Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Pick-Up Artists" in the street - AIBU?

110 replies

nadan · 16/06/2022 14:36

Has anyone ever been targeted by one of these so-called "PUA" because I think I might have been today. This was in High St, Kensington, but also a similar thing happened here a few months ago and possibly also in Hammersmith. Bearing in mind I am 47! They come up and ask if you live locally, so you expect they're going to ask directions or something. But then they start walking with you and it's hard to explain why, but it's hard to get away from them. A 'technique' seems to be to try to find something in common - "like, oh I've just moved to this area too." Then it's waffle to try and strike a rapport.

I just said "sorry I'm late for work' (god knows why I said this because I don't even work). Then they ask what you do... then they do something similar. .. then it's "shall we go for lunch, have you got time?" I just looked at the guy and said "I am 47 years old." I swear to god he was not a day over 35, possibly younger. But he didn't seem at all phased.

AIBU to think this was a PUA and he was 'training?' And maybe someone was filming him? The other alternative was that he was trying to find a desperate local woman who would be delighted to take him home and then he could rob her? There are so many crazy people on the streets and it's getting worse. Anyone else been mystified by this?

OP posts:
Orchardsandpianos · 17/06/2022 09:13

IrisVersicolor · 17/06/2022 01:29

Men hit on women all the time. Men sexually harass women all the time.

Using the term PUA for a man who may or may not have anything to do with the PUA bollocks is cringe. It’s trying to sound worldly but sounding naive.

You tell me to look on Reddit when I already mentioned Reddit in my post - but the rabbit holes of misogyny online are actually endless.

IMO women can call men who try to harass them in the streets whatever names they want

Because the harassment is the behaviour we should be criticising here, not being pedantic about the words women use to describe their harassers

CaptSkippy · 17/06/2022 07:59

IrisVersicolor · 16/06/2022 23:11

Men try to pick up women, always will, always have. Some clumsily weirdly obsessively. Whether or not one particular bloke read a particular book/influenced by a particular fad is really neither here nor there.

The real question is why MNers insist on such labels - PUA, Wendy, narc etc.

I am sure no one here does. That's what they call themselves. They still hold these stupid seminars and then go out in groups to hassle women in the streets. Often times they will film each other harassing women for some reason.

Ohhhhladz · 17/06/2022 03:54

Borisblondboufant · 16/06/2022 19:53

I think when you aren’t attractive men speaking to you randomly is a very strange thing.

Do you really? I find that being sexually harassed - which is what this thread is about - actually happens much, much more when I look like absolute crap: tired, sick, out in very casual clothes, wet hair, no makeup, on the way home from a workout, etc. Of course there's a lot of misogynist shite all the time, but let's do Occam's Razor here: there are a whole shite tonne of reasons why you get sexually harassed - and geography is a really big factor - but being attractive is really only significant in that you are attractive to predators. That's not - for most women, you certainly may be an exception - a good or welcomed or desirable thing.

UniversalAunt · 17/06/2022 03:32

Tell them you are out on licence & speaking to any man under 50yo breaks your probation.

But then that might make them keener…

PlantSpider · 17/06/2022 03:16

The reasons these posts are showing up is because it’s a different tactic that women are noticing. We’re all used to the common or garden type but instinct says this is a bit different and that’s why these threads pop up. Knowledge is power. Some of these twats actually use their tactics once they’re in a relationship and it helps some women to recognise the weird backhanded compliments. Anyway, ignore the thread police.

PlantSpider · 17/06/2022 03:14

IrisVersicolor · 17/06/2022 01:29

Men hit on women all the time. Men sexually harass women all the time.

Using the term PUA for a man who may or may not have anything to do with the PUA bollocks is cringe. It’s trying to sound worldly but sounding naive.

You tell me to look on Reddit when I already mentioned Reddit in my post - but the rabbit holes of misogyny online are actually endless.

Cringe? That sounds like something a teenager would say. But who cares about someone thinking what we’re saying sounds cringe. We’re not trying to impress anyone here. It’s women sharing experiences.

pipping · 17/06/2022 02:28

I don’t think I’ve ever heard the term before but how awful! How dare these men think they have a right to harass women who are going about their business?

Sometimes I am grateful to be ugly.

Maybe there’s an argument that men need to be able to try and find a potential partner but this is not the way to go about it!

sleepingophelia · 17/06/2022 01:34

You tell me to look on Reddit when I already mentioned Reddit in my post - but the rabbit holes of misogyny online are actually endless.

I didn't tell you to look on Reddit, just to notice the number of sites and forums for PUA including Reddit, while you were noting the number of titles of books specifically written by and for PUAs.

I think most women can tell when they are being hit on, and when it is quasi-appropriate/sincere albeit misguided, and when it is plain confusing and weird.

PUAs exist. PUA classes exist. And telling people off for using a correct label - and in my experience, naming is power - is silly.

IrisVersicolor · 17/06/2022 01:29

Men hit on women all the time. Men sexually harass women all the time.

Using the term PUA for a man who may or may not have anything to do with the PUA bollocks is cringe. It’s trying to sound worldly but sounding naive.

You tell me to look on Reddit when I already mentioned Reddit in my post - but the rabbit holes of misogyny online are actually endless.

sleepingophelia · 17/06/2022 00:30

Men try to pick up women, always will, always have. Some clumsily weirdly obsessively. Whether or not one particular bloke read a particular book/influenced by a particular fad is really neither here nor there.
The real question is why MNers insist on such labels - PUA, Wendy, narc etc.

I'm sort of grasping your point is we on MN should not use the term PUA, for men who describe themselves as PUA, who attend little classes held by men who describe themselves as expert PUAs and then go out on the street to practice their PUA techniques on women, any women, using them as course experiences as if they were plastic dummies in a resuscitation class.

We should not use the term PUA because there are other random creepy chancers about - amateurs! - and we should also not use any other easy shorthand terms for describing easily recognisable types, because... ?

EmmaH2022 · 17/06/2022 00:20

Iris it started forever ago but it's still very much a thing.

sleepingophelia · 17/06/2022 00:18

Oh, what is the point, wise one?!

IrisVersicolor · 17/06/2022 00:16

sleepingophelia · 17/06/2022 00:11

PUAs aren’t really a thing outside MN though

You might want to tell that to the men who are writing the books, and selling the classes!

Type "pick up artists book" into Google, and also notice the number of forum links to sites like reddit with PUA forums, etc etc. "15 Best PUA Books for Men Ever Written" shows just a few of the offerings.

<misses the point>

sleepingophelia · 17/06/2022 00:11

PUAs aren’t really a thing outside MN though

You might want to tell that to the men who are writing the books, and selling the classes!

Type "pick up artists book" into Google, and also notice the number of forum links to sites like reddit with PUA forums, etc etc. "15 Best PUA Books for Men Ever Written" shows just a few of the offerings.

ThreeLocusts · 17/06/2022 00:06

I once had a couple of Mormon missionaries try PUA techniques on me, in central Edinburgh. 'So what's your favourite sight?' etc. Somehow you can just tell they're following a script.

Luckily my grandfather (parish priest by profession) had a copy of the book of Mormon that I'd read (tried to read- boooring) as a kid, so I could inform them that I knew what they were about and definitely not interested.

I think you're right OP, PUA out on training mission.

Cookingutensil · 16/06/2022 23:19

Pick Up Artist? Ugh, horrible terminology, call it what it is; sexual harassment, sex pest, misogynist etc. Let's not use the language of abusers.

Sorry to hear OP and sorry that women have to be forever on guard for creeps.

IrisVersicolor · 16/06/2022 23:11

CaptSkippy · 16/06/2022 23:04

Unfortunately PUA's are on the rise again. They have a lower profile now, as many of them know they are not welcome in many venues. At least they are less brazen and many people now know they exist.

Men try to pick up women, always will, always have. Some clumsily weirdly obsessively. Whether or not one particular bloke read a particular book/influenced by a particular fad is really neither here nor there.

The real question is why MNers insist on such labels - PUA, Wendy, narc etc.

CaptSkippy · 16/06/2022 23:04

IrisVersicolor · 16/06/2022 22:49

PUAs aren’t really a thing outside MN though, it’s very dated. There are men. There are weird men. There are men who try to pick you up weirdly. Some may have swallowed PUA stuff. The influence on the weird ones is now more porn, Reddit, incel, MGTOW, Jordan Peterson etc.

Unfortunately PUA's are on the rise again. They have a lower profile now, as many of them know they are not welcome in many venues. At least they are less brazen and many people now know they exist.

IrisVersicolor · 16/06/2022 22:49

PUAs aren’t really a thing outside MN though, it’s very dated. There are men. There are weird men. There are men who try to pick you up weirdly. Some may have swallowed PUA stuff. The influence on the weird ones is now more porn, Reddit, incel, MGTOW, Jordan Peterson etc.

MattoMatto · 16/06/2022 21:09

They often advocate travelling abroad to places like eastern europe of south america as the women are less hostile to being approached (sexually harrased) there apparently.

This thread took me back to living in Brazil when I was younger. Very, very normal there for men to walk with you, follow you, ask hotel receptionists for your room number or your neighbours to let them into your apartment building. They haven’t been on courses, it’s just a totally shit part of the culture. So it’s lovely to hear that these losers are taking advantage of the crap women in these parts of the world already face.

WhoppingBigBackside · 16/06/2022 20:56

It happens to me a lot. I pretend I don't speak English. It usually works

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 16/06/2022 20:44

Dd got this in the European city she’s been living in. Found a little park she’d not been too, sat having a coffee and a read. This guy cycled up and gave this line about how he’d just moved there, he didn’t speak the language (she was reading an English book) in his culture sharing food was a way of making friends, would she come for lunch. She got rid, but then noticed him calling someone, he was not far away, and heard him say “no, she wouldn’t.... I could I guess, I can still see her” she got in her bike and cycled home like the clappers.she was pissed off she wouldn’t go back to that park.

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 16/06/2022 20:13

DD lives in a big city and frequently gets called after in the street (girl you are peng!) or winked at. It doesn't bother her that much as it's fit, cheeky, young men having a laugh. However she recently got hassled in our local small town by a really creepy guy who wanted to strike up a conversation with her and wouldn't go away.
In the end she started to yell "can I have some help please, this man is hassling me" and about a dozen passers by stopped to help.

EnjoythemoneyJane · 16/06/2022 20:04

Yes, definitely a thing. As you suspected, OP, almost certainly a PUA ‘in training’ - he’s likely to have been being observed (possibly even listened to) by the twat running it and any other participants.

Had this on Charing Cross Road a few years back. The guy was offering up excessive compliments (“I crossed the road just to tell you how beautiful you are”, etc), walking beside me for quite a distance, even managed to touch me (picked up my hand and asked if my wedding ring meant I was married).

It was creepy AF and very disconcerting, although I didn’t realise what exactly was going on until afterwards, when I saw an article in the Sunday Times about it. The more women who learn to recognise this manipulative, predatory, incel BS the better - we should definitely be calling it out.

Christ, when will it ever end?

Borisblondboufant · 16/06/2022 19:53

I think when you aren’t attractive men speaking to you randomly is a very strange thing.