Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shall I push my daughter to keep up her dancing?

57 replies

Greenginghamdress · 16/06/2022 15:10

Hi all.

Hoping for quick advice as the class is tonight! My daughter has attended dancing for just over a year. She's made friends and seems to enjoy it.
Her interest has been tailing off the last few weeks though and today she has told me she doesn't want to go anymore. Apparently she doesn't like the teacher and it's too strict? It doesn't seem to be.

I have noticed that she doesnt seem to have a natural skill for it and the other week she poured juice on the floor just before the class started (the teacher was not happy and I told her off off this at home).

I'm wondering what to do as have made friends there myself with other mums. I don't want to be pushy and force her but this is her only hobby. It is however, very expensive and they have a show coming up in autumn which will be lots of rehersals and extra coat for costumes etc. She is 4.5 so pretty little.

Aibu?
YABU- tell her she has to go
YANBU- accept and don't send her

Thank you!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Miss2018 · 16/06/2022 18:35

I don’t think you can call spending time with your child doing fun activities abusive. And it’s offensive.

We did messy play as a baby, it was fun, got us it the house and made friends which later became a toddler class where you went once a week and tried new skills together; sometimes it was ballet, sometimes gymnastics, sometimes taekwondo. It lasted 30 minutes once a week. She obviously stopped going to this once she started school and I was back at work.

I am a piano teacher so we did basics together at home as she watched me play until she said she’d rather play violin at school as her friends were in the after school club (I don’t think 30 minutes a week is bad). She also does art class in after school club on a different day as I don’t finish work until 5 to pick her up.

Swimming is an essential life skill.(obviously 2 years gap for covid when it was closed).

Over the last 6 years she’s been to 1 baby toddler class, 2 after school clubs and swimming. If she didn’t want to do them I would let her go to the homework club or something else in school but to be honest she enjoys doing these things with her friends in after school club and I’d be at work anyway.

Gizlotsmum · 16/06/2022 18:05

I’d give it till the end of this term then decide, it may be she didn’t like being told off and that’s the trigger, it might just not be her thing. My kids have both gone through phases of wanting to stop something, normally by the end of the term that decision has been settled on either way ( often with them continuing)

Malbecfan · 16/06/2022 17:59

There are some massive generalisations here.

My older DD was desperate to learn ballet before her 3rd birthday. She loved Tweenies, particularly Fizz, and because Fizz danced, DD1 had to. I asked my year 9 students if any of them knew of a dance teacher for almost 3 year olds and one piped up with "Try my teacher, Miss. She's brilliant." We did, and DD stayed there until she was 18 and left to go to university. DD studied ballet and tap, then aged 15 started a pointe class. Now she's 22 and does acrobatic rock & roll. However, lots of the children who started with DD got fed up, preferred other activities or moved away. It's not a problem. I most definitely did not force DD to dance. She also asked for a cello when she was 3 (I am a music teacher so DD spent quite a lot of time watching DH and me performing). We relented when she was 4, and again, she stuck that out until she left school, with regular lessons and playing in different groups. These activities gave her a much wider circle of friends than simply her school ones.

DH and I wanted our DDs to learn an instrument, but beyond that we didn't really mind what they did. We did remind them about being reliable and putting in practice between lessons, and other than the skills they learned, they picked up some life lessons. The poster who thinks they would be happier at home with their crayons would have bored my now adult DDs to death.

SweetSakura · 16/06/2022 17:42

There are some real black and white views about hobbies in this thread.

My daughter insisted on signing up to theatre school age 3. She was doing baby ballet and could hear the fun they were having in the room next door and asked me if she could try it. She went once and was very clear she wanted to keep doing it. She insisted on auditioning for her first show aged 3.5 and had spoken her first line on stage at age 4. I am sure some people thought I was a pushy mum but far from it. The drive all came from her. She's still loving being part of a theatre school years later. She has a group of friends she has grown up with and a wonderful confidence that comes from having a passion.

I never saw it as any different from her big sister who built complex Lego models before she started school and had a huge passion for learning about space.

In each case they also did plenty of mucking about with friends and playing too.

But yes, if your daughter really hates it then I wouldnt make a four year old persevere

Anothernamechangeplease · 16/06/2022 17:35

I think the key is to understand your own child, and not to project your own preferences and expectations on to them.

As a child, I was shy and happiest at home with a book. I didn't want to do a ton of activities, I just wanted to do my own thing or play with my closest friends. My dd was the opposite of that. She was happy to read and entertain herself when she needed to, but she is way more extroverted than I am and enjoys external stimulation, so she loved nothing better than being in a big organised group. I expect some of you might have considered her to be overscheduled as a young child (or even now tbh) but it was very much led by her and based on what she needed. If anything, I was the one who found it all a bit too much, and it was a constant negotiation with her about how much she should be allowed to take on.

Funnily enough, it doesn't appear to have inhibited the development of her social skills in the slightest @MsTSwift. If anything, it has probably helped to develop them - she is socially very confident and has lots of lovely friends. Perhaps your friend's dc would have been even more awkward without that early exposure...we shall never know!

OrangeBagel · 16/06/2022 17:34

If she doesn’t want to go, don’t make her go. Simple as that really. I’m sure she’ll find something else she’d rather do.

Alb0 · 16/06/2022 17:32

Greenginghamdress · 16/06/2022 17:27

Oh dear. I do not want to get rid of my child at all and she's not a project! She's extremely energetic and she always seemed to enjoy activities. She's also my only so I feel I need to keep her busy so she doesn't get bored with me and her dad for company. But I'm aware this may not be a good idea.

Regarding the juice incident, it appears she did it deliberately which I think was not on, so was letting her know that.

I thank everyone for your advice, its good to hear other insights.

She probably wants to do activities - with you and her dad. At home. No child gets bored with their parents. As long as she has friends in the neighbourhood or at school. And has books, crayons etc at home.

Would a child really spill juice deliberately? Think about that. That doesn't even make any sense. Unless she herself said she spilled juice deliberately.

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 16/06/2022 17:29

Haha! I can still picture my DD aged 5, all indignant in a ballet class and shouting back at the bloody awful (Miss Trunchbull) teacher "You aren't supposed to shout at children like that, you are supposed to be kind and encouraging".
We never went back.

Greenginghamdress · 16/06/2022 17:27

Oh dear. I do not want to get rid of my child at all and she's not a project! She's extremely energetic and she always seemed to enjoy activities. She's also my only so I feel I need to keep her busy so she doesn't get bored with me and her dad for company. But I'm aware this may not be a good idea.

Regarding the juice incident, it appears she did it deliberately which I think was not on, so was letting her know that.

I thank everyone for your advice, its good to hear other insights.

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 16/06/2022 17:27

My 4yo is currently running in and out between trampoline and paddling pool covered in dirt and mainlining squash.

Biscuitsandpizza · 16/06/2022 17:23

MsTSwift · 16/06/2022 17:14

Be careful my friend over scheduled hers so they never learned how to knock about with others kids and make friends - they are struggling socially as young teens now. She thought she was doing the right thing and was very smug about their great lists of activities - but you can take this too far.

Be careful of confusing correlation with causation here.

Being over-scheduled presumably meant that they met lots of new people and mixed with many, it might not have been the cause of them struggling socially as teens, there can be a multitude of reasons for that happening.

@Greenginghamdress I think you're doing the right thing, be led by your own daughter and what you think she needs. Some parents gasp in horror at kids having hobbies, and some gasp in horror at kids having none. The truth is, what works for some will be different for others, so all you can do is what you think is right.

Alb0 · 16/06/2022 17:21

MsTSwift · 16/06/2022 17:14

Be careful my friend over scheduled hers so they never learned how to knock about with others kids and make friends - they are struggling socially as young teens now. She thought she was doing the right thing and was very smug about their great lists of activities - but you can take this too far.

Yes, just read Miss2018's post above. Disgraceful and sad. It's clearly about getting rid of the child and keeping the child 'busy' so they are out of the adults hair. I've come across parents like this, it's quite abusive. The children are the one who suffer because they cannot relate to other kids and have little relationship with their parents. They pretend they are happy because they don't want to offend their parents, who they desperately just want the love of, and to spend time with, instead of being sent away all the time.

MsTSwift · 16/06/2022 17:14

Be careful my friend over scheduled hers so they never learned how to knock about with others kids and make friends - they are struggling socially as young teens now. She thought she was doing the right thing and was very smug about their great lists of activities - but you can take this too far.

Anothernamechangeplease · 16/06/2022 17:13

Alb0 · 16/06/2022 17:09

so thinking of pursuing something else.

How about just letting her be, instead of signing her up for anything? She's 4 years old! Not a project.

How about letting her mum follow her instincts about what's right for her daughter?

Some 4yos want to be left just to "be" and that's absolutely fine. Some want and need more external stimulation. And that's fine too.

I'm sure that the OP is not treating her dd as a project in the slightest, just trying to expose her to a variety of things that she might enjoy.

Miss2018 · 16/06/2022 17:10

At that age my daughter had been through ballet, gymnastics, taekwondo, swimming, piano, messy play etc once she got bored we swapped. She’s now 6 and has settled on swimming, fine art class and violin for the last year. I don’t regret her doing those things, she really enjoyed herself and learned a lot and it helped her find what she really wanted to do ultimately

Alb0 · 16/06/2022 17:09

Greenginghamdress · 16/06/2022 17:07

Thanks everyone. This is actually not the first time she has said it. We had tears today so I haven't taken her. We have paid for up to next week and I've told her if it's a no next week, then that's it done for now.
She's more the kind of child who enjoys bikes, football and parks so thinking of pursuing something else. Or she can pick up dancing again later.
I remember dancing lessons when I was young and it wasn't my thing so I left it, then started back at 11 or 12.
And of course it's nothing to do with the mums I've made friends with. It was just as I've found it hard to make mum friends over the years and these were the first, but obviously it's not about me!
DD is also one of the youngest in the class and it may be a lot for her.

so thinking of pursuing something else.

How about just letting her be, instead of signing her up for anything? She's 4 years old! Not a project.

Greenginghamdress · 16/06/2022 17:07

Thanks everyone. This is actually not the first time she has said it. We had tears today so I haven't taken her. We have paid for up to next week and I've told her if it's a no next week, then that's it done for now.
She's more the kind of child who enjoys bikes, football and parks so thinking of pursuing something else. Or she can pick up dancing again later.
I remember dancing lessons when I was young and it wasn't my thing so I left it, then started back at 11 or 12.
And of course it's nothing to do with the mums I've made friends with. It was just as I've found it hard to make mum friends over the years and these were the first, but obviously it's not about me!
DD is also one of the youngest in the class and it may be a lot for her.

OP posts:
Alb0 · 16/06/2022 17:06

Merryoldgoat · 16/06/2022 16:58

Is this a joke? You told a 4 year old off spilling a drink?

And you’re worried she’s not very skilled?

Yep, and the 4 year old was upset that her teacher told her off, it affected the 4 year old little girl so much that she no longer wants to dance. No 4 year old small child should be told off for spilling a drink. That's what they do! It sounds like the teacher is a bit of a monster and the mother doesn't understand that it's normal for 4 year old little girls to spill drinks. They expect perfection and body/muscle/motor control at all of 4 years. No wonder the girl has been upset and wants to quit.

Toottooot · 16/06/2022 17:00

Sounds like you want her to keep going for your benefit as you don’t want to lose the friendships of the other mums. Poor geet.

Merryoldgoat · 16/06/2022 16:58

Is this a joke? You told a 4 year old off spilling a drink?

And you’re worried she’s not very skilled?

Lonecatwithkitten · 16/06/2022 16:54

Finish the term then stop, as others have said she should enjoy it.
Just because she stops now doesn't mean she won't take it up again. My DD had an on/off relationship with dance (all types) starting and stopping several times between the ages of 4 and 14. At 14 she had a light bulb moment and is now moving onto a degree that has all dance styles at it's core.

Alb0 · 16/06/2022 16:53

zingally · 16/06/2022 16:45

Christ, at the beginning of your post I thought you were going to say she was 11 or 12!
She's 4! Of course she can quit if she doesn't like it. Try something else. Surely one of the joys of being 4 is being able to try out lots of different things?

Or try nothing at all. Just let her be a 4 year old, without signing her up to anything.

zingally · 16/06/2022 16:45

Christ, at the beginning of your post I thought you were going to say she was 11 or 12!
She's 4! Of course she can quit if she doesn't like it. Try something else. Surely one of the joys of being 4 is being able to try out lots of different things?

BlackCatTabbyCat · 16/06/2022 16:29

It depends how serious you think she is about not wanting to go. When my oldest daughter was that age she often said she didn't want to go but she did enjoy it when there so I continued to send her and now she's 10 and dancing at a competitive level. My youngest daughter has just turned 5 and didn't want to go to one of her dance classes and was really upset I couldn't even bribe her so I didn't force her and pulled her from that class.

Also my oldest didn't have a natural skill either it's took a lot of years and a lot of work to get her to the level she is now.

ForestofD · 16/06/2022 16:20

I would persevere for another lesson or two then give up.

My oldest pestered me constantly when she was 3 to go to ballet. I don't dance, it wasn't even something I'd considered, she was way to young etc etc. She watched a ballet DVD and she wanted to do it more than anything.

I relented and 12 years later, she's still going. I never in a month of Sundays expected to be a ballet Mum. I work extra hours to cover the lessons and the only time she's missed in 12 years was with a small injury a few months ago.

If they love it, they love it. Give her a little time but if it's not for her now, she may come back to it later. The ballet teacher also made lessons really fun. I still remember the stretches being 'Goodbye Toes, Hello Toes....'

Swipe left for the next trending thread