Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people these days are not prepared to make marriage work?

214 replies

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 14:23

Most of my friends have gone or are currently going through divorce/separation. Some of them have got children some don't but most of them are not separating because of any 'big' issues (cheating/abuse/alcoholism etc). It seems that people reach a stage in their marriages when they cannot be bothered to fight for it anymore at least this seems to be the case from the experience of my friends and colleagues.

I frequently get annoyed with my husband over small things and that can often lead to big arguments but I always thought that these things are normal when you live with someone 24/7 and you both experience the best and the worst of this life together side by side. Many of my friends tell me that they just want to be able to enjoy fun things with their partner and are tired of problems that come with the marriage.

AIBU to think that you truly cannot have a carefree marriage/relationship and that sometimes people give up too easily?

P.S I don't really think there is right or wrong answer to that and that every situation is different but just wanted to hear opinions on that.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 17/06/2022 17:31

I think that most people subconsciously just know when it's 'time to call time'. It's not for me to judge or to decide that their reasons aren't 'good enough'. Whether or not they follow their own 'advice' to themselves is up to them. You don't earn any brownie points from me for staying in a miserable marriage. But I respect your decision and will keep my mouth shut and support as best I can without compromising my integrity. Meaning that if someone is married to an abuser or a criminal I'm not going to tell them that staying is the right thing to do.

Now, you aren't going to get much sympathy from me if you're a 'bolter' or a cheat looking for 'greener pastures' and I'm not going to support their decision, but it's still that person's decision and they can live with the consequences.

My mum (born 1922) used to tell me stories of her friends who stayed in terrible marriages. Partly as a warning to 'pick the right man' and partly as a cautionary tale that 'marriage is for life'. Like hell it is!! I picked the wrong one and I knew exactly when it was time to GTFO (it was at the altar). It took me 4 years to get the courage to kick him out. Mum was upset at first because 'marriage is for life' but Dad had my back all the way. Dad soon set her straight in his own lovely way.

If you are unhappy, do what you need to do to figure out why. If it's not abuse (of any kind), addiction, or criminal behaviour (of any kind) then you need to figure out if your spouse will meet you half way to try and 'heal' the marriage. If the work isn't worth it to you, then leave in as 'kind' but 'definite' a manner as you can'.

Twilight7777 · 17/06/2022 17:30

YABU because putting it simply, people lie. The reason they may have said they are splitting up/divorcing may not be the true reason. I know of several couples who were being badly abused by other halves but they gave a different reason for the end of the marriage.

drpet49 · 17/06/2022 17:28

Too many women think they can change a man, they get married and oh look man hasn’t changed. Then they get divorced.

CousinKrispy · 17/06/2022 17:28

I really hope that as a culture we can move more to accepting that not every relationship is meant to last forever and some come to a natural end--whether you are legally married or not.

No one is a better person just because their marriage happened to be one that lasted for decades. Maybe it was a happy, healthy, loving relationship, and that's great if so. But many long-lasting marriages simply aren't.

Some relationships simply run their course and that shouldn't be seen as any sort of mark of shame.

mam0918 · 17/06/2022 17:26

It varies by group.

Most of my DH friends (+ us) and all his friends parents (including his own) started dating between 15-25 all, got married to that person and all still happily married. I know people who are 40 celebrating 25 years together and 20 happily married etc...

Most of my friends and family are devorced or never married but have split and moved on from their childrens other parent - lots of blended families.

Theres lots of other differences too.

My side are very family focused lots of big extended families and happy to 'adopt' in new to the area people without family where as over half of his side are strictly child free and keep to themselves (they are a very tough group to break into, took me 10 years).

Lifestyles are different with camping and hiking weekends popular on his side, while big family/friend at get together meals where the more the merrier popular on my side.

Maybe its a class thing - lots of my side are manual labor like cleaners, butchers, mechanics, truck drivers, builders while his side are teachers and medical assistants mostly so maybe pushing more towards middle class or maybe different groups are just different and put emphasis on different things.

Tintackedsea · 17/06/2022 17:23

My grandparents never divorced, had six kids together and were utterly miserable with each other. They set a terrible model of a marriage for their children. Grim endurance is not a positive in a marriage.

Orchardsandpianos · 17/06/2022 17:22

I think there are more divorces because more women are unwilling to accept a lack of respect from men.

Saying 'the fun has gone out of it' is probably shorthand for: 'he doesn't pull his weight in housework or childcare, expects me to do all the thinking and fundamentally doesn't respect me or perceive me as an equal human being.'

If more women divorce more men like that then maybe men will have to start pulling their weight and taking on 50% of the responsibilities and mental load, and respecting their partners and then maybe it will be possible to have a more carefree relationship.

pointythings · 17/06/2022 17:22

I will never assume that someone I know is divorcing for trivial reasons. Too many people judged me - my mother included. She felt I shouldn't divorce my husband because he 'liked a few drinks'. He was an alcoholic on the slope to becoming non functioning and my marriage had been hell for the past 5 years. On the surface we looked like an absolutely fine couple, because I was the swan's feet, madly flapping to keep us afloat.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 17/06/2022 17:21

I know a few older couples who have been married a long time and hate each other. It's heartbreaking - they are so resentful and pissed off that it affects their entire life and often damages their relationship with their children. For what? So they can say 'I didn't get divorced'? Who actually even cares?

Treacletoots · 17/06/2022 17:17

What a horribly outdated notion.

Being happy is far more important than being married.

When being married means you're not happy, it's time to change that.

Ideally being happy and married is always a good combination but so often not the case and the reason why so many people are miserable.

You only get one life. Don't spend it miserable just so you can say 'you fought for something that on the face of it is utterly irrelevant.

TheLeadbetterLife · 17/06/2022 17:17

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 17:06

No but there’s a trend nowadays towards things like hookup culture, not settling down , “playing the field”, and seeing marriage as some sort of prison. And then you’ve got people who act like the wedding is more important than the person they’re marrying.

Cos no-one ever cheated in the good old days, eh?

Marriage has always been a prison for a lot of people (especially women). Thankfully these days more people have a key.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 17/06/2022 17:16

If I frequently got annoyed with my husband and it often led to big arguments I think I'd be exhausted and pissed off. Are you?

My DH rarely annoys me and we never have big arguments. He really is lovely and I enjoy his presence immensely. I don't have to 'fight' to be in the relationship, it makes my life better, more fun and more enjoyable. That's as it should be IMO and if it ever stopped being that way I'd try to change it but if I couldn't I would leave. What is the point of being frequently annoyed by a person?

AngelinaFibres · 17/06/2022 17:07

Some marriages last forever. Some marriages were great in the beginning ,but have a sell by date. There is no prize in heaven for sticking with a marriage that died years before. You don't get a better seat. My mother brought us up with the mantra that ' when you get married you stay married'. My first husband was not a nice man. I stayed, and put up with shed loads of rubbish because I had tiny children, no job and nowhere to go. He left me for a 17 year old when the children were 2 and 3. It was very hard but I eventually met my second husband and we have been married for 19 years. He is a brilliant step dad to my sons and a fabulous grandad to our new grandson. I have an absolutely wonderful life. I would never, ever have had that if I had carried on 'working at my marriage'. My first marriage was probably doomed from the start, I just didn't gave the eyes to see it. I tried everything to keep him happy. It was exhausting and ultimately ,pointless. He came from a family where everyone was divorced at least once so leaving wasn't a big deal to him. He did me a enormous favour by leaving. I would never have gone and the lovely life I have now would never have happened

Babyroobs · 17/06/2022 17:07

I do agree a lot seem to give up pretty easily but then again in my work I see loads of old couples who seem to loathe each other and I get the impression they have just stayed together for year for convenience, the women often haven't worked much etc and I guess they were financially dependent. I always think it's sad to see and am pleased that people these days seem to have more choices. i do sometimes wince at what it must be costing the economy though as it does seem like every other couple is splitting up.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 17:06

neverbeenskiing · 17/06/2022 16:19

both me and DH think particularly younger people don’t take marriage or commitment seriously any more.

Both you and DH have no clue how serious or committed other people are about their marriages though. The only marriage you really know all the ins and outs of is your own. Just because a marriage ultimately doesn't work out that doesn't mean they didn't take it seriously. That's incredibly judgemental to make that assumption. Divorce is stressful enough I imagine without people around you speculating that it's your fault for not working hard enough at your marriage.

No but there’s a trend nowadays towards things like hookup culture, not settling down , “playing the field”, and seeing marriage as some sort of prison. And then you’ve got people who act like the wedding is more important than the person they’re marrying.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 17/06/2022 17:05

I don't know anyone who left their marraige over minor issues or their inability to compromise or over come story term issues.

All of my close friends who seperated,

1 - hands off dad, she put up with that for far too long until he cheated

2 - chronic, gambling issues - tried to work on it but after the 3rd relapse she went

3 - every single thing was his way or no way. Never shouted, never very abusive, just stubborn & had a superiority complex - where they lived, what they did, when they did it,her opinion was never taken into consideration etc. He is still shocked she left because all of his decisions were for the best!!!

I would have left before all 3 did. They tried everything to make it work until they were just broken and needed out.

Ofcourseandyouknowit · 17/06/2022 17:05

It’s an interesting question. Based on the threads I’ve read here and personal experience I suspect there are a few things going on in terms of trends-

  1. I think within the current married age generation you have a lot of women who weren’t raised specifically be wives (hurray) but a lot of men who were raised to be husbands. In other words, women no longer want or expect to run the household and family exclusively and instead they bring in a good income, but men often seem to not expect to take on those roles at all. This puts a lot of women on an endless hamster wheel of responsibility and work, without much upside. This grows resentment.
  2. I get the impression a lot people don’t have conflict resolution skills anymore. There’s a strong sense of what is fair and not fair, but not a lot of skilled approaches to getting what’s fair. One without the other is very bad for marriage I think.
  3. Life is tough for people, time was you could have a single income household and have a house, a car, a holiday a few kids and maybe a dog. These things are genuinely aspirational on double income now, so you have two people working really hard and they may still struggle to afford the basics- nevermind the all of above. People have always struggled of course, but everyone working flat out and struggling maybe wasn’t as widespread before? I’m not old and I remember when the normal work day was 9-5 with an hour for lunch, with the occasional bit of late working. Late working is everynight now for many professional careers. Relationships take energy but there’s not much leftover at the end of the day for most people.
  4. Because a fair few men still seem to see their wives as quasi servants, women are often happier divorced, and they may have very few roll models of happy marriages to emulate.
Now- I put a challenge to you- this is AYBU afterall. You’ve sort of normalised marriage being a bit miserable in your post @HipsterMum, is it miserable for you? If so why should people want that? If it’s not- would people looking in on your relationship know that? Honestly I think marriage can be mostly a haven for both partners, and it should be, otherwise what’s the point? Good to power through difficult times of course, but getting annoyed and having arguments shouldn’t be the norm.
AlisonDonut · 17/06/2022 17:00

Why fight for some random made up concept?

Or because the neighbours will talk?

Fuck that shit.

MarianosOnHisWay · 17/06/2022 16:57

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 17/06/2022 16:36

I'll be flamed for this but I agree in some cases.

Used to work for divorce lawyers and the amount of couples (no kids) who came in and squabbled over seemingly petty things which led to the divorce and seemingly married on a whim. One of them was quite funny, involved an alarm clock being thrown as being the final straw for the wife to divorce the husband!

I always thought it would be a good idea to have (not religious but you could do if so inclined) to have pre-marriage advice beforehand - maybe from an advisory service.

What’s funny about having a husband who throws household objects?

Trogbog · 17/06/2022 16:56

I think the overwhelming message of the relationships board, and elsewhere on here, is that people don't leave their marriages soon enough. People stay and make excuses for shit behaviour of partners. We need more education about how to spot signs of a shit partner and relationship, so that people get out quicker - hopefully before marriage and certainly before children.

Lookingoutside · 17/06/2022 16:53

People are much less inclined to tolerate mediocrity and misery.

We get one life.

CousinKrispy · 17/06/2022 16:50

I think it just shows that you don't necessarily know what's truly going on in anyone else's relationship, even when it's a good friend or family member. Any more than you think posters here understand your relationship from what you said about it in your first post. It's not your place to judge whether your friends, or a bunch of strangers, gave up on their marriage too quickly rather than "fighting for it."

Bottom line is more women have economic independence these days, either because they earn their own money, have access to benefits, or the law very fairly says that the father of their children should contribute to the children's upkeep. Many centuries of human history weren't nearly as fair.

That makes it feasible to walk away when it's necessary ... though still very very difficult for many people.

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 16:49

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/06/2022 16:41

I think it depends on what you mean by “make marriage work”. If you mean overlooking minor annoyances, being considerate to each other, keeping communication open then yes I think that’s all part of keeping a marriage alive.

If you mean living with a lack of connection, no intimacy, low level disregard, or constant unhappiness then no, I think at that point it’s over and people can decide to leave. I don’t think longevity is a good marker of the success in a marriage anyway, sometimes it’s kinder and shows more integrity to leave.

Thank you of course 'making marriage work' can be interpreted completely differently. I personally meant minor issues, looking past short challenging periods and of course always communicating. But I think its too late to add that when posters are saying I am a doormat in a worthless relationship and am a horrible judgemental human being. MN makes me lose hope in having an intelligent conversation. Thank u for your comment.

OP posts:
BingeBitch · 17/06/2022 16:49

Ouch, truth hurts eh?

lapasion · 17/06/2022 16:49

I thought divorce rates were on the decline? I’m guessing a lot of people can’t afford to divorce and run two homes nowadays.