Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your cringeworthy interview experiences where you were the interviewer?

215 replies

AlternativePerspective · 16/06/2022 21:55

A friend was just telling me about the interviews they were holding recently. One candidate was apparently awful. Kept interrupting, threw a pile of certificates down on the desk when asked about his qualification, referred to people with disabilities (it was in a disability focussed organisation) as “mentals” and he wanted to help them because he was sure they aren’t stupid.

Then when he had the rejection he has sent numerous emails insisting he should have been employed.

The story is so horrifying that I wonder whether he was deliberately that objectionable. From their end I do know it really happened, but could it be he was being like that deliberately? Or …?

So, as an interviewer, have you ever conducted any awful, cringeworthy interviews?

OP posts:
FavouriteMug · 17/06/2022 07:45

WizardOfAus · 17/06/2022 07:42

We had a guy shit himself.
He was so nervous when he arrived, shaking as he poured himself a glass of water.
As he was answering the first question, we all heard an audible wet fart.
He apologised and tried to carry on.
Then his face just turned bright red.
This was followed by a god awful stench.
The man quickly stood up and excused himself and hobbled from the room.
He didn't return.

Poor man, that's awful

WizardOfAus · 17/06/2022 07:42

We had a guy shit himself.
He was so nervous when he arrived, shaking as he poured himself a glass of water.
As he was answering the first question, we all heard an audible wet fart.
He apologised and tried to carry on.
Then his face just turned bright red.
This was followed by a god awful stench.
The man quickly stood up and excused himself and hobbled from the room.
He didn't return.

SarahProblem · 17/06/2022 07:33

I interviewed a candidate for an admin role. She was so nervous and practically vibrating off her chair. To make matters worse she proceeded to have some acid reflux type issue so at the end of every sentence let out a burp.

Primatrying · 17/06/2022 07:23

I went to an interview once where I'm sure the interview panel look back and cringe. I walked in, and they told me that they would start with an easy ice-breaker question, and said "how's your home life?".

I was a teenager whose parents had announced their divorce the previous week. I burst into tears. The interviewers looked soooo mortified. Asked if I wanted a time out but I said no, I'd be fine.

Amazingly I got the job. In feedback they told me that they were impressed that I'd managed to recollect myself.

AnuSTart · 17/06/2022 07:09

In probably my most important ever interview, I was asked why I wanted to leave my job and I went blank and could only think of the honest answer. I asked the interviewer if he wanted my honest answer and he said honesty is the best policy. I told him that working in an industry which has a sole purpose of shifting very wealthy people's vast wealth around so they can avoid tax and social responsibility was killing my very soul and that I couldn't stand to even look at them anymore.
He smiled and suddenly someone else appeared next to him on the screen who had overheard, laughed and said that his feeling about investments and banking was roughly the same.
I got the job. Yay! I've since interviewed many people for the company and love it when I get brutal answers.

ThinWomansBrain · 17/06/2022 07:00

@Hawkins001 Deferred income - where you receive income in one accounting period, but don't recognise it until the next (eg a multi year grant). It is fairly technical, but common in charity accounting - we were recriting for a senior finance manager.

ItWillBeOkHonestly · 17/06/2022 06:55

I once interviewed a young guy on zoom and when he came on the screen he was outside in what appeared to be a really sunny location. He apologised and said he was working abroad for the summer. About 5 minutes into the interview, a man came up behind him and started shouting. It seems this guy was working in a beach bar and had just skived off to do the interview...the man shouting at him was his boss wanting to know why he wasn't inside serving customers.

I've also had several people cry in interviews and one time in response to 'tell us a bit about yourself' a guy told me he'd taken a career break to be a carer for his elderly father but his father was a 'nasty selfish man' and he was very glad when he 'eventually died'.

ijustcouldntthinkofausername · 17/06/2022 06:54

At a previous job, I was once sat in on an in interview my area manager was doing (for my shop). It turns out the girl was a singer on the weekend, round the pubs etc.
My manager asked her to sing! 🫣
She went all red and just laughed, but we realised my manager was being deadly serious "oh go on just a little bit" 🤭☺️
She laughed again and just cheekily said "ah maybe once I've got the job I'll do a sing song for ya" 😁

This was 15 years ago. She got the job. And we eventually became great friends both in different jobs now but still life long friends 😊

DoItAfraid · 17/06/2022 04:23

LiIo · 16/06/2022 23:00

Not me but my colleagues.

They were interviewing a guy. The guy went to pour himself a glass of water from a bottle in the middle of the table. He was shaking so badly and was not looking at what he was doing so he completely missed his glass. I am not talking about just a drop but about half a bottle worth. The table was absolutely full of water.

The odd thing is, despite everyone seeing what had happened no one acknowledged it. Everyone just acted like nothing had happened and continued with the interview, even though there was a huge puddle of water streaming off the side of the table. When they told me what happened I asked them why they didn’t say anything or get a towel to mop it up and said they were not sure themselves - it was just less awkward to do nothing than acknowledge it.

Some really odd group think going on there 🫤

@lilo this is WHY I never ever touch those water bottles in interviews 🤣.

Wincarnis · 17/06/2022 04:15

Greeted candidate on arrival. We shook hands… he then said “sorry, my hands are wet, I’ve just been for a piss”

”

EarringsandLipstick · 17/06/2022 03:43

BarnacleNora · 16/06/2022 23:29

Not me but my dad who is a design engineer. During the course of the interview he asked the candidate some fairly basic (to them anyway, I'd have been absolutely stumped) maths questions, using formulae that were pretty much used every day as part of being an engineer. Candidate was recently graduated so this should have been incredibly easy for them, no time to get lazy and rely on a certain programme etc.

Candidate was totally stumped, couldn't do any of it and actually, despite what I earlier said, even I could do one of them (area of a circle, thank you very much gcse maths!) What made it worse was my dad had a coffee mug with all the formulae on it along with pictures of drawing tools and a big 'design engineer essentials' slogan, which he subtly and then not so subtly kept turning around the face the candidate, tapping with his pen, knocking on the table etc but the guy had no clue.

My dad reported in his usual dry tones that he could understand freezing with nerves but he did try and help him out until it all just became a bit farcical really and as attention to detail was quite a key part of the job it was pretty clear this wasn't going to be a good fit

That's really poor interview practice by your dad.

First of all asking any form of calculations verbally is pointless - in the actual role they'd be at the very least working them out on paper.

Secondly if they didn't know, it would be stressful & distracting to be pointing to a mug & tapping.

And if his summation of why the candidate didn't get the job is ridiculous - his version of trying to help out is completely distracting

Hawkins001 · 17/06/2022 02:04

ThinWomansBrain · 17/06/2022 00:03

Children's charity - whatever questions we asked, candidate just kept waffling about how much he liked children, to the point that after the interview my colleague and I both thought he must be a paedophile.

My line manager had a killer question about deferred income - amazing how many candidates it floored, but a good test of their technical knowledge and ability to explain a concept.
We always had a non accountant join the panel - after the interview, non-accountant enthused about how clearly she'd explained it. We fell about laughing, she'd explained a totally differnt thing.

Just into the start of an interview - maybe two questions of eight, candidate starts laughing loudly, then banging her hands on the table and shouting "no, no, no.... no more questions, enough of the questions" and laughing hysterically.

I googled deferred income, what was your line managers q about it please ?

Hawkins001 · 17/06/2022 02:03

MsShopper · 17/06/2022 00:02

Oh that reminds me of a woman I interviewed a few years ago. Public sector role, fairly standard set of competency-based questions, but she somehow got to talking, in detail, about her fascination with serial killers and how they murdered their victims. “I’m just… you know… really into death.” 😬

Considering the popularity of shows like csi, Dexter, ect why was that a bad perspectives ?

Hawkins001 · 17/06/2022 01:54

*bad ?

Hawkins001 · 17/06/2022 01:54

bitofawait · 16/06/2022 23:07

Asked about her interests and she said zombie vampires. Now I could have maybe accepted this, she was dressed on the gothic side, but not inappropriately, but she went into an epilogue about them biting people and blood sucking.

Why was that has ? Based on you asking the question ?

SammyScrounge · 17/06/2022 01:12

I was on the panel interviewing for a new depute head in our primary school. The candidates were high quality until a young man came in. He was unkempt, ill mannered, and mumbled his replies to us. He did manage to make clear to us that he was male and knew that primary schools were in need of male role models. He started fidgeting in his chair and then swung one leg over the arm rest and sort of arranged himself in a foetal position along the chair back and closed his eyes.
He was asked what role he thought parents should have in helping the school run and he drawled that they could make the teas at sporting events. Silence. Then he uncurled himself, stood up. and without a word quietly left the room. We waited till we heard the swing doors shut and howled with laughter. How did he get on the interview list?

DeanStockwelll · 17/06/2022 00:26

I have been interviewing today , 1st person comes in and plonks himself down at the desk that was set up for me to sit at , lap top, note book , files etc so I asked him to move to one of the other 5 tables that were set up to face me he said he just needed to use my laptop for a minute to check his emails !

Next two people attending said they did not want to fill in our info pack ( names , address, reference info, last two places worked etc ) as it was a breach of data protection.
And one that said he couldn't fill in the info pack because he would only write in blue ink . (We don't mind what colour they use but I happened to only have black pens with me. ) so he just walked out .

I have a load more to do tomorrow 😕

MrsMoastyToasty · 17/06/2022 00:09

A colleague and I were interviewing candidates and one kept giving one word answers or very short answers. The only thing wax her voice would have been her job - it was a call centre role.

pixie5121 · 17/06/2022 00:08

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 16/06/2022 22:15

Not me but a former boss.

Graduate trainee interview for a big blue chip. My boss had just returned to the Uk after 10 years in China. One CV said they were fluent in Mandarin so boss interviewing greeted them in Mandarin and asked how the journey had been.

The interviewee looked totally blank. Boss tried again, slowly. Still blank.

It was basically a total lie.

They went through the whole interview but it was excruciating because they'd blown it in the first 10 seconds.

Maybe it was your boss who spoke shit Mandarin?

I looked blankly at someone who asked me something in Spanish in an interview once. It came out of nowhere, I wasn't expecting it and their accent was so bad that I didn't even realise it was Spanish they were attempting to speak. I thought I'd just misheard. I wondered afterwards whether they told their colleagues they'd caught me out. I couldn't think of a way of saying I hadn't understood without insulting them.

PeopleRStrange · 17/06/2022 00:04

Lurleene · 16/06/2022 22:47

Not an interview but someone applied to where my husband worked and obviously sent in a draft of their application rather than the finished version. Most of the answer sections only contained the words 'Bullshit here'.

Love this 😂

ThinWomansBrain · 17/06/2022 00:03

Children's charity - whatever questions we asked, candidate just kept waffling about how much he liked children, to the point that after the interview my colleague and I both thought he must be a paedophile.

My line manager had a killer question about deferred income - amazing how many candidates it floored, but a good test of their technical knowledge and ability to explain a concept.
We always had a non accountant join the panel - after the interview, non-accountant enthused about how clearly she'd explained it. We fell about laughing, she'd explained a totally differnt thing.

Just into the start of an interview - maybe two questions of eight, candidate starts laughing loudly, then banging her hands on the table and shouting "no, no, no.... no more questions, enough of the questions" and laughing hysterically.

MsShopper · 17/06/2022 00:02

bitofawait · 16/06/2022 23:07

Asked about her interests and she said zombie vampires. Now I could have maybe accepted this, she was dressed on the gothic side, but not inappropriately, but she went into an epilogue about them biting people and blood sucking.

Oh that reminds me of a woman I interviewed a few years ago. Public sector role, fairly standard set of competency-based questions, but she somehow got to talking, in detail, about her fascination with serial killers and how they murdered their victims. “I’m just… you know… really into death.” 😬

InPraiseOfBacchus · 16/06/2022 23:53

justasmalltownmum · 16/06/2022 22:57

So tell me something interesting about yourself:

I'm not interesting at all. Actually I'm really boring.

Ok then..

To be fair on the candidate, that is a really useless and hacky interview question. I'd take that as a red flag about the employer's poor hiring practices if I was asked that.

StartupRepair · 16/06/2022 23:49

We interviewed someone for a facilitator position. Asked him for second interview to present on something small for 10 minutes only so we could see his style. He embarked on a deck with 90 slides.

Limesaregreen · 16/06/2022 23:42

My boss interviewed someone who burst into song during the interview. This was for an admin job in the Council btw, nothing theatrical or dramatic about it but she enjoyed singing as a hobby and she wanted everyone to hear.