Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the renters reform bill is going to kill people with allergies?

335 replies

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:29

Just that really. I know many people will see this as a good thing. I know too that the severity of allergy to pets which means they can kill you is rare. But it does happen. I am that severely allergic. So if landlords can't give a blanket ban then there are no pet-free properties for me to move into.

For those who don't know - antihistamines make no difference and the only way to get all allergens out of the place is to remove all soft furnishings including carpets and underlay. Deep cleaning things does not work. So unless the landlords change all carpets, curtains, sofas etc. in between tenants, then it still has enough allergens to trigger a life-threatening reaction. For me that reaction is asthma and I already see a hospital specialist so there is no further treatment that can be offered. Avoiding allergens is the key advice. I'm really worried that the full implications have not been thought through.

OP posts:
SmallPrawnEnergy · 16/06/2022 09:59

People lie about having pets all the time though so even if a landlord says “no pets” it doesn’t mean there hasn’t ever been pets. How would you negotiate this? Surely it’s a thought when you’re moving home or are you that naive?

Teder · 16/06/2022 09:59

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 09:56

It’s not about anaphylaxis. It’s about severe asthma.

I think some people are just responding to the “killing people” and not considering the impact of allergies on quality of life and health day to day.

AllCatsAreBeautiful · 16/06/2022 09:57

Would you prefer for pets to simply be banned from all properties in the UK, op? Because if somebody having had a pet in a property in the past is this bad, surely it also affects people buying and selling homes, not just renters?

I don’t think this would be a reasonable restriction on people — after all, having no pets would hugely impact on peoples’ MH, loneliness etc, so I think the health effects of dis-allowing pets would be worse. But I’m confused as to why you think this restriction should specifically apply to renters when presumably someone with dogs/cats selling their house is also a risk to people with severe allergies? Out of interest are you also a landlord?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 09:56

It’s not about anaphylaxis. It’s about severe asthma.

Katya213 · 16/06/2022 09:55

I don't want to come across rude but how do you live day to day, do you leave the house? Animals are everywhere.

andweallsingalong · 16/06/2022 09:54

I would have thought the bill would benefit you OP.

At the moment some renters are dishonest about having a pet due to the banning clause in their lease. Now these people have no excuse to be dishonest.

There will still be people who chose not to have pets and so pet free properties should be available, but at least now the landlord should be able to accurately tell you whether or not the tenant has had a pet or visiting pet.

crysania · 16/06/2022 09:51

I agree with the pps that you can't guarantee those 'pet free' homes were actually so, either because of visitors or pets not declared to the landlord.

If your allergy is particularly bad then it would make sense, as a precaution, to get any potential new house deep cleaned and laundered and opt for somewhere without carpeting if they cannot be cleaned to a safe level.

TheGoogleMum · 16/06/2022 09:51

As others have said most landlords would prefer not to rent to people with pets so where there is competition for a property those without pets will likely get priority. A few years ago before the rental market was as competitive as it is now we wanted to rent a place and it was between us and another couple- the landlord would accept pets (i happen to know those who rented after us got a cat) but the other couple had a dog so we were preferred as we had no pets at the time

Tiani4 · 16/06/2022 09:51

If the OP's allergy is that severe (as others have said, to be so allergic you can't even live in a property that once had a cat in it is as rare as a very rare thing) then appropriate housing would be facilitated by the local authorities

Sorry but this is so unrealistic ! And really seems to misunderstand housing legislation and realities.

Housing teams (usually under local borough council remit) have huge waiting lists - so an able-bodied independent person, even with a severe allergy, would be unlikely to get sufficient medical points enough to put them high priority on housing wait list- there's so many people who'd be above them for eg thousands of disabled people with mobility problems, hundreds of parents in temporary accomodation with children, all awaiting suitable housing ..

Even then, a housing association would very unlikely be able to guarantee the tenants before didn't have pets or visiting pets so they wouldn't promise that. They'd happily remove carpets but all other decoration or additional deep cleaning arrangements would be down to the tennant to arrange once they'd signed the tenancy and picked up keys.

I'm not sure how that is any more helpful to OP than private rental would be. There might be new build HA flats fresh off the builder site come up, but that can take years to wait for and well I guess it depends on the housing area / lists/ other priorities. As OP could equally try to find a new build to rent privately

It does seem OP's unlikely to be Care Act or continuing healthcare eligible unless OP has missed huge swaths of pretty serious relevant information!

Health are the only ones with significant responsibility here which is to treat / help medically manage her allergy. I wonder if OP also carries an epipen or whether it's not anaphylactic level?

Teder · 16/06/2022 09:45

YABU but I do have a lot of empathy because it must be really worrying and frustrating. On a statistical level, there won’t be many (any?) people who are so allergic that it will kill them. That said, I appreciate there will be far more people who will suffer with their allergies which will affect their quality of life.
With so many pet owners who rent, I suspect this is by far the larger group of people.

violetsanddaisies · 16/06/2022 09:43

Wouldn't the easiest solution be for you to rent an unfurnished property that isn't carpeted - wooden floors/laminate/vinyl/tiles are becoming more and more common and are much more hygienic anyway.

woodencoffetable · 16/06/2022 09:43

You can't guarantee an animal other than human has visited or lived in a home though. Firstly saying "no pets" does not guarantee the tenant will not get an animal to live with them, they can just ignore it in practise.

Secondly they are still very likely to have those with dogs come and visit, even stay over, which I don't even think is against the rules if the tenant is obligated to be pet free?

I think the difference will be as minimal as weed being illegal (in that those who want to smoke weed/live with cats or dogs will do it regardless of the law)

Chouetted · 16/06/2022 09:42

I think you may be in a better position, as you will be more likely to be able to ask whether pets have been in previously and get a truthful answer.

It must be very difficult for you though - I own no pets, but my house is not allergen free, since the local cats hang out in my garden and like to slip indoors when I'm not looking. I don't feed or water them, but I've had to evict a strange cat more than once!

OperationRinka · 16/06/2022 09:38

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 09:30

Unfortunately, it's ultimately the allergy sufferers responsibility to avoid or eliminate triggers from their environment

But how can they if every house is allowed pets?

Just because every house (except the ones with exemptions) is allowed pets it doesn't mean that every tenant will actually have pets. Anaphylaxis level allergies to pets are pretty rare but there are loads of families where one member has a milder allergy who will keep pet free homes..

Youaremysunshine14 · 16/06/2022 09:38

katkit · 16/06/2022 09:34

It’s not forcing landlords to say yes to pets, it’s just saying they can’t post ads saying NO PETS. In reality, I expect there will be plenty of landlords who still blanket ban them, just not so overtly.

I just read that renters will be able to challenge a landlord's refusal to let them have pets and the landlord has to come up with a good reason.

BunsyGirl · 16/06/2022 09:37

I have every sympathy with you OP. I also have a severe allergy to animals. For me dogs and horses are the worst and I have been hospitalised on several occasions after coming into contact with them. For people saying what about going to other peoples houses, pet friendly restaurants etc. The answer is that I can’t. It’s getting harder and harder to manage as more places are becoming dog friendly. The worst thing is that if I mention it to people they think that I don’t like their pets and are insulted. Just wish people would understand how ill their animals can make me. Would also be great if modern medicine could come up with a way of treating this.

katkit · 16/06/2022 09:34

It’s not forcing landlords to say yes to pets, it’s just saying they can’t post ads saying NO PETS. In reality, I expect there will be plenty of landlords who still blanket ban them, just not so overtly.

PansyPetunia · 16/06/2022 09:34

Prob been said

But replace carpet with laminate
Curtains for blinds
Not many places come furnished so s sofa would likely be your own

Be inventive op! You can make it work for you!

katkit · 16/06/2022 09:33

It’s not forcing landlords to say yes to pets, it’s just saying they can’t post ads saying NO PETS. In reality, I expect there will be plenty of landlords who still blanket ban them, just not so overtly.

ShirleyPhallus · 16/06/2022 09:33

But dictating that I'm not allowed to own a dog simply because I'm a millennial who hasn't yet managed to get on the property ladder? Sod off

It isn’t a human right to own a dog you know

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 09:33

Yes it’s a disability.

Youaremysunshine14 · 16/06/2022 09:32

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 09:20

And where are ‘the tiny minority’ supposed to live? Don’t their disabilities count?

Is an allergy a disability? I swear I'm not being goady, it's a genuine question because I didn't know they were classified as that.

I'm not saying the rights of those with allergies should be ignored. Maybe they should strike out the pets clause in the Bill. But the rest of it is a brilliant step forward for the rights of renters.

IncessantNameChanger · 16/06/2022 09:31

RampantIvy · 16/06/2022 07:37

Wow. I'm surprised at the responses. I'm sure there are landlords who won't want to rent to pet owners.

I think that's the point OP is trying to make. Landlords choices are going to be removed in regards who they rent too.

Yes landlords will just sell up instead.

OP your only choice is to completely remove and replace all carpets at your own expense. That's your only guarantee but I'd not want to do that in a house I didnt own. My carpets are 20 years old in our rented house. I'm not paying for new ones

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 09:30

Unfortunately, it's ultimately the allergy sufferers responsibility to avoid or eliminate triggers from their environment

But how can they if every house is allowed pets?

OperationRinka · 16/06/2022 09:30

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 09:20

And where are ‘the tiny minority’ supposed to live? Don’t their disabilities count?

They live in homes where the previous tenant didn't have a pet (probably with a better certainty that they wouldn't have been lying about it to avoid eviction).
Or they live in homes where the landlord has an exemption certificate.
Or they live in unfurnished homes with hard floors and get them deep cleaned before moving in.