Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

His ex

83 replies

PepsiKitty · 17/06/2022 00:58

This is so ridiculous but I’m posting to prove I’m not crazy…

been with OH for 2 years. I am 36, him 32. Engaged and living together for the last 4m.

bear with me because I don’t want to drip feed

OH has only ever had 2 relationships

first relationship 2009 age 18 - they were together for a year total. When he met her she was in a relationship with someone else (we will call him John). She “couldn’t decide” between OH and John for a while but eventually stayed with OH. She later had a threesome behind his back, they broke up, he forgave her a month later, then she eventually left him. All this in just one year. He was devastated, suicidal he said. He loved her and she said she loved him.

For the next 6 years he admits he was embarrassingly hung up on her - think Facebook statuses about missing her, dreaming of her on one occasion in 2015 (!) saying she’s his perfect girl, he will wait til the end of time for her, misses her etc. During this period he is desperate and trying to find a new girlfriend but with no success.

age 25 he meets his next girlfriend, not keen on her but his mum threw him out of the house so he moves in with her. She has a 3 month old baby and the dad isn’t around. OH stands by her and the baby for 3 years. This girlfriend is physically and emotionally abusive to him. She also regularly cheats. They then end the relationship in 2018, but she doesn’t move out until 2019.

he then meets me end of 2020.

he tells me he messaged first girl (we will call her amy) right before he met the second girlfriend, but she didn’t want to talk to him. Bear in mind it had been 6 years!

For a few months every time I ask him something he brings up amy. For example “do you like cheese?” “Amy liked cheese”. He says he’s trying to share his life experiences. I compliment him and he says “amy said that” and says it’s because it was an odd compliment. I ask if he loves her still (no) if he thinks of her (never) if he wants her (no) and what he’d do if she came back (nothing). I asked this because I felt he was hung up on her.

Things go well, it’s a good relationship although OH is emotionally very immature and Doesn’t seem to know how to be in an adult relationship (not his fault given he’s never really had one). I was married for 10 years so we are very different.

fast forward to a few weeks ago…

amy adds OH to Snapchat. He adds her back and they talk. She basically says she misses him and asks if he ever thinks of her (he says not as often as he used to but things remind him of her), she asks if he would meet her and he says no because he’s engaged but that he would if he was single. He says her adding him is a mindfuck. He says he waited for her and she was all he thought about. She says feelings don’t go away and he puts a sad face.

now bear with me because here it gets ridiculous.

i then get added by her to Snapchat and she sends me the screenshots. I then see that he’s messaging her at the same time as me, but her first. Telling me he loves me while telling her he thinks of her.

i confront him. He says he never believed it was her and was trying to catch her out. She then texts him, and he shows me the screenshots and here he is blatantly trying to catch her out by asking questions only she’d know the answers to. I point out that what he said on Snapchat wasn’t catching her out.

turns out it wasn’t even Amy in the first place, it was his abusive ex pretending to be her. So now OH is saying he knew all along it wasn’t her etc but I feel like because amy doesn’t want him, he’s turning to me.

we argue as he doesn’t understand my point of view. He says he’d talk to her if he was single and hear her out, maybe give her a chance because she’s familiar and it’s easier than meeting someone new. But then says he wouldn’t give his other ex a chance (odd given that she’s more resent but hey ho)

he can’t possibly even know Amy after 12 years… she was 17 when she dated him and she’s 29 now…

its all ridiculous and childish to me. The man is just shy of 32 years old. Clearly hung up on his high school ex , all she did was lie and cheat and hurt him, they only lasted a year.

to be honest I feel like he’s with me because she didn’t want him, and he said all he said because she came back too late. He’s trapped now as I have kids he’s stepdad to and we are TTC.

OH is quite immature emotionally and admits this. But I find the whole situation ridiculous and I want no part of it.

he is adamant he doesn’t love or want her and added her out of curiosity… but to be honest I think he will say whatever he has to say to keep me.

AIBU to think he did wrong and needs to let go of her or is he unreasonable?

OP posts:
Arthursmom · 17/06/2022 08:55

You're about to marry this guy. Save yourself the heartache and walk away now

KettrickenSmiled · 17/06/2022 08:41

RedHelenB · 17/06/2022 07:37

If it were a woman which been abused like this there would be a lot more sympathy. Forget words, Di his actions show he loves and cares about you? If yes I'd forget all about Amy, ignore it of he mentions her name. If no then yes, you need to split up before ttc.

Mainly because women don't tend to lie about DA - they tend to cover up for their abuser.

Whereas a man whose every ex is a "crazy bitch" is usually the crazy-maker himself. He needs no sympathy.

This man has "tend to my emotions at the expense of your own wellbeing" written all over him. But OP is calling him her kids' stepdad, & TTC, so IT MUST BE TROO LOVE. Or she is teasing us, I think ...

BaaCake · 17/06/2022 08:38

I also don't know many adults that use snap chat

KettrickenSmiled · 17/06/2022 08:36

He’s trapped now as I have kids he’s stepdad to and we are TTC.
Oh. I'd missed the fact that you are a parent.

You're coming across as just as immature as he is with this comment.
He's not your kids' stepdad.
He's a madman you've been shagging for a couple of years.
He will abandon you, & the kids you are passing off as his stepkids, just like he abandoned Ex 2's child, as soon as there's a sniff of his Next Relationship. Maybe that will be with a woman who looks a bit like Amy, or who likes cheese, just like Amy.

You know he is fixated on Amy, & you MUST know he's full of shit about Ex 2?
He only moved in with her because his mum threw him out - despite him cheerfully admitting to you that he was not keen on her. Does that not strike you as the actions of a cruel & selfish user? 3 years later, SHE has to move out of the home HE chose to land in like a cuckoo. Despite her having a child? WTF?
That's not him "standing by" a woman with a baby.
That's him doing what's best for him, & making a woman he's "not keen on" responsible for housing him. But he tells you SHE was the abusive one, so that's ok then. And this doesn't strike you as hogwash?

But you keep TTC with a man who "doesn't know how to have a relationship", because you have "trapped" him. Congratulations.
It's not going to fuck your kids up AT ALL, is it?

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 17/06/2022 08:29

BadNomad · 17/06/2022 02:30

Hmm I wonder how abusive his second ex really was. I'll bet she had to deal with the ghost of Amy in their relationship too. Was this her way of warning you that you'll never be enough?

This. You will never be enough op. He thinks of his ex all the time, he proves that in his responses. Why he does, we don't know. I think it is probably what someone else said, she was his first girlfriend and he has never gotten over that.

Don't have kids with him for certain. Maybe split up for a while to let him figure out what he wants. But it's clear it's her and not you. If she came on the scene for real and said jump, he'd instantly reply how high.

XelaM · 17/06/2022 08:18

I think you need to rethink your marriage and TTC plans, as he is still hung up on his high school sweetheart. It's difficult to compete with a fantasy.

RedHelenB · 17/06/2022 07:37

Aquamarine1029 · 17/06/2022 01:08

Why the fuck are you with this emotionally stunted man child? You are light years apart, and I can't imagine anything more foolish than having a baby with him. You should be running for the hills.

If it were a woman which been abused like this there would be a lot more sympathy. Forget words, Di his actions show he loves and cares about you? If yes I'd forget all about Amy, ignore it of he mentions her name. If no then yes, you need to split up before ttc.

villamariavintrapp · 17/06/2022 07:35

I think 'Amy' is a red herring here. Maybe he wants to be with her, maybe he'll never get over her, maybe not. Either way, you can do better. Why did you continue the relationship when he kept on bringing her into your conversations? At best that's disrespectful, boring, and weird. And why would you choose to be with someone disrespectful, boring and weird? Never mind choose him as the father to a baby!

ElenaSt · 17/06/2022 07:23

He will always be hung up on her. Over the years he has probably embellished her memory making her to be the most perfect woman who he longs for when in reality she's probably nothing like that.

Personally, I would walk away as he sounds a complete drip.

LadyCampanulaTottington · 17/06/2022 07:20

I wouldn’t want to be anyones second choice OP.

Why don’t you think you deserve to be someone’s world? I can’t imagine how utterly exhausted you must be with all this unnecessary shite. Walk away and leave him with his ghost of girlfriend past.

Riverlee · 17/06/2022 07:20

At 18, you’re first real relationship can be overwhelming and I get how this can be significant to him.

However, the red flags jumped out to me with the ‘Amy likes cheese’ comment. It means he’s still thinking of her constantly. It would be a bit different if it was something unique, ie, you were watching Mamma Mia in London and he commented he’d first seen it ten years ago with Amy. However, weird to mention more mundane things.

You know that if Amy walks through the door, you’d be dumped, even if he had no hope with her.

ladydimitrescu · 17/06/2022 07:16

Why on earth are you trying to conceive with this idiot? Ffs, run a mile!

Shoxfordian · 17/06/2022 07:13

I don’t know why you even entertained this idiot in the first place op

Break up with him; too much drama

SarahProblem · 17/06/2022 07:08

How do you have the energy to deal with this juvenile bullshit? So many red flags.

End it. Don't have this this man's child as he's a manchild.

HoppingPavlova · 17/06/2022 07:03

You are trying to have a baby with this man😳.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 07:03

Oh good God, drop the whole thing. It's like a 90s teen drama with social media.

Bella37 · 17/06/2022 06:54

*pretty

Bella37 · 17/06/2022 06:54

PepsiKitty · 17/06/2022 00:58

This is so ridiculous but I’m posting to prove I’m not crazy…

been with OH for 2 years. I am 36, him 32. Engaged and living together for the last 4m.

bear with me because I don’t want to drip feed

OH has only ever had 2 relationships

first relationship 2009 age 18 - they were together for a year total. When he met her she was in a relationship with someone else (we will call him John). She “couldn’t decide” between OH and John for a while but eventually stayed with OH. She later had a threesome behind his back, they broke up, he forgave her a month later, then she eventually left him. All this in just one year. He was devastated, suicidal he said. He loved her and she said she loved him.

For the next 6 years he admits he was embarrassingly hung up on her - think Facebook statuses about missing her, dreaming of her on one occasion in 2015 (!) saying she’s his perfect girl, he will wait til the end of time for her, misses her etc. During this period he is desperate and trying to find a new girlfriend but with no success.

age 25 he meets his next girlfriend, not keen on her but his mum threw him out of the house so he moves in with her. She has a 3 month old baby and the dad isn’t around. OH stands by her and the baby for 3 years. This girlfriend is physically and emotionally abusive to him. She also regularly cheats. They then end the relationship in 2018, but she doesn’t move out until 2019.

he then meets me end of 2020.

he tells me he messaged first girl (we will call her amy) right before he met the second girlfriend, but she didn’t want to talk to him. Bear in mind it had been 6 years!

For a few months every time I ask him something he brings up amy. For example “do you like cheese?” “Amy liked cheese”. He says he’s trying to share his life experiences. I compliment him and he says “amy said that” and says it’s because it was an odd compliment. I ask if he loves her still (no) if he thinks of her (never) if he wants her (no) and what he’d do if she came back (nothing). I asked this because I felt he was hung up on her.

Things go well, it’s a good relationship although OH is emotionally very immature and Doesn’t seem to know how to be in an adult relationship (not his fault given he’s never really had one). I was married for 10 years so we are very different.

fast forward to a few weeks ago…

amy adds OH to Snapchat. He adds her back and they talk. She basically says she misses him and asks if he ever thinks of her (he says not as often as he used to but things remind him of her), she asks if he would meet her and he says no because he’s engaged but that he would if he was single. He says her adding him is a mindfuck. He says he waited for her and she was all he thought about. She says feelings don’t go away and he puts a sad face.

now bear with me because here it gets ridiculous.

i then get added by her to Snapchat and she sends me the screenshots. I then see that he’s messaging her at the same time as me, but her first. Telling me he loves me while telling her he thinks of her.

i confront him. He says he never believed it was her and was trying to catch her out. She then texts him, and he shows me the screenshots and here he is blatantly trying to catch her out by asking questions only she’d know the answers to. I point out that what he said on Snapchat wasn’t catching her out.

turns out it wasn’t even Amy in the first place, it was his abusive ex pretending to be her. So now OH is saying he knew all along it wasn’t her etc but I feel like because amy doesn’t want him, he’s turning to me.

we argue as he doesn’t understand my point of view. He says he’d talk to her if he was single and hear her out, maybe give her a chance because she’s familiar and it’s easier than meeting someone new. But then says he wouldn’t give his other ex a chance (odd given that she’s more resent but hey ho)

he can’t possibly even know Amy after 12 years… she was 17 when she dated him and she’s 29 now…

its all ridiculous and childish to me. The man is just shy of 32 years old. Clearly hung up on his high school ex , all she did was lie and cheat and hurt him, they only lasted a year.

to be honest I feel like he’s with me because she didn’t want him, and he said all he said because she came back too late. He’s trapped now as I have kids he’s stepdad to and we are TTC.

OH is quite immature emotionally and admits this. But I find the whole situation ridiculous and I want no part of it.

he is adamant he doesn’t love or want her and added her out of curiosity… but to be honest I think he will say whatever he has to say to keep me.

AIBU to think he did wrong and needs to let go of her or is he unreasonable?

I have been through orettt similar, however it went in much longer than 2 years, in the end it made me think I had gone mad and I lost all my self worth and became a shell. I know how hard it is but I really would get out the relationship now, it will be easier now than further down the line and I’m pretty confident it won’t last. He sounds so pathetic and immature x

ahunf · 17/06/2022 06:52

Stop using the excuse he's never had a relationship. He's lived with two women for a year and 3 years.

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 17/06/2022 06:31

YABU for TTC with this emotionally stunted male. What on earth are you thinking!?

Philisophigal · 17/06/2022 06:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

PAFMO · 17/06/2022 06:15

Does he talk about anything else, ever, apart from his exes and how hard done to he is?
This is how he'll represent you.
Run as fast as you can and don't look back.

BaaCake · 17/06/2022 06:08

He’s trapped now as I have kids he’s stepdad to and we are TTC.

He's not "trapped". He can walk away from your kids. They will be fine.

Also I wouldn't be too quick to belive his side of the story re the last relationship. It seems odd he would move in with someone he isn't even that keen on and then they move out. Unless she's running away from him maybe.

Anyway he's hung up on this Amy, end it. He needs counselling or something.

ventreàterre · 17/06/2022 05:13

Would you be satisfied with a man who is still unhealthily obsessed with his long-ago ex? I would always feel second-best and on shaky ground. I wouldn't have a child with him, and I'd worry about letting your children come to rely on a man who is so emotionally immature. He doesn't seem likely to be at all reliable.

DatingIsDifficult · 17/06/2022 04:42

YABU to be entertaining any of this nonsense.

Swipe left for the next trending thread