Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the renters reform bill is going to kill people with allergies?

335 replies

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:29

Just that really. I know many people will see this as a good thing. I know too that the severity of allergy to pets which means they can kill you is rare. But it does happen. I am that severely allergic. So if landlords can't give a blanket ban then there are no pet-free properties for me to move into.

For those who don't know - antihistamines make no difference and the only way to get all allergens out of the place is to remove all soft furnishings including carpets and underlay. Deep cleaning things does not work. So unless the landlords change all carpets, curtains, sofas etc. in between tenants, then it still has enough allergens to trigger a life-threatening reaction. For me that reaction is asthma and I already see a hospital specialist so there is no further treatment that can be offered. Avoiding allergens is the key advice. I'm really worried that the full implications have not been thought through.

OP posts:
changeornot · 16/06/2022 15:10

onthefencesitter · 16/06/2022 15:00

My DH sent me a link to a flat in the Barbican estate-£1 million 2/3 bed flat and said we could perhaps afford that it in a few years. I said even if we could, I looked it up and said it's not the best place for us as the Barbican doesn't allow pets (and I have a hamster). He said that hamster is discreet! I wasn't going to get into an argument over a fantasy flat we aren't in the position to purchase now (the zone 3 flats that are closer to reach generally allow pets as long as they are not destructive as opposed to blanket ban)... But I am not sure the residents of the Barbican are not privileged just because they aren't allowed pets.. those flats are desirable (and expensive!) In fact you could argue the many rules make it a more pleasant place to live. .

Ha.. but its definitely a choice to live in the Barbican???

I highly suspect there may be the odd Bengal or sausage dog hiding?

In plain sight?

changeornot · 16/06/2022 15:08

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 14:54

Anyway the rule meant you had to evict a tenant--- which made him and his dogs(which in all likelihood had to be put in a dogs home). Caused him considerable cost and stress as well as for yourself for this rule......

Can you read? It’s in the leasehold, not the tenancy agreement. And yes, the tenant was made aware of this (by us as LL and by the agent), but she didn’t understand the difference between a tenancy agreement and a leasehold interest in a property. We were at great pains to point it out because, as you said, it’s so unusual.

What do you suggest we could have done? Persuade 30 plus other homeowners to make an exception for our (dishonest) tenant? Lose our own investment to protect her mangy unwelcome dogs? (Even if we had, they’d still have been evicted by the freeholder - plenty of residents have a vg reason to not want to be near dogs, including allergies). If they did end up in a dogs home, I’m afraid it’s on her.

And there were 18 other tenants, all pet-free, waiting to take the tenancy on in their place. The government can fanny about with this crowd-pleasing bollocks all it wants: nothing will change, there is not enough vacant property for everyone who wants it.

Yes- I doth my cap to you- I might rent but I can read. Thank you.

I of course meant the leasehold- it was the terms of the leasehold not your tenancy agreement- you made that clear.

If you explained clearly to the tenant, and gave her an ok reference so she could move on , than fair enough. You did your bit.
You did what you had to do.... but ....
I highly doubt that 30 plus homeowners chose their property because it did not have dogs.

This rule will hopefully make leases where you have a blanket ban on all animals ( in suitable properties) less likely in the future.

So you wouldn't have this issue in the future.

I don't think you should have that much power over peoples lives.

This rule will move towards a culture in the long term, where the landlord's wants are not always paramount and give more autonomy for the tenant to live out their lives as they choose.

Interesting to note- that leaseholds are being banned for houses (not retrospectively) obviously.

riesenrad · 16/06/2022 15:06

I am far from convinced that it is legal to ban pets already - I strongly suspect that if challenged under human rights grounds tenants would win

I'm not sure having a pet equates to a human right. In fact there is an argument that some pets have a detrimental effect on other people and therefore have an adverse impact on their human rights. Such as the thread on here recently about the poster who couldn't cope with the barking dogs next door.

onthefencesitter · 16/06/2022 15:00

dollybird · 16/06/2022 14:44

changeornot you're changing what you said now. You said children would feel like second class citizens because they are not allowed to have a pet. Lots of children aren't allowed to have pets, for many reasons including, but not exclusively because, they rent. No-one should be made to feel like second class citizens for any reason, but the things listed above are not what I was first responding to.

We are surrounded by dogs on all sides, and are made to feel unreasonable because we object to being barked at aggressively at the fence for just going in our garden, being woken at midnight by a barking dog in the garden, or having to listen to a dog barking indoors every time a person or vehicle goes past the front door. But hey, pets are great!

My DH sent me a link to a flat in the Barbican estate-£1 million 2/3 bed flat and said we could perhaps afford that it in a few years. I said even if we could, I looked it up and said it's not the best place for us as the Barbican doesn't allow pets (and I have a hamster). He said that hamster is discreet! I wasn't going to get into an argument over a fantasy flat we aren't in the position to purchase now (the zone 3 flats that are closer to reach generally allow pets as long as they are not destructive as opposed to blanket ban)... But I am not sure the residents of the Barbican are not privileged just because they aren't allowed pets.. those flats are desirable (and expensive!) In fact you could argue the many rules make it a more pleasant place to live. .

420Bruh · 16/06/2022 14:58

Most properties are let unfurnished. This is such a weird take.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 14:54

Anyway the rule meant you had to evict a tenant--- which made him and his dogs(which in all likelihood had to be put in a dogs home). Caused him considerable cost and stress as well as for yourself for this rule......

Can you read? It’s in the leasehold, not the tenancy agreement. And yes, the tenant was made aware of this (by us as LL and by the agent), but she didn’t understand the difference between a tenancy agreement and a leasehold interest in a property. We were at great pains to point it out because, as you said, it’s so unusual.

What do you suggest we could have done? Persuade 30 plus other homeowners to make an exception for our (dishonest) tenant? Lose our own investment to protect her mangy unwelcome dogs? (Even if we had, they’d still have been evicted by the freeholder - plenty of residents have a vg reason to not want to be near dogs, including allergies). If they did end up in a dogs home, I’m afraid it’s on her.

And there were 18 other tenants, all pet-free, waiting to take the tenancy on in their place. The government can fanny about with this crowd-pleasing bollocks all it wants: nothing will change, there is not enough vacant property for everyone who wants it.

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 14:44

kagerou · 16/06/2022 10:19

So would you not be able to go to a friends house if they had pets previously? Or a shop / office that allowed pets or somebody had a support dog?

I'm sorry that your allergy is so severe but if your logic was followed then pets or support animals would not be allowed anywhere on the off chance someone had what you yourself admit to be a very rare reaction.

Also why should pet allergies be prioritized over others? Would you say landlords should not allow nuts to be consumed on their property? or that they should be banned from using certain building materials a tiny amount of people have allergies too?

That's right. I can't go to friends houses if they've had pets in the last year. I couldn't work in a place where someone had a support dog. I think nuts are different as eating them does no contaminate the whole house for months or years. That is the case with my nut allergies anyway though I'm open to being corrected by people with more severe nut allergies. Are there building materials which can trigger life threatening allergies?

OP posts:
dollybird · 16/06/2022 14:44

changeornot you're changing what you said now. You said children would feel like second class citizens because they are not allowed to have a pet. Lots of children aren't allowed to have pets, for many reasons including, but not exclusively because, they rent. No-one should be made to feel like second class citizens for any reason, but the things listed above are not what I was first responding to.

We are surrounded by dogs on all sides, and are made to feel unreasonable because we object to being barked at aggressively at the fence for just going in our garden, being woken at midnight by a barking dog in the garden, or having to listen to a dog barking indoors every time a person or vehicle goes past the front door. But hey, pets are great!

changeornot · 16/06/2022 14:36

dollybird · 16/06/2022 14:10

But who is making children feel like second class citizens? How can they be, if nearly half the population (according to your figures) don't have pets? Shame on anyone that makes children feel like this.

Yes I agree shame on anyone that makes my children feel like a second class citizen because they grew up in a rented home.

Shame on the rule that they can't redecorate or have their own furniture. They can't move- to a larger house, because no one wants to rent to families. Yes SHAME on that system.
Shame on the system that meant that their much loved pet cats had to be rehomed.

SHAME on the system that means they can be evicted and have to move schools at a months notice.

Yes SHAME on that too..

No fault eviction meant that my kids had to move over christmas, to a small, damp flat with bars not he window, and we had to rehome their much loved pets.

That made them feel like a second class citizen.

I don't think you get it for people who keep pets, and have a tradition of keeping pets from childhood, your pet is part of your family.

Growing up I don't think I knew anyone who didn't have a pet.

Renting as it is is housing insecurity...

Why should there be one rule for people who rent and one rule for owner occupiers?

changeornot · 16/06/2022 14:24

slowcookerforone · 16/06/2022 14:04

As an ex-LL I'm so glad I'm out of it.

Tenants are such a nightmare to deal with, the fact you can't take a big enough deposit to cover the damage that can be done by tenants and let alone their pets.

I only had 2 sets of tenants in my time as a LL (sadly inherited property) and I allowed them both pets, and the pets did no damage - but at least I was able to have the conversation and the tenants were careful about protecting the property against damage from pets because they knew that no many LL allowed pets so they respected the trust I had given them.

I'd never do it again it was an eye opener.

I think the model in the UK is moving more towards very very large LL companies rather than individual LLs. Which I think is a shame personally as those companies are going to have such a monopoly.

To be honest in my experience the very best landlords I've experienced have multiple properties- The best had 50 plus- all victorian superficially in not a great condition, but all of them unfurnished. Employed people to look after the basics in the properties, let you go about your business, let you decorate, allow pets, kids etc... Similar to renting from the council ( but obviously more expensive).

My present landlord is good they have 5 properties so are fairly professional- although they insist in furnishing their properties- which I hate but I put up with as the rent is cheaper than others in the area.

The absolute worse experiences I have had is from landlords who have one investment property or used to own the property. Despite superficially these properties being in better condition.

Very slow and resentful for mending broken things, very interfering and controlling. No pets, didn't like children.
Would suggest unreasonable arbitrary rent hikes. As they read an article that the are was on the up, now they want an extra £300 a month.
Over friendly, but also quite rude and demanding. Cant you get a better paid job?
Acted like they were doing a massive favour renting out their property.
Refused to pay for the very basics., and hugely resentful if told about heating that needed to be fixed.
. I was frightened to report repairs, ended up in paying for most of them myself. It was very stressful, as always felt that we were going to be thrown out, which he did just before christmas one year.

dollybird · 16/06/2022 14:10

changeornot · 16/06/2022 13:58

That's because you don't want a pet- not because you are a tenant. It's your choice.

I personally wouldn't buy a flat with those terms on the lease, as there are loads of properties to buy that do not have that clause.

That is not so with rented properties- I don't have a choice.

59% of UK people do have pets.

Yes my kids felt like second class citizen when I had to re-home my much loved cats because my landlord served notice (no fault eviction) and I couldn't find anyone that would take kids and pets on a short notice.

Lots of children would love a pet, but know they cannot have one because there parents have told them we rent.

I've told this to my children.

Blanket ban on pets is unnecessary, divisive and unfair.

But who is making children feel like second class citizens? How can they be, if nearly half the population (according to your figures) don't have pets? Shame on anyone that makes children feel like this.

slowcookerforone · 16/06/2022 14:04

As an ex-LL I'm so glad I'm out of it.

Tenants are such a nightmare to deal with, the fact you can't take a big enough deposit to cover the damage that can be done by tenants and let alone their pets.

I only had 2 sets of tenants in my time as a LL (sadly inherited property) and I allowed them both pets, and the pets did no damage - but at least I was able to have the conversation and the tenants were careful about protecting the property against damage from pets because they knew that no many LL allowed pets so they respected the trust I had given them.

I'd never do it again it was an eye opener.

I think the model in the UK is moving more towards very very large LL companies rather than individual LLs. Which I think is a shame personally as those companies are going to have such a monopoly.

changeornot · 16/06/2022 13:58

dollybird · 16/06/2022 13:44

Why should millions of children get to feel like second class citizens as they are not allowed to have simple pleasures like a dog, cat, guniea pig etc...?

WTF? I can categorically say neither myself, DH, my DC or DP have ever felt like second class citizens because we don't have pets.

Someone else mentioned upthread about not allowing places to have carpet. We are buying a flat and it is in the lease that carpet must be used apart from in kitchen and bathroom for sound protection. It also says no 'animal, bird or reptile' unless agreed with the landlord, and then stipulations might be put in place.

That's because you don't want a pet- not because you are a tenant. It's your choice.

I personally wouldn't buy a flat with those terms on the lease, as there are loads of properties to buy that do not have that clause.

That is not so with rented properties- I don't have a choice.

59% of UK people do have pets.

Yes my kids felt like second class citizen when I had to re-home my much loved cats because my landlord served notice (no fault eviction) and I couldn't find anyone that would take kids and pets on a short notice.

Lots of children would love a pet, but know they cannot have one because there parents have told them we rent.

I've told this to my children.

Blanket ban on pets is unnecessary, divisive and unfair.

dollybird · 16/06/2022 13:44

Why should millions of children get to feel like second class citizens as they are not allowed to have simple pleasures like a dog, cat, guniea pig etc...?

WTF? I can categorically say neither myself, DH, my DC or DP have ever felt like second class citizens because we don't have pets.

Someone else mentioned upthread about not allowing places to have carpet. We are buying a flat and it is in the lease that carpet must be used apart from in kitchen and bathroom for sound protection. It also says no 'animal, bird or reptile' unless agreed with the landlord, and then stipulations might be put in place.

onthefencesitter · 16/06/2022 13:43

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:56

"One of my neighbours has Persian cats, aren't they supposed to be kept inside anyway due to fears of theft? I don't really mind the dogs but once a resident's dog was running around in the communal garden and I was holding my hamster in its carrier, it leapt on me and it was a big dog! That was a bit scary."

Well, I'd argue that if a cat breed is at such risk of theft that it can;t be left outside then it's not a cat breed that should be allowed really. I suppose that there are some cats that are fine with being indoors, but I can't imagine keeping ours in. He was fine inside getting acclimatised to his new home, but by the end he was itching to get outside - the idea of keeping him locked inside for 14 years seems barbaric.

I know ragdoll cats specifically can't be let outside because they have very little road awareness..a lot of people walk their ragdoll cats on a leash!

In Australia and USA, I know a lot of cat owners keep their cats in. I didn't even know pet cats could be allowed to roam before I came to the UK!

changeornot · 16/06/2022 13:31

BunsyGirl · 16/06/2022 12:55

Exposure didn’t help me. As a small child I spent a lot of time with family who had dogs. I would also ride ponies. I had absolutely no allergy to these. My allergies started when I was around 9 or 10 and my parents had no idea what was causing them at first so I was still in contact with animals. It was only after I had an asthma attack and an off duty nurse came to help and told my parents it was an asthma attack that they took me to the GP who arranged for allergy tests. Complete suprise to my parents that I was allergic to dogs! The allergies have got worse over time. The last time I went near a pony was about three or four years ago. I thought I would be ok stood two metres away outside whilst my DCs rode. Wrong! I started to have an attack within a few minutes.

For people commenting about buying a house, it’s a complete nightmare even just to view never mind buy a house where a dog has lived. We’re on our fourth new build for that very reason!

Also, entering a large shop where an animal has been briefly is completely different to sitting in the living room of someone who has a dog. The longer the exposure the worse my asthma is. So, if I see an animal, I walk away, leave the building etc. One of my worse experiences was when I was in a meeting room with a client who had just been horse riding. I had no idea at the outset of the meeting and didn’t understand why my breathing was deteriorating. Thanks goodness that I now WFH and meetings are via Teams!!!

I get that this must be difficult for you--

But what do you suggest --That everyone doesn't own a pet in the UK,?

When currently 59% do own pets?

Where are all these pets going to live?

You can't buy, you can't rent?

Surely you need to do a deep clean- wood floors- new furniture- or move into an unfurnished new build.

I'm not an expect- there needs more research into this but the solution is NOT to encourage a blanket ban on pets of ONLY private rented properties.

changeornot · 16/06/2022 13:26

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:29

Just that really. I know many people will see this as a good thing. I know too that the severity of allergy to pets which means they can kill you is rare. But it does happen. I am that severely allergic. So if landlords can't give a blanket ban then there are no pet-free properties for me to move into.

For those who don't know - antihistamines make no difference and the only way to get all allergens out of the place is to remove all soft furnishings including carpets and underlay. Deep cleaning things does not work. So unless the landlords change all carpets, curtains, sofas etc. in between tenants, then it still has enough allergens to trigger a life-threatening reaction. For me that reaction is asthma and I already see a hospital specialist so there is no further treatment that can be offered. Avoiding allergens is the key advice. I'm really worried that the full implications have not been thought through.

I'm sorry you have very severe asthma.
But I don't understand why ALL tenants should not be allowed to keep pets because one day in the future you might want to move into that property.

Do you understand how unworkable that policy is?

the most recent data suggest that pet ownership has increased over the pandemic from 52%

59% of people living in the UK now own pets

As you also wouldn't be able to purchase a property?

Or rent from the council?

Why should this only affect tenants.

As you would still need to live somewhere that is unfurnished with a hard floor and a deep clean to stay safe.

Also at the moment- many ,many people get pets and do not tell their landlord.
So you cannot assume a rented property has had pets than any other property, as their is a huge incentive to omit this detail at present.

What this brilliant policy will encourage is more stability for tenants and for landlords to provide wood flooring on unfurnished properties.

So will make your life actually easier.....

Message to landlords----

I do not want to look after your 20 year old brown DFS sofa/ 15 year old broken billy bookcase, 70 year old table (too big) for the dinning room. I would rather buy my own.

I (like most) tenants want unfurnished or a least the option to keep or remove your horrible furniture.

I would prefer a wood floor- as I can add my own rugs/flooring. This is cheaper (in the long run) for you and better for me.

Lineala · 16/06/2022 13:10

Currently there is nothing in the HRA or the ECHR that would provide a course of action against a landlord who refused a pet or who refused to offer a tenancy to a prospective tenant with a pet other than those provided already in law via the Equaliry Act. So refusing a tenant with an assistance animal might be actionable. A number of landlords including me cannot offer tenancies to pet owners due to prohibition in the lease.

ShirleyPhallus · 16/06/2022 12:56

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:53

Tenants are suffering because you are using lazy inventry clerks to justify not allowing pets.

I mean this is just bullshit at this point. If an inventory clerk doesn’t note on the checkout report that the flat smells like cat urine there is literally nothing a landlord can do about it. They cannot take money from a tenant for this. If it went to dispute the dispute would land squarely in favour of the tenant because it’s up to the landlord to prove they have suffered a material loss and they have no way to do this. This is IN FAVOUR OF TENANTS.

If you;re such a great professional landlord why aren;t you employing better inventry clerks or suing the incompetent ones who let you down? What level of PII cover do your inventry clerks have? How much can you sue them for if they fail to spot faults that should have been paid for by tenants?

Why do you care one jot what risks I take as a landlord?

Ah I see, you can’t get further with your poor argument because I’ve pointed out that deposit schemes protect tenants so you’re moving on to some completely irrelevant point. Gotcha.

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:56

"One of my neighbours has Persian cats, aren't they supposed to be kept inside anyway due to fears of theft? I don't really mind the dogs but once a resident's dog was running around in the communal garden and I was holding my hamster in its carrier, it leapt on me and it was a big dog! That was a bit scary."

Well, I'd argue that if a cat breed is at such risk of theft that it can;t be left outside then it's not a cat breed that should be allowed really. I suppose that there are some cats that are fine with being indoors, but I can't imagine keeping ours in. He was fine inside getting acclimatised to his new home, but by the end he was itching to get outside - the idea of keeping him locked inside for 14 years seems barbaric.

BunsyGirl · 16/06/2022 12:55

Exposure didn’t help me. As a small child I spent a lot of time with family who had dogs. I would also ride ponies. I had absolutely no allergy to these. My allergies started when I was around 9 or 10 and my parents had no idea what was causing them at first so I was still in contact with animals. It was only after I had an asthma attack and an off duty nurse came to help and told my parents it was an asthma attack that they took me to the GP who arranged for allergy tests. Complete suprise to my parents that I was allergic to dogs! The allergies have got worse over time. The last time I went near a pony was about three or four years ago. I thought I would be ok stood two metres away outside whilst my DCs rode. Wrong! I started to have an attack within a few minutes.

For people commenting about buying a house, it’s a complete nightmare even just to view never mind buy a house where a dog has lived. We’re on our fourth new build for that very reason!

Also, entering a large shop where an animal has been briefly is completely different to sitting in the living room of someone who has a dog. The longer the exposure the worse my asthma is. So, if I see an animal, I walk away, leave the building etc. One of my worse experiences was when I was in a meeting room with a client who had just been horse riding. I had no idea at the outset of the meeting and didn’t understand why my breathing was deteriorating. Thanks goodness that I now WFH and meetings are via Teams!!!

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:53

Tenants are suffering because you are using lazy inventry clerks to justify not allowing pets.

I mean this is just bullshit at this point. If an inventory clerk doesn’t note on the checkout report that the flat smells like cat urine there is literally nothing a landlord can do about it. They cannot take money from a tenant for this. If it went to dispute the dispute would land squarely in favour of the tenant because it’s up to the landlord to prove they have suffered a material loss and they have no way to do this. This is IN FAVOUR OF TENANTS.

If you;re such a great professional landlord why aren;t you employing better inventry clerks or suing the incompetent ones who let you down? What level of PII cover do your inventry clerks have? How much can you sue them for if they fail to spot faults that should have been paid for by tenants?

onthefencesitter · 16/06/2022 12:51

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:15

Minor scratches by a cat sound like wear and tear. Big deal.

I would support the law making it a legal requirement for every landlord to pay for a deep clean between tenants. Why should tenants have to move into a home that potentially has human tissue lying around?

Why should tenants suffer because of issues so trivial they aren;t noticed by lazy inventory clerks?

I am far from convinced that it is legal to ban pets already - I strongly suspect that if challenged under human rights grounds tenants would win.

Saying all that I might be minded to make it illegal to keep cats and dogs in flats full stop - it isn;t fair on cats to have them living in flats, and it isn't fair on neighbours (and dogs) to have dogs in flats.

I own a flat and my flat block allows all cats and dogs. I have a hamster!

One of my neighbours has Persian cats, aren't they supposed to be kept inside anyway due to fears of theft? I don't really mind the dogs but once a resident's dog was running around in the communal garden and I was holding my hamster in its carrier, it leapt on me and it was a big dog! That was a bit scary.

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:51

"Every business owner runs it in the most profitable way possible, ie lowest cost and highest margins. Allowing pets in to a property DOES cost the landlord more."

No, you miss the bit about the fact that they do that within the law. And here we are talking about where the law should be and IMHO it probably needs to move even further in favour of tenants than this proposal in order to better balance landlord and tenant rights.

ShirleyPhallus · 16/06/2022 12:50

GCRich · 16/06/2022 12:42

IMHO tenants should pay deposit and rent and not a penny more. I would never charge a tenant for the inevitable clean that is needed, even if they leave it pretty damn clean. Obviously if they leave it as state then getting it "pretty clean and tidy" should come out of the deposit, then the deep clean should be paid by landlord.

Tenants are suffering because you are using lazy inventry clerks to justify not allowing pets.

Tenants are suffering because you are using lazy inventry clerks to justify not allowing pets.

I mean this is just bullshit at this point. If an inventory clerk doesn’t note on the checkout report that the flat smells like cat urine there is literally nothing a landlord can do about it. They cannot take money from a tenant for this. If it went to dispute the dispute would land squarely in favour of the tenant because it’s up to the landlord to prove they have suffered a material loss and they have no way to do this. This is IN FAVOUR OF TENANTS.

exactly which tenants are “suffering” by not being allowed pets? My tenants ARE allowed pets!