Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the renters reform bill is going to kill people with allergies?

335 replies

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:29

Just that really. I know many people will see this as a good thing. I know too that the severity of allergy to pets which means they can kill you is rare. But it does happen. I am that severely allergic. So if landlords can't give a blanket ban then there are no pet-free properties for me to move into.

For those who don't know - antihistamines make no difference and the only way to get all allergens out of the place is to remove all soft furnishings including carpets and underlay. Deep cleaning things does not work. So unless the landlords change all carpets, curtains, sofas etc. in between tenants, then it still has enough allergens to trigger a life-threatening reaction. For me that reaction is asthma and I already see a hospital specialist so there is no further treatment that can be offered. Avoiding allergens is the key advice. I'm really worried that the full implications have not been thought through.

OP posts:
Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 16/06/2022 18:59

It’s a very standard clause that if you rent a property with a lawn you will take care of it. I agree that the LL should provide a mower but they shouldn’t need to get a gardener in, if a tenant wants the garden they also need to be prepared to mow the lawn on occasion

yeah but it depends on what the LL’s standards are. Mowing the lawn is fine but my mum’s garden for instance needs about a full day of work a week to keep nice. If she rented her house out, it would not be reasonable to expect the tenant to do all that work. I think it’s okay to expect lawn mowing (if lawn mower is supplied) but in reality, it’s extremely common for tenants to neglect the garden. Most landlords would choose a low maintenance one for a long term rental but if it’s something that’s really important to the LL, having a gardener can reduce that stress.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 18:44

The houses are all first time buyer houses though. Small little terraced ones.

LezzaTheBean · 16/06/2022 18:42

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow That is rubbish for your son. It may well be that investors are the problem. However, it's also the case that there is generally a massive shortage of properties coming on the market, and each property has 20+ people viewing it, most of whom are cash buyers - partly as a result of having sold up pre-lockdown and then sat tight in rented until things returned to normal. So a lot of the cash buyers are couples/families. Not that this helps your son at all (one of my DC is in a similar position) - and I hope he finds something soon.

Gooseberrypies · 16/06/2022 18:26

You could well rent a home today that was ‘pet free’ as far as the landlord knows but the tenant lied about it and had a pet there anyway. To those saying it will still be possible for landlords to choose non-pet owners - nobody will disclose it if it disadvantages them even if it’s not an official clause. And they shouldn’t have to. Sorry you have an allergy but everything in the world can’t pander to you.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 18:25

Generation Rent

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/06/2022 18:24

As for the idea that families would be able to buy the properties that LL sell: if they could afford to buy property, and were able to obtain a mortgage, don't you think they would have done that already? Nothing is stopping them. There are plenty of houses available already

There are no houses available though. My ds is trying to buy his first home. Very very few are coming up. He’s been beaten 5 times by cash buyers, aka landlords or investors. I wish they’d all leave the market then Generstion are t could become Generation Buy.

LezzaTheBean · 16/06/2022 18:22

Good- we need professional landlords. We need the amateurs to leave the market and allow families to buy their properties

I'm a professional LL, as it happens - but that's irrelevant. If LL sell up, there's no guarantee at all that they will sell to other professional landlords. They may well sell to unscrupulous amateurs who tick the various boxes but find ways round the law. Section 8 will become the new Section 21. So if the OP were a LL, she could quite reasonably argue under Section 8 that any tenant introducing a pet into the house could be evicted on the grounds that it would make her severely ill if she needed to visit the property for any reason. This is obviously a hyperbolised example, but this sort of thing will be exploited all the same.

LL could sell to investors who want to use the property as a Furnished Holiday Let - thereby taking it out of circulation for 'normal' people. They could choose to do this themself. They could start to let to students instead of families, in the pretty certain knowledge that students will stay for a maximum of two years - and if they get jobs and can carry on paying the rent after that, a LL will be delighted.

The more LL sell up, the more the supply of rental accommodation will reduce. So the prices will go up, and it will become more difficult to find/afford what's available. The supply of accommodation available to be rented by individuals/families (as opposed to holiday lets) went down 50% between 2019 and 2022.

It's also worth bearing in mind that 88% of tenancies end because the tenants want to move on, not because the LL kicks them out. Most evictions are the result of antisocial behaviour on the part of tenants (or, equally, because the LL wants to sell up). People like to act as if LL were the Devil and all tenants are whiter than white; neither of these things is true. There are good and bad LL and good and bad tenants. So, as is so often the case, we're talking about a marginal number of people. The overwhelming majority of tenants will remain completely unaffected by changes to the law, other than having to pay higher rents as there being a reduced supply of rental property availabler.

As for the idea that families would be able to buy the properties that LL sell: if they could afford to buy property, and were able to obtain a mortgage, don't you think they would have done that already? Nothing is stopping them. There are plenty of houses available already.

MrsDThomas · 16/06/2022 18:21

As a landlord, I would definitely choose non pet owners.

rental properties round here are very hard to get by. So the demand is there so i would opt for the no pet people.

my house.

Pyri · 16/06/2022 18:17

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 16/06/2022 18:15

Yeah it’s weird how people don’t tend to give much of a shit when it’s not their own property... It’s hardly an extreme thing - that’s why it’s not a good idea to have a high maintenance garden in a rental property because it’s unlikely that the tenant will be out there come rain and shine making it look nice. If you really care, employ a gardener and add it to the rent 🤷‍♀️
Your gardening woes are not a good example of how terrible tenants are, nor what a generous landlord you are. If it pisses you off, get an agent to manage it. Clearly you’re too tight to do so so then you have to expect that not everything goes smoothly.

It’s a very standard clause that if you rent a property with a lawn you will take care of it. I agree that the LL should provide a mower but they shouldn’t need to get a gardener in, if a tenant wants the garden they also need to be prepared to mow the lawn on occasion

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 16/06/2022 18:15

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 16:35

LL’s are not legally obliged to supply gardening equipment and my tenant had signed a standard garden care clause in the TA. (He’d also signed an inventory that made no reference to a lawnmower).

Being nice sort of LL’s and having just bought a bigger house needing a drive-on mower, we gave him our old one. Then got a call from the tenant’s neighbour complaining about the jungle that the lawn had become ie even with a free mower he still didn’t cut the bloody grass.

Yeah it’s weird how people don’t tend to give much of a shit when it’s not their own property... It’s hardly an extreme thing - that’s why it’s not a good idea to have a high maintenance garden in a rental property because it’s unlikely that the tenant will be out there come rain and shine making it look nice. If you really care, employ a gardener and add it to the rent 🤷‍♀️
Your gardening woes are not a good example of how terrible tenants are, nor what a generous landlord you are. If it pisses you off, get an agent to manage it. Clearly you’re too tight to do so so then you have to expect that not everything goes smoothly.

BunsyGirl · 16/06/2022 17:43

@changeornot I was just commenting on some of the points raised on here as there are so many throwaway comments on pet allergies which are largely untrue, at least in my case. It’s bloody hard when you have no choice in the situation and are made to feel like you are an evil person for not being able to go near someone’s pet. I think that Landords should be allowed an exemption if they have a pet allergy themselves. I used to let my house out when I moved for work and it would have been impossible to manage it never mind move back in had I been forced to allow pets.

Gymnopedie · 16/06/2022 17:27

Nice. So just ignore one disability as all the others trump it apparently? Having a severe animal allergy doesn’t count on MN. It’s just stupid people making a fuss about nothing after all.

But isn't that what the OP is doing? Saying that despite the many health and wellbeing advantages to having a pet, they should be overlooked because of her allergy?

Nobody deliberately wants her to suffer, but equally they don't want others to suffer either.

Lineala · 16/06/2022 16:36

You raise interesting points about enforcement and these currently are twofold. Environmental Health at councils are the enforcement agents for disrepair. Legal aid housing lawyers were the other enforcers and I've acted for tenants in the past of both HA and PRS tenants to enforce their rights and seek damages or/and injunctions in some cases. Unfortunately when legal aid was cut in 2012 (LASPO) many lawyers practices and law centres closed limiting poorer tenants ability to enforce their rights.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 16:35

LL’s are not legally obliged to supply gardening equipment and my tenant had signed a standard garden care clause in the TA. (He’d also signed an inventory that made no reference to a lawnmower).

Being nice sort of LL’s and having just bought a bigger house needing a drive-on mower, we gave him our old one. Then got a call from the tenant’s neighbour complaining about the jungle that the lawn had become ie even with a free mower he still didn’t cut the bloody grass.

Lineala · 16/06/2022 16:27

changeornot · 16/06/2022 14:36

Yes I agree shame on anyone that makes my children feel like a second class citizen because they grew up in a rented home.

Shame on the rule that they can't redecorate or have their own furniture. They can't move- to a larger house, because no one wants to rent to families. Yes SHAME on that system.
Shame on the system that meant that their much loved pet cats had to be rehomed.

SHAME on the system that means they can be evicted and have to move schools at a months notice.

Yes SHAME on that too..

No fault eviction meant that my kids had to move over christmas, to a small, damp flat with bars not he window, and we had to rehome their much loved pets.

That made them feel like a second class citizen.

I don't think you get it for people who keep pets, and have a tradition of keeping pets from childhood, your pet is part of your family.

Growing up I don't think I knew anyone who didn't have a pet.

Renting as it is is housing insecurity...

Why should there be one rule for people who rent and one rule for owner occupiers?

There is no eviction at a months notice, and if this is what happened to you, read up on the law so you can prevent a landlord attempting this. The statutory law is already in place that states a requirement for two months notice. If you choose not to leave which is your right, the ll must apply to court for a possession order and if you still won't leave, a warrant of possession. Claims for costs would also be made and these are fixed at around £400. Peddling your sort of crap doesn't help anyone and is misleading other tenants who may believe you and not realise statutory protections are in place.

In my experience as a housing solicitor of some years, illegal eviction carries such huge penalties, very few dodgy landlords will try it. They're more likely these days to offer you money to leave.

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 16/06/2022 16:19

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 16:10

@slowcookerforone sympathies from me. I had one tenant refuse to maintain the garden unless I supplied a mower. (When I asked why he took a lease on a place with a garden, he insisted it was his right to have outdoor space and my job to provide tools).

Another called me hysterical in the middle of the night because an elderly neighbour had accidentally floored the accelerator and driven through another neighbour’s fence and what was I going to do about it? (Nothing: it’s not my fence.)

Yet another expected me to water her plants while she was away and was extremely aggrieved when I wouldn’t let her put my phone number on the intruder alarm. (I lived 2 hours away and had a newborn at the time).

But yeah, bloody landlords eh? 🙄

The second two are pretty bad but it’s not unreasonable for you to supply a lawnmower. Why should the tenant buy one when their next property might not even have a garden? That’s not really on the same level as the other two.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 16:10

@slowcookerforone sympathies from me. I had one tenant refuse to maintain the garden unless I supplied a mower. (When I asked why he took a lease on a place with a garden, he insisted it was his right to have outdoor space and my job to provide tools).

Another called me hysterical in the middle of the night because an elderly neighbour had accidentally floored the accelerator and driven through another neighbour’s fence and what was I going to do about it? (Nothing: it’s not my fence.)

Yet another expected me to water her plants while she was away and was extremely aggrieved when I wouldn’t let her put my phone number on the intruder alarm. (I lived 2 hours away and had a newborn at the time).

But yeah, bloody landlords eh? 🙄

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 16/06/2022 16:08

BungleandGeorge · 16/06/2022 10:49

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist More recourse to insist isn’t actually the same as saying that you can insist. However, You can insist before you take a tenancy, it is of course up to the landlord whether they rent to you and whether that is cost effective for them
I’ve had pets, staining and odour isn’t effectively removed with cleaning. Neither is damage from claws, chewing etc. I’d choose a pet free property every time

Ah! Semantics.

It's my job to report such damage at Check Out. It is also my job to note what kind of cleaning occurred and, in absence of an incontinent aninmal and a totally bereft owner, normal usage, pet accidents, can be washed out of carpets, all dander etc too, if the cleaner knows what they are doing and have the right equipment. Yes, some discolouration may be left in carpets, that is up to the landlord .

As for scratches etc. A good decorator would eliminate them entirely from doors, walls, skirting etc. It is, again, up to the landlord how much they want to spend on this.

And many landlords are happy to have pets. Odd as that might sound on here. I see houses every week with pets from cats and dogs to chickens and even a pig or two!

onthefencesitter · 16/06/2022 16:01

changeornot · 16/06/2022 15:10

Ha.. but its definitely a choice to live in the Barbican???

I highly suspect there may be the odd Bengal or sausage dog hiding?

In plain sight?

I doubt it though. Probably there are people hiding pedigree cats and small caged animals; after all, how are they going to find out unless they search the flat and if you own the flat, the managing agent doesn't generally do that...dogs are pretty obvious and would attract complaining neighbours!

My DH is a director of the management company for our flat and there are lots of complaints about the pet dogs (people not picking up after them)! So I can understand if you are a LL, you don't really want to be held responsible for your tenant's pets.

crosstalk · 16/06/2022 15:58

The trouble for the OP appears to be the extreme allergy, and I'm sympathetic. But I own a small flat with a garden in a block of 6 half owner occupied. I did bar animals from the flat (after 10 years of replacing floors, lawn, vinyl from various chewy monsters) but I can't control what owners or their tenants choose to do.

What OP seems to need is a new solo build with no animals in the vicinity.

As for not allowing tenants with children - never have not done. A couple have had babies in the flat and have moved of their own volition for more space when the third child arrives.

The OP has rather derailed this from the putative bill itself which would mean disgusting landlords who rent out appalling and dangerous flats or houses and don't even abide by the existing rules (gas, electricity checks, fire alarms) and don't respond to failures of boilers, dangerous damp and infestations, water bursts etc should pay back rents.

However who is going to police it? who is going to jump in when someone needs an immediate place when the landlord has wrongfully evicted his tenants? Councils have very little money for inspectors or taking on cases.

slowcookerforone · 16/06/2022 15:52

@changeornot I see your point.

I hated being a LL (the situation was forced upon me due to unexpected death in the family and a contested will).

I wasn't remotely interfering and I lived several hundreds of miles away and didn't even meet one set of tenants (agent handled that bit.)

I felt utterly bullied by one set of tenants, they would constantly be WhatsApping me about things in the middle of the night etc.

I get from their point of view I wasn't resolving issues within 1 working day - but they lived in a beautiful grade 1 listed house - and therefore, yes there wasn't double glazing and yes I wasn't able to put double glazing in for them just because they decided on a Friday night in Dec they wanted that. The rent very much reflected the condition of the house (agents handled the rental and house was fit for rent) but as soon as the tenants moved in they didn't stop demanding things on a almost weekly basis.

Luckily we were able to sell the house and they left.

Maybe you are right, bigger companies are better handled to deal with all aspects and they have maintenance and legal department to deal with everything.
I do think once they have a monopoly in an area (Ashford springs to mind) then that becomes a problem.

dreamingofsun · 16/06/2022 15:51

Once our current tenants move out in our two properties i think we will sell up. Both our properties are well decorated and our tenants pay below market rent (just increased a bit after 4 years of no rises, but still below whats charged in our area). Fed up with all the increasing legislation and it takes for ever to evict bad tenants who dont pay rent and trash places. The reason why LL's are so picky is because they dont want one of those tenants from hell.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 16/06/2022 15:43

Yes- I doth my cap to you- I might rent but I can read. Thank you.

I think you mean doff.

I highly doubt that 30 plus homeowners chose their property because it did not have dogs.

It’s self-selecting: all of us were happy to live in an environment with no pets, whether for noise, cleanliness, allergies. Pet people wouldn’t buy (or rent) there.

I don't think you should have that much power over peoples lives.

Not my rule. I’m not the leaseholder, I’m the LL. If I lived there, I couldn’t have a pet either - not sure why you’re trying to make this into a “nasty landlords” issue. It isn’t and we’re not.

This rule will move towards a culture in the long term, where the landlord's wants are not always paramount and give more autonomy for the tenant to live out their lives as they choose.

It really won’t. The imbalance of power is caused by scarcity of houses. I’d like to see greater protection for tenants but this isn’t it. I cannot remember a time when we were not deluged with scores of applications every time one of our properties became vacant. Why wouldn’t I pick the one least likely to be problematic? (And yes I obviously get it wrong too - as with the lying owner of a brace of dogs!)

Interesting to note- that leaseholds are being banned for houses (not retrospectively) obviously.

Not yet, and not without exceptions - it remains to be seen what they are.

Innocenta · 16/06/2022 15:36

People have severe allergies to so many different things. It isn't possible to eliminate the risk completely because we'd have to remove everything! Unfortunately I think this is one where you'll have to make your own arrangements, OP. I have severe asthma and numerous (including anaphylactic) allergies so I am not downplaying your concern, but I feel like most allergy management does come down to personal responsibility in the end, anyway.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 16/06/2022 15:11

well you just rent a house that didn't have pets in it before then. I mean any house you go to view and potentially could have had a pet in it before anyway with or without this rule.

Swipe left for the next trending thread