Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your cringeworthy interview experiences where you were the interviewer?

215 replies

AlternativePerspective · 16/06/2022 21:55

A friend was just telling me about the interviews they were holding recently. One candidate was apparently awful. Kept interrupting, threw a pile of certificates down on the desk when asked about his qualification, referred to people with disabilities (it was in a disability focussed organisation) as “mentals” and he wanted to help them because he was sure they aren’t stupid.

Then when he had the rejection he has sent numerous emails insisting he should have been employed.

The story is so horrifying that I wonder whether he was deliberately that objectionable. From their end I do know it really happened, but could it be he was being like that deliberately? Or …?

So, as an interviewer, have you ever conducted any awful, cringeworthy interviews?

OP posts:
MyView2 · 17/06/2022 12:55

I have a few.....there was the occasion when I was rather enthusiastically waving my hands around whilst asking my question and managed to knock a full glass of water all over the candidate. Full credit to him as despite being soaked through, he laughed it off, carried on and secured the job.

Another time the candidate arrived and I took his coat to hang it up on a wooden coat stand. It weighed a tonne, I don't know what he had in his pockets - bricks or something. Anyway halfway through the interview the coat stand buckled under the weight and the wood snapped in two and his coat fell to the ground in a heap. Unlike a normal person who would have acknowledged what had happened, the chap carried on talking like nothing had happened and unfortunately this put me and my fellow interviewer into a fit of giggles and the more the interviewee carried on regardless the funnier it got. Somehow we managed to get through to the end but I could see our shoulders bobbing up and down as we struggled not to laugh out loud - how very unprofessional!

I also had a candidate once who went on and on without answering the question properly and without taking a breath for us to intervene. In the end we had all put down our pens and sat so still that the movement operated lights plunged us into darkness! There were no windows in the room so nobody could see each but it did provide an excellent opportunity to interrupt and move things along.

I've had some other funny times too with powerpoint presentations with sounds effects added in which I'm sure seemed like an excellent idea at the time but not so clever when talking about your IT strategy with bullet points coming on the screen to screeching brake sounds.

Ah I love interviewing, you never know what you are going to get!

youlightupmyday · 17/06/2022 12:55

I once, in an interview for a role in compliance, referenced those who had gone rogue as 'baddies'. Still cringe 20 years later.

Got the job though 😅

Fimofriend · 17/06/2022 12:39

A woman in her fifties applied for a job in accounting. She did not have relevant experience nor a relevant education but she had 30 cats.

A former sergeant applied for the same job. He too had neither relevant experience nor a relevant education but he felt he was a good match as he was "good at making people do as they are told".

Floella22 · 17/06/2022 12:37

@PipeScatter

I'm not sure what Mum was proposing - coming along every day and sitting with them?!

I worked in a job where we did shifts and some technical staff did nights on their own.
We discovered that a recently qualified, fully trained, staff member was bringing her Mum to work on nights. Her dm was sitting in the staff room, she had no expertise whatsoever in her dd’s work.
She was a very self entitled woman who once refused to drive to a clinic in bad weather and expected me to stand in for her although I lived the same distance away.

Polyethyl · 17/06/2022 12:36

Interviewing a chartered Surveyor specialising in managing commercial properties. In the technical questions we asked him about the Landlord and Tenant 1954 Act. He'd never heard of it, which is like a doctor never having heard of Diabetes.

3 months later we were Interviewing again (expanding the team) and the same bloke walks in again. I think, ok, interesting choice to try again, perhaps he's revised this time. No. He still said he'd never heard of it.

I'm not joking, 3 months later he's back again. I had told HR I wouldn't waste my time on him but HR said it was compulsory that I interview him. HR said he could make a claim if we didn't interview him again. (I'm not an employment expert but I'm guessing that's nonsense. )

At the third interview, asking precisely the same technical question, he again didn't know.

He applied a 4th time and I persuaded HR to decline a 4th interview.

EmilyBolton · 17/06/2022 12:35

QuidditchThroughtheAges · 17/06/2022 11:29

@EmilyBolton I feel really sorry for him

Yes, sorry if that didn’t come across. It was tragic. It was just so shocking for him to just real out these horrible details.
what was really sad was that the folks that job centre sent to us were long term unemployed. Clearly this guy had probably had other interviews and come out with similar things and scared employees off. I don’t know what feedback our company gave to him and job centre, but he did really need to know that using such terrible experiences is very difficult for employers to handle in that scenario and help him identify more appropriate examples for the occasion.
it was horrible becuase clearly he need to talk and tell people…but it just wasn’t the right place or time to do that
the fact I still think about him 30 years later says something…it had a profound effect on me listening to him casually coming out with this horrible history.

ThreeImaginaryBoys · 17/06/2022 12:28

For several years I ran graduate recruitment in an advertising agency. To say we had some colourful applications is an understatement.

One young woman listed under 'interests':
'Spending Saturday afternoons in bed with my boyfriend ... not sleeping'.
(It was in the days before emojis but I'm sure there would have been a winky face).

Another hopeful brought us a powerpoint presentation about herself (which we hadn't asked for). About halfway through she clicked on a slide that simply said 'I love anal' in massive letters. She then did a whole OTT 'oh, whoops, can't think how that got there!' routine. I still cringe thinking about it.

Fun times :)

Hoppinggreen · 17/06/2022 12:18

Gufo · 17/06/2022 10:40

Me: Do you have any questions before we start?
Interviewee: Yes. You must have been really impressed with my application. What was it in particular that you liked?

I can't remember what I said, but I was thinking 'you arrogant shit', especially because the pool was small and pretty terrible - best of a bad bunch rather than impressive.

He didn't get the job but continued to email examples of (irrelevant) work he'd done for weeks.

I have done this when being interviewed, although I did phrase it better.
It was a Sales role though so we are supposed to be “assertive “
I did get offered the job and my new manager said that he loved the approach
Wouldnt work with all jobs and all interviewers though

Pudmyboy · 17/06/2022 12:17

Lurleene · 16/06/2022 22:47

Not an interview but someone applied to where my husband worked and obviously sent in a draft of their application rather than the finished version. Most of the answer sections only contained the words 'Bullshit here'.

Love this!

Jerabilis · 17/06/2022 12:17

When I worked for one of the big accountancy firms the graduate scheme interview process included two mock meetings with actors whilst we took notes in the corner. One of the male candidates had a female actor for their first ‘meeting’ and asked my male colleague who was taking notes if he could have a male actor for the second ‘meeting’ as he got in much better with men as “they were better at their jobs”.

He was immediately asked to leave.

IneedsomeSleeppleasenow · 17/06/2022 12:16

Someone who burped continuously through the interview (without acknowledging/excusing himself)

Another answered the phone multiple times

Pluvia · 17/06/2022 12:15

Lougle · 17/06/2022 11:34

We have loads of people cry during an interview....why is that a bar to employment? If they've had a tricky work experience, or life experience, then crying doesn't show weakness, just the rawness of it all.

Those were my feelings too. Being made redundant can be horrible and leave people panicked. If someone was otherwise what we needed but had a little cry when recounting their recent, unpleasant, work experience it wouldn't out me off.

BronwenFrideswide · 17/06/2022 12:09

InPraiseOfBacchus · 16/06/2022 23:53

To be fair on the candidate, that is a really useless and hacky interview question. I'd take that as a red flag about the employer's poor hiring practices if I was asked that.

I agree @InPraiseOfBacchus - one person's interesting is another person's extremely boring, it's a daft, meaningless question.

SpaceFarce · 17/06/2022 12:04

I had one repeatedly address me as the wrong name (along the lines of Kirsten/Kristy). I corrected them three times and then gave up. It was a contributing factor to us not hiring them.

exceptmeandmymonkey · 17/06/2022 12:01

Surprised by some of these answers. I've had multiple people cry on interviews (sometimes returning mums who lacked confidence). I still hired them if they suited the role and I thought I was the right manager for them.

One very bad interview stands out. Man in his 20s asked a standard set of competency based questions. We got to the second question and he objected and said he didn't want to be 'quizzed.' My co-panellist explained that we asked a standard set of questions to all candidates to gauge technical abilities. He said it was insulting, 'had never been treated this way,' and got up and walked.

RustyShackleford3 · 17/06/2022 11:51

@PipeScatter I see you've had similar encounters to me 😆

RustyShackleford3 · 17/06/2022 11:50

I used to work in recruitment. You'd be amazed how many younger adults' mummy's and daddy give you a call/drop you an email. (I'm talking roughly 18-28ish) It's terrifying. Sometimes they're just "touching base" so you know they are there if you have any concerns, sometimes they are very angry that their child did not get the job and are there to tell you that you must give it to them. Some of these were candidates who were rejected because they didn't even bother turning up for the interview...

I feel so sorry for these people because I'm sure as shit that a large portion of them do not want or need their parents meddling!

PipeScatter · 17/06/2022 11:49

Not me, but I was talking to a recruitment agent recently who told me of a candidate that he'd put forward to a company for a training position on the basis of their CV and emails back and forth.

Trainee candidate turns up at their interview with their mum! Mum insists on sitting in on the interview. It transpired that the candidate couldn't speak any English at all and Mum was supposedly "translating" questions and replies. The candidate looked thoroughly and utterly bored throughout, barely saying anything, so it was clear that Mum wanted them to take a career path they didn't, let alone the fact that they couldn't even speak the language they'd have had to have worked in.

I'm not sure what Mum was proposing - coming along every day and sitting with them?!

SummerLobelia · 17/06/2022 11:46

One of my jobs there was a panel of 3. One of them started being really aggressive asking me to explain why they should employ me over a native English person (I have dual citizenship, was born abroad and spent formative years abroad). I thought it was a joke at first, but the embarrassed silence of the other panel members told me it was not eventually. Anyway, I got the job, the aggressive one was my line manager and she proceeded to sabotage me at every turn and also have screaming hissy fits at me in my office about me being a migrant.

The kicker- it was a firm specialising in employment law . i lasted 4 years.

Alaimo · 17/06/2022 11:46

First time I was interviewing candidates for a position line managed by me. One of the candidates kept asking me & the other panellists questions during the interview. To the extent that it felt like he was interviewing us. I'm all for candidates being engaged, but this was a bit much. I have sometimes wondered if the company he was working for sent him to spy on us.

CounsellorTroi · 17/06/2022 11:40

A general point about interviews, where I last worked it was a smallish organisation of 250-300 people. I hated going for internal jobs as I knew I would know the panel. I would rather be interviewed by strangers who don’t have any preconceptions about me.

Lougle · 17/06/2022 11:38

SleepSleepRaveAsleep · 16/06/2022 22:50

@AlternativePerspective my husband is a teacher and has never wanted to live next door to kids he teaches, not because we are snobs and think we are better, more from a privacy point of view and not wanting the kids/their parents knowing our business. Funnily in the end my husband ended up getting a job at a school 3 minutes from our house, he teaches 4 of the neighbour's kids!

I don't understand why saying you don't want to live next door to the kids you teach means you are rejected for a job? Surely you score candidates at the interview, I can't see how it would be fair rejecting on such a thing.

It wasn't about the kids. The person said that they wouldn't like the 'likes of parents like that' - it shows a judgemental attitude to parents who are not in the luxurious position of having either money, life opportunities or both. I wouldn't have employed her either, no mattter how good the interview was. Values matter just as much as skill in education.

Lougle · 17/06/2022 11:34

Coffeetree · 16/06/2022 22:30

Oh and I had an interviewee cry during an interview. She'd been made redundant after trying really hard to keep her department running. Nothing but sympathy of course but no way did I consider her candidacy any further.

We have loads of people cry during an interview....why is that a bar to employment? If they've had a tricky work experience, or life experience, then crying doesn't show weakness, just the rawness of it all.

QuidditchThroughtheAges · 17/06/2022 11:29

@EmilyBolton I feel really sorry for him

FlimFlamJimJams · 17/06/2022 11:28

I interviewed a lady the other day who would not stop talking about her ex husband.
I try and keep my interviews light and casual as I find that it makes candidates more realistic, rather than putting on a show - but it's still professional.

This lady talked ENDLESSLY about how awful her ex was, and about numerous health concerns etc. And I couldn't get her to stop. It was awful.