Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Historical novels – authenticity v. offensiveness?

64 replies

duckyegg · 17/06/2022 16:25

Looking for some guidance from the wise folks of Mumsnet, please.

I am trying to write my first novel – it is set in 16th/17th Century England featuring a female lead character, and is based on real life events. I’ve done quite a lot of research into the period, reading original documents etc, and have gained a lot of insight into how these people would think, behave and view the world. The opinions of a 16th/17th Century Englishwoman seem to be as far removed as it is possible to be from modern views and may well include some, if not all, of the following:

• Sexism (the man is the head of the household, and a wife should be in subjection to him)
• Racism (the English are better than other nations)
• Homophobia
• Religious sectarianism (strongly held Protestant/Catholic views, and viewing the other side as evil heretics)
• Colonialism (it is fine to go and settle in other lands, as non-Christian people are savages)

So my question is – do modern readers want to read this in a novel?

I’ve read a couple of novels set in this period where the author seems to get around this by giving the main character a modern mindset. It makes it easier for the reader to identify with the character, but can seem inauthentic – like a 21st Century woman scampering around a historical setting in a dressing-up outfit.

As a reader, what would your preference be?

Is authenticity most important, or is it better to have a main character whose views you share?

Would really appreciate some guidance with this before I get too far into writing.
All voting and comments very gratefully received – thank you!

YABU – I don’t want to read a novel where the main character holds these offensive views. I want a lead character whose values are similar to mine so that I can identify with her.

YANBU – I want all the characters to be as authentic as possible, even if I don’t share their views.

OP posts:
TryingToBeUnique · 17/06/2022 20:58

I know that’s a bit later, but I think it shows you can be very parochial, avoid politics but still be very interesting.

TryingToBeUnique · 17/06/2022 20:49

Do modern readers find much to be offended by in Jane Austen?

JohannSebastianBach · 17/06/2022 20:48

I also think that your summing up of average views of a 16th/17th century woman is a bit simplistic. People were not a homogeneous hive mind then, not everyone held all those views.

I imagine most average women at the time outside of big cities and major ports probably didn't spend that much time thinking about a lot of those things. They were probably too busy working hard to feed themselves.

It's difficult to comprehend now how people physically worked so hard in the past.

JohannSebastianBach · 17/06/2022 20:38

Writing a person in and of their time does not mean an author endorses the views held by a character and depending on the story would you need to examine all those things in minute detail?

Presumably not all of those "issues" would come up?

ElizabethinherGermanGarden · 17/06/2022 20:26

Have you read Valerie Martin's Property? I loved it precisely because the 'heroine' has pretty awful attitudes linked to her time and class and is still a well-rounded character. She's horrifyingly racist and entitled while still being brave and admirable in some other aspects of her character. The idea that people are not just one thing seems like an important one.

FinallyHere · 17/06/2022 20:09

Authenticity but you don't have to put the awkward parts front and centre.

Jane Austen skimmed over a lot of what was happening at that point on history and still provided believable characters grounded in honesty (with a spice of ludicrous nonsense from others )

BeautifulWar · 17/06/2022 20:01

I prefer authenticity but depending on the story, half of these issues won't need to represented. I think the most everyday issue would be sexism, but history is also littered with women who has 'unusual' ideas.

SarahAndQuack · 17/06/2022 19:53

I don't like importing modern ideas/values.

But I also think what would make me wince would be a character from the 16th/17th century displaying 'homophobia' or very broad-strokes misogyny or whatever. I know you're using those terms as shorthand, but IMO it's books that don't really trying to engage with the specific ways people thought that bother me the most.

A friend of a friend got me to read part of her unpublished novel a while back, and she had a male character whose internal monologue was all about how guilty he felt that he loved his male best friend, and how awful it made him feel, and so on. There was nothing sexual mentioned. It was such bullshit, because that's a modern perception of how a person with (internalised) homophobic attitudes might feel, not one from the era she was dealing with.

SammyScrounge · 17/06/2022 19:40

There is little point in arguing with the past - it was what it was. Rewriting it is futile. Imposing modern thinking on it is farcical..

DramaAlpaca · 17/06/2022 19:17

Authenticity please, or I'll end up putting it down in annoyance and not finishing it.

DyingForACuppa · 17/06/2022 19:14

I prefer authenticity, unless you are going for total Heyer/Julia Quinn fluff.

I particularly hate the trope where the servants all totally love the rich hero/heroine like a member of their own family.

ShaneTwane · 17/06/2022 19:10

Authenticity all the way otherwise there is no point set your novel now. History is important otherwise how can anyone learn and improve and that goes for historic novels as well . You can still have a rebellious character who doesn't quite fit society norms of the time, Cathy from wuthering heights is a prime example of this in real time!

I'm currently reading a story set in Elizabethan England about a teenager who is accused of being a witch. It's a bit of a weird one because some details are good but I feel the author is really trying to make the dad likeable to the reader so he shuns some of the ideals of the time teaching his daughter which in turn makes them think she's a witch. It all seems a bit try hard to make us feel she and her father would slot right into modern society.

FrancescaContini · 17/06/2022 19:05

You can’t “clean up” history to suit the delicate sensibility of an early 21st century British reader. I also don’t think you can write to a formula or ticking boxes as you go…I’m not a writer but I find your questions strange. Are you doing an evening class in creative writing?

TheMarzipanDildo · 17/06/2022 19:04

I think it’s great that you’re thinking about that- I’ve read too much historical fiction in which the hero is some kind of ‘judge’ of those around them. Like they are looking at the past (their present!) knowing exactly what is going to happen next. (I blame Walter Scott)

Ylvamoon · 17/06/2022 19:02

It has to be authentic otherwise it wouldn't be classified as a historic novel.

A well researched historical novel based in facts and real events is alway better! That includes all the stuff we as a society don't approve of or have come to understand that they are wrong/ untrue.
Think about your readers, who would read your novel?

DogInATent · 17/06/2022 19:01

Realism where it pertains to the plot and without explanation. Don't contrive in any of these realisms, and don't lose the thread by explaining why. Focus on the story, and whether those views of the heroine are relevant to advancing it. If the heroine has views that are overtly offensive to the reader it will be incredibly hard to make her sympathetic.

Turefu · 17/06/2022 18:58

I hate historical dramas written with XXI century mind. They just don’t work, they’re awful. There was a character in the last series of Poldark, daughter of wealthy man , who wants to marry her of well, while she wants to be “ her own person” and gets involved with anti- slavery movement. She’s ending up leaving her father and England for America, where she’s going to “build the life for herself”. Yeah, right. With no money, no skills and not being able to represent herself within law. Likely she’d ended up as courtesan.
OP, write a fantastic novel. I’ll read it.

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 17/06/2022 18:58

Authenticity the whole way. How else do we get reminded of how things were. It also sparks conversation.

MadMadMadamMim · 17/06/2022 18:50

Authenticity. There is no point writing an historical novel that is a load of bollocks, basically. And the PP talking about Georgette Heyer having a 'grain of realism' obviously doesn't realise how very seriously Heyer took her research. She was an absolute expert on Georgian matters and they are absolutely accurate in every tiny detail. She was obsessive about it. They are far from a 'device' to introduce pretty dresses and horses. Yes, they are frothy romance - but the historical detail is spot on.

SpaceJamtart · 17/06/2022 18:39

I think it depends what you are writing,
I don't mind reading books where people have opinions that are different from mine and If you were writing about a very specific period in history because you are writing about real people then it is probably important to be authentic. Same as if you were writing a boook where the main character is working on the underground railroad, obviously the circumstances have to reflect reality.

On the other hand, having what are now known to be cruel and horrible opinions stated as fact does narrow your audience.
I dont like reading about the hero of a story who also thinks I should be in a freak show or that my sister should be enslaved, because it feels bad. and I'm not saying that people shouldn't write those books, but I'm not going to read them because thankfully we live in a time where I dont have to listen to those horrible opinions especially if its not relevant to the storyline.

And also if it is a made up story with made up characters and its not a story that that revolves on the concept of colonialism, then I dont see the point.
If you are inventing people, inventing buildings and events that didn't actually take place in history even if they are based in the past. Then you are creating a world and If I was going to get to invent a world and invent a past, I'm not gonna invent one with racism in it.

PlanetNormal · 17/06/2022 18:36

YANBU.

I am an adult, and well educated. I am therefore quite capable of dealing with the fact that not everyone who has ever lived agreed with me, or subscribed to the prevailing virtue-signalling pieties of the 21st century’s generation snowflake.

EcoEcoIA · 17/06/2022 18:32

YANBU Recently I read a Faulker novel, Intruder in the Dust, wincing at every use of the n-word, and the racist attitudes, but that is how people spoke and thought in the Southern state of the USA in those times. To have that ugly past whitewashed would diminish the truth and the struggle of those who came after, and the significance of the novel in its day.

Also recently I watched a Netflix drama, Hollywood, in which a film with a black American female romantic lead with a white male lead was actually made in the 1940s, and the film winning the oscars, and Rock Hudson able to go to the Oscars ceremony as an openly gay man holding his black screenwriters hand. Poetic licence if fine, but a wish fulfilment phantasy about triumphing over racism, sexism and homophobia in the 1940s is naive.

The past was horrible. It should make you feel uncomfortable. Dickens was good at making people feel uncomfortable in his own time.

Sarah Waters manages the historic/modern mindset thing quite well, but I still feel it's a bit too right on.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 17/06/2022 18:27

I think that you can learn a lot about the attitudes and mores of a particular historical period by reading the documents that have survived, and also, to a certain extent, from the art of the period.

frogswimming · 17/06/2022 18:17

Do you think it's possible to actually know how a historical character would think?

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 17/06/2022 18:11

I read a lot of historical fiction, and I expect authenticity - and the attitudes of the time are as much of the scene setting as making sure the descriptions of the clothing, the houses, the things that happen etc are. I don’t expect a 16th century character to act or think like a 21st century one.

I hope that makes sense - I know what I am trying to say, but I think my brain is scrambling it.