Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people these days are not prepared to make marriage work?

214 replies

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 14:23

Most of my friends have gone or are currently going through divorce/separation. Some of them have got children some don't but most of them are not separating because of any 'big' issues (cheating/abuse/alcoholism etc). It seems that people reach a stage in their marriages when they cannot be bothered to fight for it anymore at least this seems to be the case from the experience of my friends and colleagues.

I frequently get annoyed with my husband over small things and that can often lead to big arguments but I always thought that these things are normal when you live with someone 24/7 and you both experience the best and the worst of this life together side by side. Many of my friends tell me that they just want to be able to enjoy fun things with their partner and are tired of problems that come with the marriage.

AIBU to think that you truly cannot have a carefree marriage/relationship and that sometimes people give up too easily?

P.S I don't really think there is right or wrong answer to that and that every situation is different but just wanted to hear opinions on that.

OP posts:
Loadedforest · 17/06/2022 18:46

I’ve found in real life that people that have opinions/ voice thoughts like this quite often are trying to justify staying in their own failing / unsatisfactory relationship. I did it for years.

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/06/2022 18:43

Lots of my friends are divorced and almost all of them say having children was the main cause of the problems.

I’m divorcing 5 years after having children, the children aren’t at all the cause of the problem but having children flushed out the problems that were there.

When you don’t have kids you both have time and space to cover up the cracks, I know I spent a lot of time planning things for us to do together, making an effort to maintain our connection to each other, basically keeping things ticking over. Along came kids and I no longer had time or emotional energy to make the effort for both of us, because the kids needed me to make the effort for them. As I stepped back, he didn’t step forward to fill the chasm that had grown between us.

That chasm had been there for a while but there was enough else going on to fill that gap, when it came down to just him and I the gap was too wide. Very often the changes that come with kids show up the cracks, rather than being the cause of the cracks.

ComputerQueen · 17/06/2022 18:38

Mahanii · 17/06/2022 18:29

If young people are avoiding commitment and see marriage as a prison, it's worth thinking about the example they grew up with that looked like a prison that they're now trying to avoid.

@Mahanii IME it’s usually men who don’t want to commit. Because they don’t want to hand over half their assets to the mother of their kids.

Many women go along with the ‘piece of paper’ narrative but sadly find themselves up shit creek when he runs off with a younger woman and her name isn’t even on the deeds.

If people really didn’t want to ‘commit’ they wouldn’t be having children but that’s not the case.

BitBehind · 17/06/2022 18:38

I think the opposite is true. People go into marriage way too easily and take far too long to leave. This entire website is full to the brim of women trying everything under the sun to make it work and still not leaving as worried about impact on others and disrupting the lives of others. I don't know anyone has left a marriage because that seems like easy option. They have picked the hard thing because they can't tolerate living a lie anymore or being mistreated. Especially if there are kids involved, women try and try and try to make it work on the whole.

mydogisthebest · 17/06/2022 18:36

I do think if you are unhappy you should split up/get divorced but I also think couples with children should take time to think about whether they are really that unhappy.

The problem is so many couples have a baby very early on in the relationship/ marriage (far too often an "accident") and when things go wrong they split up. Children put a strain on even the happiest of relationships so, on the whole, having them so quickly is asking for trouble. The chances are that even without a child the relationship would not have worked and no child would have to see their parents divorce/separate.

Lots of my friends are divorced and almost all of them say having children was the main cause of the problems.

May be coincidence but none of my childfree friends or family are divorced and I know quite a few couples who have chosen to remain childfree. All have long marriages, the shortest being 20 years

mummyrocks1 · 17/06/2022 18:35

Why would you marry someone you have major ideological differences though if you are not prepared to accept them? Surely that's what you usually pay attention to during the dating stage, no? Genuinely asking.

I think it depends on your age. I am currently separating from my DH after 20 years. It became apparent we have huge differences in opinion over many things. Partly I should have paid more attention when we were dating and when I think back now there were many red flags. But I was 21 I thought love was enough, we fancied each other, we got on ok but have always argued. We had fun together, we're spontaneous. Fast forward 20 years we are two different people now. I am no longer the shy, under confident person he married. Throw in stresses of business, studying, kids, money, jobs. things change and you don't know are going to change when you marry. You don't know how people are going to react until you are there. But I must admit I should have thought more carefully about how compatible DH and I really were when we married aged 29.

madasawethen · 17/06/2022 18:32

I was brought up with the fight for your marriage belief.
It made me stay in 2 bad marriages much much longer than I should.
My DSis stays in a horrible marriage. I'm not sure why. The glowing sm posts about 30 years together.
I don't see much reason for women to stay in miserable marriages these days.

ComputerQueen · 17/06/2022 18:32

YANBU, but there’s no prizes for making a marriage ‘work’.

Despite the prevailing media narrative and endless celebrity remarriage/divorces it’s not a decision to be taken lightly. People don’t divorce on the spur of the moment.

Mahanii · 17/06/2022 18:29

If young people are avoiding commitment and see marriage as a prison, it's worth thinking about the example they grew up with that looked like a prison that they're now trying to avoid.

Sortilege · 17/06/2022 18:27

Marriage isn’t such a blessed state that it’s worth being miserable for.

greatblueheron · 17/06/2022 18:23

YABU

People do not divorce over petty, trivial annoyances. They just don't.

You have no idea what goes on behind closed doors.

dottypotter · 17/06/2022 18:22

CallOnMe · 17/06/2022 18:08

Everyone has their own bar of what they’ll put up with.

Back in the day divorce was frowned upon so it wasn’t an easy option.

Nowadays it is an easy option but I don’t think that’s a bad thing.

Personally I think being happy is much more important than staying married.
I do not believe in rushing into a marriage for that very reason and believe people should live with each other for a couple of years to see if they’re compatible or not.

Arguments/disagreements are bound to happen but they shouldn’t be a regular thing and a partner is meant to enhance your life not make it more stressful.

I am single and I happy 90% of the time.
If someone came along and made me even happier then great - I would happily be in a committed relationship.
But if someone came along and made my life harder and more stressful - then I don’t see the point in being with that person and I wouldn’t be with them.
The same goes for if I was already married - if I would be happier single, then I might as well be single.

People divorce even when they have I've together.

Even if you think your compatible no guarantee your going to stay together.

chiffchaffchiff · 17/06/2022 18:22

Life is too long (not short) to spend it with someone who makes you unhappy and I say that as someone who is happily married. I'd think a good deal of people living in an unhappy marriage are only doing it for financial reasons. Trying to find a family house with half the assets is difficult if you have young children.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 18:19

Orchardsandpianos · 17/06/2022 18:16

I get your point, its just that I'm not as convinced this is a 'young person' attitude. I think the difference is young people are doing this without getting married, where as the reality is cheating is an age old problem.

'turning a blind eye', men having mistresses etc etc these things have been going on for generations. Its just they used to happen more often inside marriage and were probably talked about less.

In fact the peak age for infidelity in a relationship is 51-59 years old - that said these statistics are likely to unreliable but still again its not specifically a 'young person' issue

That’s possibly true, maybe they’re just more blatant about it!

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 18:17

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 18:16

But his siblings are allowed to go clubbing and have consensual casual sex. How are they throwing it in his face?

Sounds like they're also reacting to their parents' crap marriage. Why was the divorce acrimonious? Did they hold on for too long because they thought they shouldn't divorce?

That’s not the issue, it’s that they cheat on their girlfriends and treat women like shit. Talk about women in degrading terms etc. DH q like it and finds it disrespctful

there are cultural factors at play, DH is Indian and their marriage was arranged.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 17/06/2022 18:16

I'm just not prepared to live with a useless man. I gave my first husband 8 years and the 2nd 20 years, neither improved at all, neither were concerned about their family responsibilities and were lazy and childish.
Life is too short.

Orchardsandpianos · 17/06/2022 18:16

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 18:08

Consensual polyamory, nothing is wrong with it. However, glorifying lying, cheating, and generally being a shitty partner isn’t great, and it also makes things difficult for people who don’t want to engage in things like that. My DH for example, used to believe that barely anyone was as monogamous anymore and everyone had affairs due to constantly having stuff like this thrown in his face by society (DH has never and never will engaged in anything like that, neither have I).

I get your point, its just that I'm not as convinced this is a 'young person' attitude. I think the difference is young people are doing this without getting married, where as the reality is cheating is an age old problem.

'turning a blind eye', men having mistresses etc etc these things have been going on for generations. Its just they used to happen more often inside marriage and were probably talked about less.

In fact the peak age for infidelity in a relationship is 51-59 years old - that said these statistics are likely to unreliable but still again its not specifically a 'young person' issue

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 18:16

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 18:13

Yes, we did luckily.

He has siblings who are into the clubbing life and engage in such behaviours, and his parents had an acrimonious divorce when he was young. As a result, he’s very much pro marriage, marriage is for life, you don’t fuck around etc.

But his siblings are allowed to go clubbing and have consensual casual sex. How are they throwing it in his face?

Sounds like they're also reacting to their parents' crap marriage. Why was the divorce acrimonious? Did they hold on for too long because they thought they shouldn't divorce?

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 18:13

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 18:11

My DH for example, used to believe that barely anyone was as monogamous anymore and everyone had affairs due to constantly having stuff like this thrown in his face by society (DH has never and never will engaged in anything like that, neither have I).

And you managed to find each other. Do you really not know many other monogamous couples?

How is he having this stuff thrown in his face? What exactly is happening to offend him?

Yes, we did luckily.

He has siblings who are into the clubbing life and engage in such behaviours, and his parents had an acrimonious divorce when he was young. As a result, he’s very much pro marriage, marriage is for life, you don’t fuck around etc.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 18:12

Discovereads · 17/06/2022 18:09

@ForestFae
Im curious about super gonorrhoea as well. Thank you for the compliment, it is very interesting to look at behaviour and then think about, why are young people doing x, y, z. It’s not always due to immorality or morality. My generations attitude towards casual sex was completely and deeply affected by the AIDS pandemic and crisis. We didn’t avoid casual sex because we were somehow morally superior or Handmaids of the patriarchy or conservative/traditionalists…it was purely a matter of avoiding risk of an early death.

I know I’d find it worrying if I were a single person today! It absolutely makes sense that AIDS had a massive influence on peoples attitudes, it must’ve been very scary to live through.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 18:11

My DH for example, used to believe that barely anyone was as monogamous anymore and everyone had affairs due to constantly having stuff like this thrown in his face by society (DH has never and never will engaged in anything like that, neither have I).

And you managed to find each other. Do you really not know many other monogamous couples?

How is he having this stuff thrown in his face? What exactly is happening to offend him?

Kris02 · 17/06/2022 18:10

gingersplodgecat · 17/06/2022 14:28

I think that people these days are no longer prepared to tolerate being in an abusive or otherwise toxic relationship, whereas in days gone by they just put up with it and carried on.

Nobody should feel obliged to stay in a relationship like that just because they are married to their abuser.

Very true. Both my sets of grandparents had utterly wretched marriages. My paternal grandmother was a screeching, self-pitying monster who made her husband's life a misery. And my maternal grandmother was driven to a breakdown by living with my grandfather. In those days, however, you just stuck it out.

Evolution meant us to reproduce at 15 and be dead by 25 or 30. We certainly didn't evolve to share a brick box with someone for 50 odd years. Frankly, it's a miracle any marriage survives!

Discovereads · 17/06/2022 18:09

@ForestFae
Im curious about super gonorrhoea as well. Thank you for the compliment, it is very interesting to look at behaviour and then think about, why are young people doing x, y, z. It’s not always due to immorality or morality. My generations attitude towards casual sex was completely and deeply affected by the AIDS pandemic and crisis. We didn’t avoid casual sex because we were somehow morally superior or Handmaids of the patriarchy or conservative/traditionalists…it was purely a matter of avoiding risk of an early death.

CallOnMe · 17/06/2022 18:08

Everyone has their own bar of what they’ll put up with.

Back in the day divorce was frowned upon so it wasn’t an easy option.

Nowadays it is an easy option but I don’t think that’s a bad thing.

Personally I think being happy is much more important than staying married.
I do not believe in rushing into a marriage for that very reason and believe people should live with each other for a couple of years to see if they’re compatible or not.

Arguments/disagreements are bound to happen but they shouldn’t be a regular thing and a partner is meant to enhance your life not make it more stressful.

I am single and I happy 90% of the time.
If someone came along and made me even happier then great - I would happily be in a committed relationship.
But if someone came along and made my life harder and more stressful - then I don’t see the point in being with that person and I wouldn’t be with them.
The same goes for if I was already married - if I would be happier single, then I might as well be single.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 18:08

Orchardsandpianos · 17/06/2022 18:02

but whats wrong with those things?

Consensual polyamory, nothing is wrong with it. However, glorifying lying, cheating, and generally being a shitty partner isn’t great, and it also makes things difficult for people who don’t want to engage in things like that. My DH for example, used to believe that barely anyone was as monogamous anymore and everyone had affairs due to constantly having stuff like this thrown in his face by society (DH has never and never will engaged in anything like that, neither have I).