Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to be a social worker?

54 replies

user0512 · 17/06/2022 16:12

Hi All,

So, sometimes I contemplate on completing a child social work degree (I already have a degree - but I contemplate doing a conversion so I can practice as a social worker). But I wanted to know what it's really like?

What are the pros and cons? What kinds of cases are you currently working with (of course without mentioning any names etc)

Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notnownorma · 11/07/2022 17:33

user0512 · 17/06/2022 22:01

Are you held accountable when they go missing? is it up to you to find them? Surely that would be down to the police right?

Yes because social workers are hard bitches and only care about things that are their legal responsibility.🙄

Knockknockandout · 11/07/2022 17:23

socialworkme · 17/06/2022 18:50

I'm currently a social worker, for how long I'm not sure.
I have worked in frontline (child protection, court and children in care) and in roles like adoption and fostering too.

It's really really hard. There's never enough time/support/resources.

If you're in frontline roles you will be fire fighting. You'll be working well over your paid hours, you'll be working weekends and evenings doing all the paperwork you don't have time to do in your hours.

There are good bits and there will be rewarding days too but you really do have to be very resilient to get through it.

In terms of cases, it really depends on your role but in safeguarding you'll have neglect, abuse, children with non-accidental injuries, parents with mental health and addiction issues.

You'll be pretty unpopular with most of these families because a social worker turning up at your door is rarely welcomed. I have never been physically attacked but colleagues have. I have been verbally abused very regularly. Tensions are high, parents are frightened, stressed, worried.

You'll often have a really good understanding of what can be done to help these families, but they probably won't get it.

If you work with a children's disabilities team for example, there's less conflict and hostility but you and the families will be endlessly frustrated.

Child in care social work is very busy also, big caseloads and there are always placements in crisis and breaking down. Huge amounts of travel.
You could live in Essex and have a child placed in wales for example.

Fostering and adoption are different roles. Not without their challenges and pressures. You'd be assessing prospective carers/adopters and supervising/supporting them whist safeguarding the children in their care.
Still high case loads unless you go to independent agencies.

So I've painted a fairly bleak picture as have others but that's not the whole story.
I believe passionately in the role and I am proud to be a social worker. It is rewarding and you will help people and support them to make positive change.

All the hard bits of social work are manageable with:
Good management and support.

Lower caseloads.

Resources available to you.

Good annual leave and the time to take it.

Feeling safe and protected yourself as it's very hard to do your best for the children if you aren't ok yourself.

At the moment mostly that stuff isn't where it should be and social workers are trying to patch and fill those gaps which is relentless and soul destroying.
It's devastating to know that children aren't getting what they need to be safe, well and thriving.

This is so spot on!

FriendofDorothy · 05/07/2022 16:42

I have been a social worker for 22 years and I work in substance misuse. My job involves working with adults but being involved in a lot of child protection cases, ongoing therapeutic work with individual clients, domestic violence meetings and some prison work.

I love my job but it is bloody hard work. You need to have clear, strong boundaries and be prepared to put up with a lot of shit. I have had clients threaten me and my children and I have been verbally abused on multiple occasions.

Hpowever, I like most of my clients, They are resileint and entertainign and I love seeing then make change, Of course it can be disappointing and sad at times but it is definitely not boring.

I am also a Practice Educator so I have students on placement. Hugely satisfying but you had to really want to do the job to make it work for you.

bettyswaps1 · 18/06/2022 22:35

i agree @giddygallopgirl . The lack of services makes the really tough job worse. I find it all really demoralising. I know the families think SW are useless and doing nothing to help but it really is out of our control.

I definitely think it would be a good idea trying out a social work assistant job first to see if you like it and also to get some experience. You might find they offer to pay for you to do your degree if you do like it.

It’s a shame, as with the right level of staff, budget and services it would be such a rewarding and enjoyable job.

Good luck

giddygallopgirl · 18/06/2022 22:22

I've been in adult social work for 6 years and I am utterly burnt out, stressed and depressed. Social work in children's and adults is such an essential job but there are literally no resources..no staff..no support..its impossible to help.
If you decide against social work..Still make sure you don't vote Tory!

RogerThatBravoOne · 18/06/2022 22:04

I think from what you’ve said the unpredictable nature in frontline social work might not be for you. You can be dealing with really motivated but limited parents, really aggressive and dishonest parents, acting as an appropriate adult in a police interview, removing a child… all in one day!

You need to remember that as a pp said a lot of professionals can refuse to see people/ban them from services. Police for example go into risky situations with another officer, a radio, body amour and a baton. The first whiff of danger/abuse they can arrest. We often go in alone with a diary and a pen and tend to try to calm situations and build relationships.

notanothertakeaway · 18/06/2022 12:26

OP, could you work in addictions? That would be rewarding

SnowWhitesSM · 18/06/2022 12:04

Don't do it. Frontline and burnt TF out!

Emotionally it's really taken it's toll and I don't have anything left over for my own dc. It's not a rewarding job, it's a shit job and one of the only jobs where you have to take abuse and continue to work. Drs etc all get to refuse service to an abusive person, we don't.

Also the current climate around corporate parenting is SHIT. Sound's good in theory, that you treat each child like they were your own in terms of getting them what they need, but it doesn't work in reality. Boundaries get blurred.

Snowpaw · 18/06/2022 11:57

user0512 · 17/06/2022 22:17

@Snowpaw
What's your career or background? That sounds good too as you're still playing a key role in helping children but it isn't front line as such

I did a psychology A Level but have an Administrative background really. I started out as his typist many years ago and he's trained me to score psychometric tests / summarise medical histories and court evidence bundles etc over the years. I proof read everything he writes and make the appointments / do the accounts etc. I find it really interesting and varied work, but all I'm doing is reading about it, not having the stress of involvement myself.

Nothappyatwork · 17/06/2022 23:51

Well it depends very much on your motivation doesn’t it as to whether you’re being unreasonable or not, if you’re wanting to do the job for the glamour and the money you probably are being very unreasonable.

Zpoa · 17/06/2022 23:10

I'm going to go against the grain. I've been a social worker with lac/cic since 1994. Some people are not cut out for working with this group of young people. I continue to love it

BarryStir · 17/06/2022 23:02

user0512 · 17/06/2022 21:26

Oh dear. From the responses I've gathered that it's an underpaid, stretched and a department under immense pressure.

When people say it's not for the faint hearted, what would you say is the worst you've dealt with? Alcoholic parents? Parental mental health? The general 'toxic trio'? Or could it be worse than that on a regular basis?

The worst I’ve dealt with is senior management in the Local Authority where I used to work.

Seriously though (although that is my honest answer) I’m now 9 years in, having worked in child protection and now in the courts. It is hard work but as long as you are realistic, resilient, have good personal boundaries and a mix of empathy and honesty, it can work well. I have built some great relationships with the families I’ve worked with, and I hope I’ve helped overall. If you go in thinking like a rescuer, you’ll burn out. I’ve never been attacked, sometimes been sworn at, rarely threatened. I don’t regret my career choice at all, but I can’t see myself going back to local authority work because of the toxic management culture.

Micemice · 17/06/2022 22:56

Having a social work degree is a very beneficial qualification even if you don’t work as a statutory social work, many many other jobs ask for a social worker qualification - eg project worker with specialist services - eg drugs, young carers, cse service etc or the likes of an independent advocate of an independent guardian for unaccompanied young people , team leader at a learning disability residential or day service - these need to be social worker qualified . If you do decide to do the degree I would recommend doing a various roles to build experience . You do need to be open minded, not easily shocked and prepared to work very very hard in frustrating circumstances at times.
As an alternative how about think what job you would like ( look up services online) and then consider what qualification would be most beneficial, for example a qcf5 in health and social care could be another good option . Or youth work( if interested in children and young people )

Turmerictolly · 17/06/2022 22:51

Maybe look at allied health professions; training as an OT, Physio etc. Same pay, far less stress and responsibility in my opinion.

socialworkme · 17/06/2022 22:38

Knowing what I know now, I wouldn't have qualified as a social worker, I'd have gone for a support role or early help. You have far more time to actually do some direct work with children and young people rather than having to write endless reports etc

anotherminiadventure · 17/06/2022 22:29

I don't know if this is specific to Scotland but we have Social Work Assistants. In my team they essentially do the same job as Social Workers but can't do legislative work and tend not to get the extremely complex cases.

You can become a SWA with your current degree so you'd maybe be best looking at that type of role. Or a Family Support Worker type role.

If you don't have experience in this field (and from your posts it sounds like you maybe don't), I would really recommend you get some before starting the degree. Social Work is an incredibly challenging but rewarding role. But you literally are a Jack of all trades and you will see, hear and experience things that will stay with you forever.

user0512 · 17/06/2022 22:17

@Snowpaw
What's your career or background? That sounds good too as you're still playing a key role in helping children but it isn't front line as such

OP posts:
Snowpaw · 17/06/2022 22:14

user0512 · 17/06/2022 22:06

What is your job title if you don't mind sharing? Perhaps it could be a career choice I research as I feel like I'm going through a career crisis 😩

I’m a PA to a clin psych who assesses children in family law proceedings

pinkunicorns54 · 17/06/2022 22:13

Crazykefir · 17/06/2022 22:12

I'm I think if you want to go into a caring profession get an unqualified job on a related field. It will support your UCAS application. Good luck.

This is great advice! You can then also understand the challenges a bit better to make an informed decision

Crazykefir · 17/06/2022 22:12

I'm I think if you want to go into a caring profession get an unqualified job on a related field. It will support your UCAS application. Good luck.

user0512 · 17/06/2022 22:11

pinkunicorns54 · 17/06/2022 22:08

I've never once been physically assaulted - I wouldn't even say I've been able personally verbally assaulted - I've had angry parents shout and swear but not directed at me.
Although I know colleagues who have!

Dogs are tricky - most of the time I ask if they can be put outside or in another room and that's respected. If I felt unsafe, I would leave and come back with a colleague / police (depending on how unsafe).

I may be just have been very lucky as well, but the type of families that show that level of violence, in my experience, are the exception rather than the rule.

Thank you. Your responses have been very helpful. I just wanted to make a somewhat informed choice this time as I feel like I've wasted three years 😳!

OP posts:
pinkunicorns54 · 17/06/2022 22:08

I've never once been physically assaulted - I wouldn't even say I've been able personally verbally assaulted - I've had angry parents shout and swear but not directed at me.
Although I know colleagues who have!

Dogs are tricky - most of the time I ask if they can be put outside or in another room and that's respected. If I felt unsafe, I would leave and come back with a colleague / police (depending on how unsafe).

I may be just have been very lucky as well, but the type of families that show that level of violence, in my experience, are the exception rather than the rule.

user0512 · 17/06/2022 22:06

Snowpaw · 17/06/2022 22:05

I am not a social worker but my job involves reading their (very long) reports - be prepared for a lot of writing and paperwork

What is your job title if you don't mind sharing? Perhaps it could be a career choice I research as I feel like I'm going through a career crisis 😩

OP posts:
Snowpaw · 17/06/2022 22:05

I am not a social worker but my job involves reading their (very long) reports - be prepared for a lot of writing and paperwork

user0512 · 17/06/2022 22:04

pinkunicorns54 · 17/06/2022 22:01

It is a job that you need high levels of resilience, but that also comes with experience on the job.

But it is also very rewarding, once you've got your head around the red tape and budgets, you work with what you've got. And seeing the impact and change families have made (some of the time) is really fab.

Of course there a times where families aren't able to recognise the harm and make the changes.

But if it's something you want to do, I think you can find your niche. After spending many years working in front line safeguarding - I'm now doing a role which supports student social workers and it's fab!

Did you get assaulted often? i watched a documentary on YouTube where the social worker has to enter a house with hardly any furniture. The mother (a pregnant lady who had many kids prior to being pregnant taken off of her) was with a man who was abusive and was on drugs.

When the social worker would visit he would give her such a hard time and his dogs would go mental. If it is like that then I guess it's defo not the career for me as that would scare the living life of of me

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread