Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to start tough love with DC5 re food

183 replies

Twocrabs20 · 17/06/2022 14:06

So, I have a DC, 5 years old.

On advice from various professionals, I did baby led weaning, I have offered healthy food at meals, and while they eat some food:


  • many types of fruit

  • some protein such as eggs, pork sausage and bolognaise sauce - they won’t however eat fish or any seafood products or chicken; and

  • a range of carbs.


They simply won’t eat any vegetables and are extremely fussy, which is starting to impact the eating habits of their younger sibling - who does enjoy a wide range of foods.

I feel like I have reached a point of something has to change; and NOW, that this habit / power game of refusing perfectly pleasant child friendly meals has got to stop. My DC is overweight for their age (not massively, but enough), and they can’t be getting the nutrients they need to be their best self. And I feel like I’m failing DC.

None of the suggestions by the various dieticians / nurses / paediatric consultants as to how to get them into eating vegetables has worked. I have tried every suggestion under the sun, including: I have grown stacks of vegetables they will pick but won’t eat; DC will cook vegetables with me and not eat the vegetables; and DC won’t ‘taste’ any of the vegetables even in small portions.

We have continued scenes of DC having tantrums that they don’t want any vegetables on their plate, even though I explain the vegetable has to remain on their plate, even if they don’t eat it. But I encourage DC to taste it, but not to take it off.

AIBU to now start some ‘tough love’ in now forcing DC to eat some vegetables or some part of our family meals which is beyond carbs and pork / bolognaise.

I dread doing this, and I don’t even know how to do tough love with eating - save for perhaps having a stand off with DC that you can’t leave the table unless you eat / taste said vegetable or re-serving any uneaten meal at the next meal, so they can’t wait for something better to come along. However my sense is the whole ‘they’ll come round to eating vegetables eventually’ simply isn’t going to happen; unless I take some significant action now.

My DC is increasingly becoming more overweight, and I think their poor diet will have impacts with their socialisation at school, ability to learn, and be the best version of themselves.

If anyone has got to the point of ‘tough love’ re food, what did you do, and were you successful in changing your child’s habit?

OP posts:
mobilecrane · 17/06/2022 17:31

Is she definitely overweight? If so, adding in some vegetables won't change that.

A PP asked if those lunchboxes were for between breakfast and teatime/supper. Are they? If so, way too much.

TheViscountessBridgerton · 17/06/2022 17:31

Yes, YABVU

My 6yo son has food aversions and sensory issues, which I suspect yours does too, as young children don't persistently engage in "power games" with an adult when it brings them nothing but their parents ire. To force him to eat that would be like forcing you to eat food scrounged from the bottom of a bin, or a dead spider. It wouldn't kill you, but it would be unreasonable, distressing, cruel and certainly something that would affect you emotionally. It doesn't matter that you know it as healthy food. His brain knows it as horrible, and even if you make him have it, it will still be horrible, but so will you

AllFreeOwls · 17/06/2022 17:30

save for perhaps having a stand off with DC that you can’t leave the table unless you eat / taste said vegetable or re-serving any uneaten meal at the next meal

My mum did this... The hill she decided to die on was a steak and kidney pie (which seems a weird one as I can't imagine many 5 year old would have eaten it without complaint). She served it breakfast, lunch & dinner for 3 days. I didn't to eat for 3 days and went hungry instead. Did it make me eat the steak & kidney pie? No.
Did it make me eat other things without complaint? No.
Did this help her in any way to make me less fussy? No.

StationaryMagpie · 17/06/2022 17:29

i have a teenager with ARFID (avoidant restrictive food intake disorder) he has never voluntarily eaten ANY fruit or veg in his life, his diet is almost entirely meat/carb/sugar based and he isn't fat... infact he's skinny. The only veg i can get in him is what i can hide in bolognese sauces, the tomato sauce on his cheese pizza, and the bit of fruit in the fruited bread he eats daily. I have managed to get him to take vitamins in pill form as 'medicine' (as he's got older i've managed to explain its necessary because of his restricted diet, but when he was little it was medication)

Your issue where his weight is concerned is you're feeding him too much, its not about whats in it.

Force feeding and making a song and dance about meal time is the absolute worse thing you can do with a picky/fussy eater, whether its normal developmental pickyness, or the start of a more serious issue/eating disorder like ARFID.

Stressing them out will make them more resistant to eating, it'll make you all miserable, and will traumatise them and give them an even worse relationship with food.

You need to just feed what he will eat, in correct portion sizes and remove the stress from meal times from all of you.. he is likely to do better with food as he gets older if this isn't ARFID or a sensory related issue.

skyeisthelimit · 17/06/2022 17:28

YABU to force your child to eat anything that they don't want to eat. I was forced by my father, and by my primary school teacher, to eat things that I didn't like and was left with lasting issues. They forced me to eat foods that I couldn't stand the smell or the taste of, like salad and vegetables, fatty meat, mincemeat, liver, to the point that I had to wash down things like cold cabbage with water while gagging.

As an adult, I now only eat carrots and peas and no salad stuff whatsoever. I eat some fruit and I eat potatoes.

If they had left me alone, I may have grown to like some of it, but being forced to it it until I was 11, left me with lasting damage. I was in heaven when I started secondary school and could choose my own lunch and started to stand up to my father at home (albeit I was still shouted at for not eating the food, he couldn't physically force me at that point).

I think for me it was very much a sensory issue, I couldn't stand the texture, smell, taste of so many foods. My childhood was miserable thanks to adults forcing me to eat this stuff and to clear my plate of it.

What worked for my DD to get her eating veg, was eating school dinners. She eats all sorts of veg that I don't eat, because she ate it at school with her friends. But if they had forced her to eat anything, I would have put her onto packed lunch.

There is NO WAY that I will do to my child what was done to me. Please don't do that to your child.

Cryofthecurlew · 17/06/2022 17:27

I was “forced” to eat food by a teacher at school I clearly remember vomiting cabbage back onto the plate and still being made to eat it. It took me years to get over it and I rarely if ever eat green vegetables/carrots/mash/roast potatoes just looking at cabbage makes my stomach turn. I’m now middle aged and am exceedingly healthy. On weaning knowing that being a fussy eater causes issues I encouraged both my DC’s to eat a varied diet is farting then a bit of everything but my older DC never wanted to eat vegetables, I never made anything of it just served him food he liked, in contrast my younger DC would literally eat anything. As children my older DC never had a days illness my younger son multiple admissions to hospital for chest related conditions. As adults my older DC is still not mad on vegetable he’ll eat some my younger DC will eat anything probably averaging 10 portions of veg/pulses etc a day he has far more colds/throat problems than the older one.
OP just leave him if you “force” him you are likely to scar him for life.
I have this theory that we don’t all taste/smell things the same way I loathe peas even the smell of them cooking turns my stomach (pre incidence of being forced to eat veg at school) my older son was once telling me the same thing in contrast my younger son thinks cooking peas smell divine.

Paddingtonsmarmlade · 17/06/2022 17:25

www.jamieoliver.com/recipes/pasta-recipes/seven-veg-tomato-sauce/ Definitely read the hack at the bottom about roasting the veg it's much easier. Bag it up in small quantities and freeze. Slowly substitute your tinned tomato in your Bolognese?

Id also agree with reducing portion size of carbs and snacks other than fruit/veg and keep offering veg

also if he has a texture thing over soup perhaps try raw veg or al denta incase it's a mushy texture issue.

SmallestInTheClass · 17/06/2022 17:20

Please don't unless you want a child who grows up into an adult with issues about food. Our DDs didn't each much fruit and veg at that age but have gradually done so as they got older. We went for the approach that you have to have one bit on your plate and try it - often really tiny amounts though - one round slice of carrot, one pea, one quarter of a green bean etc. If they ate that and didn't like it, they didn't have to have any more.

CharSiu · 17/06/2022 17:19

Do you all eat together? I found quite a few of my English friends fed their children at a separate sitting and ate after their dc had gone to bed.

If it’s a sensory thing then they may or may not grow out of it, knew a woman whose DS ate really limited food and no veg. He was under a paediatrician, she sort of hinted at what his diagnosis was but sort of pretended it wasn’t happening.

Londontown12 · 17/06/2022 17:17

Give up the battle it’s obvious it’s making the family unhappy at mealtimes !
I remember my parents doing the tough love at mealtimes and I ended up with an eating disorder !!
while my own children were fussy like most children are ! I would use reverse psychology on them example :
everyone had broccoli on there plates not including Dd she hated it but she then felt left out and asked her dad if she cud have his tree lol 😂 she gobbled it up and then she had some on her plate the next time !
It’s simple and no pressure and meal times will be stress free x

Dixiechickonhols · 17/06/2022 17:09

If they are used to lots of sweet foods and carbs their palate will need to adjust. Just keep going. I’d try with sweeter veg first eg carrot.
If they eat sausages would they eat chicken sausages then try and transition to actual chicken.
You can add grated carrots or courgette to porridge too.

Pollyforever · 17/06/2022 17:05

Do you think you have unrealistic expectations? I have 3 DC eldest is 7 and none of them or their friends would eat seafood, they don't love vegetables, they wouldnt eat noodles with veg, they also wouldn't eat much from those packed lunches that you uploaded.
My DC have all gone through phases of being fussy. I keep things plain and simple when they're in a phase of being fussy. Fruit that I know they like, offer them new food but don't force it. I use what i know they like, they love roast dinners so I will make a quick roast a few nights a week most weeks. I blend my bolognaise sauce before I add the meat, could you try the same? This means I can add any veg and the DC don't know because the sauce looks the same every time. My DC eat a lot more veg than they realise. If I limit treat foods I find that after a couple of days they will eat more fruit as snacks too. Try not to stress. I didnt eat any vegetables at all as a child and I love them now.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 17/06/2022 17:03

I have a fussy child. I've read books on it and talked to various health professionals and all the advice is not to make a big deal of it.

If they dont want it on their plate I wouldn't put it on their plate

Dont link rewards to food eg eating veg will get you a pudding.

It's hard and I've broken my rules before but its never worked. The only thing that works sometimes for us is us all snacking on something before a meal from a shared plate and they will try some too. Seeing friends help themselves to things from a central serving plate works better than putting it on their plate.

My child is genuinely scared of trying new food and if I push it they just associates the new food with fear

I'm really hoping they grow out of it. I know someone who ate only white bread, plain pasta with butter and grapes til they were 15 and now they are strong and healthy and work in finance

In the mean time if you are worried about nutrition could you make smoothies where you blend a bit of veg in with the fruit? Or blend more veg into spaghetti bolognese (so make a tomato sauce but blend in carrots and other veg like peppers and courgettes and sweet potato) as there is nothing to spot or pick out

WhamBamMam85 · 17/06/2022 17:02

Honestly? I’d do nothing. Most kids go through a fussy stage at some point - mine certainly did. If you make a big thing of it, you’re in danger of creating issues and stresses around eating.

Telling a child they “must” eat certain foods or amounts of foods is basically forcing them to eat.

If your child only ate chips and green Smarties, I might be inclined to agree that you need to do something but it sounds like they have a decent variety among the foods they DO eat.

I know this probably goes against everything you feel you should be doing but just be really casual, don’t comment on it and I bet you eventually they will start trying new things.

Bonjovispjs · 17/06/2022 16:55

You sound just like my parents, I wouldn't eat veg as a kid (and some other things) I wasn't a fussy eater though, everyone has some food they don't like, but I was forced to eat it every day and wasn't allowed to leave the table until it was all gone, all they succeeded in doing was give me an unhealthy relationship with food and a lifetime battle with my weight, but yeah, you go ahead if you think that'll help🙄

Havehope21 · 17/06/2022 16:54

Hi OP, have you looked up ARFID? Might be worth looking into. Look at SR Nutrition - she has some very good advice. Can you add more veg grated into the bolognese? Also hold firm on meals as in, this is all there is at this meal, you can leave it if you don't like it but no alternatives. Next meal is whatever you are having and then continue on.

Stroopwaffels · 17/06/2022 16:53

Not that it makes any difference, but why are you being so coy over whether you are talking about your son or your daughter? All this "my DC" and constructing sentences to avoid revealing the sex is... weird.

Anyway - don't force him/her. If she/he is overweight, it's because they are eating too many of the wrong things, substituting proper meals for sugar or carbs.

Muppetryofthepenis · 17/06/2022 16:52

Just offer a good variety of tasty food every meal. Take it away if not eaten. Rinse and repeat. They'll soon learn to eat what's put in front of them. Stop offering alternatives.

WouldBeGood · 17/06/2022 16:51

I wouldn’t stress. Just give them
less food overall to stabilise weight. The rest will sort itself out.

becausetrampslikeus · 17/06/2022 16:50

Child overweight and not eating any veg

Serve less food overall , especially less of the carbs / protein that the child is eating but have plenty of veg around if they are hungry ?

MargaretThursday · 17/06/2022 16:47

Go ahead and try it... if you want to give them food issues.

I have two things that if i try to eat I will probably vomit-they're both things my parents thought were non-negotiable to eat.
I'd love to be able to eat them. Unfortunately I can't.
Other things I didn't like as a child and was not forced to eat, I enjoy eating now.

Dixiechickonhols · 17/06/2022 16:42

I think advice is to do opposite and back off. So serve things family style inc 1 thing they eat encourage you try a bit of each and chat about day not food. If uneaten don’t get cross or try and persuade just tidy up. No snacks or offering toast instead etc. watch he’s not filling up or having lots of calories in drinks. Maybe try no snacks and see if that helps. Don’t buy junk if you’ve not got crisps and biscuits he can’t have them. Would he help cook - might encourage him to try things. If he likes plain eg chicken no sauce or raw veg stuff serve that.

Flipflopblowout · 17/06/2022 16:40

Wow, tough love on a 5 year old's eating habits? How many days are you prepared to let him/her go without food?

Swipe left for the next trending thread