Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Charity being mis-managed

59 replies

NCOneDayOnly · 17/06/2022 12:57

I've name changed for this and would really appreciate any guidance from anyone with experience of working within the charitable sector who may have experienced something similar, or anyone who has experience of Charity Commission procedures.

I work for a charity that I have serious concerns is being mis-managed; both by the chief exec and all of the board of trustees (with one notable exception).

My concerns relate mainly to operational and financial mis-management; for example:


  • CEO and board of trustees being entirely dis-interested in day-to-day oversight, governance or interaction with staff and the various projects we run in the charity's name

  • failure to act in a timely manner to avoid unnecessary expenditure and costs to the charity's available funds

  • promises of actions/work being undertaken by the CEO which never materialise (the CEO essentially sits in meetings with staff, agrees to undertake tasks, admits they need to act differently and then does precisely nothing different)

  • inconsistency in budgeting eg: applying costs to a project that the CEO knows cannot afford to pay them owing to lack of funds (funding being exceptionally difficult for some of the charity's projects in the wake of covid), no clear guidance on how budgets are set up, repeatedly failing to address budgeting inconsistencies and failure to understand or act upon staff concerns around budgetary issues

  • board of trustees do not act with any impetus, for example: a major source of funding was lost to the charity during 2018/19 and a strategic review for the organisation to address this was not implemented until 2021/22

  • once the strategic review was begun, and recommendations were put to the board of trustees, the trustees once again failed to respond in a timely manner and/or ignored or watered-down the recommendations - for example; a 'deep dive' financial review was recommended. That 'deep dive' was undertaken only by the CEO and the chairman of the board of trustees who declined an offer of assistance and support from an external, independent officer.

  • office space costs the charity around £30,000 p/a. The office space has not been used to any really degree since the start of the first pandemic lockdown and all staff have been working remotely for around 95% of the time. Trustees have STILL not agreed that notice can be given to give up the office space, thus forcing the charity to pay around (to date) £75,000 in rent which could have been avoided. Staff unanimously agreed that the charity should give up the office to save costs, money which could have been diverted to the projects, but the board of trustees did not wish to enter into discussions with any staff members about this.


Several colleagues and I feel that the charity is being mismanaged and that the board of trustees has allowed it to run into financial difficulties. The last set of filed accounts state very plainly that money applicable to 12 weeks reserves should be maintained with an accompanying note stating that the reserves at the end of 2021 were actually very much less than that - surely, that means the trustees have been negligent - if only on that one point?

Staff have reported concerns to the CEO and various members of the board of trustees on numerous occasions, but nothing ever happens. Colleagues who have worked for the charity for longer than I have been through two previous strategic reviews and NOTHING has changed. The charity simply limps along until the next lot of interim funding saves it from collapse in the nick of time. As a result, medium to long-term planning is impossible.

Charity Commission guidance on whistleblowing says the Charity Commission will '... if we investigate a concern we usually work with the charity and the trustees to get it back on track...'. There's also some advice that says you can report 'mis-management' if you think it actually is happening, has happened or is 'likely' to happen, so that might cover some of the above.

I am conscious that any whistleblowing would/could have an impact on jobs, but I am also hugely concerned that a charity is being managed in such a careless way.

Any advice would be very much appreciated. Thank you.

OP posts:
Jalisco · 17/06/2022 13:59

Sorry I should have said - I have loads of background in working with charities and the CC. I have seen cases of charity trustees literally breaking the law and the CC have refused to intervene, saying it is up to someone to prosecute if they think the trustees are wrong. What you are describing might be bad management but that isn't illegal, so they won't do a thing. If they acted on the sorts of things you describe half the small charities in the country would be being investigated.

Philisophigal · 17/06/2022 13:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

NCOneDayOnly · 17/06/2022 13:54

@saraclara - the loss of funding if over 20% of the whole income has already happened. It happened several years ago and is STILL being cited as a reason for our current deficit. I've just found out our current deficit is running at around 18% of income, and has been as high as '25% of 30%' in previous years.

OP posts:
saraclara · 17/06/2022 13:37

I'm not convinced that most of the things you mention will be of any interest to the CC. I've added a screenshot of the level of issue that they would expect to hear about.

www.gov.uk/guidance/report-serious-wrongdoing-at-a-charity-as-a-worker-or-volunteer

Charity being mis-managed
saraclara · 17/06/2022 13:31

I'm not sure that aibu is the place for this. I am a trustee of a charity, and the role, the relationships and the responsibilities (and what we're NOT responsible for) are very very complex. Even our lovely staff, though it's been explained to them time and again, seem to think we can do things that we can't. It's very easy for a charity CEO to shift the blame onto their trustees (and vice versa) because of the complexity of the relationship.

Unless each responding poster is able to confirm that they have experience in this area, their advice isn't likely to be that helpful to you. You're likely to just get a knee jerk "they're wasting money, report them!" from everyone

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 17/06/2022 13:22

Yep.
Charities' Commission.

Jalisco · 17/06/2022 13:21

They won't do anything. Being rubbish at your job, stupid, incompetent etyc isn't against the law. And the 12 weeks reserves note in the audited accounts is a standard clause - it isn't illegal to have less. What is far more likely is that the CC will tip off the CEO / trustees and there will be a "hunt for the guilty".

NCOneDayOnly · 17/06/2022 13:10

Rather tellingly, the whistleblowing policy doesn't mention anything about 'mis-management', and only includes the following:


  • committing a criminal offence

  • failure to comply with a legal obligation

  • miscarriage of justice

  • endangering the health and safety of an individual

  • environmental damage

  • concealment of information related to any of the above


It's almost as though they KNOW they're mis-managing the charity and are trying to say, via the whistleblowing policy, that their actions don't form part of anything that could be reported.

OP posts:
Clarinet1 · 17/06/2022 13:03

My first thought (before you even mentioned them) was the Charity Commissioners. If is this one trustee you have faith in, perhaps he/she would be prepared to back you.
In terms of whistleblowing, the charity should have a policy to protect you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread