Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Historical novels – authenticity v. offensiveness?

64 replies

duckyegg · 17/06/2022 16:25

Looking for some guidance from the wise folks of Mumsnet, please.

I am trying to write my first novel – it is set in 16th/17th Century England featuring a female lead character, and is based on real life events. I’ve done quite a lot of research into the period, reading original documents etc, and have gained a lot of insight into how these people would think, behave and view the world. The opinions of a 16th/17th Century Englishwoman seem to be as far removed as it is possible to be from modern views and may well include some, if not all, of the following:

• Sexism (the man is the head of the household, and a wife should be in subjection to him)
• Racism (the English are better than other nations)
• Homophobia
• Religious sectarianism (strongly held Protestant/Catholic views, and viewing the other side as evil heretics)
• Colonialism (it is fine to go and settle in other lands, as non-Christian people are savages)

So my question is – do modern readers want to read this in a novel?

I’ve read a couple of novels set in this period where the author seems to get around this by giving the main character a modern mindset. It makes it easier for the reader to identify with the character, but can seem inauthentic – like a 21st Century woman scampering around a historical setting in a dressing-up outfit.

As a reader, what would your preference be?

Is authenticity most important, or is it better to have a main character whose views you share?

Would really appreciate some guidance with this before I get too far into writing.
All voting and comments very gratefully received – thank you!

YABU – I don’t want to read a novel where the main character holds these offensive views. I want a lead character whose values are similar to mine so that I can identify with her.

YANBU – I want all the characters to be as authentic as possible, even if I don’t share their views.

OP posts:
GCRich · 17/06/2022 18:05

PonyPatter44 · 17/06/2022 18:00

What is the point of transforming the past into a pallid reflection of the present? Surely the point of a historical novel is to transport you into the minds and hearts of the people who lived then? You don’t have to endorse what we currently consider to be their mistaken views.

Exactly this!

Yep... agree too.

But surely it all depends. Does OP want to write a book that gives an insight into the past, or does she want to write a book that pretends to give an insight into the past whilst actually being about the present more than the time it is set it.

Or does she not care, it's all about sales and it really is a question of writing whatever she thinks will sell.

PonyPatter44 · 17/06/2022 18:00

What is the point of transforming the past into a pallid reflection of the present? Surely the point of a historical novel is to transport you into the minds and hearts of the people who lived then? You don’t have to endorse what we currently consider to be their mistaken views.

Exactly this!

ChagSameachDoreen · 17/06/2022 17:57

Sorry - in historical fiction!

ChagSameachDoreen · 17/06/2022 17:57

TryingToBeUnique · 17/06/2022 16:37

Well, I like the Flashman novels so I probably would go for authenticity. The man is a rapist and a racist. I suppose that’s one way round it: a totally amoral main character.
I can see it’s difficult though and I’m not sure they (The Flashman novels) could find a publisher today.

They were republished in 2015! I analysed "Flashman and the Dragon" as part of my PhD on racist representations of the Chinese in ho

cormorant5 · 17/06/2022 17:54

Do you want to write about how it really was or about how would you have preferred it to be?
Some of the popular writers such as Georgette Heyer have a grain of realism but mainly it is a device to introduce pretty dresses and horses.

Nahnanananahna · 17/06/2022 17:17

I think it's best to avoid the contentious topics if possible. If you have to cover them, try to be true to the era but I'd remove the worst of it if you want the character to be likeable.

Not a novel but the recent(ish,) adaptation of Anne of Green Gables annoyed me a lot by having a story line where she was unthinkingly welcoming to members of the local black community, and everyone else around Anne ended up being too with very little difficulty. I felt it was completely unrealistic for that that would have ever been the case at the time or that that storyline would have played out that way in the book and to pretend it would was glossing over unpleasantness in the past. Similarly there was a storyline on her being completely accepting of a gay friend. She was a sheltered girl growing up in a highly religious community on Prince Edward Island in the late 19th century - come on!

parietal · 17/06/2022 17:17

historical accuracy where possible, but you can also think about whether / how your character might confront these issues. I'd find it hard to read a novel where the main character lazily instructs her butler to buy some more slaves for her plantation with no negative consequences, but it might be realistic to have a main character who makes ignorant negative comments about foreigners or who makes sexist comments but still feels and rails against the negative consequences of society's overall sexism.

Novella12 · 17/06/2022 16:58

I had to navigate a lot of this when writing my own novel (about the 1612 Pendle witch trials). I think the fact that you are telling a story based on real life events means you may well have to weave these things in. With my novel, there are obviously very heavy themes of sexism and patriarchal religion, but readers have taken this as part of the time that it is set and, of course, they are integral to the story. The publishers were happy and readers seem to be to!

Focus on what is necessary for your story. Historical romances may well avoid this sort of thing to allow for a better reading experience- your own novel may need it.

Sounds really interesting by the way, and good luck!

1stTimeMama · 17/06/2022 16:56

Accurate and historically factual all the way. We can't change history, nothing anyone does today, no matter how many busts and statues they demand are removed, is going to change anything that happened in the past. Stick to the realities, otherwise I think it reads too try hard.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 17/06/2022 16:53

‘Racism : the English are better than other nations’ : thats not racism, it is what they would have defined as patriotism. Racism is disliking someone for racial characteristics, for example skin colour or facial features.

Most of the women in the period you are writing about would have had very little concept of anyone of a different race, unless they lived in a port town or were high status and travelled out of England. A Foreigner was someone who came from across the county border ( still is, where I used to live in France!).

What is the point of transforming the past into a pallid reflection of the present? Surely the point of a historical novel is to transport you into the minds and hearts of the people who lived then? You don’t have to endorse what we currently consider to be their mistaken views.

EatYourVegetables · 17/06/2022 16:50

Would a 17th century heroine frequently be asked to express her views on the topic of gay rights?

TheNoonBell · 17/06/2022 16:47

I hate "historial" books that have been written with modern sensibilities in mind. They just don't work. I for one read historical fiction to see how awful things were and how far we have come.

forinborin · 17/06/2022 16:43

I suggest you go and read through the Outlander subreddit, the book that probably threads very carefully alongside "YABU" scenario as the heroine is conveniently a time traveller (and even then, unusually progressive even for a woman from 1940s / 1960s), but with occassional glimpses from "YANBU" world from secondary characters. And you will see that many people are indeed mortally offended that an 18th century sailor is not enlightened about feminism or equality.

Me personally, I prefer believable characters, true to their epoch, with vices and flaws native to the time as well. You need to give them something immediately redeemable, I think, to show that they are inherently good.

TryingToBeUnique · 17/06/2022 16:37

Well, I like the Flashman novels so I probably would go for authenticity. The man is a rapist and a racist. I suppose that’s one way round it: a totally amoral main character.
I can see it’s difficult though and I’m not sure they (The Flashman novels) could find a publisher today.