Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Historical novels – authenticity v. offensiveness?

64 replies

duckyegg · 17/06/2022 16:25

Looking for some guidance from the wise folks of Mumsnet, please.

I am trying to write my first novel – it is set in 16th/17th Century England featuring a female lead character, and is based on real life events. I’ve done quite a lot of research into the period, reading original documents etc, and have gained a lot of insight into how these people would think, behave and view the world. The opinions of a 16th/17th Century Englishwoman seem to be as far removed as it is possible to be from modern views and may well include some, if not all, of the following:

• Sexism (the man is the head of the household, and a wife should be in subjection to him)
• Racism (the English are better than other nations)
• Homophobia
• Religious sectarianism (strongly held Protestant/Catholic views, and viewing the other side as evil heretics)
• Colonialism (it is fine to go and settle in other lands, as non-Christian people are savages)

So my question is – do modern readers want to read this in a novel?

I’ve read a couple of novels set in this period where the author seems to get around this by giving the main character a modern mindset. It makes it easier for the reader to identify with the character, but can seem inauthentic – like a 21st Century woman scampering around a historical setting in a dressing-up outfit.

As a reader, what would your preference be?

Is authenticity most important, or is it better to have a main character whose views you share?

Would really appreciate some guidance with this before I get too far into writing.
All voting and comments very gratefully received – thank you!

YABU – I don’t want to read a novel where the main character holds these offensive views. I want a lead character whose values are similar to mine so that I can identify with her.

YANBU – I want all the characters to be as authentic as possible, even if I don’t share their views.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SquirrelFan · 19/06/2022 13:38

Please don't too closely emulate Hilary Mantel - I found Wolf Hall very hard to follow! That said, I prefer a third-person viewpoint. First - person seems presumptuous, somehow. Also in a first - person novel, the description is never quite as good, because it's unrealistic to have the main character constantly describing /narrating her surroundings!

Gusfringrules · 19/06/2022 07:15

duckyegg · 17/06/2022 16:25

Looking for some guidance from the wise folks of Mumsnet, please.

I am trying to write my first novel – it is set in 16th/17th Century England featuring a female lead character, and is based on real life events. I’ve done quite a lot of research into the period, reading original documents etc, and have gained a lot of insight into how these people would think, behave and view the world. The opinions of a 16th/17th Century Englishwoman seem to be as far removed as it is possible to be from modern views and may well include some, if not all, of the following:

• Sexism (the man is the head of the household, and a wife should be in subjection to him)
• Racism (the English are better than other nations)
• Homophobia
• Religious sectarianism (strongly held Protestant/Catholic views, and viewing the other side as evil heretics)
• Colonialism (it is fine to go and settle in other lands, as non-Christian people are savages)

So my question is – do modern readers want to read this in a novel?

I’ve read a couple of novels set in this period where the author seems to get around this by giving the main character a modern mindset. It makes it easier for the reader to identify with the character, but can seem inauthentic – like a 21st Century woman scampering around a historical setting in a dressing-up outfit.

As a reader, what would your preference be?

Is authenticity most important, or is it better to have a main character whose views you share?

Would really appreciate some guidance with this before I get too far into writing.
All voting and comments very gratefully received – thank you!

YABU – I don’t want to read a novel where the main character holds these offensive views. I want a lead character whose values are similar to mine so that I can identify with her.

YANBU – I want all the characters to be as authentic as possible, even if I don’t share their views.

Authenticity all the way, even if it is a novel
Everything historical is being whitewashed away. We can't learn from history if we continually revise or delete it
Women were considered to be their husband's property for hundreds of years; their life, goods and chattels belonged to him. Yes, it is almost impossible to think of this today, but it is still happening in many, many countries today (think middle east, etc)
Women are still considered unclean while menstruating or post-partum
Homophobia is alive and well in 100s of countries whether legal or not
The British remain convinced they are the arbiters of religious and cultural superiority

So, your historical novel is as up to date as it was in the 16 century; kerp everything in because nothing has changed

entropynow · 19/06/2022 00:19

Just make sure it is properly researched from historians' work and not secondhand assumptions about how much more enlightened we are now.
They weren't a monolith in the past - some groups during the Commonwealth had very radical views.
Had to chuck a historical novel away the other week due to the author clearly having absorbed myths about the 19th century without checking.

SarahAndQuack · 18/06/2022 22:32

I don't think it's the pronoun choice that makes Cromwell sympathetic in the Wolf Hall trilogy. I think it's that she makes his decisions seem rooted in such genuine, thoughtful, emotionally honest principles. So we might not agree with him, but she makes him seem a really decent person who tries to do his best.

IMO the reason some historical fiction sounds wrong, is that it presumes people think about issues in the abstract, so if the question is whether we believe in witches or not, the lead character will constantly be thinking about that in the abstract, as if they were about to answer a GCSE question. It's not realistic.

Fulbe · 18/06/2022 17:10

I can't stand sappy women and misogynist men, such as in Georgette Heyer's novels, or Bleak House. In fact I had to stop reading Bleak House for that reason. However, these are of course popular amongst the general public.

I think there's a fine line between parroting the ideas of the past and having a character who recognises injustices and does something to try to remedy them. Elizabeth Gaskell's North and South is a great example of this.

londonmummy1966 · 18/06/2022 16:53

I've researched this period a lot so a modern viewpoint would really jar for me. I agree with PP that you should only really go into offensive thoughts/beliefs if they are relevant to the plot or if you are working with a real character if they have expressed them in someway. So if for eg you were writing about the wife/mistress of a privateer involved in the new world and slave trade then I would prefer to see an authentic voice but you could couple it with narrative/description that demonstrates the human suffering that this entails - easier perhaps to incorporate this if writing in the third person.

The sexism side might be easier to handle as there are plenty of so called "rebellious women" in the ballads and pamphlets of the time so you could address it with the internal dialogue of a woman who has to curb her own inclinations to fall into line with the dictates of her husband without necessarily being inauthentic.

hattie43 · 18/06/2022 16:11

Authenticity.

We are going to end up in a very sanitised world where we know nothing about history because we've erased it otherwise .

ShaneTwane · 18/06/2022 15:48

Op in regards to first or third person that's so individual to each reader. I write in both depending on what I want from the story I'm writing. Sometimes I want to just tell a story as if I know the tale and want to share what I know. Other times I want to write in first person and have the reader come along with the protagonist and experience it in real time so to speak. If first person is your preferred method then that's what you should do as it's more natural and free flowing rather than trying to please readers. Your telling your story not theirs :)

duckyegg · 18/06/2022 15:18

Thank you to all who have replied. It’s really helpful to hear your thoughts, and thank you for the references to other books etc.

My reason for asking about this is because the person I am writing about holds a very particular set of religious/political views which determine her actions and therefore drive the storyline. Her views however, are very different from those of the modern world/my own, and that is why I find her so interesting/challenging – it is like putting on a completely different head.

So, I have a second question for you – do you prefer novels that are written with a first person point of view (I did this, I did that), or a third person (she did this, she did that)?

I generally prefer books that are written in the first person, and my instinct is to write it this way. However, I wonder if dealing with a somewhat challenging character is better done in third person – I find it interesting how Hilary Mantel deals with Thomas Cromwell (who is a pretty unpleasant bloke) by referring to him as ‘he’, as if she is keeping him at arms length.

What would your preference be?

OP posts:
LeniGray · 18/06/2022 13:50

I’ve stopped reading newer historical fiction. I’d prefer a more accurate reflection of what a particular period would’ve been like, for me that’s part of the appeal of reading it in the first place. If you want to get it published you can only be so authentic though - publishers seem to be especially frightened of releasing anything that could be construed as ‘offensive’ in any way now.

HardbackWriter · 18/06/2022 13:48

Surely it depends on the role you want your protagonist to play? If they're an anti-hero then it won't be such a problem but if they're supposed to be the sympathetic heart of the book that the reader really roots for then realistically it'll be a hard sell for people if you have them espouse views that would, to most readers, make them a bad person.

cormorant5 · 18/06/2022 13:37

@TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross
Yes you are right about Infamous Army, so apologies from me.
I was thinking of books like Grand Sophy.
On her writing style, she often rushed her endings. Pressure from publisher or Tax man.

oopsfellover · 18/06/2022 11:14

I'd find it interesting to read a novel where a character lived in a society shaped by these views but kicked against them (either inwardly or outwardly) in some way, for example by doubting the existence of God. I think there can be a tendency to simplify and generalise about our ancestors, whilst viewing our own age as nuanced and complex. The balance needs to be there though, to preserve some degree of authenticity. Good luck with your novel - what a brilliant project.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 18/06/2022 11:13

cormorant5 · 17/06/2022 17:54

Do you want to write about how it really was or about how would you have preferred it to be?
Some of the popular writers such as Georgette Heyer have a grain of realism but mainly it is a device to introduce pretty dresses and horses.

‘A grain of realism’? Have you ever READ any Georgette Heyer? Her novels are meticulously researched. An Infamous Army was recommended reading at Sandhurst, it was deemed such an accurate depiction of the Battle of Waterloo.

It really irritates me that she is written off as some kind of chick lit author, usually by people who have never read a single word of what she’s written.

latetothefisting · 18/06/2022 11:06

Novella12 · 17/06/2022 16:58

I had to navigate a lot of this when writing my own novel (about the 1612 Pendle witch trials). I think the fact that you are telling a story based on real life events means you may well have to weave these things in. With my novel, there are obviously very heavy themes of sexism and patriarchal religion, but readers have taken this as part of the time that it is set and, of course, they are integral to the story. The publishers were happy and readers seem to be to!

Focus on what is necessary for your story. Historical romances may well avoid this sort of thing to allow for a better reading experience- your own novel may need it.

Sounds really interesting by the way, and good luck!

On the off-chance you are Stacey Halls, I loved The Familiars Grin

OP - I agree with the posters saying authentic BUT actually to reflect on how many of those attitudes there will be an actual need to address organically during the novel, rather than throwing it in for a bit of flavour. The thing you haven't mentioned, which would be hardest to avoid, is class and how people thought of that in terms of pretty much all their daily interactions with others.

e.g. if your character is fairly wealthy, even if she likes one of her servants, it's not going to be the awkward MN-etter chatting politely to her cleaner and agonising over a christmas tip relationship.

Strathyre · 18/06/2022 03:16

A previous poster mentioned relevance to the story, and I think that's really important. If these issues are central to the plot, they need to be dealt with realistically. But there's no need to chuck in gratuitous racism or homophobia just as scene setting. Better to just walk past them. As a previous poster also said, how much time would your average 17th century woman have spent thinking about e.g. homosexuality?

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/06/2022 00:15

There are plenty of historical novels where lead characters have all these views, they can still be sympathetic, you just have to write them well.

Nat6999 · 17/06/2022 23:49

I love romantic fiction set in WW2, the best ones are the ones that are set in real places. I love looking on Google Earth at the places in the story, it makes me feel like I am inside the story.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/06/2022 23:36

Very good job!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/06/2022 23:36

@Nahnanananahna , exactly right.

My DM, born 1918 in the S of England, and had a very job in central London in her early 20s, had never even heard of gay men until she’d been married for a couple of years. Someone at work told her - she didn’t believe them! Had to wait until my DF was home on leave during WW2, to ask him.,

I’m another who loathes modern opinions/beliefs being grafted on to fictional characters from former eras. It just doesn’t ring true.

Having said that, I do wince a bit at e.g. anti-Semitic sentiments in Victorian novels, but they did reflect attitudes at the time. But while expressing these in some of his characters, Anthony Trollope (e.g.) does make it clear that such sentiments were already becoming old fashioned, and in one of his novels he does portray a Jewish man as an infinitely better person that the aristocratic girl of violently anti-Semitic parents who he’d hoped to marry - until she revealed that she was interested only in his money.

Thatswhyimacat · 17/06/2022 23:08

I love books that find a modern, relatable angle from the attitudes of the time - for example, recent books that frame the experiences of Katharine Howard more as sexual abuse rather than the downfall of a slovenly woman. However, I get extremely irritated by books set in the past where the women have entirely modern attitudes. It seems a tiresome shortcut to write them as a strong character, where I'd be more interested in the strength women found within the confines of their time. I absolutely don't mind a character having outdated views and morals, so long as it isn't done gratuitously - I'd like the book to have something to say about these issues and be presenting the characters views as something to be considered. For example, in The Sweetness of Water, there are plenty of racist characters as it is set in immediately post civil war USA, and it isn't sanitised or presented as something it wasn't, but it also includes the perspective of the black characters to avoid it becoming gratuitous racism. I would think about WHY your character might need to express say, colonialist views - what does it add? What does it tell us about her?

forinborin · 17/06/2022 23:00

SomewhereEast · 17/06/2022 21:33

I'm a historian by background (have a PhD in a particular obscure area of early 20thc history) and would perhaps inevitably opt for authenticity. Writers projecting a particular set of early 21st century Western values onto the past make my teeth itch. If people are going to be offended by fictional presentations of values other than their own they probably shouldn't read any fiction written or set before about...I don't know? 2019?

Anything set before Q1 2022 is risky.

SomewhereEast · 17/06/2022 21:33

I'm a historian by background (have a PhD in a particular obscure area of early 20thc history) and would perhaps inevitably opt for authenticity. Writers projecting a particular set of early 21st century Western values onto the past make my teeth itch. If people are going to be offended by fictional presentations of values other than their own they probably shouldn't read any fiction written or set before about...I don't know? 2019?

MaChienEstUnDick · 17/06/2022 21:00

I think the question to ask yourself is the same question any aspiring novelist has to ask: WHY do I want to tell THIS story and WHY am I the best - and only - person to tell it?

Austen was a genius but you certainly don't come away from any of her novels thinking that sexism was OK, even though her characters were all operating in a system of complete sexism and patriarchy. She wrote about genteel women's fight for their very survival - her characters didn't need to have a modern sensibility to display that story arc, they just got on with doing the do.

I think it's incredibly important for a first-time novelist to have a likeable lead character - you need a lot of experience to pull off an unreliable narrator or a baddie - so just put your character in that situation and let her fight her fight.

toastofthetown · 17/06/2022 21:00

I think there's a balance to be struck between authenticity and not being offensive. And also, why are you writing a book? If you want it to be traditionally published, then a book containing overt racism and homophobia which is never addressed is unlikely to picked up. I don't need a character to have modern views in a very jarring way, but I also don't really want to follow a protagonist who is so far apart from views that I find it distasteful. Unless the character is written as an antihero, but I assume she's planned to be a heroine type. Do all of these points need to be addressed. I read a a novel set in the 16th century recently and no notice was paid to the characters view on colonialism or homosexuality etc as it just wasn't relevant.

I don't read a lot of historical fiction, but what is on the market at the moment? That's your benchmark, and that's who you are hoping your book will sit alongside in the bookstore, so for something like this, I'd try to fit in. Unless you are trying to make specific point something, which sets your book apart. In general the best advice for most publishing questions is to read many new releases in your genre.

Swipe left for the next trending thread