Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thoughts on taking your DC out of school to enjoy the sunshine?

495 replies

Dorsetdelight211 · 17/06/2022 07:55

DD is 14, year 9. She's just had a message off her best friend to say she won't be in school today as her mum is taking her and her younger sister to the beach for the day. Que DD saying how cool the mum is and how unfair it is that I never let her miss school for fun stuff. I've got to work and even if I didn't I still wouldn't let her do it.

YABU-its a beautiful day, one day off school won't make a difference
YANBU-school is important and you can't skive off just because the weathers nice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jack80 · 24/06/2022 21:03

It’s up to the individual parent, I’m all for parents taking their kids out of school if it’s the only time they have off to spend with their child. You don’t know peoples circumstances.

Dorsetdelight211 · 23/06/2022 17:58

theshadyplantlady no you're missing the point entirely. I dont live to work, far from it! I work to give my DC a great childhood and start in life. I'm saving for uni and house deposits, a trip to florida this year and Australia when they turn 18. I have goals. I value my job, I want to be reliable, I want a good reputation, I have patients who need me, I love what I do and the contribution I make to society. I want the same for my DC. A healthy work life balance can be achieved without lying.

OP posts:
Parker231 · 23/06/2022 17:04

theshadyplantlady · 23/06/2022 15:42

A lot of these parents live to work and it shows. They're also ensuring to instill these same "values" into the next generation. There is absolutely nothing wrong with calling in "well". If it's a beautiful day out, taking a single day off work and/or school to enjoy your life is not the end of the world. Call in and say you don't feel well, and say the same for your kid(s) and play hooky. If your child's education in severely or irreparably damaged, or your work/department falls into shambles from one day off, there are much bigger issues at play. All this to say YABU. If you have no hobbies or will to enjoy your life outside the few waking hours a day that you aren't at work, that's a YOU problem. DD's friend's mom probably has (and is teaching her daughter) a healthy work-life balance. More people need this.

A fun day is always good - at weekends and during school holidays. Teaching a child to lie for a day off school (and the same at work) is always wrong.

theshadyplantlady · 23/06/2022 15:42

A lot of these parents live to work and it shows. They're also ensuring to instill these same "values" into the next generation. There is absolutely nothing wrong with calling in "well". If it's a beautiful day out, taking a single day off work and/or school to enjoy your life is not the end of the world. Call in and say you don't feel well, and say the same for your kid(s) and play hooky. If your child's education in severely or irreparably damaged, or your work/department falls into shambles from one day off, there are much bigger issues at play. All this to say YABU. If you have no hobbies or will to enjoy your life outside the few waking hours a day that you aren't at work, that's a YOU problem. DD's friend's mom probably has (and is teaching her daughter) a healthy work-life balance. More people need this.

1HappyTraveller · 20/06/2022 05:51

YANBU

School is important. Your DD needs to understand that she can’t skip school for the day in the same way that you can’t skip work to go to the beach. There are plenty of days in the year when the weather is warm and the beach can be enjoyed including plenty of weekends and school holidays.

Reading some of the responses on here I’m not surprised that some kids grow up to be irresponsible adults - if they think they can just sack off school when they feel like it what sort of lesson does that set?! 🤷‍♀️

Gemcat1 · 19/06/2022 23:43

It's not about the weather, it's about what you are teaching your child. If you say it's OK to take a day off school because it's nice then why not take the week off? Then what happens at exam time? This attitude will continue, why go to work at all when it's nice? Actions have consequences.

KleoPatraJonz · 19/06/2022 23:09

She let her child have a fun day. These days with your kids will be over then what will you have? Why is everyone treating it like the end of the world? If you don't want your kids to skip then don't but could you all stop acting as if it's the end of the world?

Raybo5890 · 19/06/2022 22:09

I think it is up to the parents. I myself let my child stay home sometimes just for a day off. I don't think it teaches anything wrong. Adults do take off from time to time just because. However, his dad is not like that. He would not do let him stay home unless he is sick. So again it's up to the parent/guardian.

Kidron2001 · 19/06/2022 20:21

First that is a wonderful thing to do. I'm a mother of four but I have 3 now. Something's in life can change one's perspective. I took my kids out of school for a day. My children two eldest and my youngest. Why did I do it because I CAN my choice. I love my kids. I wanted them to have a great surprise absolute Joy on their faces. They're great children, they're kind to others, they're considerate to others. They do wonderful in school and they're my children my choice. They don't front fall behind on their education. That's nobody's business.

NicRin · 19/06/2022 17:40

You only live once. Building memories with your kids is way more important than a day at school. I cannot believe people are saying this is a bad idea. My kids don't even go to school. We can do whatever we want whenever we want. I know not everyone can do that, so I think it's great that you share these fun times with them now. It all goes bye too fast!!

Spaceshiphaslanded · 19/06/2022 16:05

I think this depends on the kid really. If my 14 YO was studying hard and needed a break - I’d have gone. It’s not really anyone else’s business.

LovelyIssues · 19/06/2022 15:32

I work in a school so can't take days off, but if I could I would 100% have spent the day off with my 1 DC in the sun

Crumpleton · 19/06/2022 15:15

YANBU....No I wouldn't, and never did let my daughter have a day off to enjoy the sun she can enjoy it in school. I know it's a rare sight in good old UK but they'll be other times. Maybe just me but I'd be more concerned that I'd be telling a lie, does this not teach kids it's ok to do so?

ChoiceMummy · 19/06/2022 15:11

Burgoo · 19/06/2022 15:00

Its fine to allow kids off school - as long as you are willing to pay money back into the school system for the hours. Taxpayers footing the bill for your child to miss education? No, nonsense. It shows a complete lack of respect for education and total contempt for taxpayers who have to foot the bill for your child.

Funnily enough, the majority of those parents are the ones who are also footing the bill. The same as they're fitting the bill for the nhs, social services and every other social institution!

And tbh if we're going down this road, then I'd like some refunds on what I have to fund due to the failings of the school system where they're not meeting the needs of my child. Perhaps you'll be the first to refund me?

Burgoo · 19/06/2022 15:00

Its fine to allow kids off school - as long as you are willing to pay money back into the school system for the hours. Taxpayers footing the bill for your child to miss education? No, nonsense. It shows a complete lack of respect for education and total contempt for taxpayers who have to foot the bill for your child.

ImAvingOops · 19/06/2022 14:56

It pissed with rain all day yesterday here, so the parents waiting for the weekend would have missed it!
My dd's school are going to waste a whole day soon on sports day, they'll waste another one on doing a whole school walk. Quite often the SMT member who is scheduled to take a class, doesn't turn up due to clashing commitments and that lesson time is lost. They waste valuable school days on ski trips etc. Im not inclined to listen to lectures from school on how important daily attendance is. I think experiences with family are just as important and if a family has the occasional opportunity to do something that is a bit different to the norm, it should be valued.

Buttonjugs · 19/06/2022 13:21

It was sunny and that’s nice but I would have thought keeping children out of the sun when it’s that hot would be more sensible. People in this country go nuts when the sun comes out. I wonder how many will be suffering with sunburn as a result.

rainbowmilk · 19/06/2022 13:16

Yes education is extremely important but these public schools are not teaching kids anything valuable for them to actually use in the world,

Hmm
Baconbgr · 19/06/2022 13:09

Dorsetdelight211 · 17/06/2022 07:55

DD is 14, year 9. She's just had a message off her best friend to say she won't be in school today as her mum is taking her and her younger sister to the beach for the day. Que DD saying how cool the mum is and how unfair it is that I never let her miss school for fun stuff. I've got to work and even if I didn't I still wouldn't let her do it.

YABU-its a beautiful day, one day off school won't make a difference
YANBU-school is important and you can't skive off just because the weathers nice.

And people don't call out a day of work for "being sick" or coming in late because of a "flat tire". People really love to mom shame don't they. I guess these are the same people that work 60+ hours and barely see their kids. Or SAHM that can't wait to be away from their kids. Yes education is extremely important but these public schools are not teaching kids anything valuable for them to actually use in the world, it's also letting you kid know it's ok to just take a day for yourself. It's not like it's once a month or once a week.

Summerwhereareyou · 19/06/2022 11:05

Good post, choice mummy.

It's always the children from poorer homes who suffer.

I will never forget our dreadful head saying " we all face the same holiday costs" whilst simulatenos moaning about teaches pay.

We worked out DH was on a far lower wage than the teaches and especially lower than her. Face the same costs,on vastly different salaries.

One year we could afford one night aways.

Summerwhereareyou · 19/06/2022 11:02

Harmony why on earth would you want to impose your ideas into others though!
We are supposedly in a free democracy?

If my DC are leaning and achieving why on earth should they miss a day of fun here and there?

Your idea of fun soujds like it would be vastly different to ours.

LondonMrsA · 19/06/2022 10:23

N.B. I am not a Mother.
My heart goes out to working Mums.
If, for some reason, there is an unforeseen day off - childcare arrangements have to be made.

AYBU? NO

At 14, one would hope DD is sensible and can be trusted to be home alone.

I’d let her have a day home in the garden in the sunshine. Life is short and one day off school makes little or no difference to an education.

Schools rarely have Air Con. and it’s miserable sitting indoors when it’s too hot or too cold.

ChoiceMummy · 19/06/2022 10:17

Harmonypuss · 19/06/2022 04:49

Kids already get 13 weeks off school every year, they only do about 5hrs of lessons a day, so there's barely enough time in the days they are expected to be in school to give them a proper education as it is, without people taking them out for a day here and a day there, even one day can disrupt the whole class in some cases.

I'm proud to say that when I was putting my two kids through school, they both went through 7yrs of infants and juniors and 5yrs of secondary school with only 3 days worth of absence between them. Yes, that's 3 days lost across what amounts to 24yrs of education.

I can go further, because my youngest also went to college for 3yrs and university for another 3yrs and had to have 2 days off due to a family funeral and hospital appointments, so that takes our total to 5 days of education lost across 30yrs.

We still had fun days out, they never missed out on being kids and enjoying themselves but neither did they miss out on taking full advantage of the education they were being offered.

In my opinion, which i know won't be popular but everyone is entitled to have an opinion, unless you can provide 'proof' that a child is actually out of school 'sick' even for a single day, fines should be imposed and I don't mean the paltry fines that schools are imposing for taking kids out of school to go on holidays during term-time, they need to be much, much higher to dissuade people from thinking that school isn't as important as their day/week/fortnight on the beach.

That's wonderful for your little cherubs. Winning their 100% attendance certificates, regardless of whether they were ill or not they must attend.
Likewise, no doubt wonderful that you were in a privileged position of eving able to afford holidays abroad out of term time etc.
But many cannot.

Likewise your absence fine rhetoric is insane. Unless there are serious absence issues, that's unworkable. GPS will not and don't have the capacity to see children for every illness and concern, let alone write sicknotes, which is what would then be needed. Or even more sick children at school spreading the germs. Look at covid!

Given your children are post university and you sound really out of touch and I suspect, tbh, that your little cherubs would never have told you if they missed a lecture, tutorial etc, for fear of your self imposed regime.

I'd far rather see the poorer families have a day off for the beach, when it's sunny, than have no experiences that you can take for granted and that's the reality for many children. What you see as a given, are not for hundreds of thousands of children.

Will that one day make any difference to their academic achievements? Like hell it will.
Very different to children with poor attendance due to choosing not to attend, for genuine health reasons and you seem to have assumed that all absences are in effect ungenuine.

ChoiceMummy · 19/06/2022 10:05

Dorsetdelight211 · 17/06/2022 08:10

SweetSakura but equally what about the kids whose parents work therefore can't take their kids out for a beach day, that's not fair either is it?

But in all honesty, they're their circumstances and not all are equal.
I am very lucky, live in very close proximity, walking distance, so for us, even if a beautiful day can combine both school and beach. But being reliant on school holidays/weekends/low Tide timings can mean for some they'd never get a day at the beach in Nice weather.
I come from being a teacher and genuinely believe that education is important, but so are experiences. And for some, a beach day, would be a life experience, understanding tides etc, which if I'm honest, the majority of city visitors down here don't, and at that time of year when exams/sats are over there is less significant learning happening, despite the fact that schools don't want to say this... But look at the time given to sports events practice, end of year shows, suddenly the arts feature, residentials, trips etc.

Foxgloves123 · 19/06/2022 09:56

I take mine on holiday every year for around one week so five days of school and will do it regardless of being fined as the cost of being fined is less than the extortionate costs of taking your family away during the school holidays. I also can’t stand it being too overcrowded as that’s not a holiday for me either and I think it’s totally unfair if your child has overall good attendance: I understand them fining poor attendance though if people just take the piss. I wouldn’t take my child out for a beach day though. Unless I didn’t have enough money to go abroad and r on a proper holiday then I absolutely would if I could and would call off sick. Why not! They’re only little once and as long as they’re not falling behind academically then family bonding is equally as important. Life is so frikking regimental and everyone is so focussed in this country on hard work and the ‘system’. It’s the kids who never go to school that this should be aimed at really.