Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thoughts on taking your DC out of school to enjoy the sunshine?

495 replies

Dorsetdelight211 · 17/06/2022 07:55

DD is 14, year 9. She's just had a message off her best friend to say she won't be in school today as her mum is taking her and her younger sister to the beach for the day. Que DD saying how cool the mum is and how unfair it is that I never let her miss school for fun stuff. I've got to work and even if I didn't I still wouldn't let her do it.

YABU-its a beautiful day, one day off school won't make a difference
YANBU-school is important and you can't skive off just because the weathers nice.

OP posts:
frydae · 19/06/2022 09:13

Juced · 19/06/2022 08:46

do it school is bullshit! They don’t think twice about having teach training days! leaving parents with the inconvenience of having to rearrange work etc!

You don't want your DCs teachers to have continuous training?

tigger1001 · 19/06/2022 09:02

Harmonypuss · 19/06/2022 04:49

Kids already get 13 weeks off school every year, they only do about 5hrs of lessons a day, so there's barely enough time in the days they are expected to be in school to give them a proper education as it is, without people taking them out for a day here and a day there, even one day can disrupt the whole class in some cases.

I'm proud to say that when I was putting my two kids through school, they both went through 7yrs of infants and juniors and 5yrs of secondary school with only 3 days worth of absence between them. Yes, that's 3 days lost across what amounts to 24yrs of education.

I can go further, because my youngest also went to college for 3yrs and university for another 3yrs and had to have 2 days off due to a family funeral and hospital appointments, so that takes our total to 5 days of education lost across 30yrs.

We still had fun days out, they never missed out on being kids and enjoying themselves but neither did they miss out on taking full advantage of the education they were being offered.

In my opinion, which i know won't be popular but everyone is entitled to have an opinion, unless you can provide 'proof' that a child is actually out of school 'sick' even for a single day, fines should be imposed and I don't mean the paltry fines that schools are imposing for taking kids out of school to go on holidays during term-time, they need to be much, much higher to dissuade people from thinking that school isn't as important as their day/week/fortnight on the beach.

You are aware of covid right? Aware that it was required to be off school with a symptom of covid? In 2020 ie was required to be off if you had been in contact with someone who turned out to be positive. They were off for 10 days at a time. And often not ill.

You would have thought that people would be more wary of sending an ill child to school in case it's passed on. But no, here we have someone who thinks you have to prove the child is ill or risk being fined.

And these days getting an appointment at the doctors is rarer than findings hens teeth.

It's fantastic your children were rarely ill. It's not an achievement though. It's luck. Not everyone is that lucky. My kids are generally that lucky and until covid were rarely off ill. But it was luck. Just like it was unlucky that my child sat next to someone who vomited everywhere and passed on norovirus. That was an "interesting" week

RampantIvy · 19/06/2022 08:47

Juced · 19/06/2022 08:46

do it school is bullshit! They don’t think twice about having teach training days! leaving parents with the inconvenience of having to rearrange work etc!

Teacher training days are usually on the school calendar, so parents get plenty of advance warning. It sounds like your DC's school doesn't do this, so complain to them.

Juced · 19/06/2022 08:46

do it school is bullshit! They don’t think twice about having teach training days! leaving parents with the inconvenience of having to rearrange work etc!

ForestFae · 19/06/2022 08:15

jewishmum · 19/06/2022 02:09

Don't do it. One slip up and you'll be paying a fine. Kids these days advertise everything online. Police officer could stop you and ask why child isn't at school.

Given how grossly underfunded they are and how they often don’t investigate actual crimes, I don’t think that’s a very real risk…

frydae · 19/06/2022 08:07

jewishmum · 19/06/2022 02:09

Don't do it. One slip up and you'll be paying a fine. Kids these days advertise everything online. Police officer could stop you and ask why child isn't at school.

Police 🤦🏻‍♀️🤣

Sizzer40 · 19/06/2022 07:33

I think it’s lovely. It’s the kind of think my mum would have done with me when I was young. I had very average results at school because there was very little pressure from her. But I was always happy and stress free. My career and prospects did not suffer and I have a fantastic relationship with her.
How people choose to raise their kids is their own business, they know their own children more than other parents do. Some people value education over fun and that’s fine, some people don’t really prioritise eduction at all. You do what you think is best and leave them to it.

RooLou85 · 19/06/2022 07:28

Why do you care OP? Because your child thinks friends mum is cool? Because it is something you want to do and feel bitter that they are able? Or because you genuinely think it is terrible to miss a single day of school?

I work full time but took full advantage of our flexi policy to have Friday afternoon off, my daughter had three substitute teachers during Thursday/Friday. Not on the habit of taking her out of school for trips but not against it, our next holiday starts two days before school officially ends, and if we’d happened to be in a situation where me and dh had the same day off and the weather looked good we might have been tempted to have a family day out.

overall if it doesn’t affect you why waste the energy getting upset about it?

garlictwist · 19/06/2022 05:43

Full disclosure I skived off work on Friday because of the weather. And I don't care. It is never hot and sunny where I live and I'd be damned if I was wasting it sitting in an office.

I don't know the next time I will see a temperature like that so I don't regret it.

Harmonypuss · 19/06/2022 04:49

Kids already get 13 weeks off school every year, they only do about 5hrs of lessons a day, so there's barely enough time in the days they are expected to be in school to give them a proper education as it is, without people taking them out for a day here and a day there, even one day can disrupt the whole class in some cases.

I'm proud to say that when I was putting my two kids through school, they both went through 7yrs of infants and juniors and 5yrs of secondary school with only 3 days worth of absence between them. Yes, that's 3 days lost across what amounts to 24yrs of education.

I can go further, because my youngest also went to college for 3yrs and university for another 3yrs and had to have 2 days off due to a family funeral and hospital appointments, so that takes our total to 5 days of education lost across 30yrs.

We still had fun days out, they never missed out on being kids and enjoying themselves but neither did they miss out on taking full advantage of the education they were being offered.

In my opinion, which i know won't be popular but everyone is entitled to have an opinion, unless you can provide 'proof' that a child is actually out of school 'sick' even for a single day, fines should be imposed and I don't mean the paltry fines that schools are imposing for taking kids out of school to go on holidays during term-time, they need to be much, much higher to dissuade people from thinking that school isn't as important as their day/week/fortnight on the beach.

Runciblefork · 19/06/2022 04:32

If they go to Sandbanks, please ask them not to park in my parents drive! I am all for missing school for treats but what is it about a bit of sun that turns people into complete idiots 🤨

Pauladaniale · 19/06/2022 02:49

Life is too short to be critical of ourselves, others, and children. Our kids can be gone any second. If this Mother wants to keep her kids home and enjoy a day at the Beach, who is anyone to judge her or anyone else for for it. Nor should anyone judge you for not taking the day off for fun for your kids. Your kids. Responsibility is important. So is mental health. I would say at this time more than any, all of our kids' mental health is highly important and our responsibility as parents.

jewishmum · 19/06/2022 02:09

Don't do it. One slip up and you'll be paying a fine. Kids these days advertise everything online. Police officer could stop you and ask why child isn't at school.

Dominuse · 19/06/2022 01:32

SweetSakura · 17/06/2022 08:08

Yabu.
Apparently it's fine for my son's school to take a hand picked bunch of children out for a bonus weeks residential, but I would get a fine if I took him out. (Hand picked I don't doubt because they have had difficult lives, but my god so has he)

I hugely value education, but there has to be less hypocrisy in the system.

Bit different a school trip though. Mine have always go load out of a class beach day such as coach ride (yes) games with peers etc learning about the coastline

plenty of opportunity during the other 13 weeks of holiday to go to the beach

Ineke · 19/06/2022 01:29

Lessons are not random, they are planned and timetabled in. Your child could be missing an important part of their curriculum. Unless you are planning on asking for the topics missed so you can go through them at home I would not do this. School finishes mid afternoon when the sun is not so powerful but it’s still hot enough to go down to the beach then, and maybe have a picnic/ barbecue for tea.

marktayloruk · 18/06/2022 23:36

Banning termtime holidays was what put me off Michael.Gove.

Snoopsnoggysnog · 18/06/2022 23:05

Or if they’re a teacher themselves, bunk off too…

Snoopsnoggysnog · 18/06/2022 23:05

Booklover3 · 18/06/2022 22:17

I agree with this

This is bollocks, anyone who works can book annual leave then let their kid bunk off and go to the seaside Confused

HeArInGhandsgirl11 · 18/06/2022 23:04

Really late to the party only read your first few comments OP- from that I think this is more about you being annoyed you can't as you have to work-

I may be wrong

MrsPetty · 18/06/2022 22:58

@Kerensa70 No. I don’t expect my DDs to lie when they go back to school. Thankfully they go to very small schools on the island that we live on and the principals are both good friends. I always give them the heads up. Last time one of them recommended the hotel we stayed in…

fUNNYfACE36 · 18/06/2022 22:50

I think you are sending your dc the wrong message. They shojkd value their education, and how it affects their life chances

Booklover3 · 18/06/2022 22:17

Lesserspottedmama · 18/06/2022 21:52

I think it’s wonderful. I think this most is more about OP (and others) feeling triggered and upset that they can’t do this with their own children because of work. Which I empathise with! But the sanctimonious ones saying their education is paramount etc - I don’t agree, I think experiences like this can be so powerful, create amazing memories, strengthen family relationships and give a much needed boost to wellbeing and happiness levels.

I agree with this

Dorsetdelight211 · 18/06/2022 22:05

Lesserspottedmama

I think it’s wonderful. I think this most is more about OP (and others) feeling triggered and upset that they can’t do this with their own children because of work the assumptions on here are infuriating! If I wanted to book annual leave to take my child out of school for a day at the beach I could, I'm not a teacher, im not tied to term time hours. I dont want to. It has absolutely nothing to do with being 'triggered' (what does that even mean?!).

OP posts:
Lesserspottedmama · 18/06/2022 22:00

Just read through all of OP’s comments - Good grief. Barrel of laughs she is. So much anger and bitterness. We all know people who are able to smell the roses a bit more then ourselves, because their circumstances are different - it’s such a waste of energy to stew and seethe over it. You speak a lot about role modelling to children OP, I hope your children are not aware of how het up you’ve got over this - because that is not preparing them well for ‘the real world’ as you put it, where there will always be people who think differently to us, and have different values and priorities. Lighten up!

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 18/06/2022 21:53

Buttercupsx · 18/06/2022 20:06

When a child is absent from school it does have an indirect impact on other students/teachers. I have already explained this in a previous post. I know it might seem illogical to suggest that but in many cases it’s true.

As for the personal jab, I’ll leave that to one side. Not sure why you felt the need to make it.

Eurghhh just ride your horse with your lack of compassion Mrs busy body. The DC was ill for crying out loud!

Your embarrassing 😳 the utter audacity to speak about personal jab..
Behave!