Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people these days are not prepared to make marriage work?

214 replies

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 14:23

Most of my friends have gone or are currently going through divorce/separation. Some of them have got children some don't but most of them are not separating because of any 'big' issues (cheating/abuse/alcoholism etc). It seems that people reach a stage in their marriages when they cannot be bothered to fight for it anymore at least this seems to be the case from the experience of my friends and colleagues.

I frequently get annoyed with my husband over small things and that can often lead to big arguments but I always thought that these things are normal when you live with someone 24/7 and you both experience the best and the worst of this life together side by side. Many of my friends tell me that they just want to be able to enjoy fun things with their partner and are tired of problems that come with the marriage.

AIBU to think that you truly cannot have a carefree marriage/relationship and that sometimes people give up too easily?

P.S I don't really think there is right or wrong answer to that and that every situation is different but just wanted to hear opinions on that.

OP posts:
Deliaskis · 17/06/2022 16:24

Why is it a noble thing though, to stick and work at a sub-par relationship to demonstrate you are committed and in it for the long haul? Why is that something everybody should try harder for? Why should people spend years flogging the dead horse of their failing relationship when both parties would be much happier apart? I don't get why anybody would see it as 'better', to stick at something that doesn't make either party happy.

DH have been married nearly 20 yrs and have had the odd blip during that time, but nothing major. Had I spent even a third of that time wondering if we'd be better off apart, we wouldn't still be married.

I think the divorce rates now represent freedom and choice. People are now less frequently 'stuck' in bad relationships for financial or security reasons (although many still are).

Puffalicious · 17/06/2022 16:23

OP, as we all know, personalities are complex and when people grow in relationships different aspects to our partners become clear. When I met exDH we were perfect together, but when the socialising, partying, travelling and spontaneous stuff calmed after 2 kids we realised we were very different people. He was definitely my Mr Right Now, not Mr Right. I've realised over the years that his upbringing has a huge amount to do with it - it explains why he is the way he his. We argued all the time and made each other miserable. He's a great person in so many ways, but was a crap husband and I became a crap wife as I was so unhappy. We disagreed about everything, not least how to raise our children/ our basic philosophy of life.

He continues to be an outstanding father and we get on incredibly well. My DH of 12 years and he get on even better, I think. My DH is just the best person and I'm, thankfully, very happy. It sounds like your friends haven't been lucky to find someone who makes them happy yet: I hope they will. You were just lucky that you and your OH are compatible.

entropynow · 17/06/2022 16:23

OrientalDaisy · 17/06/2022 14:28

Why would you marry someone you have major ideological differences though if you are not prepared to accept them? Surely that's what you usually pay attention to during the dating stage, no? Genuinely asking.

People can change though. Sometimes quite drastically. Think of perfectly regular people who get caught up in cults, qanon etc

AnneLovesGilbert · 17/06/2022 16:22

stressedsloth · 17/06/2022 16:21

I'm separating. Things went south with my husbands mental health 4 years ago. I've worked at it for 4 years and I'm so exhausted it's taking away my ability to be a good mum. My feelings towards him suddenly changed. I'm so mentally abused and exhausted from him that I'm done. I can't do it anymore.

In the beginning he was going to be amicable but now he's turned which was expected so I've told him to leave immediately and I have an appointment with a solicitor.

It's going to be tough on the kids and me but how I put up with the mental torture for 4 years I have no idea. Im almost broken so it's now or never.

Good for you. You’ve got nothing to prove to anyone and I wish you and your DC many happier easier years ahead of you.

stressedsloth · 17/06/2022 16:21

I'm separating. Things went south with my husbands mental health 4 years ago. I've worked at it for 4 years and I'm so exhausted it's taking away my ability to be a good mum. My feelings towards him suddenly changed. I'm so mentally abused and exhausted from him that I'm done. I can't do it anymore.

In the beginning he was going to be amicable but now he's turned which was expected so I've told him to leave immediately and I have an appointment with a solicitor.

It's going to be tough on the kids and me but how I put up with the mental torture for 4 years I have no idea. Im almost broken so it's now or never.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 16:20

"I've been married for 45 miserable years and I don't see why anyone else should get out of it!"

neverbeenskiing · 17/06/2022 16:19

both me and DH think particularly younger people don’t take marriage or commitment seriously any more.

Both you and DH have no clue how serious or committed other people are about their marriages though. The only marriage you really know all the ins and outs of is your own. Just because a marriage ultimately doesn't work out that doesn't mean they didn't take it seriously. That's incredibly judgemental to make that assumption. Divorce is stressful enough I imagine without people around you speculating that it's your fault for not working hard enough at your marriage.

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 16:19

MarianosOnHisWay · 17/06/2022 16:10

Your OP came across and judgemental. Own it. You think you’re better than people who are separated/divorced.
To answer your exact question in your OP- yes, you are being unreasonable to think that you truly cannot have a carefree marriage/relationship. Many people on this thread are telling you it’s not normal for your husband to annoy you and to have frequent big arguments. Life’s too short and that’s not a nice way to spend your time.

It's also not nice to go through unemployment, poverty, to have to move your family across multiple countries to survive, to be discriminated , to have chronic illnesses, to see your children get sick, to lose people you love, to go through mental health problems or support someone in any of those things. It is not happy times and are not carefree. Of course they affect relationship with your partner how would they not? You are saying I am unreasonable to think that you cannot have a carefree marriage for many many years that will not go through any of those things and not be affected one bit? Perhaps we simply live in a different world.

OP posts:
OopsAnotherOne · 17/06/2022 16:17

I've heard this a few times in the past, and I've generally just figured it was because people are less prepared to put up with abuse now than they used to be.

GinGym · 17/06/2022 16:16

How78 · 17/06/2022 14:28

It depends. Why stay in a marriage if it's a complete chore and only brings you sadness. What is worth fighting for? The problem comes when the worst of times are far more frequent than the best of times for a prolonged period. I assume you haven't reached that point with your DH hence why you're happy to fight.

This! If the arguments are constant even if over small things, why bother? You only get one life so why spend it with someone who annoys you so much you are frequently arguing over petty things?

Tryhard40 · 17/06/2022 16:16

Sunshine10012 · 17/06/2022 16:11

I think it’s because there’s too much equality to the point women aren’t just giving birth and being mothers they’re also working full time and paying bills etc. men are being redundant as providers and women are overworked and resentful.
also more women go out and have fun then they used to.

Those damn women! How dare they? 😂

Too much equality? Isn't that an oxymoron or something?

GabriellaMontez · 17/06/2022 16:14

Is it a good thing to spend years working on something that doesn't make anyone happy? Is that an achievement or something to be proud of? Of that's how you feel... knock yourself out. Sounds like your friends had other ideas.

Yabu

LocalHobo · 17/06/2022 16:13

GCRich · 17/06/2022 16:00

Because you vowed til the day you die, and whilst we all know that is not always realistic marriage is suppose to be damn important and should be worked at and left for big reasons not relatively trivial ones.

YANBU OP.

This^ . If a life long marriage is not something you can both commit too, why get married? There is no societal pressure to do so.
I have said before on here that I (and thankfully my DH), don't make promises we believe we can't stick too. And yes, I have a long 30+ year marriage.

IncompleteSenten · 17/06/2022 16:13

I think if judgemental posts bother you you probably shouldn't have started a thread that reads like a very judgemental attack on people who don't want to be unhappily married.

You can't put something out there that reads like a big criticism then get cross that people respond in kind.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 16:13

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 16:11

Again my original OP wasn't ' AiBU to judge my friends who divorced whilst I am fighting through sweat to make my worthless marriage work'. 🙉 I was interested in a discussion, opinions perhaps observations.. not personal attacks at my marriage which is a good respectful loving marriage but not completely without a cloud every day of every month of every year. I tell that honestly to everyone including my children because happiness to me is not a constant , it is one of many feelings and a very very important one but its ok not to feel like it at times and be honest .

People always do that on here…you make a general observation and people start attacking you personally because they don’t like it. I agree with some of your points, both me and DH think particularly younger people don’t take marriage or commitment seriously any more. 🤷🏻‍♀️

aSofaNearYou · 17/06/2022 16:13

I think life is too short to stay with someone that isn't making you happy. Marriage should be a useful tool for people, not a jail sentence.

Joystir59 · 17/06/2022 16:12

Good luck to any woman trying to make heterosexual marriage work. Women are refusing to conform, hence the high divorce rate. Entirely understandable and to be applauded imo.

neverbeenskiing · 17/06/2022 16:12

It seems that people reach a stage in their marriages when they cannot be bothered to fight for it anymore at least this seems to be the case from the experience of my friends and colleagues.

You cannot possibly know this with any degree of certainty. You have no idea how hard people have fought behind the scenes to make their relationships work. What might seem to others like petty resentments and little disappointments might have built up over the years to become something much bigger. Couples who seem fine in public could be extremely unhappy and frustrated behind closed doors. You only know what they choose to tell you and it would be incredibly naive to think that they tell you everything. The only people who truly know what goes on in a marriage are the two people in it.

A cursory glance at the relationships board on here will tell you that divorce is expensive, stressful, destabilising and quite a drawn out process so not something people just do on a whim for the sheer hell of it. I'm sure I've read that on average people think about getting divorced for at least 2 years before they actually take steps to do it.

Sunshine10012 · 17/06/2022 16:11

I think it’s because there’s too much equality to the point women aren’t just giving birth and being mothers they’re also working full time and paying bills etc. men are being redundant as providers and women are overworked and resentful.
also more women go out and have fun then they used to.

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 16:11

Again my original OP wasn't ' AiBU to judge my friends who divorced whilst I am fighting through sweat to make my worthless marriage work'. 🙉 I was interested in a discussion, opinions perhaps observations.. not personal attacks at my marriage which is a good respectful loving marriage but not completely without a cloud every day of every month of every year. I tell that honestly to everyone including my children because happiness to me is not a constant , it is one of many feelings and a very very important one but its ok not to feel like it at times and be honest .

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 16:10

"Work on the marriage" so often means "accept more shit, woman".

I don't think anyone divorces lightly, especially with kids involved.

MarianosOnHisWay · 17/06/2022 16:10

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 16:01

Thank you for all the constructive responses. I love to read comments from people who don't make it a personal attack on the OP and try to keep it as what it actually is, a topic for discussion. I am always surprised to see people who come across very aggressive even via a response on MN and start making OPs feel uneasy, digging into their lives, telling you are pathetic or your 'relationship sounds shit' and then claim they are in the most happiest, light, wonderful, warm-hearted relationship ever how they never fight with no one in their family, etc. Then wouldn't your responses to strangers be light and philosophical too then and not feel like an attack 🙈🙉

Is it just me who doesn't like that on MN??

Your OP came across and judgemental. Own it. You think you’re better than people who are separated/divorced.
To answer your exact question in your OP- yes, you are being unreasonable to think that you truly cannot have a carefree marriage/relationship. Many people on this thread are telling you it’s not normal for your husband to annoy you and to have frequent big arguments. Life’s too short and that’s not a nice way to spend your time.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 16:09

I also think a lot of people just completely marry the wrong person by taking marriage too lightly in the first place, which is a different but related phenomenon

Tadpoll · 17/06/2022 16:07

biggreenhouse · 17/06/2022 14:32

I very much doubt your friends have got divorced of the small things you think you know. There will be many issues you have no idea about that will have made them come to that decision.

Exactly this.

From the outside we looked like the perfect family. People had no idea.

mewkins · 17/06/2022 16:07

HarryStottel · 17/06/2022 15:59

Why on earth should you have to ' fight' for a marriage to continue?

What a pathetic concept.

If you have to ' fight' to save a relationship, then it's not worth saving, IMO.

I'm of the opinion that ' relate' and other such services are just money making schemes. If you are unhappy see your own personal therapist or GP. There shouldn't be such a thing as ' Marriage Counselling'.

All I can think of is it comes from is old fashioned societal pressures. In the past both men and women accepted abuse and infidelity to keep a marriage together. Fortunately that isn't the case anymore.

There's loads of people out there anyway, why try and stick plasters on an incompatible relationship, because ' marriage' , when there's probably someone out there able to make you happier, or if you'd be happier on your own?

I agree with you. Marriage is a construct not a natural state. The whole idea you need to fight and change and be miserable in order to stay with someone is weird when you think about it.

You don't get a special medal at the end of your life for putting up with someone or something.

Also OP you may not have intended your post to be judgmental but look at the words you use suggest otherwise.