Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I be happy with my weight?

139 replies

Nananananahh · 17/06/2022 19:45

Am 5ft5 and 11st 6lbs.

My BMI is 26.6

Ive lost a lot of weight and have naturally settled here.

Nothing I do makes me lose more (and if I do lose a few lbs it creeps back up to around 11.6)

I am alright with how I look in general but I am still very round of belly (that could be due to excess skin too)

Should I just accept this as my weight?

My goal was always to me a 'normal BMI/<25'
26.6 is overweight still.

OP posts:
Nananananahh · 18/06/2022 17:04

Nobody else in the house has ever used the scales. It's linked to my phone with a single profile.

I find that astounding.

OP posts:
paulajon · 18/06/2022 17:01

"How is that possible? Losing 6 stone has only taken me down 6%?!"
A brief explanation might be:
When you lose 'weight' some of it is fat, some is water and - if you lose it too quickly - some could be muscle (which is to be avoided if possible).
Assuming you use the same device for your start and finish statistics, you could get a more accurate indication from a calibrated device in a clinic or similar.
** Just another check to make - my scales set has 4 settings (for up to 4 people) and my OH often leaves it on another setting. This led on one occasion to my thinking I'd lost rather more fat % than I'd anticipated. I've since indicated (forcefully) that the device is to be left 'as found' - or else!

Nananananahh · 18/06/2022 16:50

paulajon · 18/06/2022 16:43

How do you check body fat?
I use a decent set of electronic weigh-scales. (Lidl - £24). It gives weight, body fat and water percentages. If you always use the same set of scales, you mightn't know your exact body fat, but you'll see over time if it's decreasing.

OK so I have body fat scales!

At 17st+ it says my body fat % was 41

Ive lost 6 stone and it says my body fat % is now 35

How is that possible? Losing 6 stone has only taken me down 6%?!

How am I supposed to get to the recommended 25% then?

That's another 10%!!

And 6 stone was 6%

I don't understand

OP posts:
paulajon · 18/06/2022 16:43

How do you check body fat?
I use a decent set of electronic weigh-scales. (Lidl - £24). It gives weight, body fat and water percentages. If you always use the same set of scales, you mightn't know your exact body fat, but you'll see over time if it's decreasing.

Nananananahh · 18/06/2022 16:34

paulajon · 18/06/2022 16:13

I stopped bothering about BMI, since it tells you very little that your eyes can't. Check your body fat % instead, and see whether it's within range for your age band.
I had a similar problem with disparity between my upper and lower halves. I went onto a high-fat, low-carb diet and that fixed it (but you really do have to stay away from those tempting carbs). I may not stay on high-fat for ever, but if it keeps my body fat in the 'Ideal' range, I just might stay on it most of the time.
(Probably best to check with your doc - assuming you can get an appointment nowadays! - to see if this would be okay for you, at least for a while.)

How do you check body fat?

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 18/06/2022 16:23

Really op you look fine.a healthy young woman .it really annoys me that women are made to feel they need to lose weight. Men Don't have this pressure. Y

paulajon · 18/06/2022 16:13

I stopped bothering about BMI, since it tells you very little that your eyes can't. Check your body fat % instead, and see whether it's within range for your age band.
I had a similar problem with disparity between my upper and lower halves. I went onto a high-fat, low-carb diet and that fixed it (but you really do have to stay away from those tempting carbs). I may not stay on high-fat for ever, but if it keeps my body fat in the 'Ideal' range, I just might stay on it most of the time.
(Probably best to check with your doc - assuming you can get an appointment nowadays! - to see if this would be okay for you, at least for a while.)

Should I be happy with my weight?
Hankunamatata · 18/06/2022 16:12

I think answer would be are you happy?
I'm same height and losing weight from being a 20+. My max healthy weight for my height is 10st 10lb. I'm 12 st 6lb at moment and debating if I want to go down that far as iv always been about 12 st.

I did have a panic about how awful my body started looking in underwear but using weights machine has helped massively with that. Even just twice a week with heavy weights.

Perhaps vary exercise- cross trainer etc so more whole body.

Theres some interesting articles about resetting your body's weight set point when you have plateaued

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/06/2022 16:03

Try get back into the weight training, it'll transform the bits you dislike.
I know it's hard I'm completely unmotivated to return myself.

Nananananahh · 18/06/2022 15:24

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/06/2022 14:07

If you want to tone while eating a decent diet, no starvation required, do some weight trainings.

You've done the hard part.

I really used to enjoy weight training but I've lost so much confidence that I only do the treadmill at the gym. I really need to get back into a proper workout.

OP posts:
User2145738790 · 18/06/2022 14:24

Notjustanymum · 18/06/2022 09:19

If BMI is to be believed, the average rugby player is morbidly obese! It’s only relevant to people with a specific slight frame and no additional muscle mass - and was invented by a mathematician and not a physician in 19th Century Belgium, when people were much smaller due to all sorts of deficiencies.
Why the medical profession cling to it is beyond me - strikes me as a lazy way of determining whether people are at a healthy weight…

Why do people always have to bring athletes into it?
The vast majority of people are not athletes. The high BMI people I've met irl that say this think living a sedentary life is ok just because a rugby player has a BMI over 25 as well.

User2145738790 · 18/06/2022 14:16

Excess fat around the stomach is an issue.

Hermione101 · 18/06/2022 14:11

I wouldn’t worry too much about BMI, but I would be worried about visceral fat, which can have implications for cardiovascular disease, diabetes and other “lifestyle” diseases.

You probably need to change your body composition i.e more strengthen training to build muscle to become more efficient at burning calories. As you get older, you may feel weight is harder to keep off due to declining muscle mass ( aware of this in my mid-40s now).

I would look into weight training and potentially intermittent fasting.

congratulations on the weight loss!

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/06/2022 14:10

Nananananahh ignore the absolutely nutty responses on this thread.

You've worked hard congratulations, it's a fantastic achievement. 👏

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/06/2022 14:07

If you want to tone while eating a decent diet, no starvation required, do some weight trainings.

You've done the hard part.

Carpy88999 · 18/06/2022 14:04

With weight loss and that stuff the best advice I was ever given was to close your eyes and imagine your dream physique now open them. You ain't getting it!

Aim for half of it and anything else is a bonus. Don't let perfect be the enemy of the good.

swifty1974 · 18/06/2022 13:48

Nananananahh · 18/06/2022 13:43

I would never wear a bikini so that's irrelevant. I would happily wear a swimming costume.

I do not like what I see in the mirror no. But that's very saggy skin/breats and extreme stretchmarks from weight gain.

Nothing losing more weight would fix.

Then you have your answer....stop beating yourself up about it....

Nananananahh · 18/06/2022 13:43

I would never wear a bikini so that's irrelevant. I would happily wear a swimming costume.

I do not like what I see in the mirror no. But that's very saggy skin/breats and extreme stretchmarks from weight gain.

Nothing losing more weight would fix.

OP posts:
swifty1974 · 18/06/2022 13:41

KylieKoKo · 17/06/2022 21:41

if you’re an average person. 26.6 is too fat. Sorry but it is.

Too fat for what @MrsSkylerWhite?

If a generally accepted measure is telling you you're overweight than it's probably a good idea to take notice of it....this is however completely not relevant to the question should you be happy with it....you should be happy with it if you are happy with it....if you're not then no you shouldn't....are you uncomfortable in a bikini on holiday....do you like what you see in the mirror....if so great....if not do something about it....in my opinion the only level your body finds on its own is as a result of the balance between calories consumed and energy expended....change the balance one way or the other and your body will react....it's not complicated.....you are the only person that can answer the question though

Memaww · 18/06/2022 13:38

user7637296 · 18/06/2022 13:12

Heavens no!

Then you'll never understand how being just 1.5 over a healthy BMI could be a massive achievement :)

user7637296 · 18/06/2022 13:12

Wrongkindofovercoat · 18/06/2022 11:42

@user7637296 Have you ever weighed 20 stone ?

Heavens no!

Nananananahh · 18/06/2022 12:32

user7637296 · 18/06/2022 11:33

I wouldn't be happy at that weight/BMI.

My BMI is 21.3.

But you seem content so it's all subjective!

I think it is subjective. If you've always been BMI - 21 then 26 would seem heavy to you.

In 2020 my BMI was 45 so 26 seems light to

OP posts:
Memaww · 18/06/2022 12:31

user7637296 · 18/06/2022 11:33

I wouldn't be happy at that weight/BMI.

My BMI is 21.3.

But you seem content so it's all subjective!

I thin it is subjective. If you've always been BMI21 then 26 would seem heavy to you.

In 2020 my BMI was 45 so 26 seems light to me.

Drmartens · 18/06/2022 11:57

I am the same height and weight. Ideally I would like to lose a bit more weight but I am much happier with my body now than I was.

HintofVintagePink · 18/06/2022 11:51

You’ve done brilliantly well! Agree with PP, take a mental rest now and enjoy your achievements!