Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to start tough love with DC5 re food

183 replies

Twocrabs20 · 17/06/2022 14:06

So, I have a DC, 5 years old.

On advice from various professionals, I did baby led weaning, I have offered healthy food at meals, and while they eat some food:


  • many types of fruit

  • some protein such as eggs, pork sausage and bolognaise sauce - they won’t however eat fish or any seafood products or chicken; and

  • a range of carbs.


They simply won’t eat any vegetables and are extremely fussy, which is starting to impact the eating habits of their younger sibling - who does enjoy a wide range of foods.

I feel like I have reached a point of something has to change; and NOW, that this habit / power game of refusing perfectly pleasant child friendly meals has got to stop. My DC is overweight for their age (not massively, but enough), and they can’t be getting the nutrients they need to be their best self. And I feel like I’m failing DC.

None of the suggestions by the various dieticians / nurses / paediatric consultants as to how to get them into eating vegetables has worked. I have tried every suggestion under the sun, including: I have grown stacks of vegetables they will pick but won’t eat; DC will cook vegetables with me and not eat the vegetables; and DC won’t ‘taste’ any of the vegetables even in small portions.

We have continued scenes of DC having tantrums that they don’t want any vegetables on their plate, even though I explain the vegetable has to remain on their plate, even if they don’t eat it. But I encourage DC to taste it, but not to take it off.

AIBU to now start some ‘tough love’ in now forcing DC to eat some vegetables or some part of our family meals which is beyond carbs and pork / bolognaise.

I dread doing this, and I don’t even know how to do tough love with eating - save for perhaps having a stand off with DC that you can’t leave the table unless you eat / taste said vegetable or re-serving any uneaten meal at the next meal, so they can’t wait for something better to come along. However my sense is the whole ‘they’ll come round to eating vegetables eventually’ simply isn’t going to happen; unless I take some significant action now.

My DC is increasingly becoming more overweight, and I think their poor diet will have impacts with their socialisation at school, ability to learn, and be the best version of themselves.

If anyone has got to the point of ‘tough love’ re food, what did you do, and were you successful in changing your child’s habit?

OP posts:
Snaketime · 17/06/2022 16:40

I am a fussy eater and always have been. I still don't eat any fruit or veg at all, I take multi vitamin tablets. Before anyone gets on at me I have tried but I physically can NOT eat them, I gag and heave and have actually been physically sick before now trying to eat them.
With my kids I was determined the weren't going to be like me. I did a mild form of tough love. I never forced them to eat everything on their plate, but always put some veg on their plate with their food, if they wouldn't eat it I would say, for example eat 2 carrot sticks and then you can have X (something they really like) or separate a few peas, broccoli, green beans etc and say if you eat those few you can have desert. If they didn't eat it I would stick to my guns and they wouldn't get desert. Once that started working I introduced new things and would ask that they just try a few mouthfuls, if they then say they genuinely don't like it I praise them for trying, if they do like it I ask them to have a few more mouthfuls before desert.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 17/06/2022 16:39

Find the Eat Well for Less (BBC iplayer). They had a very young looking grandma with 2 children. They made tomato sauces with broccoli which the boy hated (he ate it) and got him to eat other things.

Certain things though - I used to hate chicken (once I knew they used to be alive) and would only eat cucumber spread with butter! I've also detested prawns and because DM hated it, seafood. I now love scallops and crabs claws in batter.

Trial and error but don't force him to eat things he really doesn't like.

Blossomtoes · 17/06/2022 16:38

GrazingSheep · 17/06/2022 14:12

save for perhaps having a stand off with DC that you can’t leave the table unless you eat / taste said vegetable or re-serving any uneaten meal at the next meal, so they can’t wait for something better to come along

Please do not do either of these things.
How many times would re-serve the uneaten meal?

This. I remember my mum doing it with a chicken rissole. It kept coming back at every meal for 2.5 days. It went mouldy in the end. That was over 60 years ago.

Not eating veg won’t kill him if he eats fruit.

Workawayxx · 17/06/2022 16:34

I don't think tough love will ever work with eating. I subscribe to the theory (can't remember whose it is) that you decide what and when and they decide whether and how much. You can't force them to eat and making it a battle is just going to lead to more entrenched issues. Your DC eat a range of fruit which is great and hopefully veg will come in time. Maybe a fruit platter for snack with some veg crudite on the side? Doesn't matter if it's not eaten, it is getting them used to the sight and smell and showing it is a "normal" food.

I think 5 was fairly peak pickiness for my DS. He ate a similar range as your DC but not as much fruit (just apples and melon really, sometimes others but not often) and a very few veg (sometimes broccoli, carrot, cucumber). He now eats all sorts - lots of veg, meat, even sushi. He just had to come to it in his own time, with a little gentle encouragement and good modelling from those around him and for food not to become a control issue. It's exhausting and worrying and frustrating when good food is wasted though so I do totally sympathise!

Mostess · 17/06/2022 16:33

I'm wondering if your child has discovered this is a way to get your attention.

beeswaxbonnie · 17/06/2022 16:32

I was one of these kids who didn't like vegetables. My mum / Nan / everyone tried every trick in the book. You're not playing until you clear your plate. You're not having anything else until you eat your vegetables. They would reserve it. Eat your vegetables and starve.

It didn't go well. At 29 I still won't touch any vegetables, I just don't like them and there's nothing anyone can do about it. I just ended up dreading mealtimes.

Northe · 17/06/2022 16:31

Similar situation here. I have two sons and the oldest was baby led weaned and is super fussy. I have had some success recently with a Ninja soup maker to make sauce eg. for bolognaise. I am sure it is not recommended but beetroot in brownies is also a hit and recently he will have a tiny amount of broccoli with a Sunday dinner. He is already seven and is a healthy weight eating lots of fruit including cucumber, tomato etc. I hope some of these things might work for you. The little one eats his veggies so I keep dishing them up and hope that one day, the big one will tuck in too!

MajorCarolDanvers · 17/06/2022 16:31

Tough love will cause lifelong food issues.

Focus on the healthy things he will eat

ginsparkles · 17/06/2022 16:30

My DD was exactly the same as yours at that age. We went with giving her choice. I would basically cook her safe foods, whilst we ate a varied and normal diet. I never commented good or bad about her foods.

We cooked together, shopped together, watched food programmes together and I started introducing some of what we have on her plate, so if we have spag bol, she would have pasta and cheese with a small spoonful of the mince on the side of her plate, with the motto "you don't have to eat it"

Little by little her diet has improved. She's 10 now and whilst it's not perfect, it's lots better. She eats roast dinners, lasagne, fish of most kinds, sausages, burgers. Veg is still hard but she has one or two that she likes so we serve those regularly.

Also I would try offering things that are a variation of a safe food. They like bolognaise so try lasagne, or cottage pie.

So I would say don't force, do the opposite. Take the pressure off, just cook good healthy food, make no comments, offer food and let them get there. If they are getting over weight reduce portions, and snacking and increase their exercise.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 17/06/2022 16:30

Please don't do tough love or tough anything at mealtimes, OP.

My son is the same age and only eats olives, crisps, birthday cake and chicken nuggets. He will eat tomato ketchup with the nuggets and sometimes on its own (i.e. in a bowl with a spoon). He's thriving and is never ill. He's also been diagnosed with ARFID.

Some DC who are "picky" actually struggle with the consistency of food, especially veggies and fruit where no two are ever quite identical. We get around this by giving him those Ella pouches, although he will only eat one type (and only if we reward it). Smoothies might be good too - we don't because DS can't tolerate the noise of the blender (ASC).

You are going to give him a complex around food - DC definitely should not associate mealtimes with stress or conflict. A Mexican stand off over a bowl of carrots is not going to help him eat a more varied diet. Breezily getting on with your own meal is the best option, along with waiting for him to probably grow out of it.

We do reward DS for trying new foods. I like @hellobeautifulsoul 's jar idea.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 17/06/2022 16:29

DS 2 however, loves fruit and veg but likes things clearly separated so he can see what they are. Mild processing issues.

No amount of forcing him will make him do anything other than gag.

BreakfastClub80 · 17/06/2022 16:28

Lots of good advice OP, I can only add that I agree forcing a child to eat will be counter productive. However, enabling a child to eat badly can be stopped. I’m not necessarily saying that you do this, but I know parents who have continually set rules about eating the main before dessert and then always give in. They’re the same with bedtimes etc, where their child will never go to bed but is allowed to watch to etc, so of course they won’t.

My own approach was that if the main meal was rejected, that was ok but the only alternative was an apple. And subsequently, if they were hungry later, more fruit was offered. Dd isn’t great with all vegetables even at 13 but she will eat many. Salad is a disaster, carrots only really. But isn’t fight it, I’m fussy too and as she gets older you do realise you won’t be able to ‘force’ anything without looking very hypocritical! We just add more veg to our plates and sometimes others,to keep encouraging her to try.

Imissmoominmama · 17/06/2022 16:28

Take the pancake out of the lunchbox, and offer less fruit and veg in it.

Your child will eat the pancake first, and be overwhelmed by the variety of different stuff in there.

Keep it simple for now!

collieresponder88 · 17/06/2022 16:26

Do not force anything you could give your child an eating disorder. Just leave them be and let them eat what they want for goodness sake

Dencar · 17/06/2022 16:26

have you looked at “Solid Starts” on Instagram. Fabulous lady began this during lockdown. It began due to her child’s picky eating. Although it’s initially aimed at weaning, I’m sure there’s a load of info for the bigger kids - hers aren’t babies.
great info there - really recommend looking at this

SusanStoHelitsPoker · 17/06/2022 16:25

Are you 100% sure there's nothing else to it? My DS is very restricted and his main thing is he hates food mixed, e.g. he'll eat spaghetti bol but only with the spaghetti separated and no sauce. He drove me mad when he was younger refusing to eat so many different meals. Turns out a lot of it was due to the sensory issues around mixed foods. He still only eats foods he deems safe. He's on the autistic spectrum and also has sensory issues. I'm just saying be careful because 5 is still so young and you don't want to give him eating fears etc for the rest of his life.

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 17/06/2022 16:25

A really sensible approach @Enko

WheresTheLambSauce · 17/06/2022 16:25

I like vegetables but hate chunky sauces, so what I do with bolegnase is blend it all until it’s very fine and then mix that into the sauce. It’s almost unnoticeable that way. (Speaking as someone who can otherwise detect the tiniest chunks of mushroom in a dish).

CamCurls · 17/06/2022 16:24

Mine are all grown up now but getting them to eat a good range of foods was something I never quite got right. I wish I had known about this

www.ellynsatterinstitute.org/resources-and-links-for-the-public/

TooHotTooGreedy · 17/06/2022 16:23

Twocrabs20 · 17/06/2022 14:27

When I have added red peppers to bolognaise DC has declared it is yuck and refuses to eat the whole meal. Same with lentils for more protein / complex carbs.
I could probably add celery to the sauce without them noticing.

I used to pulse peppers and carrots in the blender to match head size. Once cooked down in bolognese they are undetectable. You could always try hidden veg muffins
www.myfussyeater.com/secret-veggie-muffins/

RedPlumbob · 17/06/2022 16:21

Slightly different issue here as my 6YO is tall for her age and so is slightly underweight, and has been the same way since she was born.

She has a dairy allergy so that already restricts us somewhat but in the last year she’s been ridiculously picky. I was stumped because my elder two have always just eaten anything.

No vegetables or salad at all, but eats a lot of fruit. Hardly any sweet treats because frankly they’re expensive to buy.

I just kept serving her things even though I knew she wouldn’t eat them. On a separate plate. Next to her meal. Didn’t say a word. Didn’t discuss any of it with her.

For about 10 months, nothing changed.

In the last 6 weeks, she now eats

  • cucumber
  • peppers
  • sweetcorn
  • carrots
Only small amounts, but it’s huge progress.
hellobeautifulsoul · 17/06/2022 16:19

I don't know if this will help but my DS was the same about 5yo. He's not overweight but had a bad habit of not eating any veggies. He can stomach a banana or an apple but that's as far as it went. I spoke to a professional who said that getting them to try things was half the battle, and to try the pasta jars.
We got two empty glass jars and painted loads of pasta pieces in different colours and patterns. We filled one jar and left the other empty. Each time DS would try a new food he could put a piece of pasta into the empty jar and when it was full he would get either a treat/small toy/favourite meal etc whatever you decide. I was apprehensive but it actually worked and the more he tried the more he discovered he liked. If that fails, if he likes tomato pasta, Tesco do a small tomato pasta sauce that has hidden veggies blended in which I also use for my DCs and they can't tell the difference. We also make smoothies and he chooses what to put in, the best one we've made yet had strawberries, bananas, raspberry yoghurt and milk blended and he loved it. And honestly he would never try anything like that before.
Wishing you all the best!

Enko · 17/06/2022 16:19

Many years ago I read an article that I used with great success on dd3 who was becoming a fussy eater (she is now 18 and the most broad taste of all my 4)

The basic of the article was not to make a fight out of it but to make an expectation

So dinner would be served and on the plate there would be some vegetables (not over the top but some) conversation happens and chatter -it is important for the family to eat together btw to show what others do) then as say the peas are being left you point at the peas and say " don't forget to eat your peas" then focus OFF the child and back to conversation.. continue this over a period of time no comment if they are not eaten and no comment fi they ARE eaten but make the expectation of " this will be eaten" after a while they begin to taste and eat as they realise this is the expected.

DO NOT praise if they taste a new vegetable (its not anything special its simply expected we try new things) Do not compare to other in the family just lead by example of eating yourself. do not focus on the child if they tantrum or begin to whinge focus off the food focus ON the family spending time together.

it worked soo well for us. ALso took any sensation off stress out of the dinner situation and eating together was a pleasure again.

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 17/06/2022 16:19

I'm inclined to agree @WeAreBob

Seems to be a British/US thing.

NannyR · 17/06/2022 16:19

I read about this scheme tiny tastes in a very good book (First Bite by Bee Wilson). The tiny tastes is all about the child being in control and repeatedly being exposed to and eventually tasting a tiny piece of the food they are averse to.
It would be worth reading the book - it's all about the psychology around eating and why people develop into fussy eaters and it's an entertaining, easy book to read.