Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your cringeworthy interview experiences where you were the interviewer?

215 replies

AlternativePerspective · 16/06/2022 21:55

A friend was just telling me about the interviews they were holding recently. One candidate was apparently awful. Kept interrupting, threw a pile of certificates down on the desk when asked about his qualification, referred to people with disabilities (it was in a disability focussed organisation) as “mentals” and he wanted to help them because he was sure they aren’t stupid.

Then when he had the rejection he has sent numerous emails insisting he should have been employed.

The story is so horrifying that I wonder whether he was deliberately that objectionable. From their end I do know it really happened, but could it be he was being like that deliberately? Or …?

So, as an interviewer, have you ever conducted any awful, cringeworthy interviews?

OP posts:
TreacheryPepper · 17/06/2022 11:24

Questions like this always make me think of Spud from Trainspotting.

DeanStockwelll · 17/06/2022 11:18

Rosehugger · 17/06/2022 08:37

Re that though, why don't you have their details before they come? Surely they have already filled in an application form or you have a CV? That would already annoy me as a candidate, to have to provide information I'd already provided.

We have some if the info , I found people rarely put reference contact details on cvs anymore and also don't often put addresses on we don't use an application forms ( I wish we did ! )
The packs are also used to update information later on if we give them the job bank details, DBS information, on going training , when training needs renewing etc.
We obviously keep a lot of this information electronically but particularly with the training certificates it has to be kept on site to prove quickly and easily to the client that we are all up to date.

( its a two part pack so clients only get to see certs, not bank/ address info )

WhackingPhoenix · 17/06/2022 11:16

I’ve had some truly awful interviews! One springs to mind where the interviewer sneered at my choice of top and told me I would be “too fluffy to join this organisation” (it was a smart, coral-coloured blouse with a subtle pattern) and looked completely disinterested throughout the interview, I walked out in the end and got an earful from the recruiter.

I am utterly shocked I was offered my current job as I was so unwell during my online interview, I had flu and could barely concentrate, kept losing my voice and my dog started barking downstairs. When the interviewer rang the next day, I think I actually said “are you joking?!” 😂

Sashytomps · 17/06/2022 11:05

ItWillBeOkHonestly · 17/06/2022 09:30

I also once interviewed a chap who when asked if he was comfortable and ready to begin, explained he had a bowel problem and this sometimes caused flatulence and a need to rush urgently to the loo. He then went on to tell us about his recent colonoscopy and how he'd had several large polyps removed. Literally no one knew what to say after that.

What you, or one of your colleagues, should have said @ItWillBeOkHonestly was ‘Thank you for letting us know. Should you need a break, please don’t hesitate to ask’. Then moved on with the interview. Still, at least you all showed yourselves up as poor disability employers.

Some people on here really showing themselves up as shitty interviewers and most likely shitty employers/colleagues.

JustFrustrated · 17/06/2022 11:02

Can I share one about being the bad interviewee?

When asked the question "what's one of your weaknesses"

I lead with a joke (chocolate) and finished with "when I make a mistake I commit to it, even when I know it's wrong, I'll see it through and then resolve it after"

Obviously they asked "what if you could change it whilst you were doing it"

My reply "I'd still stick to it"

I got the job. Apparently my honesty was refreshing.

My mom who happened to be sat in the other room (was a first stage teams interview, and she'd gotten to mine early) was gobsmacked, understandably.

HarryStottel · 17/06/2022 11:01

I've had a few as an interviewer and an interviewee.

One job I went for, I knew the three women panel had all been out the night before, but they didn't know I knew that ( I was an internal candidate )

They were totally disinterested, and had already decided who to employ , and couldn't get me out of there fast enough.

I complained to the HR department, but apparently there wasn't a process for candidates to raise concerns about interview panels. It turns out they should have had an independent none departmental member on the panel, not just three mates who worked together, but there wasn't anything HR was prepared to do about it.

This was at a major university as well.

Pluvia · 17/06/2022 11:00

Hawkins001 · 17/06/2022 02:03

Considering the popularity of shows like csi, Dexter, ect why was that a bad perspectives ?

Because it's an interview and you're supposed to answer questions professionally in a way that doesn't have the interviewers wondering whether you have psychopathic tendencies or whether you're likely to be a good fit with valued colleagues.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 17/06/2022 11:00

On an interview panel where clients were given a small scenario then had to talk us through their decision making. Rather than giving a full name it started with something like 'A is a 25 man who comes in saying .... and went on to give relevant details. One candidate had come in with a very superior air from the start, seemed surprised all the interviewers were women and sneered, 'well, I would want to know their actual name before I did anything else'. Was amazed to find out in his feedback that he had not come over well.

SpaceJamtart · 17/06/2022 10:44

I worked behind the bar at a small pub and had to interview for a weekend morning cleaner.
Usually this job goes to teens as its only an hour and a half twice a week so fits well around end of school/ college. So we dont mind about experience, just someone who is responsible and can follow instructions. It's a little pub that would be closed whilst they work and there is nothing compicated.

We had one come in and from the start she was openly rude about people who work in pubs, kept saying how it was a seedy job because we serve " gross drunk men" and that we probably only worked there because we couldnt get work at the strip club down the street.
And continued by making references to how this job was a last resort but was obviously beneath her and she would move on as soon as possible.
Seemed offended when I asked if she had worked as a cleaner before.

She didnt get the job, and sent two patronising emails about me not recognising potential and that she could have been running the place within a year

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 17/06/2022 10:43

Not as an interviewer but someone interviewing me...

two women and one was very rude (in person). Constantly sighing, looking upwards, playing with her hair (not that young either too). Other woman was fine.

I messaged the HR dept straight after it to complain and they said she'd be spoken to, was offered job but turned it down!

Pluvia · 17/06/2022 10:43

Coffeetree · 16/06/2022 22:30

Oh and I had an interviewee cry during an interview. She'd been made redundant after trying really hard to keep her department running. Nothing but sympathy of course but no way did I consider her candidacy any further.

Why wouldn't you consider her? You've acknowledged that she was a hard worker who'd shown dedication in a previous position. Why would you reject a good candidate on the basis that nerves and possibly desperation got the better of them for a moment?

MargaretThursday · 17/06/2022 10:41

Dh had one.
They applied with a masters qualification that didn't seem to exist according to the university. So they phoned the university department up and had a chat. He said basically they awarded that qualification if the person was doing a PhD but didn't complete/failed but had achieved enough to get a masters.
They were very happy with that explanation, they don't require either a masters or PhD so not at all bothered. But in the (telephone) interview they asked about it, and what he'd done towards it. He promptly grew very defensive, and refused to talk about it. So trying to help, one of the interviewers said that they were aware that he'd started as a PhD, because they'd talked to the university. He shouted at them down the phone that he had entirely meant to get a masters and the university was stitching him up.

When they turned him down, he put in a claim for racial discrimination, despite the fact that they had absolutely no idea what race he was (including looking at name etc)... nor had he any idea the race of the interviewers who weren't the "white middle class males who only employed people like them" he accused them of being.

Gufo · 17/06/2022 10:40

Me: Do you have any questions before we start?
Interviewee: Yes. You must have been really impressed with my application. What was it in particular that you liked?

I can't remember what I said, but I was thinking 'you arrogant shit', especially because the pool was small and pretty terrible - best of a bad bunch rather than impressive.

He didn't get the job but continued to email examples of (irrelevant) work he'd done for weeks.

mintybobs · 17/06/2022 10:39

Yep- one where it was me and a male member of management interviewing a guy. Every question we asked (even when I asked the question) he directed his answer at my male colleague as if it was impossible for him to acknowledge he was being interviewed/addressed by a woman.

Another one was the interview question "how would your friends describe you?" - eg hard working, friendly, sociable, team player etc. He answered, "about 5'10" with dark hair?" 😂

Neither got the job.

Justthisonceharold · 17/06/2022 10:36

I'd just got back from a summer holiday and was a bit sunburnt. At the end of the interview (it was a formal interview, not a chat), the interviewee leant forward across the desk and peeled a flake of dry skin from my nose...

VirginiaQ · 17/06/2022 10:30

I was on an interviewing panel. An older lady was asked a question relating to diversity and inclusion and she provided a very competent example of a talk she'd given at the local Chinese Centre where there'd been a bit of a language barrier. She finished her example and we were about to move on when for reasons I'll never understand she decided to add, 'Oh and they were all so lovely. They just sat there clapping and smiling when I'd finished'. She then decided to demonstrate this by pulling the sides of eyes to mimic an oriental eye shape; pulling an exaggerated smile; shaking her head from side to side then clapping like a seal. We were all in complete shock and no one knew what to say at first and just moved on but she did get very detailed feedback!

Not an interview but also bizarre situation. Paper sifting application forms which asked for examples of specific experience. One lady was clearly a mature student who had just got a degree later in life and was very proud of the fact (and rightly so). The job didn't really need a degree just relevant experience but I think she was so pleased with herself at getting a degree that we'd also be so impressed and give her the job out of hand. In each of the boxes where she was asked to provide an example she would write something like, ' Covered in module 3 of degree year two. Speak to Prof Smith for details'. it was the same for every question. I couldn't believe that she really thought that would provide evidence (we really needed practical knowledge) and that I would be ringing up her college to speak to various tutors about her course content.

Hairyfairy01 · 17/06/2022 10:11

The 2 that have stuck in my mind are a man interviewing for learning disability support worker post having spent the morning shadowing other support workers. When feeding back on his experiences of the morning he replied 'it's like the lights are on, but there's nobody home'. He didn't get the job.
Another one was for a position that basically involved covering a large geographical area, going to peoples houses, often with large pieces of equipment. It turned out at interview that he didn't drive. When asked if he felt this may be a problem, the reply was that he was good at problem solving.

StEthelburgaRose · 17/06/2022 10:08

EmilyBolton · 17/06/2022 09:59

🤔wrong post?

No

youcantparktheresir · 17/06/2022 10:04

AlternativePerspective · 16/06/2022 22:04

I had another one.

I was chair of governors at a school and we recruited a head teacher.

It was actually between exercises that one of the candidates made reference to some of the areas around where we were, and then said, “well, you wouldn’t want some of the likes of the parents whose kids go to my school moving in next door to you.”

It didn’t matter that she hadn’t said it in interview. She didn’t get the job.

I don't get what's so bad about this..

Beseen22 · 17/06/2022 10:01

My DH went to an interview with a pain in his side which was getting worse and worse. He took cocodamol and ibuprofen and was pretty out of it but did the best he could. He couldn't drive to the interview because he was in so much pain. When I picked him up from the interview he passed out from pain on the way to the car and I had to drive him to A&E because he was bright yellow with jaundice. He had an emergency procedure and was in for 3 weeks.

He doesn't have a clue what he said in the interview but he got the job.

EmilyBolton · 17/06/2022 09:59

StEthelburgaRose · 17/06/2022 09:50

Some parents behave anti socially in their neighbourhood and are aggressive to teachers. I wouldn't them as next door neighbours

🤔wrong post?

TheLadyDIdGood · 17/06/2022 09:52

Lacedwithgrace · 16/06/2022 23:30

I interviewed online for a while and had a young uni graduate (with incredible experience and grades) add her mum to the call. I thought it was a mistake at first and declined before her mum connected and the candidate said "Could you let my mum in? I told her she could join us." I said no and she actually pouted.

Another candidate had a problem with their camera and so had to leave it off. Only at the end of the call they clicked on the wrong button and turned the camera on rather than ending the call- showing them sat in their dressing gown still in bed. They wasted about 20 minutes pretending to attempt to fix the problem

Both were candidates for a role with a potential salary of £100k+. Neither got the job.

£100k salary & this is the calibre of candidates that apply?!! No wonder the world's going belly up!

IwaswhoIam · 17/06/2022 09:52

I interviewed a guy who had his phone alarm go off ten minutes into the interview . He turned it off and told me that it was his reminder for the interview 🤔 😆

Personally I wouldn’t have set an alarm for ten minutes into an interview 😂 but he didn’t come across as the brightest anyway !

StEthelburgaRose · 17/06/2022 09:50

Some parents behave anti socially in their neighbourhood and are aggressive to teachers. I wouldn't them as next door neighbours

EmilyBolton · 17/06/2022 09:44

Not a real interview fortunately….but…
our company used competency (Star) based interview techniques. Interviewers were given training which included role play. For many years they used to contact the local job centre to offer “interview practice” with us for that role play- generally it worked really well, the job centre folks got 5-6 mock interviews and feedback and Trainee interviewers got lots of practice on “real” people
however, when I was trained my second “practice” was with clearly quite elderly guy (this was also about 30 years ago). I asked one of our standard question “ can you tell me about a time you had to complete a task working with difficult people “ and he proceeded to tell me about his experience in a concentration camp as a young boy during the war. I was in my early 20s, I didn’t know what to say. He was literally talking about dealing with concentration camp SS guards and how he would get beaten and see people being shot if they didn’t do work fast enough. I don’t even remember what I said as I was so shocked. I remember asking the next question which I got something more work related from him, and thought phew ok, but next question was back to concentration camp …I really could not deal with what his saying and make sense of it. It was surreal in that he was talking quite calmly as if this was a perfectly normal example of STAR, but explain ly the most horrific situations.
Luckily the observer who was in the room, who was obviously feeling the same shock and horror, intervened after about 10 minutes and put a stop to it. I can’t remember how she did but it couldn’t have been easy for her either. None of the others interviewed him so I assume he was gently asked to leave or they called the job centre in desperation. It was a horrible experience - but it always stayed with me that this guys whole life had been dictated by his experiences nearly 50 years earlier as a young boy, and that even in his 60s he was struggling to come to terms with it and had effectively “normalised” it all .
The only positive was that I was never taken by surprise by anything anyone said at an interview.

Swipe left for the next trending thread