Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people these days are not prepared to make marriage work?

214 replies

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 14:23

Most of my friends have gone or are currently going through divorce/separation. Some of them have got children some don't but most of them are not separating because of any 'big' issues (cheating/abuse/alcoholism etc). It seems that people reach a stage in their marriages when they cannot be bothered to fight for it anymore at least this seems to be the case from the experience of my friends and colleagues.

I frequently get annoyed with my husband over small things and that can often lead to big arguments but I always thought that these things are normal when you live with someone 24/7 and you both experience the best and the worst of this life together side by side. Many of my friends tell me that they just want to be able to enjoy fun things with their partner and are tired of problems that come with the marriage.

AIBU to think that you truly cannot have a carefree marriage/relationship and that sometimes people give up too easily?

P.S I don't really think there is right or wrong answer to that and that every situation is different but just wanted to hear opinions on that.

OP posts:
Crumbleburntbits · 17/06/2022 18:07

‘Weren’t getting on’ is an ‘I don’t want to discuss it with you’ reason. After all, nobody is going to tell you ‘Frank could only get it up if I watched hardcore porn with him and while hitting him with a fish slice’ Smile

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 18:05

AllNightDiner · 17/06/2022 17:56

In my view, it's not divorce that is too easy, but marriage. The assumption is that proposals and marriages are good and happy things, but too few couples really think through the implications of the fact that they are entering into a legally binding contract with another individual, and that they ought to do all the same due diligence that they would do if that contract concerned a business or a property.

I think attendance at a briefing session by the registrar's office or the CAB or similar should be a requirement of getting a marriage licence, both about the administrative realities of marriage and about the personal implications of tethering your ups and downs to another individual. I also think prenups should be a requirement of entering into a marriage contract, so that there was no 'unromantic' stigma attached to them. Couples should make a full declaration of assets, liabilities and financial arrangements regarding children from previous relationships. Too many people, just using MN threads as a snapshot, seem to have no idea of the answers to some of these questions.

If this seems like a right load of faff, try disentangling a relationship with children and joint finances when none of it has ever been thought about previously. What I'm suggesting is simpler, and hopefully a lot less emotionally loaded at the beginning than it is at the end (or at least the emotions are more positive anyway). I also think that when an unmarried couple has children, the same kind of process should follow the registering of the birth, even though the legal undertakings would take a different form than that of a marriage contract.

I think a lot of people probably wouldn't get as far as the altar if you had to do all of that, and it would save people a lot of heartache. The 'love and romance' culture (aka industry) has a lot to answer for imo.

I think this is a great post, but compulsory prenupts defeat the object of marriage somewhat. They can prevent the lower earner being fairly compensated for making a greater non-financial contribution such as child rearing and homemaking.

Orchardsandpianos · 17/06/2022 18:02

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 17:44

It’s not just about divorces, it’s about not wanting commitment, an obsession with hookup culture and non exclusivity etc.

but whats wrong with those things?

pointythings · 17/06/2022 18:00

We agree then - those things do not come under open, honest and consenting.

But as a single woman who only just missed being divorced (he died 12 days before the Nisi was pronounced) I really feel that a lot of it is to do with women no longer accepting shitty relationships and shitty lives, and being far happier single. I certainly am.

Confused7979 · 17/06/2022 18:00

People change. Things that were once endearing could now be an annoyance, which sometimes leads to other gripes and all built up it gets too much. As you get older some are less tolerant. I do think in some cases if neither of you is at fault and you just grow apart then unfortunately that's life.... why stay with someone who you're unhappy with. Children are better in a happy home, whether that be with one parent or two. There's no right answer but you both have to be on the same page.

Viviennemary · 17/06/2022 17:59

I agree. Somebody told me some friends of her were divorcing because 'they weren't getting on'. People expect too much. And there are a lot of folk who make out they have married Mr or Mrs Wonderful and in reality they haven't, and it leads to other folk feeling dissatisfied.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 17:58

In my view, it's not divorce that is too easy, but marriage. The assumption is that proposals and marriages are good and happy things, but too few couples really think through the implications of the fact that they are entering into a legally binding contract with another individual.

I agree with this, but I don’t think people should be forced into pre nups and briefings.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 17:57

Discovereads · 17/06/2022 17:55

There are generational differences in views on casual sex/ monogamy and I think it’s mostly driven by environment.

My mother was a free love hippie and although she married, she had several affairs. But this was in an era where there was easy access to the BC pill and STIs were mostly curable, certainly wouldn’t kill you.

I was a teen at the dawn of the AIDS crisis and it persisted well into my 20s. My generation is a bit “prudish” because when we were teens/young adults HIV was a 1 in 4 chance of catching it every time you had sex with a new partner and at the time, HIV was a death sentence. Also at the time, the thought was that condoms didn’t prevent transmission. For a few years they even thought kissing/oral sex could transmit HIV (hence all the water fountains being ripped out of public areas). So my generation was more cautious and gravitated towards monogamy and less casual sex.

But the generations after me, and even now because AIDS isn’t a killer anymore they are back in that era that my mother was in of great contraception and no STIs that will kill you…mostly curable…and the stigma of herpes etc is much less. So it’s no wonder that more casual sex abounds and fewer young people today are gravitating towards monogamy. It’s because they can more freely choose what they personally prefer.

Interesting theory! I think contraception and STIs being curable will have an impact. I wonder if the arrival of things like “super gonhorrea” which is resistant to most antibx will have a similar effect.

Monkey2001 · 17/06/2022 17:57

Marriage is no longer what it was, people have higher expectations of how happy they should be and don't regard marriage vows as a barrier to splitting up. As long as nobody else is affected, surely it is their choice about how to be happy and whether to feel bound by promises they have made.

I would always put children first in the decision if there is no abuse going on, but growing up in a household where parents are sniping at each other is probably worse than having divorced parents.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 17:57

Franklyfrost · 17/06/2022 17:51

I want to leave my partner for what are very very trivial reasons: any thought or feeling I express he deems ‘wrong’ and ends the discussion there. It’s not one big problem, I don’t think he’s much of a cheater or much of an alcoholic, nor especially physically violent. But to have my opinions consistently dismissed without discussion, to feel so unloved day in day out, it kills you. What op is hearing will be the proverbial straw 🐪

"Much" of a cheater or alcoholic? "Especially" physically violent?

And yes, being constantly shut down is miserable living.

AllNightDiner · 17/06/2022 17:56

In my view, it's not divorce that is too easy, but marriage. The assumption is that proposals and marriages are good and happy things, but too few couples really think through the implications of the fact that they are entering into a legally binding contract with another individual, and that they ought to do all the same due diligence that they would do if that contract concerned a business or a property.

I think attendance at a briefing session by the registrar's office or the CAB or similar should be a requirement of getting a marriage licence, both about the administrative realities of marriage and about the personal implications of tethering your ups and downs to another individual. I also think prenups should be a requirement of entering into a marriage contract, so that there was no 'unromantic' stigma attached to them. Couples should make a full declaration of assets, liabilities and financial arrangements regarding children from previous relationships. Too many people, just using MN threads as a snapshot, seem to have no idea of the answers to some of these questions.

If this seems like a right load of faff, try disentangling a relationship with children and joint finances when none of it has ever been thought about previously. What I'm suggesting is simpler, and hopefully a lot less emotionally loaded at the beginning than it is at the end (or at least the emotions are more positive anyway). I also think that when an unmarried couple has children, the same kind of process should follow the registering of the birth, even though the legal undertakings would take a different form than that of a marriage contract.

I think a lot of people probably wouldn't get as far as the altar if you had to do all of that, and it would save people a lot of heartache. The 'love and romance' culture (aka industry) has a lot to answer for imo.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 17:55

pointythings · 17/06/2022 17:54

@ForestFae I don't see the problem with not wanting commitment, wanting casual sex and being OK with non-exclusivity - as long as everyone involved is open, honest and consenting about what is on offer. Monogamy is by no means the only game in town and there is nothing wrong with that at all.

I agree to a point, I have no issue with consensual polyamory but people seem to glorify cheating or playing games with people and I take issue with that

Discovereads · 17/06/2022 17:55

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 17:44

It’s not just about divorces, it’s about not wanting commitment, an obsession with hookup culture and non exclusivity etc.

There are generational differences in views on casual sex/ monogamy and I think it’s mostly driven by environment.

My mother was a free love hippie and although she married, she had several affairs. But this was in an era where there was easy access to the BC pill and STIs were mostly curable, certainly wouldn’t kill you.

I was a teen at the dawn of the AIDS crisis and it persisted well into my 20s. My generation is a bit “prudish” because when we were teens/young adults HIV was a 1 in 4 chance of catching it every time you had sex with a new partner and at the time, HIV was a death sentence. Also at the time, the thought was that condoms didn’t prevent transmission. For a few years they even thought kissing/oral sex could transmit HIV (hence all the water fountains being ripped out of public areas). So my generation was more cautious and gravitated towards monogamy and less casual sex.

But the generations after me, and even now because AIDS isn’t a killer anymore they are back in that era that my mother was in of great contraception and no STIs that will kill you…mostly curable…and the stigma of herpes etc is much less. So it’s no wonder that more casual sex abounds and fewer young people today are gravitating towards monogamy. It’s because they can more freely choose what they personally prefer.

pointythings · 17/06/2022 17:54

@ForestFae I don't see the problem with not wanting commitment, wanting casual sex and being OK with non-exclusivity - as long as everyone involved is open, honest and consenting about what is on offer. Monogamy is by no means the only game in town and there is nothing wrong with that at all.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 17:52

Silly things like him getting up as soon as he finished his food and leaving to start washing dishes whilst we are still eating with the kids.

You think people divorce over things like that?

nex18 · 17/06/2022 17:51

YABU. I tried to put up with/ work on the lower level problems in my marriage for too long (xh did not), in the end he had an affair and I obviously qualified for one of your reasons to divorce. I’m loads happier since, even in the early days when things were difficult I knew that the main problems were that we were no longer compatible and should have called it a day years before.

Franklyfrost · 17/06/2022 17:51

I want to leave my partner for what are very very trivial reasons: any thought or feeling I express he deems ‘wrong’ and ends the discussion there. It’s not one big problem, I don’t think he’s much of a cheater or much of an alcoholic, nor especially physically violent. But to have my opinions consistently dismissed without discussion, to feel so unloved day in day out, it kills you. What op is hearing will be the proverbial straw 🐪

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 17:44

Orchardsandpianos · 17/06/2022 17:41

both me and DH think particularly younger people don’t take marriage or commitment seriously any more.

Divorce rates are highest between 45 - 50 year olds, closely followed by the 50-54 year olds. Whilst, as someone who is rapidly approaching that age range, I love to hear it called young, I have a feeling that wasn't the age range you were referring to when you are claiming young people don't take marriage seriously any more.

It’s not just about divorces, it’s about not wanting commitment, an obsession with hookup culture and non exclusivity etc.

Orchardsandpianos · 17/06/2022 17:41

both me and DH think particularly younger people don’t take marriage or commitment seriously any more.

Divorce rates are highest between 45 - 50 year olds, closely followed by the 50-54 year olds. Whilst, as someone who is rapidly approaching that age range, I love to hear it called young, I have a feeling that wasn't the age range you were referring to when you are claiming young people don't take marriage seriously any more.

Mumoblue · 17/06/2022 17:39

@flower04958 To be honest the only reason I can think of to get married is tax/property benefits and security, it’s a legal contract. It is “binding” but I don’t think it should be unbreakable or make people feel like they have to stay when they’re unhappy.

Todonow · 17/06/2022 17:37

I have found it to be quite the opposite actually.
Many people who are miserable in their relationship but choose to stay for convenience, children, fear of loneliness, finance, etc...

My husband was arrested for possession of indecent images of children, and even with the disgust and resentment I have towards him, I'm finding the process of leaving with a child, really really hard

VioletCharlotte · 17/06/2022 17:35

I feel like staying with one partner for life is pretty unnatural actually. You change and grow over the years. The person you fell in love with at 25, you may have little in common with at 40.

I think if you have children then you owe it to them to try and make it work, but ultimately it's not healthy for them to live with unhappy parents, so it's better to separate and work hard to do parent successfully.

Herja · 17/06/2022 17:34

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/06/2022 16:41

I think it depends on what you mean by “make marriage work”. If you mean overlooking minor annoyances, being considerate to each other, keeping communication open then yes I think that’s all part of keeping a marriage alive.

If you mean living with a lack of connection, no intimacy, low level disregard, or constant unhappiness then no, I think at that point it’s over and people can decide to leave. I don’t think longevity is a good marker of the success in a marriage anyway, sometimes it’s kinder and shows more integrity to leave.

If the former is enough to make you split, clearly you just shouldn't be together. If that sort of thing is enough, it's just not good match, is it?

The latter obviously should split because it's toxic.

Life is short. Much too short to spend your home life irritated, even if it is by someone who isn't fundamentally 'bad', but just winds you up. (I also disagree with the concept of marriage though, which probably clouds my view.)

flower04958 · 17/06/2022 17:33

So if you're someone who thinks that relationships shouldn't be "binding" or worth staying in if there are major issues to address (which seems totally reasonable), my only question is - why get married then? Why not just remain at "relationship" status?

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 17:33

Just a final post as I would not be anymore engaged with this thread as I do not tolerate personal attacks and being called a doormat. Fighting for a marriage was more of a phrase people use to describe sticking by one another through tough times thats why I used it. I wasn't saying my daily life is a fight with my husband and insisting all women should be staying in bad marriages.

For all those worried, yes, I am content with my marriage and I love my DH who always was and still after many years is a lovely man. I am not really bothered what other people think 'really goes behind our closed doors'. No i do not think an occasional argument over nothing is the end of the world. Yes some of my DH's habits annoy me because we had a different upbringing. Silly things like him getting up as soon as he finished his food and leaving to start washing dishes whilst we are still eating with the kids. It is how things used to be in his family and he does it without realising. We don't have arguments over that always, sometimes we laugh how things stick and become a habit.

The post had nothing to do with my marriage but just a general observation. Nor was it intended as a dig at women who went through tough divorces and are much happier now. I just don't like how some people attack others online and it causes me a lot of anxiety. Thank you for all the useful posts taking this thread for what it was intended- just an open question and not my opinion on the matter.

OP posts: