Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emily bridges may have to wait 2 years to compete against women in British cycling

110 replies

GretaGip · 16/06/2022 21:50

In today's Daily mail.Dm article

AIBU to think the tide might be turning?

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 17/06/2022 07:14

Im confused - so this person is still competing or has been very recently competing, competitively, in mens races, but now they are also saying they should be able to compete in women’s races and there’s no advantage? My brain hurts.

Yes, Bridges was part of the Nottingham Uni men’s team pursuit in the student championships in February. They came 3rd. Bridges was happily accepted by team mates in doing so. Bridges was doing that while waiting to meet the original criteria to be able to switch over to women’s cycling, because cycling competitively, winning medals, and having the support of teammates isn’t enough for Bridges, apparently. It demonstrates clearly that it is all about identity and validation, not remotely about “just want to ride a bike.”

nickthefox · 17/06/2022 07:14

I love reading about the trans issues because it feels so easy compared to climate change, refugees and rape statistics. Still riles me up though

ScurryfungeMaster · 17/06/2022 07:13

I suppose it's a step in the right direction, but males should never compete in female sports anyway so it doesn't feel like a victory when all they have to do is wait a couple of years.

Runningslow · 17/06/2022 07:08

i voted yabu because I optimistically had thought that they’d changed their minds about men in womens sports completely, so this feels really demoralising again.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 06:58

DragonflyNights · 17/06/2022 06:42

Im confused - so this person is still competing or has been very recently competing, competitively, in mens races, but now they are also saying they should be able to compete in women’s races and there’s no advantage? My brain hurts.

That's because you're thinking about what you're being told to accept. Bad person assigned female at birth. Stop thinking.

SidewaysOtter · 17/06/2022 06:48

I can - just about - have a small shred of sympathy for Emily. Emily was born male and has therefore grown up with male entitlement. Emily has probably also received endless validation for Emily’s decision to transition and told that yes, Emily is a woman and will be able to compete as such and all Emily needed to do was reduce testosterone levels and bingo! Woman status. Biological reality has brought that crashing down, rules have been changed and plenty of people are now saying the emperor has no clothes Emily is not a woman, which all it marks something of a reversal of fortunes which, if you’ve only ever been patted on the back and told how brave you are, must be something of a shock.

It’s a vanishingly small shred though. The vast, VAST amount of my sympathy lies with women pushed out of their own sports categories, missing out on placings, medals and recognition, for someone who should never have been there in the first place.

Merryclaire · 17/06/2022 06:47

Genuine question - are there any trans men competing in professional sport?

I always hear about trans women, but are there any trans men at that level, and if so, do they compete in men or women’s categories?

I’m imagining the reverse is true for them, and they are disadvantaged in men’s sport - so have never really heard about them campaigning to be allowed to compete against men (unless I missed it). Which is quite telling I think.

BuanoKubiamVej · 17/06/2022 06:47

Yanbu but a 2 year wait will not change the facts that Emily Bridges' body has gone through male puberty and has been permanently affected by that in ways that no surgery or hormone treatment can compensate for. There is no waiting period that can make facts be different. There is no way for Emily Bridges to compete on a level playing field with women who bodies are not affected in this way. The "mens" category in cycling (and in every other sport where these issues are happening) should be abolished and replaced with an "open" category where any woman, whatever her biology or gender history, has every right to compete, and Emily Brudges will theb have an appropriate category to compete in. What's the justification for a category being "Men's" rather than "Open"?

OperaStation · 17/06/2022 06:43

It’s a step in the right direction. It’s been increased to two years because that’s the “minimum” time it takes for muscle mass to reduce to a level closer to that of a woman. So for some trans athletes it will take longer, which begs the question why not make it 5 years, or 10 years, or never!

Also, none of this takes into account the advantage of having a male sized body. Even with reduced muscle mass these athletes will be taller, broader and possibly have larger king capacity.

I would be much happier if they just had their own category. That would be the fairest solution for all.

DragonflyNights · 17/06/2022 06:42

NotBadConsidering · 17/06/2022 00:33

I also do not feel for Bridges. Bridges has competed in the male category this year. Bridges is accepted in the male category (arm in arm with team mates on the podium) and competitive in the male category. Bridges wants to compete in the women’s category for Bridges’ own validation, not to compete in the sport.

Bridges has been lucky thus far that organisations like the UCI had their heads buried in the sand hoping their pathetic policies would be enough to deter athletes from bothering, and now those organisations have pulled their heads out slightly and started to take some notice. Bridges was hopeful that they wouldn’t. Now all sports organisations need to go the way of USA powerlifting and ban males from women’s sport completely, because a) males aren’t women and therefore aren’t eligible and b) no amount of obfuscation around current levels of one hormone will ever remove the entire sex-based advantages.

What happened after USA Powerlifting took their stance? There was the usual tantrums from the TRA Twitter toddlers and then nothing. If you have the guts to do what’s right, and stick with it, the initial loud shouty fall out fades to nothing.

So come on UCI and others, stop trying to deter athletes with such policies, because you’re just setting yourself up for more shifting of the goalposts: just say no. No males in women’s sport.

Im confused - so this person is still competing or has been very recently competing, competitively, in mens races, but now they are also saying they should be able to compete in women’s races and there’s no advantage? My brain hurts.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 06:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SolasAnla · 17/06/2022 06:36

Is anybody ever in any doubt about how society is still prioritise men?

That, when given the opportunity to support women, the decision will be to justify why this can't happen?

Women's classes are there for a reason, so no jerryrigging justifies allowing a male in any women's competition.

comealongponds · 17/06/2022 06:29

She should never be allowed to compete in womens sport at all. This decision just kicks the issue down the line for a couple of years

Male bodies don’t belong in female sport.

Penners99 · 17/06/2022 06:16

XX chromosomes should compete against XX chromosomes.

XY chromosomes should compete against XY chromosomes.

Nothing else is fair or needed in today’s society.

Redglitter · 17/06/2022 01:04

Good but it should be permanent.

I feel sorry for women who have worked hard to get to the top of their sport only to have men come along & win the awards. Its farcical

Rainbowshit · 17/06/2022 01:00

There should never even have been any possibility of Emily competing in a female sporting event. No males in female sport ever.!

NotBadConsidering · 17/06/2022 00:33

I also do not feel for Bridges. Bridges has competed in the male category this year. Bridges is accepted in the male category (arm in arm with team mates on the podium) and competitive in the male category. Bridges wants to compete in the women’s category for Bridges’ own validation, not to compete in the sport.

Bridges has been lucky thus far that organisations like the UCI had their heads buried in the sand hoping their pathetic policies would be enough to deter athletes from bothering, and now those organisations have pulled their heads out slightly and started to take some notice. Bridges was hopeful that they wouldn’t. Now all sports organisations need to go the way of USA powerlifting and ban males from women’s sport completely, because a) males aren’t women and therefore aren’t eligible and b) no amount of obfuscation around current levels of one hormone will ever remove the entire sex-based advantages.

What happened after USA Powerlifting took their stance? There was the usual tantrums from the TRA Twitter toddlers and then nothing. If you have the guts to do what’s right, and stick with it, the initial loud shouty fall out fades to nothing.

So come on UCI and others, stop trying to deter athletes with such policies, because you’re just setting yourself up for more shifting of the goalposts: just say no. No males in women’s sport.

nolongersurprised · 17/06/2022 00:15

I don’t feel for Bridges.Bridges and their male body is taking opportunities away from women.

No one who has gone through a male puberty should be in women’s sport, irrespective of which ever one of the 67 genders they identify as

LeniGray · 16/06/2022 23:39

I hope the tide is finally turning. I feel for Bridges [a bit], but I feel more strongly that males shouldn’t be competing in women’s sports at all.

HintofVintagePink · 16/06/2022 23:16

‘Other’ women? 🤔

VestofAbsurdity · 16/06/2022 23:15

lifeturnsonadime · 16/06/2022 22:52

Emily Bridges has no place in female sport ever.

Women are not males with lowered testosterone.

100% this.

The only fair ruling is NO MALES IN WOMEN'S SPORTS EVER.

Women are not weakened men, cosmetically or surgically altered men, hormonally altered men, stop fucking insulting women by saying they are.

BreadInCaptivity · 16/06/2022 23:02

Emily should never compete against women.

End of.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 16/06/2022 22:58

Absolutely crazy that Emily bridges will ever be able to compete against biological women. As a pp said, women are not men with lower testosterone.

LoonyLurcher · 16/06/2022 22:54

No man should ever compete with women.
It makes a total mockery of the women who fought to be able to compete at all.

ofwarren · 16/06/2022 22:54

mum2jakie · 16/06/2022 21:52

Make it zero years - because male bodies don't belong in women's sport - then I'll be happy!

This

Swipe left for the next trending thread