Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL being too intrusive and demanding

118 replies

Safarigiraffe · 16/06/2022 20:03

MIL is 85 years old & is constantly being too intrusive/demanding. She phones us 4-5 times during the week after work (we get home 630 roughly) Weekends are the worse constantly phoning us during the day & if we are not in she will phone DH mobile to see where we are/what we are doing. During the week when we are at work she constantly phones/leaves messages for DS21 & DD18 sometimes they are busy with work, college/Uni or with friends it’s so exhausting it’s unreal. Always wants to know what we are doing, expects DH to drop everything for him to go running round there. Have spoken to DH but he doesn’t seem to think there’s a problem also spoken to MIL too. Any advice? Am I being unreasonable here to think this is excessive or am I wrong?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
I8toys · 28/12/2022 16:26

Personally I think its too much. She has a husband and needs to find other interests. Your DH needs to set boundaries with her. We are going down this route at the moment. Calls all the time. DH is just over there now fixing their washing machine. Something always needs fixing or is urgent and a drama ensues. Despite the fact we have children and full time jobs. FIL is getting tested for dementia but MIL seems to be the problem. I can see a long road ahead.

fUNNYfACE36 · 28/12/2022 13:49

She's 85 it won't be a problem for long.Show a bit of tolerance and live

Cruisebabe1 · 25/12/2022 18:21

Safarigiraffe · 16/06/2022 21:03

Basically wanting to know where they are going, doing, what time they are going/coming back, what friends are going/how many etc

Sounds like she has MH problem? Possibly onset of dementia?

PomRuns · 21/06/2022 18:07

Absolutely agree with you @ValerieDoonican

ValerieDoonican · 21/06/2022 13:50

I don't think you are being unreasonable not to want to be rung 4 times in the afternoon after seeing someone that morning. That is very weird and way too much.

And I'm not impressed by the guilt tripping "oh youll miss them when they're gone".

The fact that everyone's life is of a finite span, is not a reason for us to be dickish to our sons and daughters in law while we are alive. I'd be mortified if you told me I was going to be ringing my son's home this often , and would be interrogating my grandchildren daily about their private lives.

I didn't have children in order for them to service my needs every few hours. I want them to have their own lives.

And the ringing repeatedly when there's no answer?? There is not a lot of tolerance for entitled behaviour elsewhere on Mumsnet - but entitled is exactly what it is.

Snuffy28 · 21/06/2022 13:35

I've just realized that she has a husband. But she obviously craves contact with your family and it won't hurt you to be kind. Realistically, it won't be for many more years.

Snuffy28 · 21/06/2022 13:28

Campervangirl · 16/06/2022 20:13

Yep, she's lonely.
My dm (84) has just died, I'd give anything to talk to her again 💔
Us old folk are annoying but we just need our families and to feel loved.
Remember that inside that 80+ year old body is the young girl she was, full of love and feelings. ❤️

I agree with this. One day you'll be old yourself and I'm sure you'd be hurt if you knew that a family member was refusing to pick up the phone.

Of course you're busy, but have a bit of compassion.

Once people get to that age, it's entirely possible that some close friends have died. Your mother-in-law may not have anyone else to talk to.

CowEmergency911 · 21/06/2022 13:21

Instead of letting this drive a wedge (such as being mad she calls during week but complain abt calling on the weekend as well), why not talk to her. Explain you are busy & set a time once or twice a week where you do have a few mins to spare. And if dh doesn't have a problem, that's wonderful for both, let him call/deal w her. Doesn't have to bitter. But one day, you will all miss those calls.

UncaDonald · 21/06/2022 10:09

Unplug the landline. Most people don't use them anyway and only have the line for broadband. That way she'll just ring DH mobile and job done.

AmberSkye72 · 21/06/2022 02:27

I understand how frustrating this may seem to you.

She may be lonely AND she may not even realize how often she has called, how often she has talked or how often she has asked question(S).

This is something we had been through multiple times with elderly & not so elderly but a younger person with early onset dementia

If this is how she has always been but more excessive or a newer gradual thing then you may want to consider having her checked.

Brefugee · 20/06/2022 18:54

not sure if this has been said before: have you actually told her to stop?

Sparkletastic · 20/06/2022 18:39

Christ that's so invasive. I'd not answer the phone and encourage DH to agree that he will call her daily or whatever he's prepared to do. Once he has to deal with all the interruptions unaided he might decide to have a discussion with her about reasonable boundaries.

MouseRoar · 20/06/2022 18:36

my mil is 85, lives alove and is, I am quite sure, lonely from time to time. We visit with the kids once a fortnight and my husband phones her twice a week or so.
What you are describing is waaay too much and a good way to push people away, in my opinion. No advice but loads of sympathy for you here

SmartCarDriver · 20/06/2022 18:28

iRun2eatCake · 16/06/2022 20:10

Is it your mobile she phones? If so block
If it's the landline, let it go to answerphone

Bloody hell that's awful

ssd · 20/06/2022 18:21

True

Holly60 · 19/06/2022 23:31

I do feel for you OP, it's bloody hard. But do try to remember that ageing is horrific. Having watched close family members get to their 80s and 90s and just completely change personality really. Become needy, demanding and frustrated. Having seen several people with very different personalities basically display the same behaviour as they got older I realised it's just a reaction to getting old and infirm. As a society we don't talk about it enough which makes it really tough for the old person and their families.

Do remember as well, your children are learning how to treat you when you get old. And it will happen to you.

turquoise1988 · 19/06/2022 20:30

OP you don't seem to have acknowledged the many posters, including myself, who have raised dementia as a possibility?

The fact that you went there this morning, and she called four times this afternoon to make random chat...come on! Something clearly isn't right here.

Your posts all seem full of frustration and assumption that she is doing this because she wants to annoy you. I would put money on the fact that her brain health is deteriorating.

It is not up to you to say anything, but maybe your DH should try and broach the subject sensitively with your FIL.

ZekeZeke · 19/06/2022 19:28

Many of us have asked the same question, could your MIL have dementia?
The constant phoning is jumping out at me. A person suffering with Alzheimer's for example short term memory can be affected.
Perhaps bring this up with your DH and have him discuss with your FIL/MIL.

If she doesn't and she is just being a pain with the constant phoning the mere suggestion of Dementia might stop her in her tracks!

LicoricePizza · 19/06/2022 19:02

MajorCarolDanvers · 19/06/2022 11:08

Speak to Age UK and get her hooked up with a befriending service.

That’s a great idea.

Safarigiraffe · 19/06/2022 18:09

We ALL went round today to see them, gave FIL his gift for Father’s Day today, yet since 130pm when we left MIL has phoned us 4 times more just to make random talk so I actually after the 2nd time of getting the phone told my husband to get the phone - I have no issue with MIL phoning but when we have been there morning and come home to relax as a family to eat dinner (after all it’s DH Father’s Day too) & MIL phones 4 times more to chat about random things it’s becoming too much (loads of family/friends around her she definitely is not lonely)

OP posts:
thebabessavedme · 19/06/2022 12:26

I kind of get it OP, my parents are in their 80s, in poor health and are currently driving us all mad, they are doolally (not dementia, just doolally) they always have been but now its just getting worse, my mum needs me to help her physically, my dad wants to go to pub everyday with ALL of us or he goes stir crazy, however, they are in their 80s, this will not go on for ever, they love us, we love them (and tbf they do give us a never ending amount of things to laugh about, the fuck wittery will go on to be legend within the family! Grin) We all try to accomodate their wants and needs in the knowledge that the time of having them in our lives is becoming short, so basically, suck it up buttercup, she is 85 afterall

JubileeTrifle · 19/06/2022 11:33

Why is everything dementia on these threads. I think sometimes people do things because they can and they get into the routine of things and can’t get out of them.
I imagine it starts as a novelty and turns into a habit. Before we had mobile phones we couldn’t do this, so we didn’t. We’ve all got in the habit of being constantly in contact with each other because we can.

my friends dad is doing the same. He isn’t even that old. He has been widowed a long time and has retired. He’s bored and is having trouble finding structure to his day, so he rings my friend incessantly, especially now she works from home. There’s no issue mentally. He’s just got into the habit. She has to find projects/jobs for him to do to keep him occupied. Now she’s moved closer he keeps turning up because he can.

NumberTheory · 19/06/2022 11:23

*it's his choice to prioritise time with you over a non-urgent request from his mum

Err, wrong way round!

it's his choice to prioritise a non-urgent request from his mum over time with you.

NumberTheory · 19/06/2022 11:20

Given it doesn't sound like there is a cause (like loss of FiL) for the increase in calls and they are excessive and it sounds like a obsessive, I would probably assume it was a sign of deteriorating mental faculties.

Is there anyway to suggest that she gets dementia screening that won't go down like a lead balloon?

I don't think you can reasonably stop her calling. You need to find a way to adjust how you think about it and manage it so it doesn't impact too negatively on your life.

If your DH wants to go round to see her - is that maybe because he's worried about how she's changed? Or has he always put her before you and your kids? To some extent I think you need to treat this aspect separately from her calling constantly - he may be responding to her calls, but it seems it's his choice to prioritise time with you over a non-urgent request from his mum that's the really issue with that. What;s the reason behind that choice? A concern for his mum, or a lack of concern for you?

MajorCarolDanvers · 19/06/2022 11:08

Speak to Age UK and get her hooked up with a befriending service.