. Thoroughly odd.

10HailMarys · 20/06/2022 10:46

He wasn’t like this when they met and got married so she thinks it’s just stress

I absolutely do not believe that your sister was unaware when she married her husband that he was a racist. People don't just flip a switch one day and become, overnight, so racist that they won't be in a room with a Muslim relative. There is no way that racist views wouldn't have surfaced many times before, and yet she still managed to fall in love with him instead of finding it an abhorrent dealbreaker. She only thinks racism is a problem now that it's actually affecting her relationship with you.

If my sister had a) married a racist and b) claimed her partner's refusal to see (or allow his child to see) my partner for racist reasons was the result of 'just stress', my patience with her would have run out by this point. As you say, she is certainly being treated badly by a controlling partner - but she has also made some very clear choices at various points along the way that very much do not paint her in a good light.

Your DH is absolutely correct in all this. Frankly, he's been way more accommodating of this situation than I would have been in his situation. He is the only one out of all the adults involved who has done literally nothing wrong.

RedHelenB · 20/06/2022 08:53

whumpthereitis · 19/06/2022 20:26

So expose the daughter to racist bullshit from her own family members on the off chance the cousin will one day have a come to Jesus moment and see the light?

Yes. Just chuck her mental and emotional health under a bus for the cousin’s sake. Solid fucking plan, that one. Won’t be damaging at all.

OK then, we'll just carry on as we are, a great plan.

Hippocamp · 20/06/2022 02:55

I would shield your kids from a racist. Far too upsetting. Your DS needs to wake up and leave him.

Renniesfixeverything · 20/06/2022 00:43

Putting aside everything else for the purpose of answering your initial question OP no, your DH is not being unreasonable. He is seeing potential risk to your DD and wanting to protect her from that and he's right, there is a risk of harm to her if your DN parrots his fathers views or treats DD differently because of them. Your DD has family who love her and don't pose any threat, she's missing nothing by not having relationships with family members with the potential to expose her to racism.

In the kindest possible way the picture you have in your mind is based on your own childhood experiences, not the reality you (and more importantly DD) are faced with now. This really isn't worth the risk when it's DD in the firing line, her having the same relationship with her cousin as you had with yours is nowhere near as important as protecting her from racism.

BatshitBanshee · 20/06/2022 00:03

TurtleDucks · 19/06/2022 12:54

That’s not fair…my sister has never said a bad word against my husband or claimed he’s abusive or controlling. It’s her husband that’s the problem.

....to your face. Your sister is as bad as her husband. She's comfortable with her racist and she's comfortable playing the innocent when you're around because there's high drama to see you and it's easy to blame him. You're not there enough to judge what she's like with him.

From one mother of a mixed race child to another: protect your child and do not expose her to racists to play out some faux sentimentality.

whumpthereitis · 19/06/2022 23:45

Sometimeswinning · 19/06/2022 22:57

We're talking about a child. It hits an all time low when people stop taking chances on children because of the parenthood!

"A mixed race kid" Nice description. My racist parent uses the exact same term!

its one thing for adults to take a chance on a kid, it’s another to expect another child to take one for the team, especially a child that’s on the receiving end of racist abuse from said cousin’s family.

He’s not owed a ‘learning experience’, she’s not a tool for his enlightenment. She’s entitled to not be exposed to racist members of her extended family. I guess it also fuck her father for not wanting his kid on the receiving end too. After all her needs are lesser than those of her cousin. Fuck what impact it may have on her and the damage it could cause, cousin is entitled to his teaching aid.

Yeah, bollocks to that.

LateAF · 19/06/2022 23:10

Zwellers · 19/06/2022 20:17

LateAF thanks for the racist assumption all people living outside London are racist.

Stop being so sensitive and stop twisting my words. If I said I won’t ever walk through a park at night again because, male violence, does that mean every man is a rapist or more incidences of rape/sexual violence are perpetrated by men?

I have experienced less racism in London than anywhere else I have lived in the UK. I’m not chancing it again. Unless you lived through targeted racism and exclusion in predominantly white areas or found London to be as racist as less diverse areas, not sure why you’re commenting on my opinion since nothing you say has the weight of actual experience.

Sometimeswinning · 19/06/2022 22:57

whumpthereitis · 19/06/2022 22:19

Yes, exposing a mixed race kid to racists as a teaching aid is…racist. Stunning logic. On that note, I’m gonna go for the hard pass on that suggestion.

fucking hell 😂

We're talking about a child. It hits an all time low when people stop taking chances on children because of the parenthood!

"A mixed race kid" Nice description. My racist parent uses the exact same term!

whumpthereitis · 19/06/2022 22:19

Sometimeswinning · 19/06/2022 20:48

Yes. Just chuck her mental and emotional health under a bus for the cousin’s sake. Solid fucking plan, that one. Won’t be damaging at all.

You need to try it aswell. No one is going to learn or grow with your shitty attitude. It doesn't affect you, so it's easy to spout crap. Stop guilt tripping and facilitating hate!

Yes, exposing a mixed race kid to racists as a teaching aid is…racist. Stunning logic. On that note, I’m gonna go for the hard pass on that suggestion.

fucking hell 😂

Sceptre86 · 19/06/2022 22:05

I'm with your dh. At least he doesn't 'hate ' your nephew based on nothing else but who his father is and that can't be changed. Your bil does feel this way though towards your dh and quite likely your child. It is incredibly hurtful to know that someone would hate me or my children without knowing any of us based on our religion, so I really feel dor your dh. I also do not think your dsis is innocent in this, her dh's racism isn't an issue for her until he comes into contact with your family but I refuse to believe he doesn't air his views in their home or around your dn.

Your dh hasn't interfered in your relationship with your sister and nor should he but I would put my own nuclear family first.

Rosebel · 19/06/2022 21:47

eldora · 19/06/2022 17:21

Maybe her DH is worried about his dd constantly being told by her cousin that his dad doesn’t like her? And it will come up repeatedly, because they’re kids.

It is really harmful to kids being told they’re not liked by a supposed family member due to the colour of their skin or religion.

OP said in her first post the cousins weren't seeing each other because her BIL won't allow it.
So in that case how will her DD be affected by DN? They don't see each other so DN won't be saying anything.

Sometimeswinning · 19/06/2022 20:48

Yes. Just chuck her mental and emotional health under a bus for the cousin’s sake. Solid fucking plan, that one. Won’t be damaging at all.

You need to try it aswell. No one is going to learn or grow with your shitty attitude. It doesn't affect you, so it's easy to spout crap. Stop guilt tripping and facilitating hate!

Swipe left for the next trending thread