Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your cringeworthy interview experiences where you were the interviewer?

215 replies

AlternativePerspective · 16/06/2022 21:55

A friend was just telling me about the interviews they were holding recently. One candidate was apparently awful. Kept interrupting, threw a pile of certificates down on the desk when asked about his qualification, referred to people with disabilities (it was in a disability focussed organisation) as “mentals” and he wanted to help them because he was sure they aren’t stupid.

Then when he had the rejection he has sent numerous emails insisting he should have been employed.

The story is so horrifying that I wonder whether he was deliberately that objectionable. From their end I do know it really happened, but could it be he was being like that deliberately? Or …?

So, as an interviewer, have you ever conducted any awful, cringeworthy interviews?

OP posts:
Craver · 17/06/2022 09:43

A friend was interviewing for candidates to study to become radiologists-Question "Why to you want to be a radiologist?"
" I like working in the dark & I'm not great dealing with people"

EweCee · 17/06/2022 09:32

I had one candidate, interviewing for a senior environmental role, tell me that all this environmental stuff is a bit of a waste of time, no-one actually believes the advice and if he wants to get on multiple planes a year increasing his carbon footprint, what of it?

Had another one i invited in for a 2nd and final interview with my boss as he'd been brilliant in his first interview. He was embarrassingly bad in his 2nd - couldn't remember who we were (think he'd been interviewing with other companies and literally couldn't remember who we were or details from 1st interview) kept on talking up aspects of his experience that we'd explained in 1st interview weren't relevant for our company (think international legislation when we only work nationally) and when asked about specific environmental legislation (very relevant for role) responded 'oh that sustainability stuff is vague waffle waffle' 😮

ItWillBeOkHonestly · 17/06/2022 09:30

I also once interviewed a chap who when asked if he was comfortable and ready to begin, explained he had a bowel problem and this sometimes caused flatulence and a need to rush urgently to the loo. He then went on to tell us about his recent colonoscopy and how he'd had several large polyps removed. Literally no one knew what to say after that.

Itwasntmeright · 17/06/2022 09:07

I was once on the panel conducting an interview for a new nursery teacher. We had a candidate who spent pretty much the whole interview going on about her broken washing machine.

Catfeatured · 17/06/2022 09:03

I work in the civil service. Candidates are asked to give examples of when they have demonstrated a particular skill at work like making a difficult decision. One candidate from another government dept started talking about choosing a paint colour for her living room. It was excruciating.

PowerhouseOfTheCell · 17/06/2022 09:01

I used to sit on a desk near the interview room my old company used so could hear them all taking place. There are two that stick with me:
Interview for a senior engineer, older gent comes in and declares he has a powerpoint, interviews are a bit Confusedbut let him present, it was just 20 slides of him throughout the years on holiday with his wife and he went into full detail about each holiday. Interview was over 2 hours long in the end; never knew why anyone didn't make him stop.
Another one, mid level technician, guy about 30 comes in declares he's still on bail for ABH against his last manager but if the interviewers can look past that he'll be a great employee. Didn't get the job

user1471538283 · 17/06/2022 08:58

I had one who laid his head and hands on the table. Sighed alot. Kept on about previous jobs. Didnt know what we did. I really didnt want him but my boss made me. He did very poor work for 3 weeks, went off sick for 7 months and wished me dead.

Eileen101 · 17/06/2022 08:56

I was asked to assist with a colleague from another team, who was doing paralegal interviews.
He interviewed a recent LPC graduate and asked a (fairly basic) scenario based question that we come across time and again. She didn't have a clue, and it was quite clear she didn't. Rather than move on, he kept pushing and pushing this one point ("yes but what would you do"). She was absolutely mortified and had no idea what to say or where to put herself because he kept pushing for an answer.

Embarrassed22 · 17/06/2022 08:55

I wasn't the interviewer or interviewee. I was due to be interviewed after her.

The lady sat in the holding area under a 'no food or drink to be consumed here' sign... Took an apple out of her purse and started chomping away. When asked to stop and shown the sign she said 'well I've started now, I'll be done in a minute'. She was escorted out without interview.

Aussiegirl123456 · 17/06/2022 08:52

I said “love you, bye” when my future employer walked me out of the building. The shame. I got the job, the other candidates must have been dire!

Another role, straight from uni, I turned up for an interview and was handed a lot of paperwork so came to the conclusion it was a trial or something, so I just got on with it. The lady interviewing me kept saying “you’ll absolutely love Simon when he’s back”. Simon my was the boss of the company.

So I just got on. Zero training on the system so had to sort of learn as I went, and gradually throughout the day, people came in and introduced themselves to me and offer me any assistance etc. Such lovely people.

The lady interviewing me asked me if I’d prefer lunch at 12 or 1. I opened my mouth to ask why I’d be having lunch at an interview but 12 came out instead. Came back from lunch where I was shown a few things and I asked a few questions, I assumed the morning was to see what the job entailed and the afternoon was like a mutual interview.

At the end of the day, she just said “can you get in for 9 tomorrow? Oh and you’ll just love Simon”….

I stayed 8 years and never had my interview. Yes, Simon was lovely by the way.

It was just bazaar, the interviewing process was usually very long winded. I was too nervous to speak up so just went with the flow. At the first Christmas party, I told everyone I hadn’t even had an interview yet and apparently I was a communication blip and an oversight! Simon was on holiday and the lady interviewing me assumed I’d already been hired. Simon assumed she’d hired me.

Changechangychange · 17/06/2022 08:51

Interviews for senior medical role in a hospital. We asked about challenges facing the specialty she had apparently working in for over ten years, expecting something about ageing population, increasing demand, changes to NHS funding, or even covid.

What we got was a ten minute monologue about her ambition to travel the world saving lives and doing charitable works, taking in orphans and distributing alms. It had nothing to do with medicine. We asked again wondering if she’d misheard the question, and she told us she thought she was an exceptional person. Okay Confused

Limesaregreen · 17/06/2022 08:38

O might out myself here but I was once interviewed for a job and was asked how I would cope with some other staff knowing more than I do. I thought it was a very odd question but I answered it by saying ‘well they won’t know everything. I’m bound to know stuff they don’t. For example I know all the names of The Wombles’

I got the job :)

Rosehugger · 17/06/2022 08:37

DeanStockwelll · 17/06/2022 00:26

I have been interviewing today , 1st person comes in and plonks himself down at the desk that was set up for me to sit at , lap top, note book , files etc so I asked him to move to one of the other 5 tables that were set up to face me he said he just needed to use my laptop for a minute to check his emails !

Next two people attending said they did not want to fill in our info pack ( names , address, reference info, last two places worked etc ) as it was a breach of data protection.
And one that said he couldn't fill in the info pack because he would only write in blue ink . (We don't mind what colour they use but I happened to only have black pens with me. ) so he just walked out .

I have a load more to do tomorrow 😕

Re that though, why don't you have their details before they come? Surely they have already filled in an application form or you have a CV? That would already annoy me as a candidate, to have to provide information I'd already provided.

EpicMugs · 17/06/2022 08:35

Two stand out

The first which was a graduate interview but still.. when asked 'what attracted you to this role?' answered that she didn't know what the role was, and had just applied for "anything and everything." To give her more than a fair chance I briefly described the role then started to ask her what she thought might be the best or most challenging parts of the role. "I don't know. I've never done that job before".
"Does it sound like something you might like to do?"
"Maybe, but I am not sure".
"Shall we end the interview here then?"

Next one was a good interview but when asked about a large gap on CV, the candidate he'd been in prison for manslaughter. He'd turned his life around and I really liked him and wanted to give him a shot but he just wasn't the best candidate and I had to stick within a scoring system. Shame. I often hope he did ok.

DreamingofItaly2023 · 17/06/2022 08:31

I was pregnant. The interviewee came in and I stood up and extended my hand to shake theirs. Rather than take my hand they reached out and rubbed my belly!

Hoppinggreen · 17/06/2022 08:30

I was helping to do mock interviews for undergraduates at a local Business School.
I was using the “ tell me about a time” question (star method) and the example one candidate gave was stealing a car.
To be fair based on the marking system we were using he gave an excellent answer.

Rosehugger · 17/06/2022 08:29

Primatrying · 17/06/2022 07:23

I went to an interview once where I'm sure the interview panel look back and cringe. I walked in, and they told me that they would start with an easy ice-breaker question, and said "how's your home life?".

I was a teenager whose parents had announced their divorce the previous week. I burst into tears. The interviewers looked soooo mortified. Asked if I wanted a time out but I said no, I'd be fine.

Amazingly I got the job. In feedback they told me that they were impressed that I'd managed to recollect myself.

"How's your home life?" is intrusive and not an ice breaker.

I've had interviews where the interviewer was more nervous than me, and I had to help them out quite a lot.

starfishmummy · 17/06/2022 08:27

DoItAfraid · 17/06/2022 04:23

@lilo this is WHY I never ever touch those water bottles in interviews 🤣.

Reminds me of being a candidate at an interview on a hot day. I had water with me that I had been drinking while I waited to be seen. I was called in and there was water and cups and one of the panel kept asking me if I was sure I didn't want water because I looked thirsty!! In the end I poured myself a drink just to shut him up, and he said "I knew you wanted one"!!!

iloveeverykindofcat · 17/06/2022 08:25

I've been on a panel for one. The candidate smiled, shook hands and made eye contact with everyone except the only Black person in the room.
The Black person was the Principal Investigator.
I really, really wanted to put ' you need to hide your racism better' in the feedback.

Rosehugger · 17/06/2022 08:24

Sorry, that was meant to be a quote/reply to @Assistanttotheregionalmanager

Rosehugger · 17/06/2022 08:18

Do you not? I hope you don't work in a school.

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 17/06/2022 08:16

many years ago I was a branch manager of a small bank. We were recruiting counter staff and I well remember one candidate who when asked why they had applied for the job said "my mum thought it would be a good idea'. The advert had specified that the job required working 2 Saturday mornings a month but the same candidate made it very clear that they could not work Saturdays in the football season as they were a season ticket holder for our local club.

Her mum was waiting outside for her when she left and I'm sure was very disappointed that her daughter was not offered a position. I'm equally sure that her daughter was delighted!

Bootothegoose · 17/06/2022 08:15

I told an interviewer I loved him once and no one I have ever told the story to has let me forget it.

I shook his hand, interview went very well. He said, and I quote, 'Thanks for your time Bootothegoose, I'll be in touch to let you know the outcome.'
My response, 'Thanks so much, have a nice day, love you.'

There was a pause. I turned and left. Got the job, however, so don't know if I would recommend such an approach.

FelicityFlops · 17/06/2022 07:48

Many years ago I was interviewing with my boss for a role in our team - mixture of IT and support in the banking world. Our candidate arrived, not terribly smartly dressed (these were the days of suits for all) and promptly announced that he would not be turning his mobile off because he was expecting an important call.
Most of the interview was "ok" (although the whole team had reviewed his CV beforehand and we all agreed that it was unlikely he was a good fit) until we asked about his previous job (self-employed software developer) when he told us he was sacked as he didn't get on with the people!
Amazingly he got the job (it was a box-ticking get a permie employee into the team exercise) and then proceeded to take the proverbial for the next year or so after which he resigned. He was right about not getting on with people, though. Weirdest person.
Did a lot of interviews for roles on our team last year with my boss and his boss, too. One candidate proudly announced that he had brought the whole trading system at an international bank to a standstill by making a mistake - but immediately recognised his error, communicated it and remedied. He got the job and is a really lovely colleague.

BlueSkyWarmSea · 17/06/2022 07:48

Interviewing for an IT role we ask a series of technical competency questions, as would be the case in just about any interview for a similar role . We start with a couple of easier ones (if you know anything about the subject) to put them at ease. For example, if the role were for networking the question might be about using "ping" to test connectivity between two devices. The answer every time was along the lines of " oh, you've got an issue with network connectivity, have you. Well, I can fix that as soon as I start..." We'd try to explain again that it wasn't a problem we actually had, just a scenario to understand his troubleshooting skills and technical knowledge areas.

We were also told at least ten times he was a member of MENSA, so was very clever and could fix all our issues. This was a preliminary phone interview, but he was insistent that as he lived nearby he could come in for the afternoon and fix everything. The real concerns came when he wanted to know where my colleague and I lived, and a rough description wasn't enough and he seemed to want a street address!

I felt very sorry for the man. He appeared to have zero social skills, and no understanding of how interviews worked, despite our best efforts to help him. My colleague tried to drop big hints to the agent that some interview coaching would be a good idea, and I really hope he followed it up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread