Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the renters reform bill is going to kill people with allergies?

335 replies

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:29

Just that really. I know many people will see this as a good thing. I know too that the severity of allergy to pets which means they can kill you is rare. But it does happen. I am that severely allergic. So if landlords can't give a blanket ban then there are no pet-free properties for me to move into.

For those who don't know - antihistamines make no difference and the only way to get all allergens out of the place is to remove all soft furnishings including carpets and underlay. Deep cleaning things does not work. So unless the landlords change all carpets, curtains, sofas etc. in between tenants, then it still has enough allergens to trigger a life-threatening reaction. For me that reaction is asthma and I already see a hospital specialist so there is no further treatment that can be offered. Avoiding allergens is the key advice. I'm really worried that the full implications have not been thought through.

OP posts:
GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:47

Kerrangutan · 16/06/2022 12:39

@ShirleyPhallus your points basically sum up everything that's wrong with amateur landlords to be honest.

You can't have pets because they might piss on the sofa which will then have to be professionally cleaned WHICH IS A STANDARD TENANT COST ANYWAY according to you. And that still somehow equals less profit for you?

Imagine charging someone £1000 a month give or take for the privilege of sitting on a sofa other people have probably fucked all over and spilled their dinner on and A) thinking that it only needs professionally cleaned if it smells of cat piss and B) being able to sleep at night.

If having to refresh the decor every few years (which most homeowners do anyway) is such an issue for profits then it's probably time to find another business venture that doesn't rely on people not being allowed to live a basic life just to keep the business afloat.

Imagine other businesses started doing this. "Sorry, I know we're a cafe but if we implement basic hygiene rules we just won't be profitable anymore - so we're only going to serve people who don't care about that or are so desperate that they have to come to us anyway hehehe."

You wouldn't put up with it in the place you eat so why the fuck are we putting up with it in the places we live?
The whole system should never have been allowed to get this unregulated in the first place.

You are 100% spot on.

The only thing I might disagree with you on is that I think that corporate landlords risk being just as bad as amateur ones (imagine the call centre hell of getting repairs organised).

To my mind the best landlords are small time landlords who are very professional.

The next best are probably corporate who are very professional

Next best are small time landlords who are somewhat professional.

Next best are corporate landlords who are somewhat professional.

The worst landlords are probably all amateurs who don;t get that they are providing a service and have a moral and legal duty to be professional. I doubt many big landlords are as bad as the worst, entitled, amateurs.

ShirleyPhallus · 16/06/2022 12:46

Kerrangutan · 16/06/2022 12:39

@ShirleyPhallus your points basically sum up everything that's wrong with amateur landlords to be honest.

You can't have pets because they might piss on the sofa which will then have to be professionally cleaned WHICH IS A STANDARD TENANT COST ANYWAY according to you. And that still somehow equals less profit for you?

Imagine charging someone £1000 a month give or take for the privilege of sitting on a sofa other people have probably fucked all over and spilled their dinner on and A) thinking that it only needs professionally cleaned if it smells of cat piss and B) being able to sleep at night.

If having to refresh the decor every few years (which most homeowners do anyway) is such an issue for profits then it's probably time to find another business venture that doesn't rely on people not being allowed to live a basic life just to keep the business afloat.

Imagine other businesses started doing this. "Sorry, I know we're a cafe but if we implement basic hygiene rules we just won't be profitable anymore - so we're only going to serve people who don't care about that or are so desperate that they have to come to us anyway hehehe."

You wouldn't put up with it in the place you eat so why the fuck are we putting up with it in the places we live?
The whole system should never have been allowed to get this unregulated in the first place.

Tenants do not deep clean sofas as standard when they move out. They pay for a standard end of tenancy clean which usually doesn’t include sofas.

I didn’t say that landlords wouldn’t redecorate every few years at all? I was responding very specifically to the poster who said that landlords should run their properties as businesses. Every business owner runs it in the most profitable way possible, ie lowest cost and highest margins. Allowing pets in to a property DOES cost the landlord more.

Ive already explained I allow pets in my property. I support tenants being allowed to live a quiet and enjoyable life in their home. I also support landlords protecting their asset as best they can. The law should fall evenly on the rights of both parties.

jesus there are some angry people on this thread

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:42

ShirleyPhallus · 16/06/2022 12:22

Minor damage adds up a lot over time to much bigger issues, such as needing to redecorate more regularly. You’re the one who said landlords should run their properties as professional businesses - I am pointing out how it is less profitable to take on tenants whereby you need to redecorate more regularly!

Homes should be deep cleaned between each tenant - this is a standard tenant cost if they have moved in to a deep cleaned property. If the property is in shit state they are also welcome to leave it that way. Tenants can move out of properties in the same condition they moved in to them (allowing for wear and tear)

Why should tenants suffer because of issues so trivial they aren;t noticed by lazy inventory clerks?

what are you talking about? All the points I’ve made are IN FAVOUR of tenants

IMHO tenants should pay deposit and rent and not a penny more. I would never charge a tenant for the inevitable clean that is needed, even if they leave it pretty damn clean. Obviously if they leave it as state then getting it "pretty clean and tidy" should come out of the deposit, then the deep clean should be paid by landlord.

Tenants are suffering because you are using lazy inventry clerks to justify not allowing pets.

Kerrangutan · 16/06/2022 12:39

@ShirleyPhallus your points basically sum up everything that's wrong with amateur landlords to be honest.

You can't have pets because they might piss on the sofa which will then have to be professionally cleaned WHICH IS A STANDARD TENANT COST ANYWAY according to you. And that still somehow equals less profit for you?

Imagine charging someone £1000 a month give or take for the privilege of sitting on a sofa other people have probably fucked all over and spilled their dinner on and A) thinking that it only needs professionally cleaned if it smells of cat piss and B) being able to sleep at night.

If having to refresh the decor every few years (which most homeowners do anyway) is such an issue for profits then it's probably time to find another business venture that doesn't rely on people not being allowed to live a basic life just to keep the business afloat.

Imagine other businesses started doing this. "Sorry, I know we're a cafe but if we implement basic hygiene rules we just won't be profitable anymore - so we're only going to serve people who don't care about that or are so desperate that they have to come to us anyway hehehe."

You wouldn't put up with it in the place you eat so why the fuck are we putting up with it in the places we live?
The whole system should never have been allowed to get this unregulated in the first place.

Manekinek0 · 16/06/2022 12:24

Our tenants have dogs. Last ones had a cat and we had to rip up all the flooring. The house looked relatively clean bit once it was empty for a few days we could smell cat urine. It was under the laminate and seeped into the floorboards in two rooms. I still accept pets, we just have to factor in the cost of fully stripping the property. So I suppose all tenants will pay more for pet owner tenants.

As for those with allergies like OP, how far back would you need to know. I could advertise our property as no pets, say the previous tenants haven't had pets but what about the ones before? And you can't guarantee that tenants don't have pets, you can only trust what they tell you.

ShirleyPhallus · 16/06/2022 12:22

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:15

Minor scratches by a cat sound like wear and tear. Big deal.

I would support the law making it a legal requirement for every landlord to pay for a deep clean between tenants. Why should tenants have to move into a home that potentially has human tissue lying around?

Why should tenants suffer because of issues so trivial they aren;t noticed by lazy inventory clerks?

I am far from convinced that it is legal to ban pets already - I strongly suspect that if challenged under human rights grounds tenants would win.

Saying all that I might be minded to make it illegal to keep cats and dogs in flats full stop - it isn;t fair on cats to have them living in flats, and it isn't fair on neighbours (and dogs) to have dogs in flats.

Minor damage adds up a lot over time to much bigger issues, such as needing to redecorate more regularly. You’re the one who said landlords should run their properties as professional businesses - I am pointing out how it is less profitable to take on tenants whereby you need to redecorate more regularly!

Homes should be deep cleaned between each tenant - this is a standard tenant cost if they have moved in to a deep cleaned property. If the property is in shit state they are also welcome to leave it that way. Tenants can move out of properties in the same condition they moved in to them (allowing for wear and tear)

Why should tenants suffer because of issues so trivial they aren;t noticed by lazy inventory clerks?

what are you talking about? All the points I’ve made are IN FAVOUR of tenants

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:15

ShirleyPhallus · 16/06/2022 12:08

I am not disputing whatsoever that the tenants home should feel like their home? I certainly don’t want to micro manage my tenants lives and much prefer to have as little to do with them as possible (because issues are fixed quickly or not even brought up because the property is kept in a good condition all the time, by both parties)

But it’s naive to think that pets don’t do more damage that a landlord wouldn’t be able to take out of their deposit.

Some examples:


  • minor scratches caused by the cat - likely listed as “wear and tear” in the checkout report

  • scent of cat urine which can’t be immediately detected or pinned down to one specific source - wouldn’t be listed in the inventory but the landlord would have to get sofas, beds, carpets all deep cleaned

  • possible damage to wooden floors by pet urine - again unlikely to be detailed in a checkout report to the extent that a landlord could take funds out of the tenants deposit


Having a pet creates more damage in “wear and tear” than not, and landlords are not able to take money out of tenant deposit for wear and tear.

i have tenants in my property currently who have a cat. It’s mostly wooden floors throughout but there are a few carpets which are 6 years old so will likely need to be replaced at the end of this tenancy anyway. Which is why I accepted a cat. As an aside, it’s a term of my lease not to allow pets so I had to write to the management company to confirm they were happy with this.

Minor scratches by a cat sound like wear and tear. Big deal.

I would support the law making it a legal requirement for every landlord to pay for a deep clean between tenants. Why should tenants have to move into a home that potentially has human tissue lying around?

Why should tenants suffer because of issues so trivial they aren;t noticed by lazy inventory clerks?

I am far from convinced that it is legal to ban pets already - I strongly suspect that if challenged under human rights grounds tenants would win.

Saying all that I might be minded to make it illegal to keep cats and dogs in flats full stop - it isn;t fair on cats to have them living in flats, and it isn't fair on neighbours (and dogs) to have dogs in flats.

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:11

Narwhalelife · 16/06/2022 12:05

I have to say, I’m sorry that your allergies are so severe but it is a tiny minority of people this will affect whereas pet ownership is on the rise and has remarkable benefits for humans.

I truly believe that if landlords wish to take the rent money they must allow tenant the right to live in the home.

I have always rented (nearly 20 years) and have always been lucky to be allowed pets and do what is needed during and after the tenancy has ended. I not see the fascination of home ownership myself but I do expect to be able to actually LIVE in a home I am paying £1500 a month for!

The fascination is twofold IMHO.

(1) However good and tenant friendly the law becomes you will always have more freedom as an owner instead of tenant.

(2) When you buy you effectively set your monthly payments at today's prices, and in theory only have monthly payments for 25 years and after than you can live there rent and mortgage free. When you rent you commit to paying monthly payments (rent) at current market value which will rise every year until you die.

ShirleyPhallus · 16/06/2022 12:08

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:02

ShirleyPhallus

It is acting like a “professional property investor” to not want to rent out your property to people with pets though? People with pets = more damage and smell = more cost to the landlord = less profit.

(1) You can take a deposit to protect against damage.

(2) Any tenant could turn out to be malicious and do much more damage than any pet could

(3) You might get a slightly higher rent if you allow pets

I am of the view that you need to balance the rights of landlords and tenants. The balance is too far in favour of landlords at the moment. Being a landlord is a business and it should be treated as such - impersonally. Tenant's rights to safe and secure homes (ie places where they can feel at home, not places where they are being micro-managed by a landlord) is essential.

I am not disputing whatsoever that the tenants home should feel like their home? I certainly don’t want to micro manage my tenants lives and much prefer to have as little to do with them as possible (because issues are fixed quickly or not even brought up because the property is kept in a good condition all the time, by both parties)

But it’s naive to think that pets don’t do more damage that a landlord wouldn’t be able to take out of their deposit.

Some examples:


  • minor scratches caused by the cat - likely listed as “wear and tear” in the checkout report

  • scent of cat urine which can’t be immediately detected or pinned down to one specific source - wouldn’t be listed in the inventory but the landlord would have to get sofas, beds, carpets all deep cleaned

  • possible damage to wooden floors by pet urine - again unlikely to be detailed in a checkout report to the extent that a landlord could take funds out of the tenants deposit


Having a pet creates more damage in “wear and tear” than not, and landlords are not able to take money out of tenant deposit for wear and tear.

i have tenants in my property currently who have a cat. It’s mostly wooden floors throughout but there are a few carpets which are 6 years old so will likely need to be replaced at the end of this tenancy anyway. Which is why I accepted a cat. As an aside, it’s a term of my lease not to allow pets so I had to write to the management company to confirm they were happy with this.

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:08

LezzaTheBean · 16/06/2022 11:57

This x 1000. And not just because of the new rules about pets. It's a shit time to be a landlord, but an excellent time to sell a house.

Why on earth should anyone give a flying fuck if landlords are having a shit time (and I dispute that btw)?

If you are a business person you might have a right to choose what business you are in, but you have no right to make money or to have that business model work indefinitely. If being a landlord doesn't work for you stop whinging and sell up.

The supply of houses is unaffected by how many private landlords there are. Every rental home sold is - by definition - sold to another investor or is sold to provide another owner occupied home.

Narwhalelife · 16/06/2022 12:05

I have to say, I’m sorry that your allergies are so severe but it is a tiny minority of people this will affect whereas pet ownership is on the rise and has remarkable benefits for humans.

I truly believe that if landlords wish to take the rent money they must allow tenant the right to live in the home.

I have always rented (nearly 20 years) and have always been lucky to be allowed pets and do what is needed during and after the tenancy has ended. I not see the fascination of home ownership myself but I do expect to be able to actually LIVE in a home I am paying £1500 a month for!

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:02

antelopevalley · 16/06/2022 11:27

People need a home, not simply to have a roof over their head provided by an investor.
This is a good policy.
Landlords are running a business. That comes with some challenges like any business. You don't like the laws, then sell up.

100%

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:02

ShirleyPhallus

It is acting like a “professional property investor” to not want to rent out your property to people with pets though? People with pets = more damage and smell = more cost to the landlord = less profit.

(1) You can take a deposit to protect against damage.

(2) Any tenant could turn out to be malicious and do much more damage than any pet could

(3) You might get a slightly higher rent if you allow pets

I am of the view that you need to balance the rights of landlords and tenants. The balance is too far in favour of landlords at the moment. Being a landlord is a business and it should be treated as such - impersonally. Tenant's rights to safe and secure homes (ie places where they can feel at home, not places where they are being micro-managed by a landlord) is essential.

changeornot · 16/06/2022 11:59

LezzaTheBean · 16/06/2022 11:57

This x 1000. And not just because of the new rules about pets. It's a shit time to be a landlord, but an excellent time to sell a house.

Good- we need professional landlords. We need the amateurs to leave the market and allow families to buy their properties

changeornot · 16/06/2022 11:57

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 11:50

You could >>>. realise that this may be triggering- apologies >>>>>Try to spend time with animals- stroke them (managed) etc.. as the more you expose yourself the better your chance to reduce sever allergic reaction.
(It is true that if you grow up in spending time with animals you will not grow up to have extreme allergies to animals

What a stupid and dangerous thing to say. Why comment or something you are obviously completely unknowledgeable about. I grew up with animals and had severe asthma attacks regularly until drs said this cant continue.

Yes sorry this was a red herring weak argument- I'm really not suggesting you get a pet- I don't know your allergy but the main points are correct---

Are you going to ban all pet ownership?

Or move into a New build?

Why are only renters responsible for your allergy when the same would apply to a house rented by the council or you were going to Buy?

52% of the UK own a pet.

LezzaTheBean · 16/06/2022 11:57

Itsbackagain · 16/06/2022 07:36

You should be more worried about the amount of LL that are about to sell up tbh.

This x 1000. And not just because of the new rules about pets. It's a shit time to be a landlord, but an excellent time to sell a house.

changeornot · 16/06/2022 11:52

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 11:46

1422 people died of asthma in the UK in 2018. These attacks will have had some triggers. For many this will not be animal allergies but you're living in a bubble if you can't believe animal allergies can kill people.

As the vast majority of those deaths are caused by pollution from traffic vechiles - shall we ban renters driving?

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 11:50

You could >>>. realise that this may be triggering- apologies >>>>>Try to spend time with animals- stroke them (managed) etc.. as the more you expose yourself the better your chance to reduce sever allergic reaction.
(It is true that if you grow up in spending time with animals you will not grow up to have extreme allergies to animals

What a stupid and dangerous thing to say. Why comment or something you are obviously completely unknowledgeable about. I grew up with animals and had severe asthma attacks regularly until drs said this cant continue.

OP posts:
changeornot · 16/06/2022 11:50

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 11:35

I'm a LL; 2 of our leasehold houses have a "no pets" clause in the leasehold, presumably because the freehold owner did not want to deal with cat/dog poo. I still had a tenant lie about it, then move in with 2 dogs, prompting howls of rage from the other leaseholders, who had chosen the development for similar reasons to the OP. We had to remove the tenant and the dogs (and pay a fine, plus the clean-up cost a fortune).

TBH I suspect it makes little difference in practice. There are always more applicants than tenancies and sadly it's those prospective tenants with kids and animals who always find it more difficult to secure a rental home.

Very unusual to have a house that have leasehold "no pets" though.

If you mentioned to the tenant before moving in-you cannot have pets as the leasehold says no- rather than a blanket ban no reason given--

He may of thought about neighbours reaction.

I still think the leasehold rule in a house is unreasonable- different case in some (not most) flats.....

Anyway the rule meant you had to evict a tenant--- which made him and his dogs(which in all likelihood had to be put in a dogs home). Caused him considerable cost and stress as well as for yourself for this rule......

52% of UK adults own pets- a blanket ban is unworkable.

Families with pets generally make excellent tenants as we do not complain- take our responsibilities seriously- always pay rent---happy to do minor decorations ourselves, want to live in unfurnished properties, really care about our references. And will stay in the property a very long time. We make good neighbours and get involved in our communities.

The same as most home owners actually.......

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 11:46

1422 people died of asthma in the UK in 2018. These attacks will have had some triggers. For many this will not be animal allergies but you're living in a bubble if you can't believe animal allergies can kill people.

OP posts:
PrinnyPree · 16/06/2022 11:39

I would just request to only view properties where previous tennants didn't have pets because of my allergies. There will be plenty. Just because it may be easier for renters to have pets, doesn't mean everyone renting will go out and adopt a dog. Pets are expensive and I had neither the time or spare income for them whilst I was renting.

Maurepas · 16/06/2022 11:38

I'm surprised this is what the current govt. comes up with when they have so many other problems!!

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 11:35

I'm a LL; 2 of our leasehold houses have a "no pets" clause in the leasehold, presumably because the freehold owner did not want to deal with cat/dog poo. I still had a tenant lie about it, then move in with 2 dogs, prompting howls of rage from the other leaseholders, who had chosen the development for similar reasons to the OP. We had to remove the tenant and the dogs (and pay a fine, plus the clean-up cost a fortune).

TBH I suspect it makes little difference in practice. There are always more applicants than tenancies and sadly it's those prospective tenants with kids and animals who always find it more difficult to secure a rental home.

antelopevalley · 16/06/2022 11:35

I agree this is hyperbole. If your allergy is so severe that you could never buy or rent a property a pet has lived in, then you are already very restricted when choosing a home.

Fraaahnces · 16/06/2022 11:33

On one hand, I totally understand. My DS has anaphylaxis as a response to many animals kept as pets. He’s okay with dogs, thank goodness. (Like a lot of people allergic to animals, he loves them and vice-versa.) We are not in uk, but rent and have a dog. There appears to be an unwritten rule that is bordering on some kind of fear of discrimination that means that landlords aren’t comfortable staying what their boundaries are re:- pets. Currently we have an illicit bloody goldfish rescue (I need to grow a spine) and a large dog. If we needed to move, trying to find a landlord who is comfortable defining their boundaries regarding pets is virtually impossible. If we were to move, we would have to apply for a bajillion different houses, be refused, and then it would affect our credit rating.