Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emily bridges may have to wait 2 years to compete against women in British cycling

110 replies

GretaGip · 16/06/2022 21:50

In today's Daily mail.Dm article

AIBU to think the tide might be turning?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 17/06/2022 08:42

Merryclaire · 17/06/2022 07:53

Sounds like they are physically in the correct category then.

However, as the trans community grows, surely the answer is to have their own categories now? There may not be enough top level athletes yet, but there will be in the future if they start the ball rolling.

The whole issue is far too complex, but just allowing trans women to compete as women and trans men to compete as women feels very wrong!

I very much doubt we will see a surge in trans athletes unless the rulings state that hormone levels will not be tested. A transman taking T would be disqualified from both the mens AND the women’s competitions whilst a transwoman taking hormone blockers will not be able to reduce their T levels to that of women.
The main reason why I think its very unlikely is that as more and more children are being prescribed PBs and cross sex hormones, those children’s bodies will not develop as normal and therefore be less strong than other children. So they’d be less successful at sport in either the male or the female categories.
All the transwomen currently trying to compete in women’s sport were fully developed adult males when they decided they were ‘women’ and therefore have had the benefit of male puberty, which is why they have all been successful in male competition. Surprisingly, they also have another thing in common - after competing at top levels in male sports competitions, they’ve lost their form - either through injury or ageing - before trying to compete against women.
Theres a lot more to be asked about why failing successful male athletes suddenly decide theyre female. The power of success / devastation of failure in sport is a significant phenomenon.

user1471517095 · 17/06/2022 08:33

Hundreds of thousands of years of evolution and biology are suddenly wiped away because a man wants to identify as a woman. (And that bit doesn't particularly bother me too much) but they want to trample all over womens rights, achievements and advancements whilst they're at it.

Soontobe60 · 17/06/2022 08:32

LeniGray · 16/06/2022 23:39

I hope the tide is finally turning. I feel for Bridges [a bit], but I feel more strongly that males shouldn’t be competing in women’s sports at all.

I’m curious to know why (or indeed what) youre ‘feeling’ for Bridges?
Bridges is perfectly entitled to race against other males, as Bridges was doing only a few months ago.

Tabasco007 · 17/06/2022 08:06

Men should not be in womens sport, period. It's absolute insanity that we have got here, well insanity or male entitlement, one or the other, or both!

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 17/06/2022 08:03

That does seem to be the case. Yes.

But, given that it’s about sport in particular, Emily also wants to compete in a category in which Emily has an unfair advantage. Winning on merit doesn’t seem to matter.

People with that kind of approach are bad sportspeople. It’s no different than deciding that it’s ok to win by doping or any other way of giving yourself an unfair advantage.

SidewaysOtter · 17/06/2022 08:02

Not exactly a sporting attitude is it?

It seems that sporting fairness comes a very poor second to results at any cost (to others) and validation.

See also the comment above about Ivy - fairness is out the window, “rights” are the only show in town.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 07:57

Ignoring all the concerns expressed about fairness suggests that Emily bridges simply doesn’t care about fair competition. Not exactly a sporting attitude is it?

It isn't about fair competition. It's about appropriating and redefining womanhood until males are the ones who get to determine it. A male feeling trumps female existence and that's the way Bridges thinks it should be.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 17/06/2022 07:55

What I can’t understand is why Emily Bridges is so utterly determined to be able to compete in women’s cycling and is determined to play the victim in the media about it.

Ignoring all the concerns expressed about fairness suggests that Emily bridges simply doesn’t care about fair competition. Not exactly a sporting attitude is it?

Denying that skeletal structure, differences in lung, heart and other organs’ capacity, and all the basic physical differences of having gone through puberty with a male body make any difference is just gaslighting the world.

Merryclaire · 17/06/2022 07:53

Proudboomer · 17/06/2022 07:37

The only one I have heard about is Iszac Henig a us swimmer who trans to male but has delayed hormones and surgery so that they can still compete in womens sport. Kind of well I am a bloke but not when it comes to sport as I can’t win against them now can I.

Sounds like they are physically in the correct category then.

However, as the trans community grows, surely the answer is to have their own categories now? There may not be enough top level athletes yet, but there will be in the future if they start the ball rolling.

The whole issue is far too complex, but just allowing trans women to compete as women and trans men to compete as women feels very wrong!

SpinRiverSister · 17/06/2022 07:49

An athlete who has been through male puberty has no place in women’s sport. Ever. It’s cheating.

Queenoftheashes · 17/06/2022 07:48

I am going on the assumption that by the two years this whole nonsense will have been sorted out.
even the stonewall-biased reporting of the public’s “lack of interest” in these issues acknowledged that most people do not think TW should be competing against women in sport.

Totheweekend · 17/06/2022 07:46

(Oh and of course I’m not comparing epilepsy and being trans)

MrsWooster · 17/06/2022 07:45

Is Bridges going to spend that two years having skeletal reconstruction to change pelvic shape and femur angle, heart surgery to reduce its size (ditto lungs), neurotherapy to change muscle twitch times, blood transfusions to alter blood oxygen levels, and anti-lipo to change the body muscle:fat ratio…?

Im guessing not, so Bridges will retain all the advantages of male body other than the testosterone levels.
Women’s sport is not a consolation prize for mediocre male athletes.

(ps I voted yanbu as I think the tide is changing BUT, as my post may hint at, there is no way males belong in women’s sport)

Totheweekend · 17/06/2022 07:45

I feel for Emily who is drawn to competitive sport but just because someone wants to compete doesn’t mean they should be allowed to if they don’t have the required pre-requisites.
My friend’s son was devastated that he couldn’t fulfil his lifelong dream of becoming a navy pilot when he started to have epilepsy as a teenager. And no-one would argue that he should be allowed - it’s just a piece of rotten luck that changes the course of a life.
It’s tough for Emily too that her need to transition is not compatible with her desire to compete in sport. Simply that - tough. She and other trans-athletes need to move on

Proudboomer · 17/06/2022 07:44

Sorry slight wrong in saying Iszac Henig has delayed all surgery as they have had their boobs cut off but no other surgery and no hormone treatments that would make them ineligible for womens swimming. They swim for Yale at college level.

Pinana · 17/06/2022 07:44

It's a small step in the right direction, but a blanket 'no' would have been better!

I veer between hope and despair on this issue I'm afraid. I think we are making progress, then I try to have a discussion with friends and get totally ignored. Feels like so many people won't even engage on the topic, they're so concerned with being seen to 'be kind'.

MyWorstIsGoodEnough · 17/06/2022 07:38

There’s no place for any man in women’s sport. Or any other place that is for women. It still amazes me that it needs saying.

Proudboomer · 17/06/2022 07:37

Merryclaire · 17/06/2022 06:47

Genuine question - are there any trans men competing in professional sport?

I always hear about trans women, but are there any trans men at that level, and if so, do they compete in men or women’s categories?

I’m imagining the reverse is true for them, and they are disadvantaged in men’s sport - so have never really heard about them campaigning to be allowed to compete against men (unless I missed it). Which is quite telling I think.

The only one I have heard about is Iszac Henig a us swimmer who trans to male but has delayed hormones and surgery so that they can still compete in womens sport. Kind of well I am a bloke but not when it comes to sport as I can’t win against them now can I.

zafferana · 17/06/2022 07:29

'Emily' Bridges should NEVER be allowed to compete against females, any more than 'Lia' Thomas should. If your sex is male then you should compete against other males.

NotBadConsidering · 17/06/2022 07:27

Veronica Ivy, formerly known as Rachel McKinnon, also a cyclist who manages to wangle themselves onto places like CNN, argues that Ivy should not even have to lower testosterone because it’s an infringement on Ivy’s rights because Ivy has a female body and therefore the testosterone levels are female levels.

ivykaty44 · 17/06/2022 07:27

Can you imagine, even if there was a special trans category, there'd be the same arguments between those who had taken every medical step and those who simply "identified as" while keeping the balls and beard

this ^^

ivykaty44 · 17/06/2022 07:25

Good. Emily can compete against other men

they did this year & got a placed just a month before wanting to race in the omnium

SpringBadger · 17/06/2022 07:25

To be honest, I would have thought anyone who's regularly taking hormone supplements should be staying away from competitive sports. Can you imagine, even if there was a special trans category, there'd be the same arguments between those who had taken every medical step and those who simply "identified as" while keeping the balls and beard. I've no sympathy for Bridges, they need to learn that there are trade-offs in life, and take some responsibility. That said, if they've got to this place by age 21, they have probably not had the best influences on them.

Proudboomer · 17/06/2022 07:21

It is not good enough. Women’s sports are for women not xy chromosome people who think you can feel you way into a sex.

MsTSwift · 17/06/2022 07:18

If the governing body had held firm from the outset and not even entertained these pathetic fixes faffing about with testosterone levels that would have been clearer and fairer to all.