Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people these days are not prepared to make marriage work?

214 replies

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 14:23

Most of my friends have gone or are currently going through divorce/separation. Some of them have got children some don't but most of them are not separating because of any 'big' issues (cheating/abuse/alcoholism etc). It seems that people reach a stage in their marriages when they cannot be bothered to fight for it anymore at least this seems to be the case from the experience of my friends and colleagues.

I frequently get annoyed with my husband over small things and that can often lead to big arguments but I always thought that these things are normal when you live with someone 24/7 and you both experience the best and the worst of this life together side by side. Many of my friends tell me that they just want to be able to enjoy fun things with their partner and are tired of problems that come with the marriage.

AIBU to think that you truly cannot have a carefree marriage/relationship and that sometimes people give up too easily?

P.S I don't really think there is right or wrong answer to that and that every situation is different but just wanted to hear opinions on that.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReneBumsWombats · 18/06/2022 08:08

Apparently, the regret expressed most often by dying people is that they lived the life other people wanted them to live, rather than the one they wanted themselves.

PaperMonster · 18/06/2022 07:57

It’s not that people give up too easily, I just think people are less prepared to spend their lives being unhappy.

Chouah · 18/06/2022 07:43

*Most of my friends have gone or are currently going through divorce/separation. Some of them have got children some don't but most of them are not separating because of any 'big' issues (cheating/abuse/alcoholism etc). It seems that people reach a stage in their marriages when they cannot be bothered to fight for it anymore at least this seems to be the case from the experience of my friends and colleagues.

I frequently get annoyed with my husband over small things and that can often lead to big arguments but I always thought that these things are normal when you live with someone 24/7 and you both experience the best and the worst of this life together side by side. Many of my friends tell me that they just want to be able to enjoy fun things with their partner and are tired of problems that come with the marriage.

AIBU to think that you truly cannot have a carefree marriage/relationship and that sometimes people give up too easily? *

YABU OP. I divorced from my first marriage. I didn't give up too easily, and it wasn't because I couldn't be bothered. Things happen behind closed doors that we never disclose to friends. Your friends are unlikely to be telling you everything, and unless you live with them, you simply have no idea what their marriages are like.

I was judged, in the same way you are judging your friends decisions. My Ex Husband was a "great guy" to all who know him. That's an understandable view to take when you don't live with someone. I also perpetuated that image for him, because why wouldn't I? What idiot would I be if I told everyone I was married to a disgusting sex addict who would masturbate all day and when I came home from work he'd insist on sex, only every 48 hours mind you, and be unable to do it because he'd been at himself all day?

Do I want my friends to know this? No.

So I let everyone think it was all on me, we'd grown apart, I'd changed. And yes, they judged me because they thought the same as you. Word for word. If asked, they'd say "I couldn't be bothered " or " I gave up too easily ".

You mentioned this is your friends, and colleagues. They are never telling you everything. I promise you.

bozzabollix · 18/06/2022 07:14

It depends doesn’t it? Obviously any sign of abuse and someone needs to be out of there quickly.

But having seen the wreckage of another relationship falling apart closely and it’s fallout has made me think that seeking counselling should be far more commonplace. If it’s a failure of communication then surely people can be helped in that area? But there seems to be a reluctance to seek out help early, before things get irreversibly bad. It was a shame it didn’t happen in my friend’s case, because things don’t seem to have improved for the couple involved after the split and their child has suffered hugely. They should have tried earlier to sort things out for his sake, then at least they could say they’d tried everything. (And going into another relationship without sorting out personal problems just brings those into that next relationship, which is exactly what’s happening).

There have been times I’ve felt like walking out of the door but it’s been about external pressures aka work - his job is pretty shit in terms of life/work balance and there’s nothing he can do about that. Then I’ve thought there’s always going to be areas of any relationship that’s not brilliant, and given my husband is pretty bang on where it counts generally why would I bin that? Sometimes it’s about one person accepting something that’s not 100% what they want (and before someone says that’s daft, in any relationship you have there will be areas of compromise, nothing will be perfect).

ReneBumsWombats · 18/06/2022 07:11

Prisonbreak · 17/06/2022 23:26

Here is the cold hard truth.
No good, happy, healthy marriage ends in divorce.

Neither do plenty of shit ones.

notacooldad · 17/06/2022 23:34

I think you shouldn’t give up at the first sign of trouble but equally if you are miserable you are better off apart
Would say it depends what that trouble is.
My ex hit me. That was the first and only sign of trouble I needed to get the hell out of Dodge. I didnt hang round for a second slap.

Prisonbreak · 17/06/2022 23:26

Here is the cold hard truth.
No good, happy, healthy marriage ends in divorce.

Villagewaspbyke · 17/06/2022 23:18

I think you shouldn’t give up at the first sign of trouble but equally if you are miserable you are better off apart. My parents stayed together despite being unhappy and it was awful for us kids. They didn’t do it for us but because they were too scared yo be on their own. Things are generally better now

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/06/2022 23:13

I remember when my grandpa died and a family member predicted that grandma would probably follow soon after because that often happens with elderly married couples, said the family member. They’ve been together for so long they can’t live without each other.

I had a feeling that grandma wasn’t going to die soon just because grandpa did, that she had a lot of living to do.

And she did live for many more years. The best bit was seeing her come alive. She made a whole bunch of new friends, joined an art class, embraced new hobbies and just blossomed.

I am not saying one way or another that they had a good or bad marriage. But, I definitely saw how Grandma had obviously lost herself in her role as a wife and had the strength of character to find herself again.

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/06/2022 22:52

@DivorcedAndDelighted I really like your post. I do relate to the sentiment, wish I’d given up sooner and not kept flogging a dead horse just for the sake of marriage.

I think marriages where both people put in the effort to improve their relationship and help each other are probably more likely to endure. But so many marriages do end up with one person putting in the effort while the other person shows no consideration for their partner. Then that person putting in the effort and being treated as inconsequential ends up either being subsumed by their partner or the status quo of the relationship or they break free and end it.

I’m glad that people have the freedom to end a marriage. The alternative is that they are trapped or forced to remain and lose their own identity and freedom.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 17/06/2022 22:40

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 16:10

"Work on the marriage" so often means "accept more shit, woman".

I don't think anyone divorces lightly, especially with kids involved.

Spot on @ReneBumsWombats

DivorcedAndDelighted · 17/06/2022 22:37

most of them are not separating because of any 'big' issues (cheating/abuse/alcoholism etc).

I think this attitude is why "exit affairs" happen. Many people feel they're not "allowed" to leave the marriage just for being unhappy in it. I've heard so many women say things like "I wish he would cheat, then I could leave him". Some men seem to find it more socially acceptable to get "caught out" having a fling than to "abandon" their wife, and so you get the whole extra layer of misery that deceit brings, and another woman brought into it, rather than just manning up and saying "this isn't working any more, let's call it a day".

DivorcedAndDelighted · 17/06/2022 22:17

My dad has the same view, that people split up too easily these days. He boasts proudly that he and my mother have been married fifty years. She mutters quietly that "you only get 10 years for murder". They've been driving each other mad for the last 40 years or so, but separating would be like admitting defeat, according to him.

I feel that it's like boasting that you've been banging your head against a brick wall for 50 years. An achievement of sorts, but why would you want to?

"Working at it" often means one person putting up and shutting up. If it consists of both people constantly trying to improve their relationship and help each other, then that's wonderful. But I wonder how often that happens? And what are you supposed to do if, like me, you're married to someone who doesn't want to put any effort in? Should you continue to do what I did, and just put up with anything for 20 years, to avoid giving up on the marriage?

When I talk to fellow divorced friends, we mostly wish that we'd given up sooner, not kept flogging a dead horse just for the sake of marriage.

DivorcedAndDelighted · 17/06/2022 22:09

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 16:09

I also think a lot of people just completely marry the wrong person by taking marriage too lightly in the first place, which is a different but related phenomenon

Really?! The marriage rate is lower now than it's ever been. It's perfectly acceptable in many social groups to have sex, cohabit and raise children without getting married. This presumably means that marriage is more of a conscious choice nowadays, rather than people "having" to marry because they were caught shagging / got pregnant.
People may marry someone who they thought was right for them, but they got it wrong, or they grow apart. Doesn't mean they weren't taking it seriously in the first place.

mummyrocks1 · 17/06/2022 19:27

Basically people can change over the course of a marriage and so you find yourself not married to the same person. Therefore, over time you stop getting on as you have evolved.

mummyrocks1 · 17/06/2022 19:23

Ok this is your opinion. I didn't express my opinions nor did I at any stage say that people shouldn't divorce and that any marriage is fixable. I've been the support to most of my friends and my marriage had zero to do with them wanting to end theirs. People start making assumptions for zero reasons. We have 2 children and have a huge sense of responsibility for them to build a good life together with one another or to separate with dignity and respect for one another if that is no longer possible. But for me it would have to be a good reason because both of us went through a lot and became stronger as a couple each time. Had to move 4 countries, had our first child when we were only 23 no support network at all but felt blessed. I guess we are just quite lucky

I think it's very easy to say this until you are in the situation yourself. I always thought work on the marriage, marriage isn't easy and we tried and tried. But covid and other stresses brought out the cracks and I became so unhappy with the constant arguments I asked DH to leave. In that period DH cheated on me. I never thought he would. I remember having your attitude until I was in the situation myself. If I was you I would wait until /if you are in the situation before making these comments as in reality you really don't know what you would do.

ForestFae · 17/06/2022 19:21

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 19:19

I think you could have a template that had to be followed in any respect that was or could be relevant, and imo the financial implications of childrearing for whichever party does it (or both) would definitely need to be included in that.

I'd really need to see such a template. There are so many possible twists and turns in life that I don't know how you'd calculate this before any of it has happened.

I have to agree with this. My DD for example, needed not only normal care but extensive medical care at home, provided by me until 12 months - I had to learn how to do feeding tube pumps, aspirates and operate a suction machine. How could you a) predict that and b) “compensate” someone for that? We didn’t know she would be unwell, we didn’t know I’d have to do the medical caring.

User2145738790 · 17/06/2022 19:20

This reply has been deleted

Identifying

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 19:19

I think you could have a template that had to be followed in any respect that was or could be relevant, and imo the financial implications of childrearing for whichever party does it (or both) would definitely need to be included in that.

I'd really need to see such a template. There are so many possible twists and turns in life that I don't know how you'd calculate this before any of it has happened.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 19:17

OP, why did you start a thread saying that people give up too easily on their marriages and then take offence when they explained to you why you're wrong?

What did you expect? What outcome were you hoping for?

ThrallsWife · 17/06/2022 19:17

People said that to me all the time, including my ex: that I should have continued to work at the marriage, it is what you should do, and that I was obviously of a generation that didn't uphold the sanctity of marriage.

I didn't say anything, lost contact with all mutual friends and my ex-in-laws as a result (who knows what ex told them in the end - they simply refused to engage with me).

What I did not disclose were years of systematic abuse: shouting, throwing and breaking things to intimidate me, road rage that could have killed me and my kids, being physically prevented from leaving arguments and, at one point, strangulation. Not to mention being kept secret for a year, being convinced to have an abortion against my better judgement, having to lie about how and where we got engaged because it wasn't "grand" enough (and, again, it being kept a secret for a few months) and having to pretend I did not have severe mental health issues.

No one would have believed me if I'd tried, so there was no point, because I was the only one seeing that side of him.

I doubt I'm alone in that experience.

AllNightDiner · 17/06/2022 19:11

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 18:05

I think this is a great post, but compulsory prenupts defeat the object of marriage somewhat. They can prevent the lower earner being fairly compensated for making a greater non-financial contribution such as child rearing and homemaking.

All of which can and should be covered in advance imo. Prenups aren't (or shouldn't) just be about protecting assets. I think you could have a template that had to be followed in any respect that was or could be relevant, and imo the financial implications of childrearing for whichever party does it (or both) would definitely need to be included in that.

And no one would be forced into anything @ForestFae - marriage isn't compulsory after all. But imo no one should enter into any contract without legal advice, and yet that's what most marriages entail atm. It's no wonder so many people end up with buyer's remorse.

HipsterMum · 17/06/2022 19:00

Loadedforest · 17/06/2022 18:46

I’ve found in real life that people that have opinions/ voice thoughts like this quite often are trying to justify staying in their own failing / unsatisfactory relationship. I did it for years.

Ok this is your opinion. I didn't express my opinions nor did I at any stage say that people shouldn't divorce and that any marriage is fixable. I've been the support to most of my friends and my marriage had zero to do with them wanting to end theirs. People start making assumptions for zero reasons. We have 2 children and have a huge sense of responsibility for them to build a good life together with one another or to separate with dignity and respect for one another if that is no longer possible. But for me it would have to be a good reason because both of us went through a lot and became stronger as a couple each time. Had to move 4 countries, had our first child when we were only 23 no support network at all but felt blessed. I guess we are just quite lucky and I didn't realise that until reading some posts.

OP posts:
EmmyGoLightly · 17/06/2022 18:55

I think people i know would say this about me - that I gave up too easily….Reality is he was emotionally abusive but because we have so many mutual friends and dc most people don’t know about that.

anon12345anon · 17/06/2022 18:49

ConfusedByDesign · 17/06/2022 14:35

In my experience, women try their utmost to keep the relationship going but can't do it by themselves.
Unfortunately, it seems that quite a lot of men don't want to put the effort in. They're usually the driver of the relationship breaking down by their actions (or inactions in some cases)

This ^.....
I thought the same as you op, and I honestly believed (bar adultery or abuse) that any marriage issues could be worked through..... surely love and commitment was enough!

However, when my (ex) husband told me he didn't love me and there was no way back for him (THERE WASN'T AN OW EITHER!)..... what can you do??

I still love him, and would've worked through things together, but it takes two to make a marriage work Sad

Incidentally, I would never get married again (although I'm infertile which does change things) and if I did, I would never change my surname to his!! (What a balls ache changing it back!!) Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread