Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your cringeworthy interview experiences where you were the interviewer?

215 replies

AlternativePerspective · 16/06/2022 21:55

A friend was just telling me about the interviews they were holding recently. One candidate was apparently awful. Kept interrupting, threw a pile of certificates down on the desk when asked about his qualification, referred to people with disabilities (it was in a disability focussed organisation) as “mentals” and he wanted to help them because he was sure they aren’t stupid.

Then when he had the rejection he has sent numerous emails insisting he should have been employed.

The story is so horrifying that I wonder whether he was deliberately that objectionable. From their end I do know it really happened, but could it be he was being like that deliberately? Or …?

So, as an interviewer, have you ever conducted any awful, cringeworthy interviews?

OP posts:
DogLover22 · 20/06/2022 18:52

I was asked at an interview. "If I could choose, what animal would I be and why" I was able to answer every question up until that point.

Basilbrushgotfat · 20/06/2022 18:19

AmJustDone · 17/06/2022 16:07

But that's the point of an interview - people are seeing whether they want to work for you just as much as you're assessing whether they are suitable. They are essentially interviewing you too and it's a poor company which doesn't recognise this.

I had an interview a bit like this.

I'd been approached by the employer and asked to interview. I asked a couple of questions about the details of the role and the male interview (of course) rather sharply told me that he was the one conducting interview, not me.

There were a couple of other red flags in the interview and I took enormous pleasure in withdrawing my interest the moment I returned to my desk post interview.

EerieSilence · 20/06/2022 13:29

Assistanttotheregionalmanager · 16/06/2022 22:13

don’t really get why her saying that is so bad

Really? You are recruiting a head teacher for a school in an area they would consider bad and openly despise some parents just because they're from the area? How can they manage a school like that, deal with all possible issues?

Bednobsbroomsticks · 18/06/2022 07:29

Bootothegoose · 17/06/2022 08:15

I told an interviewer I loved him once and no one I have ever told the story to has let me forget it.

I shook his hand, interview went very well. He said, and I quote, 'Thanks for your time Bootothegoose, I'll be in touch to let you know the outcome.'
My response, 'Thanks so much, have a nice day, love you.'

There was a pause. I turned and left. Got the job, however, so don't know if I would recommend such an approach.

Hahahahah that made me roar

WhackingPhoenix · 18/06/2022 01:08

Changechangychange · 18/06/2022 00:41

Depends on what the dog is doing surely? If it’s jumping up or barking that would be pretty off-putting during an interview, no matter how much you love dogs.

I love DS5 but I would 100% kick him out of the room if I was interviewing!

I think applying to work directly with dogs would require the interviewer to observe how the candidate would interact with a dog, particularly a ‘spirited’ rescue dog. I homecheck for a charity and often bring my own dog to meet would-be owners when I interview them (especially first timers) to see how they interact with him. It’s made the world of difference in some cases, meaning our dogs haven’t been placed in unsuitable homes.

Changechangychange · 18/06/2022 00:41

NotTheBaddie · 17/06/2022 20:00

I work for a well known charity with dogs, we regularly have dogs in the room during interviews, or in the waiting room to see how people respond. I was interviewing a woman once who asked us to remove the dog because the noise of the dog was distracting her. She was applying to work directly with the dogs 🤦🏼‍♀️

Depends on what the dog is doing surely? If it’s jumping up or barking that would be pretty off-putting during an interview, no matter how much you love dogs.

I love DS5 but I would 100% kick him out of the room if I was interviewing!

NotTheBaddie · 17/06/2022 20:00

I work for a well known charity with dogs, we regularly have dogs in the room during interviews, or in the waiting room to see how people respond. I was interviewing a woman once who asked us to remove the dog because the noise of the dog was distracting her. She was applying to work directly with the dogs 🤦🏼‍♀️

goldfinchonthelawn · 17/06/2022 19:56

2bazookas · 17/06/2022 13:34

DH received a phone call from a university, saying his name had been given as a referee for Mr X who had applied for the following research post, details.
DH replies " I do know Mr X, he's an ex- colleague and he has not asked me to give a reference. He does not have the skills and experience you're looking for."

Caller says " But his CV sounds ideal; he says (reads it out).

DH replies " I have to tell you that Mr X was recently sacked by our employer for intellectual theft . And, the CV you're reading to me is not his. It's mine."

That reminds me of when, years ago I was asked to sit in on an interview where I worked, took a look at the CV of the incoming candidate and saw that it was a woman I had worked with before who had added my role to her CV, instead of the massively more junior job she'd done. She looked pretty shocked when she came in and saw me with the CV in my hands. She didn't get invited back.

goldfinchonthelawn · 17/06/2022 19:51

Primatrying · 17/06/2022 07:23

I went to an interview once where I'm sure the interview panel look back and cringe. I walked in, and they told me that they would start with an easy ice-breaker question, and said "how's your home life?".

I was a teenager whose parents had announced their divorce the previous week. I burst into tears. The interviewers looked soooo mortified. Asked if I wanted a time out but I said no, I'd be fine.

Amazingly I got the job. In feedback they told me that they were impressed that I'd managed to recollect myself.

What a colossally stupid ice-breaker question!

goldfinchonthelawn · 17/06/2022 19:37

justasmalltownmum · 16/06/2022 22:57

So tell me something interesting about yourself:

I'm not interesting at all. Actually I'm really boring.

Ok then..

How are you supposed to answer that question without sounding a bit self-satisfied?

TheLostNights · 17/06/2022 18:30

I work in a nursery and a few years back (when we could actually recruit staff), a woman was so nervous, she cried. Manager still gave her the job though.

Phineyj · 17/06/2022 18:17

Years ago, I was interviewed once for a job. I was a good match for the job spec and had prepared carefully. One of the interviewers had a dreadful cough, to the point that most of my answers were completely obliterated by her coughing. They turned me down but there was no way they could have heard more than 10% of what I said!

whirlyswirly · 17/06/2022 17:54

God, I meant continue the interview, not office. I'm tired and would fail my own test today.

whirlyswirly · 17/06/2022 17:53

Omg, so many. Interviewing is joyous and frustratingly awful in equal measure.

Totally agree about excellent attention to detail and have seen more then one CV where they've spelt detail detial, which makes the whole thing worse. It's rare to see an error-free CV.

We've had the guy who brought his dad to interview, a few criers, one person who announced she couldn't possibly work in our open plan office but then wanted to continue the office (pre hybrid being a real option).

The worst recent one was where we accidentally let in a criminal for first stage interview, toured him round the office and someone recognised him from the news. Shock

VirginiaQ · 17/06/2022 17:07

Remembered another one. Man turned up for interview. Not obviously drunk but smelling strongly of alcohol. Unfortunately for him he was applying for a job at a Police establishment and as he had driven there was given a breathalyser test, blew over (significantly) got arrested for drink driving then spent several hours in the cells before being charged and released.

Also to add this interview was about 3/4 in the afternoon so no excuse of having had a heavy night and not realising he was still over. His excuse was that he'd had a drink to calm his nerves!

Hawkins001 · 17/06/2022 17:03

Catfeatured · 17/06/2022 09:03

I work in the civil service. Candidates are asked to give examples of when they have demonstrated a particular skill at work like making a difficult decision. One candidate from another government dept started talking about choosing a paint colour for her living room. It was excruciating.

Could you use Hyperthetical examples, e.g. The three or five people and time was limited but needed to choose one group or another to save, as both was not possible and explain your reasoning and perspectives ?

AmJustDone · 17/06/2022 16:07

Alaimo · 17/06/2022 11:46

First time I was interviewing candidates for a position line managed by me. One of the candidates kept asking me & the other panellists questions during the interview. To the extent that it felt like he was interviewing us. I'm all for candidates being engaged, but this was a bit much. I have sometimes wondered if the company he was working for sent him to spy on us.

But that's the point of an interview - people are seeing whether they want to work for you just as much as you're assessing whether they are suitable. They are essentially interviewing you too and it's a poor company which doesn't recognise this.

Bananaramad · 17/06/2022 15:02

Limesaregreen · 17/06/2022 08:38

O might out myself here but I was once interviewed for a job and was asked how I would cope with some other staff knowing more than I do. I thought it was a very odd question but I answered it by saying ‘well they won’t know everything. I’m bound to know stuff they don’t. For example I know all the names of The Wombles’

I got the job :)

🤣🤣 love this.

iloveeverykindofcat · 17/06/2022 14:56

Sometimes they're just "touching base" so you know they are there if you have any concerns, sometimes they are very angry that their child did not get the job and are there to tell you that you must give it to them.

Oh my God, I always wondered what happens to those university students whose parents phone up to argue about their grades! I always thought 'what is this person going to do when their 'child' enters work'? It turns out they just....carry on...

Puzzledandpissedoff · 17/06/2022 14:56

I used to work in recruitment. You'd be amazed how many younger adults' mummy's and daddy give you a call/drop you an email

So did I, so I wouldn't be amazed at all - and these weren't school leavers but graduates

My favourite was the mum who answered her son's mobile, and didn't appreciate being asked to tell him that Arthur Brown's "Fire" wasn't a very professional choice for an intro to leaving a message - immediately after 9/11 Shock
I never did manage to contact the lad, and when his application failed mum must have called 8 or 9 times demanding he be given a chance although "a very silly boy, but he's always been the same"

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 17/06/2022 14:47

Many years ago, the HR department at the university where I worked put a job description and person specification prepared in Word on the website for all to see without noticing that Track Changes was still switched on. You could see comments all the way through. I hope they were all as innocuous as 'Jane to insert salary' or similar, but how could they be sure? I wouldn't have been impressed as a potential candidate (as an existing employee I wasn't surprised in the slightest).

PipeScatter · 17/06/2022 14:41

AlternativePerspective · 17/06/2022 14:31

Also, not interview related, but a note to anyone preparing their CV. If you have declared that you have "excellent attention to detail", please, please proof read your CV. It's at this point that I end up looking purposefully for a mistake and 9 times out of 10 find one... conversely though the number of job adverts I see which are full of spelling and grammatical errors is astounding.

The other day I saw one for a customer adviser, home based, I can’t remember the full details but the job/person spec should have taken up about 5 paragraphs. It was all written in one line, and not a single punctuation mark.

Oh I agree. When we advertise I re-read it so many times before it gets published. I appreciate if I'm expecting excellence from a candidate they should also be expecting it from us too.

It would colour my opinion of an employer if their advert was poor.

Astrabees · 17/06/2022 14:37

I needed a new assistant, we interviewed everyone who applied for the job as we were paranoid about being accused of discrimination. The one male applicant arrived drunk, and having tried to mask this with strong aftershave. He told me he could not do the "typing test" as it was badly thought out and he could devise a better one. When he didn't get the job he complained that as he had been to school with our Chair he should have been sucessfull.

AlternativePerspective · 17/06/2022 14:31

Also, not interview related, but a note to anyone preparing their CV. If you have declared that you have "excellent attention to detail", please, please proof read your CV. It's at this point that I end up looking purposefully for a mistake and 9 times out of 10 find one... conversely though the number of job adverts I see which are full of spelling and grammatical errors is astounding.

The other day I saw one for a customer adviser, home based, I can’t remember the full details but the job/person spec should have taken up about 5 paragraphs. It was all written in one line, and not a single punctuation mark.

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 17/06/2022 14:30

Great thread!

Just on the note of parents ringing up - when I was administrator for a Master's programme I took a call one day from a lovely man who said he was enquiring on behalf of his son. He outlined his son's academic and work record, which was indeed exactly what we were looking for, and I told him a bit about the course, and stressed (gently) that his son should have a good look at our website for himself, and his Dad said of course, of course, and he knew he must seem like a pushy parent, but 'You really would be lucky to get our Nick, he's a great lad'. Grin

A few days later I had a call from 'Nick', who was absolutely mortified. He did apply, though, and got a place on his own merits - did very well. I was sorry I never got to meet his Dad!