Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your cringeworthy interview experiences where you were the interviewer?

215 replies

AlternativePerspective · 16/06/2022 21:55

A friend was just telling me about the interviews they were holding recently. One candidate was apparently awful. Kept interrupting, threw a pile of certificates down on the desk when asked about his qualification, referred to people with disabilities (it was in a disability focussed organisation) as “mentals” and he wanted to help them because he was sure they aren’t stupid.

Then when he had the rejection he has sent numerous emails insisting he should have been employed.

The story is so horrifying that I wonder whether he was deliberately that objectionable. From their end I do know it really happened, but could it be he was being like that deliberately? Or …?

So, as an interviewer, have you ever conducted any awful, cringeworthy interviews?

OP posts:
AnneElliott · 17/06/2022 14:28

Interviewing for a senior position in the civil service. Candidate was asked to speak about building and leading a team. He replied 'well my current office is called Roger's harem by everyone else as we all get on so well'. Name changed obviously but no he didn't get the job.

MinglingFlamingo · 17/06/2022 14:22

Chap who didn't show up. Hr rang him no answer thought he was driving and stuck in traffic or something. Eventually got through to his DM and turns out he was still in bed. Poor mum was mortified and totally despairing about him

runforyourdog · 17/06/2022 14:16

Not me but a guy interviewed for a place I used to work and pissed himself during the interview!!!

LadyDanburysHat · 17/06/2022 14:15

2bazookas · 17/06/2022 13:34

DH received a phone call from a university, saying his name had been given as a referee for Mr X who had applied for the following research post, details.
DH replies " I do know Mr X, he's an ex- colleague and he has not asked me to give a reference. He does not have the skills and experience you're looking for."

Caller says " But his CV sounds ideal; he says (reads it out).

DH replies " I have to tell you that Mr X was recently sacked by our employer for intellectual theft . And, the CV you're reading to me is not his. It's mine."

Oh wow!!

iloveeverykindofcat · 17/06/2022 14:10

@2bazookas

That reminds me of the time a student submitted me an essay that was 75% directly plagiarized from a journal article.

I wrote the article.

D0lphine · 17/06/2022 14:06

TreacheryPepper · 17/06/2022 11:24

Questions like this always make me think of Spud from Trainspotting.

Yes!!! Hilarious!

VirginiaQ · 17/06/2022 14:03

Jerabilis · 17/06/2022 12:17

When I worked for one of the big accountancy firms the graduate scheme interview process included two mock meetings with actors whilst we took notes in the corner. One of the male candidates had a female actor for their first ‘meeting’ and asked my male colleague who was taking notes if he could have a male actor for the second ‘meeting’ as he got in much better with men as “they were better at their jobs”.

He was immediately asked to leave.

Oh this reminds me of another one. Was doing mass recruitment for the sort of job children say they want to do when they grow up.

First question was about team working. He opening sentence was about about a team task he'd had at Uni saying,' Well I was the only male in the group so obviously I took the lead'!!!!

To be fair the fact he was a bit of a knob was pretty apparent before he even arrived. He was scheduled for 1pm but we'd had some cancellations so at 9:30am admin rang to see if he could come in a bit earlier. He was clearly still in bed, fine, but when asked he then said he wasn't sure where we were and not sure how to get there!! Admin lady was on the phone to him googling train and bus timetables for him but eventually he got an Uber costing over £40 as he lived on the other side of the city and thought using public transport was too difficult. Surely you sort out how and where an interview is before the actual day of the interview!!!

PipeScatter · 17/06/2022 13:57

God, I'm thinking of more and more as I go through the thread!

This one was a cringe employer, not interviewee though. My boss and I interviewed a potential trainee that we'd been informed beforehand had a severe hearing impairment and relied predominantly on lip reading.

In terms of the work, this wasn't an issue as so much is now done by email, etc, the requirement to talk on the phone wasn't significant and could be accommodated easily.

My boss, however, spent half of the interview, leaning on the table resting his chin in his hand while he talked, making lip reading really difficult. My DM lip reads quite a lot so I'm used to exaggerating slightly, so the poor guy kept looking at me for help.

I'd not been working there long myself, and I think it was one of the first interviews I did, so I wasn't comfortable with bringing it up in the interview. I did mention it afterwards though and my boss was mortified and sent an apology.

Cherryblossoms85 · 17/06/2022 13:57

Ah so many.
There was a guy who took his shoes off, and then said he couldn't stay because his foot hurt - seemed a bit like he was on drugs really.
There was a lady who I was interviewing quite early in the morning, and who had shown up very slightly late, so I just politely said "I hope it wasn't too hard to get here", just to give her the opening to make some excuse, and she said "just because I'm from New Zealand doesn't mean I flew in this morning you know. I live here". Ok then...
Then of course there was the time I was interviewing a guy from the French Carribbean, for a role that required French skills, on top of the professional expertise. He had the perfect skill set, spoke good English, was charming and perfect for the job, but the two men I was interviewing with kept mumbling that he wasn't a good "cultural fit" and wouldn't fit in their team. Then tried to claim his English wasn't good enough. All just racist BS.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 17/06/2022 13:47

Many years ago,I was interviewing for a graduate trainee, to work directly for me. One bloke kept eyeing me up and down, obviously not paying much attention to what I was asking him. When I asked him whether he had any questions for me, he said ‘ yeah, what are you doing tonight?’

Didn’t employ him ( didn’t fancy him at all….)

I quite often interviewed people who falsified their cvs. It was a small industry, and it would be common knowledge who was responsible for a particular piece of work. It wasn’t so much the lying as the insult of them thinking I wouldn’t know they were lying.

PipeScatter · 17/06/2022 13:44

RustyShackleford3 · 17/06/2022 11:51

@PipeScatter I see you've had similar encounters to me 😆

That example wasn't me, but I know exactly what you mean.

We've recently employed a school leaver who's Dad contacted us initially on his behalf. If it was down to me I'd have discounted him immediately because of this, but it's not my department. He's OK at the job, but I definitely think it was his Dad's choice of career rather than his own.

HoppingPavlova · 17/06/2022 13:42

Once interviewed a guy who justified why he was the right fit for the role on the fact he was a man, and then went on to detail what made men better than women in that role (and seemingly in general). He was being interviewed by myself and another woman, both senior in that area. It was not a role that required a penis in any way. Needless to say we wrapped it up at that point.

Ylvamoon · 17/06/2022 13:34

I had an interview once were I was asked about my hobbies (a long, long time ago!) ... I told them that I had an agility dog and that I like hiking.

The interviewer sad: " so you have a dog? That's bad." The interview was pretty much over!
Not sure what is bad about having a dog. I still remember this like yesterday and haven't ever mentioned my pets to anyone at work in the first 6 months. (Unless there are like-minded people. )

2bazookas · 17/06/2022 13:34

DH received a phone call from a university, saying his name had been given as a referee for Mr X who had applied for the following research post, details.
DH replies " I do know Mr X, he's an ex- colleague and he has not asked me to give a reference. He does not have the skills and experience you're looking for."

Caller says " But his CV sounds ideal; he says (reads it out).

DH replies " I have to tell you that Mr X was recently sacked by our employer for intellectual theft . And, the CV you're reading to me is not his. It's mine."

BatshitBanshee · 17/06/2022 13:25

Interviewed pre covid for a management role. The role meant I would be working directly under the two interviewers. We had just done the handshaking introduction bit and were about to sit down when interviewer 2 asks interviewer 1 (the more senior) why interviewer 3 wasn't joining them. Senior asshole says "Oh no she flaked, some shit about a sick kid". I decided then and there that I did not want to work with or for them. The level of arrogance to say that about a colleague but then also to say it in front of a potential new hire was just disgusting.

Interviewer 3 followed up to let me know that she'd heard the interview had gone well and would let me know. I politely said please don't consider me, I have no interest in this role but many thanks for the opportunity.

That place regularly advertises every few months for that same role as there is such a high turnover of staff. I wonder why.

bevelino · 17/06/2022 13:21

Coffeetree · 16/06/2022 22:30

Oh and I had an interviewee cry during an interview. She'd been made redundant after trying really hard to keep her department running. Nothing but sympathy of course but no way did I consider her candidacy any further.

I interview graduates for roles every year and some have cried through sheer nerves. I usually say let’s have a short break and then start over. That reassurance helps them complete the interview without any further issues. Sometimes you have to give a little bit of leeway, particularly to young people interviewing for their first professional job.

mizu · 17/06/2022 13:20

One of the interviewers I was interviewing with fell asleep - horribly embarrassing.

PersephoneInTheGarden · 17/06/2022 13:18

I interviewed someone online. He was sitting on the loo. Don’t know if the lid was down or not and didn’t like to ask.

Years ago I had to interview students for holiday roles. Two of them insisted on being interviewed together, held both hands the whole time (not even facing me) and answered each other’s questions. That was a weird one.

PipeScatter · 17/06/2022 13:18

ThinWomansBrain · 17/06/2022 07:00

@Hawkins001 Deferred income - where you receive income in one accounting period, but don't recognise it until the next (eg a multi year grant). It is fairly technical, but common in charity accounting - we were recriting for a senior finance manager.

Reminds me of the time I was interviewing for an accounts senior who was expected to not only prepare accounts but supervise and provide guidance and assistance to more junior members of staff. He'd been working in accounts for about 4 years at this point and his CV looked good, but during a technical question he actually said "what's an accrual?"

And there was the time that my previous employer recruited an accounts trainee that had a false reference from his dad's mate, and actually turned out to be highly number dyslexic... what we'd assumed was shyness was actually his embarrassment at knowing that he was going to be totally hopeless at the job, but too scared of his father (who'd pushed him to get the job) to admit it. Poor lad.

Also, not interview related, but a note to anyone preparing their CV. If you have declared that you have "excellent attention to detail", please, please proof read your CV. It's at this point that I end up looking purposefully for a mistake and 9 times out of 10 find one...

2bazookas · 17/06/2022 13:17

I had asked the interviewee to bring references from their current/ most recent employer. On her application she said she had been there 12 years .They had now gone abroad.

The (glowing) reference she brought to the interview was signed by the same surname as herself. When I queried this she replied "He's my brother, he knows me better than anyone. My employers have moved abroad ".

When she gave their name and old address I looked it up in the phone book.They were still living there and had refused to provide a written reference because she'd been sacked for lying and theft.

ConfusedByDesign · 17/06/2022 13:10

We were interviewing when we'd just had a consultation and revamp of our Service Level Agreements which involved liaison with us, regulatory bodies and auditing firms.
The interviewee came along with the draft copy of the agreement and claimed that he was pretty much solely responsible for this revamp. We just sat there in disbelief at his audacity and stupidity and asked him
A few questions. It was really embarrassing for him when it came to light that actually we were heavily involved and had never heard of him.

bevelino · 17/06/2022 13:09

Talkingtopigeons · 16/06/2022 22:11

Had someone fall asleep in an interview once.

That was awkward.

Grin
Eatingsoupwithafork · 17/06/2022 13:06

3 awkward ones:

  1. where the person kept saying they were very good at their job but would give no examples or directly answer the interview questions
  2. where the person interviewed ok but we found someone better but they wouldn’t take the rejection so constantly emailed me as they couldn’t understand why we wouldn’t employ them even though we gave feedback.
  3. when interviewing for my maternity cover told me he would be so good they wouldn’t want me back. That didn’t put me off as I knew them from another job and knew they were just selling themselves (they were actually very nice) but the director also in the interview was not impressed.
54isanopendoor · 17/06/2022 13:04

BarnacleNora · 16/06/2022 23:29

Not me but my dad who is a design engineer. During the course of the interview he asked the candidate some fairly basic (to them anyway, I'd have been absolutely stumped) maths questions, using formulae that were pretty much used every day as part of being an engineer. Candidate was recently graduated so this should have been incredibly easy for them, no time to get lazy and rely on a certain programme etc.

Candidate was totally stumped, couldn't do any of it and actually, despite what I earlier said, even I could do one of them (area of a circle, thank you very much gcse maths!) What made it worse was my dad had a coffee mug with all the formulae on it along with pictures of drawing tools and a big 'design engineer essentials' slogan, which he subtly and then not so subtly kept turning around the face the candidate, tapping with his pen, knocking on the table etc but the guy had no clue.

My dad reported in his usual dry tones that he could understand freezing with nerves but he did try and help him out until it all just became a bit farcical really and as attention to detail was quite a key part of the job it was pretty clear this wasn't going to be a good fit

Ah. that could be my ds. He has Autism & Dyslexia. which can lead to completely overwhelming anxiety in certain situations. The Dyslexia & Anxiety would mean he'd KNOW the formulae but be temporarily completely unable to access / present them in an interview situation. The Autism would mean he would consider reading them off the side of the coffee mug as 'cheating'.
Of course this person might be entirely different and, as your (rather kind) Father said, simply a bit slow on the uptake which is a different matter. Neither are esp. helpful in a candidate, but one is interview specific & one less so possibly.

forinborin · 17/06/2022 13:01

I interviewed a candidate with another colleague once, and the interviewee did not speak to me directly, referring only in third person during the interview. Answered my questions but looking at another interviewer, and repeated the question he was answering in passive as "So I was asked: ..."

He was technically absolutely brilliant and was hired, into a different project so we did not see each other much, but he had never even acknowledged my existence or returned a "hello" when I bumped into him at the coffee machine or watering station. It wasn't even offensive, just plain weird.

I was much younger then and now I just wish that I asked him directly what that was about. I will now probably die in ignorance.