Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emily bridges may have to wait 2 years to compete against women in British cycling

110 replies

GretaGip · 16/06/2022 21:50

In today's Daily mail.Dm article

AIBU to think the tide might be turning?

OP posts:
Clarice99 · 17/06/2022 13:13

Two years? It should be forever. Bridges is a biological male. Men have no place in women's sports.

Zero sympathy for Bridges.

Belovedfool · 17/06/2022 13:06

EB is still a fully intact male. That surgery isn't something you get back on your bike after, not for a bloody long time. Think about it. It's not a manicure, is it?
Fully intact, 6'2 male with male pelvis, male heart and lungs etc etc. None of that is negated by growing your hair, having a few jabs and whining in a TV interview.
No. The only unreasonable thing about any of this is that it's not FOREVER.

WifeMotherWorkRepeat · 17/06/2022 12:40

Only biological females belong in women’s sport.

Ideology has no place in sport and allowing men, however they see themselves, competing against women is wrong, surely there cannot be ethical, logical or fair arguments against this statement!!

I stand with female athletes 100% on this.

georgarina · 17/06/2022 12:25

This is all so stupid.
We're going backwards.
More women suffer medication side effects because only men were historically allowed in drug trials.
More women die than men in car crashes because female test dummies are scaled-down male dummies.
WOMEN ARE NOT WEAK OR SCALED-DOWN MEN.
Men cannot compete in women's sports.

LeniGray · 17/06/2022 12:23

Soontobe60 · 17/06/2022 08:32

I’m curious to know why (or indeed what) youre ‘feeling’ for Bridges?
Bridges is perfectly entitled to race against other males, as Bridges was doing only a few months ago.

I think it’s a tiny bit of empathy for the disappointment Bridges must be feeling, the governing bodies haven’t exactly been clear, have they? That doesn’t mean I think Bridges should be competing against women ever - I don’t.

purpleboy · 17/06/2022 11:43

CatrinVennastin · 17/06/2022 11:10

A lot of this is, I feel, indicative of the general feelings of entitlement that people seem to have these days.

My cousin transitioned years ago (took years of therapy before surgery was even considered). He used to compete at a reasonably high level in marathon running but stopped when he began to live "as a woman".

His take on it is is that you have to make choices in life and it would be unfair to compete against biological women. His need to live "as a female" is stronger than his need to compete.

I'm flabbergasted that the ruling bodies of these top flight sports care more about one man's feelings that they do about female athletes.

And this is exactly how it should be, we make decisions everyday that potentially limit opportunities to us, this is no different.

Men have no place in woman's sports EVER

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 11:42

They're kicking the can down the road in the hope that by then, enough people will have come to their senses and seen that not only does the emperor have no clothes, but nobody has any trouble identifying his sex.

FOJN · 17/06/2022 11:41

I feel for Emily who is drawn to competitive sport but just because someone wants to compete doesn’t mean they should be allowed to if they don’t have the required pre-requisites.

No one is denying Emily the opportunity to participate in competitive sport as evidenced by Emily's own competing history. The men's category is still very much open to Emily where Emily does rather well, although not as well as Emily does when racing women.

It's cheating and we are apparently bigots for having the temerity to say so.

payable · 17/06/2022 11:36

CatrinVennastin · 17/06/2022 11:10

A lot of this is, I feel, indicative of the general feelings of entitlement that people seem to have these days.

My cousin transitioned years ago (took years of therapy before surgery was even considered). He used to compete at a reasonably high level in marathon running but stopped when he began to live "as a woman".

His take on it is is that you have to make choices in life and it would be unfair to compete against biological women. His need to live "as a female" is stronger than his need to compete.

I'm flabbergasted that the ruling bodies of these top flight sports care more about one man's feelings that they do about female athletes.

Great to hear this very balanced and reasonable approach. Shame more can't adopt the same view.

beastlyslumber · 17/06/2022 11:23

comealongponds · 17/06/2022 06:29

She should never be allowed to compete in womens sport at all. This decision just kicks the issue down the line for a couple of years

Male bodies don’t belong in female sport.

This.

Petrarkanian · 17/06/2022 11:16

Emily should never compete in women's sports

CatrinVennastin · 17/06/2022 11:10

A lot of this is, I feel, indicative of the general feelings of entitlement that people seem to have these days.

My cousin transitioned years ago (took years of therapy before surgery was even considered). He used to compete at a reasonably high level in marathon running but stopped when he began to live "as a woman".

His take on it is is that you have to make choices in life and it would be unfair to compete against biological women. His need to live "as a female" is stronger than his need to compete.

I'm flabbergasted that the ruling bodies of these top flight sports care more about one man's feelings that they do about female athletes.

daisy46 · 17/06/2022 11:07

Should have to wait forever . . . 2 years is better than today, but it's not worthy of celebrating yet.

payable · 17/06/2022 10:57

This reply has been deleted

misgendering

SpringBadger · 17/06/2022 10:56

GoodThinkingMax · 17/06/2022 10:42

Women are not just men with low testosterone and no penis and testicles

I wouldn't assume that Bridges has no penis or testicles. All the high-profile trans athletes I can think of have famously kept their tackle.

But I have heard that there can be more skill and artistry in women's sports because we don't have that brute force. Some people find it more interesting to watch for that reason. They don't want to see a male athlete steamrolling the others.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/06/2022 10:54

There is an American transman who competes in womens swimming events, because , surprise surprise, there is no point in them competing in mens events if they want to win.

Presumably he's found a way to keep his gender identity intact even while swimming in his correct sex class.

Astonishing.

bridgetreilly · 17/06/2022 10:54

He can call himself whatever he wants and wear whatever clothes and makeup he chooses. But he doesn’t get to take women’s rights away from them. Ever.

viques · 17/06/2022 10:52

Merryclaire · 17/06/2022 06:47

Genuine question - are there any trans men competing in professional sport?

I always hear about trans women, but are there any trans men at that level, and if so, do they compete in men or women’s categories?

I’m imagining the reverse is true for them, and they are disadvantaged in men’s sport - so have never really heard about them campaigning to be allowed to compete against men (unless I missed it). Which is quite telling I think.

There is an American transman who competes in womens swimming events, because , surprise surprise, there is no point in them competing in mens events if they want to win. Heck, even a decent swimmer like Lia Thomas found they couldn’t win in mens swimming events when they were swimming as a man, so no hope for a transman.

SolasAnla · 17/06/2022 10:51

Merryclaire there was also a US "ironman" type competitor who sucessful (i think 40+) and a highschool (?) wrestler in Texas who was trying to move into the male classifications.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander
What I can’t understand is why Emily Bridges is so utterly determined to be able to compete in women’s cycling and is determined to play the victim in the media about it.

You are looking at the podium win. But the competition is not the cycle track but to force people to act as if a male is a female.

GoodThinkingMax · 17/06/2022 10:42

Women are not just men with low testosterone and no penis and testicles

GoodThinkingMax · 17/06/2022 10:41

YANBU to be optimistic.

However

Bridges should not be competing in women‘s events. They are cheating.

VestaTilley · 17/06/2022 10:32

“Emily” Bridges should never be allowed to compete against women. Because Emily is male.

Dreikanter · 17/06/2022 10:29

A transman taking T would be disqualified from both the mens AND the women’s competitions

Transmen can get a therapeutic use exemption for T to allow them to take part in men’s competitions.

Transmen aren’t competitive in male sport because women with elevated T levels are not men.

Same as Emily Bridges with a lowered T level is not a woman.

DontBlameMe79 · 17/06/2022 10:05

I remember years ago when these issues were initially debated that someone cautioned that men could eventually compete in woman's sports. They were howled down as being alarmist, ridiculous, prejudiced blah blah. It was some old crusty dude as I recall and he was humiliated by the right on audience. Suppose old crusty bods can be right sometimes.

balalake · 17/06/2022 08:45

A small step in the correct direction.