Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to start tough love with DC5 re food

183 replies

Twocrabs20 · 17/06/2022 14:06

So, I have a DC, 5 years old.

On advice from various professionals, I did baby led weaning, I have offered healthy food at meals, and while they eat some food:


  • many types of fruit

  • some protein such as eggs, pork sausage and bolognaise sauce - they won’t however eat fish or any seafood products or chicken; and

  • a range of carbs.


They simply won’t eat any vegetables and are extremely fussy, which is starting to impact the eating habits of their younger sibling - who does enjoy a wide range of foods.

I feel like I have reached a point of something has to change; and NOW, that this habit / power game of refusing perfectly pleasant child friendly meals has got to stop. My DC is overweight for their age (not massively, but enough), and they can’t be getting the nutrients they need to be their best self. And I feel like I’m failing DC.

None of the suggestions by the various dieticians / nurses / paediatric consultants as to how to get them into eating vegetables has worked. I have tried every suggestion under the sun, including: I have grown stacks of vegetables they will pick but won’t eat; DC will cook vegetables with me and not eat the vegetables; and DC won’t ‘taste’ any of the vegetables even in small portions.

We have continued scenes of DC having tantrums that they don’t want any vegetables on their plate, even though I explain the vegetable has to remain on their plate, even if they don’t eat it. But I encourage DC to taste it, but not to take it off.

AIBU to now start some ‘tough love’ in now forcing DC to eat some vegetables or some part of our family meals which is beyond carbs and pork / bolognaise.

I dread doing this, and I don’t even know how to do tough love with eating - save for perhaps having a stand off with DC that you can’t leave the table unless you eat / taste said vegetable or re-serving any uneaten meal at the next meal, so they can’t wait for something better to come along. However my sense is the whole ‘they’ll come round to eating vegetables eventually’ simply isn’t going to happen; unless I take some significant action now.

My DC is increasingly becoming more overweight, and I think their poor diet will have impacts with their socialisation at school, ability to learn, and be the best version of themselves.

If anyone has got to the point of ‘tough love’ re food, what did you do, and were you successful in changing your child’s habit?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OursonGuimauve · 21/06/2022 17:11

I had a very limited diet as a kid, and issues with textures and smells. I existed basically on potatoes in most forms, spaghetti, some bread, white meats, ham gravy/stew type meals and ketchup. My palate widened when I was in charge of the food I ate myself and I could prep and cook the food I wanted to eat myself.

Now I eat most things and the things I can't eat are the things I was forced to eat as a kid, you can't get over food that you have had to gag or have anxiety about on because you associate it with being made you eat it when you couldn't stand the sight/smell/texture/taste. it also doesn't make you enjoy being around the person who made you sick and anxious.

Honestly, the biggest thing that will affect your child's socialisation/being their best self is poor self esteem, which is something that can come about when someone is hyper focussed on your weight and appearance at a young age.

CecilyP · 21/06/2022 17:10

Do not do tough love. Make a meal, and if they leave the vegetables, don't give anything else. They will soon become hungry and will be open to trying it.

Are vegetables really that filling? Eating the rest of the dinner without the vegetables wouldn’t make much difference as far as hunger is concerned.

CecilyP · 21/06/2022 17:02

^starrynight21 · 18/06/2022 01:42
My DS is 33 and has never eaten any vegetable besides potatoes, all his life. Never . He is "his best self" , always healthy, never has been to the doctor besides accidental injury. May I suggest stopping all this "tough love" and treat him like a visitor who happens not to like certain foods. You wouldn't force a visitor to eat something - don't force your DS.^

Yes this is a good idea. It will help you stop the unnecessary stressing. At 2, DS stopped all veg except carrots, occasional potatoes, and tinned tomatoes in bolognese sauce, though he did enjoy fruit. He did not have multivitamins but as far as I am aware he is ‘his best self’. He only started eats green stuff again in his 20s. He was also very slim, so your DS’s weight is more to do with whatever else he eats than lack of vegetables.

The only veg DS’s cousin would eat was potatoes and baked beans. I even had to leave the onion out of mince when she came to stay. Again a fairly slim child.

carefullycourageous · 21/06/2022 16:50

Hasn't it been proved that forcing children to eat what they don't want can cause problems later? yes categorically proven, but doesn't stop people who were controlled being controlling themselves. Forcing children to eat things they don't want is a sign the adult needs help.

Crankley · 21/06/2022 16:46

Hasn't it been proved that forcing children to eat what they don't want can cause problems later?

I was a child in the late 40s/50s. We had rationing until '54 so not much choice. I was a fussy eater but was never made to eat anything at home, unlike my new teacher who insisted we all drank the small bottles of milk which had sat in the sun all morning. I declined, she insisted, I vomitted all over her feet and still don't drink milk 70 years later.

I'm still a fussy eater - there are a mass of things I don't eat. It's not a crime.

worriedatthistime · 21/06/2022 16:04

@Lightsoutlondon but that may work for some kids and not others
My ds would go days without eating if we tried the eat it or go without or don't eat it and don't get xyz he would say ok

worriedatthistime · 21/06/2022 16:02

@Marvellousmadness but we don't live in your country and if have a child with eating issues or afiad etc don't tell me its just a mum issue
Other countries have less autism etc , doesn't mean it doesn't exsist though

starrynight21 · 18/06/2022 01:42

My DS is 33 and has never eaten any vegetable besides potatoes, all his life. Never . He is "his best self" , always healthy, never has been to the doctor besides accidental injury. May I suggest stopping all this "tough love" and treat him like a visitor who happens not to like certain foods. You wouldn't force a visitor to eat something - don't force your DS.

SingleMomIreland · 18/06/2022 01:05

There's a book called Deceptively Delicious, which has brownies made with beetroot, and lots of other recipes with a LOAD of hidden veg. Maybe worth borrowing from the library or buying on eBay or Amazon.
As others have said, it's not the lack of veg causing the obesity, it's the carbs.

Do not do tough love. Make a meal, and if they leave the vegetables, don't give anything else. They will soon become hungry and will be open to trying it.

If they refuse multivitamins, there's a new Robinsons (I think) cordial with added multi vitamins. Not ideal but better than nothing.

ElephantsFart · 18/06/2022 00:32

Just anecdotal but… My DB was a really fussy eater at that age, and no one forced him to eat, but my mother couldn’t afford to waste food or offer alternatives. So it was eat what everyone else is having or go hungry. Mealtimes were slow and he usually left a lot on his plate. He was thin until he was around 20, then he started to bulk out and eat more like regular people as it was affecting his love life! He’s now in his 50s, eats pretty normally and enjoys good health. I don’t know if that helps or not but I hope you manage to find a solution.

Emmelina · 18/06/2022 00:16

Can you do a reward system? Star on the chart for licking a veggie etc., work towards a special treat. Then up the game with a nibble etc etc.

Marvellousmadness · 17/06/2022 23:43

Your kid isn't overweight because he doesn't eat his veggies. He is overweight because he is overeating. And overeating on the unhealthy stuff. Which you give him, as he doesn't eat "anything else".

In my country there aren't any fussy eaters. Simply because parents wouldn't be able to afford to give them "special dinners". So kids eat what they are given. And if they dont want jt? That's fine. But you aren't getting anything else,that's for sure.
!and that is not 'tough love'. That's reality. And I definitely believe that fussy eaters aren't born. They are created! By moms mostly.

Give your kid his dinner for lunch. If he doesn't want to eat it? Fine. He can eat it for dinner. If he refused again,then go to bed on an empty stomach . (He is overweight hell be fine) next morning some healthy breakfast and give him (a different!) Dinner for lunch again
And tell him if he doesnt eat it he can eat it for dinner.

This wont last long before the kid will give in. As before this time he knew you were a pushover and you let him get off the hook. Dont let yourkids become fatter and unhealthier.youll create huge problems for him on the long run. You need to do better.

Miranda2308 · 17/06/2022 23:32

There are crunchy, orange-flavoured vitamins too from a big brand, which go down very well in our house. Might be worth trying. I do agree with most of the people posting replies: a tough approach could create more issues now or later. It could also be deeply stressful for you! This all sounds difficult enough. One of my children has been very fussy pretty much since birth and it all goes back to genuine digestive problems, which have revealed themselves slowly and painfully. I think I beat myself up a lot in the early days and felt like I was a bad mother for not providing good enough food. I wanted to be the mother giving her child homemade beetroot hummus, not the one feeling relieved that said child had managed to at least eat some quavers for Christmas dinner! As soon as I relaxed a bit, things did actually get easier. Best of luck!

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/06/2022 18:33

Ugh at the idea of 'doing it for attention'...

That phrase triggers a conditioned emotional response in me...

If someone, a child, an animal, anyone.. is 'doing something for attention' then either..

They're not getting enough attention.

or

The attention they're getting is not right sort/quality etc.

Either way, something is wrong.

Children do not sit and ponder ways to get parental attention, children NEED attention, if they're forced to seek it in maladaptive ways, there is a problem and almost certainly it is the parent with whom the problem lies.

But most children with serious food issues absolutely do not want that attention, in fact the attention they're getting is a huge part of the problem.

I can recall how bad that felt, that everyone was looking at me as I cried and gagged over food. That I felt so hungry it HURT but I couldn't put a certain sort of food in my mouth without retching loudly.

And if I did miraculously try something, the so called praise.. the sarcastic, patronising 'see it WASNT THAT BAD'... 'see you WERE JUST BEING SILLY'.. undermining how I felt, minimising my distress... that was frankly worse than the 'eat it or you'll get a slap' type shit.

Shallysally · 17/06/2022 18:18

Just seen the lunch boxes, that is quite a lot of food.
I remember seeing on Mumsnet re the 5 items in a lunchbox idea. So a sandwich/wrap. A portion of fruit or veg, which I know is difficult for you but honestly, I’d stop with the choice and just include 1 option.
Then a portion of dairy/dairy alternative, so yogurt/cheese cubes.
A small portion of day, popcorn or a chopped up slice of ham/few crackers.
Then a drink.
Honestly it’s plenty, and if your child is anything like a lot of 5 yr olds it’s all they have time to eat at school.

RB68 · 17/06/2022 18:10

I had a child that would happily eat veg when weening but developed an aversion to everything bar broccoli so we had several years of whizzing up a tomato and veg mix before adding to minced beef for bolognaise which she was fine with. Choose your fruit for the lower sugar fruits, will she eat yoghurt? Try her with full fat plain yog and berry type fruit - far more satisfying than low fat sugary fruit jobs. I would continue with a central plate for her to try things at her pace. Please do not go down the force it route esp if there are other issues at play. You may need some outside help as often they will respond better to other adults (ie not parents/guardians) in terms of being compliant and just putting it in their mouth which is where things should be starting.

I do get the frustration though - she is now at 16 getting more adventurous although still baulks at lots of veg - but will happily make from scratch pasta sauce with fresh toms, onion and garlic even though she wouldn't touch a fresh tom in a salad - she will eat cucumber and lettuce, carrot sticks raw and pepper raw - just not cooked!!

Lightsoutlondon · 17/06/2022 18:00

GrazingSheep · 17/06/2022 14:12

save for perhaps having a stand off with DC that you can’t leave the table unless you eat / taste said vegetable or re-serving any uneaten meal at the next meal, so they can’t wait for something better to come along

Please do not do either of these things.
How many times would re-serve the uneaten meal?

I did this kind of thing - well I didn't reserve meals but I insisted on them trying stuff, and hey guess what it worked. I just used to say I'm not putting the tele on after dinner til you try 3 bites. Or if you want dessert you need to try 3 bites. Half the time it's a control thing and actually you are their parent not their friend and part of being a parent is occasionally imposing some consequences on their choices. No you can't make them eat it but they don't get to watch TV if they don't! My Lo's eat a really varied diet and genuinely love their food now, the 'tough love' did not put them off eating it ever again as some on here claim it will!

knackeredmu · 17/06/2022 17:47

I would follow the advice and make it a non issue - serve at the table and they get to choose what they want from the meal you've made - you eat the veg / salad as usual - you can add table sauces and dressings and just keep going for 6/9 months - no fuss - and then see how things are - if you've managed to get them to have a small amount of something or not! If not then back to the drawing board

I would keep meals simple for now - pasta Bol and a salad, it will be dull for a few months but hopefully with the non issue and with them being safe on knowing that at each meal there will be something they like then the control or whatever is motivating them will go and mealtimes will be relaxed - maybe they won't eat lots but it will be normal to have some veg - good luck - I think a. Lot of us have been there .....

AliceMcK · 17/06/2022 17:37

NRTFT but from what I’ve read they sound like my oldest, now 10, she absolutely refused fruit and veg, would gag at it, this had a knock on effect with my 8yo copying her. My youngest however loves fruit and veg. Only one eats yogurts or drinks smoothies too.

I would not force it. They get to an age where you can negotiate with them and in my case they will at least try. My 8yo has suddenly started to eat peas, my 10yo will eat an odd roasted carrot & pick at lettuce. They have gotten better, some of it is due to their friends, they will ask to try something their friend likes. Usually it dosnt work but they do try.

Things I’ve done to disguise veg, blend as much into spag boll, shepards pie or general mince dishes, meatballs, burgers, tacos, lasagna etc as possible, capsicum is great as it’s full of vitamin c. Tinned carrots blend better than fresh and less noticeable I use to blend veg and mix it in with pizza sauce to put on home made pizzas. As they have gotten older I don’t blend it as fine so they do have it with bigger bits of veg now.

mine refused things like spag boll for ages due to the tomatoes so I’d just make it with beef skock. I’ve now built them up to eating it if I really blend the tomatoes so their is no lumps (I don’t like jar sauces).

If they won’t eat gummie vitamins you can buy liquid ones to hide in drinks.

mynameisnotmichaelcaine · 17/06/2022 17:37

I had eating issues as a child. What helped was getting older. I always ate absolutely loads of fruit but hardly any veg. I like basically all veg now. My parents used to be frantic and would bribe, cajole, plead and attempt to force. I just got thinner, and more stuck in my ways.

I would cut portions, serve a wide variety of fruit and lay off talking about food with your DC. My three are all slim, but good eaters because I took an extremely laid back approach and acted like I couldn't care less what they ate. They didn't fill up on crap because I didn't buy it.

Oaktree1952 · 17/06/2022 17:36

I have 3 fussy children and I have had enough of it as well. I have started refusing to give them snacks. So dd8, dd5 and dd3 will have breakfast (cereal and toast) and then if they are hungry at 10 I will offer fruit. If they are hungry they will eat it and if not then that's fine. I have had to put up with whinging but they are getting used to fruit or nothing.
For lunch and dinner I make them what I'm going to make them. So sandwiches, fruit and crisps for lunch and whatever I am cooking for dinner. I try and make sure the flavours are not too adventurous so spag Bol or shepherds pie or chicken in white sauce etc. including veg. Then if they want to eat it great, if they don't then that's fine too but nothing else is offered. If they want anything sweet (yoghurt, chocolate bar, lolly) then they have to have eaten at least half of what is on their plate.

They are getting better at eating but not amazing. But I'm not cooking silly numbers of different dinners nor are we snacking in the afternoon so they are trying more things. We also eat quite early - 4 or 5 to try and catch the after school hunger!

moita · 17/06/2022 17:36

OP - I get it. It won't work but I know how tough it is

Dogroses · 17/06/2022 17:34

Little Anecdote: my Brother wouldn't eat anything except peanut butter sandwiches, mashed potato, corn and chicken nuggets for years. He wouldn't eat sauce. His food couldn't touch. No known sensory issues etc. My mom just gave him what he liked to eat and always offered him what we were having. Eventually as he grew up be wanted to try things. Now as a grown man he eats everything - everything! More adventurous than me and I was the one who loved brocolli and sprouts as a toddler!

My own 4yo is quite fussy though he will eat some raw veggies. I used to serve him exactly what we were eating and tell him that was the only option for dinner but we started getting into food battles and 'how many bites?' Lots of tears etc. Now I give him what we're eating but adapted a bit - sauce on the side, raw veggies instead of cooked. And I try not to discuss what he's eating and how much. It's taken a lot of the stress out of it. We all enjoy meals more and I think that's crucial - making meals unpleasant will not improve eating habits.

I also agree that starting small is good. One bite can be celebrated. Everytime he takes a bite of something he doesn't like he's one step closer to developing a taste for it in future.

Another thing is that I have cut down on his snacking and moved his dinner a bit earlier. He has one snack at 3pm and sometimes another piece of fruit. Usually he's really hungry for dinner and sometimes forgets to complain and just eats it!

TeaWithFlorence · 17/06/2022 17:33

"tough love" will set your child up for a lifetime of disordered eating.

beastlyslumber · 17/06/2022 17:32

Stroopwaffels · 17/06/2022 16:53

Not that it makes any difference, but why are you being so coy over whether you are talking about your son or your daughter? All this "my DC" and constructing sentences to avoid revealing the sex is... weird.

Anyway - don't force him/her. If she/he is overweight, it's because they are eating too many of the wrong things, substituting proper meals for sugar or carbs.

I suspect it's because it's a little girl, and OP knows that what she's doing is looking for justifications to control her eating. I question the idea of children going on diets of any kind. They are still growing and changing. I was listening to a podcast recently with a woman saying her mum put her on a diet when she was 11 because her body shape was changing due to puberty - she was putting on weight because she was growing! It caused her lots of issues, including obesity and a binge eating disorder in later life.