Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I be happy with my weight?

139 replies

Nananananahh · 17/06/2022 19:45

Am 5ft5 and 11st 6lbs.

My BMI is 26.6

Ive lost a lot of weight and have naturally settled here.

Nothing I do makes me lose more (and if I do lose a few lbs it creeps back up to around 11.6)

I am alright with how I look in general but I am still very round of belly (that could be due to excess skin too)

Should I just accept this as my weight?

My goal was always to me a 'normal BMI/<25'
26.6 is overweight still.

OP posts:
Punkypinky · 18/06/2022 08:41

I've just caught up with the thread and all these comments on my post have made me smile. I'm certainly not a body builder! I'm not super slim but I'm happy as I am.

I am trying to lose a bit of weight as since I was 16 years old I've fairly consistently been 10 and a half stone (and perfectly happy) but having dd, getting divorced etc has meant it's crept up a bit and I'm trying to nip it in the bud. I'm not going mad on it though and I certainly won't feel bad about myself if I don't manage it. I guess I just wanted to share with the OP in my opinion it's ok to be happy at a weight above the 'ideal'.

PersonaNonGarter · 18/06/2022 08:07

Well done, OP, that’s amazing.

To answer your op, this could depend on what caused you to be overweight in the first place. It might be that for you there is a real risk that if you stop actively trying to lose weight you will start to put it on. That will be depressing, you might overeat, cycle begins and suddenly you are off your plateau in the wrong direction.

Whatever weight you decide to stop losing at, you should be thinking in terms of managed maintenance plan at least for the first couple of years (sorry). You’d probably want to start that only once you were in a healthy bmi.

Don’t waste the amazing work you have done for a few lollies.

Nananananahh · 18/06/2022 07:56

Wrongkindofovercoat · 18/06/2022 07:46

That's a really amazing weight loss, you have lost nearly half your body weight Star
I think some posters will struggle to understand what a massive difference that sort of weight loss makes to someone's health, especially if they feel flabby or huge when a few pounds over their ideal and they have never been very overweight or obese themselves.

How quickly have you lost the weight ? - I think if it has been a relatively quick weight loss, it is natural to hit plateaus as your body sort of recalibrates to its new normal.

How long have you been plateaued at this weight ? - I know it can be frustrating, but a couple of months wouldn't be that unusual as you reach the lower end of the scales on your weight loss journey.

What exercise are you doing ?

Thankyou. About 14 months.

Plateaud about 2.5 months.

OP posts:
Wrongkindofovercoat · 18/06/2022 07:46

That's a really amazing weight loss, you have lost nearly half your body weight Star
I think some posters will struggle to understand what a massive difference that sort of weight loss makes to someone's health, especially if they feel flabby or huge when a few pounds over their ideal and they have never been very overweight or obese themselves.

How quickly have you lost the weight ? - I think if it has been a relatively quick weight loss, it is natural to hit plateaus as your body sort of recalibrates to its new normal.

How long have you been plateaued at this weight ? - I know it can be frustrating, but a couple of months wouldn't be that unusual as you reach the lower end of the scales on your weight loss journey.

What exercise are you doing ?

70kid · 18/06/2022 07:21

I’m 5ft 6 - 11.4

my waist is 28
hips 39
so I look much slimmer than I weigh because my waist nips in
I would like to get to 11stone or just under but
I would need to eat so little I can’t be assed

At my age as J lo said I have to choose between my ass or my face 😂

autienotnaughty · 18/06/2022 03:33

Hi I'm 5.5 and weigh 11.8-11.10

I eat relatively healthily . We do veggie in the week, I get more than my share of fruit n veg a day. I do like crisps but try to limit it. I walk a hour a day plus do yoga and Pilates once a week. I can lose weight if I limit calories to about 1200 but I generally go back up very easily. I'm a14 . I want to be a 12 and would like to lose a stone. Dh doesn't understand as he is very into fitness and trains an hour a day. He weighs 1.5 stone less than me which I hate.

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 03:25

@ToysRMine yes I agree, as I said in my comments above.

ToysRMine · 18/06/2022 03:07

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 01:34

I'm 5'11" and I was HUGE at 73kg when pregnant. I can't understand how this could be healthy or comfortable at 5'4"? I was massive at that weight even though much taller. Confused

Because everyone holds weight differently. I’m 5 ft 9 and 12 stone. My waist is 26 inches. I literally hold no fat there and my muscle % is high. Weight looks different on every body for so many different reasons.

Shoemadlady · 18/06/2022 03:05

Only you can answer that question. Are you happy where you are? It's fine if you are as women are all gorgeous creatures no mattter there size but if you're not, pay for a couple of personal trainer sessions to target the areas you're unhappy with and then just carry on with there teachings after to save money.
Switch up your exercise routine and cut out booze and sugar, makes a massive difference to the mom flab tub (speaking from experience!) you'll notice a difference in about two weeks! X

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 03:01

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 01:59

Maybe it is partly about natural body structure? But on me that weight was very abnormal and horrible. It was gross. I am now back to my usual 60kg ish and it feels normal and just sorts itself out. Perhaps someone with a larger natural build would weigh more and be healthy but to be that weight at 5'4" and be fit and healthy? It doesn't seem likely, or would be very, very unusual.

Unless that person is a body builder or similar!

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 03:00

Or more importantly, BEING healthy and fit!

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 02:57

beachbumlife · 18/06/2022 02:11

It's true, it's probably about body structure and also how we each feel at different weights.

I think so. On some people my height I could imagine that looking fine. On me it did not. I do struggle to imagine it looking healthy and fit on someone 5'4" though?

RaisinGhost · 18/06/2022 02:42

It just depends on you. I'm about that bmi after losing weight, and I am happy with it. Yes I'd ideally like to be thinner, but this weight is a compromise. It's healthier than being bigger, and much easier to maintain than being smaller.

beachbumlife · 18/06/2022 02:11

It's true, it's probably about body structure and also how we each feel at different weights.

beachbumlife · 18/06/2022 02:09

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 01:34

I'm 5'11" and I was HUGE at 73kg when pregnant. I can't understand how this could be healthy or comfortable at 5'4"? I was massive at that weight even though much taller. Confused

73kg is not huge for 5'11''. It's a great weight for me at 5'7''. It's well within the healthy range for my height.

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 01:59

Maybe it is partly about natural body structure? But on me that weight was very abnormal and horrible. It was gross. I am now back to my usual 60kg ish and it feels normal and just sorts itself out. Perhaps someone with a larger natural build would weigh more and be healthy but to be that weight at 5'4" and be fit and healthy? It doesn't seem likely, or would be very, very unusual.

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 01:55

I was waaaaay too big at that weight, 15kg over my usual weight. I felt bloated and uncomfortable and flabby and unfit.

MsOllie · 18/06/2022 01:38

@TheGirlOnTheDragon I don't see how you could be huge. I'm 5ft 10 and at 14 stone I'm a size 14, 11-12 stone would make me a 12. Currently a size 16 and still not "huge"

My friend is the same height and 11 stone and she's a size 10-12 with abs!

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 01:34

Punkypinky · 17/06/2022 22:06

Hi OP I'm 5'4" and 11 stone so yes overweight but I can walk miles, pick up my disabled dd (2.5 stone) several times a day and carry her about and I don't think I look bad. I'm trying to loose a bit of weight as I used to hover at 10.5 stone but if I don't manage it I don't really care. Well done on yr weight loss enjoy your body l. I loved yr boots / outfit in the photo 😊

I'm 5'11" and I was HUGE at 73kg when pregnant. I can't understand how this could be healthy or comfortable at 5'4"? I was massive at that weight even though much taller. Confused

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 18/06/2022 01:31

AngelinaFibres · 17/06/2022 21:54

Do the string test. Take a piece of string and cut it so that it is as tall as you. Fold it in half and wrap it around your waist. The 2 ends should pass through the loop end when the string sits on your natural waist. If the string folded in half doesn't go around your waist with some left over then you are too fat. Doesn't matter how tall anyone is a healthy ratio is the same.

It's crazy that this could not be possible for some people, unless there are serious health issues. Basically you're saying someone's waist should be less than half their height? That seems pretty obvious?!

ConfusedGin · 17/06/2022 23:08

Nothing useful to add but my thanks for starting this thread as you could be me! I've managed to lose a fair amount of weight and am now 3-5lbs above my initial target (which was a healthy BMI) and have consistently been here for 2 months whether I've had a 'good' week or a 'bad' one.

I wasn't really aware of the concept a set weight point before but I'm starting to think maybe that's where I am. And overall I feel good and happy with where I am - although I need to start properly exercising to tone up. My target was the top end of a healthy BMI and honestly now I'm so close I think I'd look gaunt if I really pushed to go much below it.

NagevMama · 17/06/2022 22:35

If you're happy and feel fit enough for everyday tasks, then surely that's all that matters?

BMI was never invented to define what is/is not a healthy individual, it was created to plot indicators of societal health. It was intended to only show how healthy populations are by averaging out individuals' BMI. AND... like most science from its era, was completely based on men. Women have 3 extra organs than men...

If you want to use a more accurate measure of individual health, get your body fat percentage measured instead.

Personally, when I was recovering from an ED that had me obsessed with BMI and the 'skinny ideal' that we see in the West, I had to remind myself that I'm a woman and that a woman's body needs a certain amount of fat to function properly. I started looking at the bodies of tribal women as they live/eat/exercise in the way we are all naturally meant to, and they aren't usually skinny-they have boobs and lumps in all the places I see on myself.

Darbs76 · 17/06/2022 22:24

Definitelynotem · 17/06/2022 21:26

You’re absolutely fine.

To the person who said it will have long term health implications, how ridiculous! You really need to do your research.

BMI is a good general indicator but it’s not accurate at all. In fact, people in the overweight (not obese) category actually live longer than people in the normal weight category.

Having a lot of stomach fat does have health implications. I carry weight on my stomach but have thin arms and legs. When I measured my stomach before I lost 2 stone it was in dangerous to health category. Losing weight isn’t just about vanity, but for health. Whether people believe in BMI or not it can’t be disputed that being fat brings risks.

sausageandbeansx · 17/06/2022 22:13

As long as you’re eating healthy and exercising regularly then you’re fine. If you find that you’re eating a normal amount of calories and exercising and your weight settles at that level, then it is what it is.

Nananananahh · 17/06/2022 22:11

PurpleDaisies · 17/06/2022 21:50

Have you name changed?

For some reason it keeps reverting back to another of my names unless I type it in the box at top so forgot a few times

OP posts: