Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the renters reform bill is going to kill people with allergies?

335 replies

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:29

Just that really. I know many people will see this as a good thing. I know too that the severity of allergy to pets which means they can kill you is rare. But it does happen. I am that severely allergic. So if landlords can't give a blanket ban then there are no pet-free properties for me to move into.

For those who don't know - antihistamines make no difference and the only way to get all allergens out of the place is to remove all soft furnishings including carpets and underlay. Deep cleaning things does not work. So unless the landlords change all carpets, curtains, sofas etc. in between tenants, then it still has enough allergens to trigger a life-threatening reaction. For me that reaction is asthma and I already see a hospital specialist so there is no further treatment that can be offered. Avoiding allergens is the key advice. I'm really worried that the full implications have not been thought through.

OP posts:
dreamingofsun · 18/06/2022 13:20

petallergysufferer - some of your suggestions would contravene the leasehold of our flat - not having pets; and no hardwood floors on all but the ground floor ones. I think they have both been put in place to keep the block as quiet at possible for the other flatholders. So the leaseholds would all need to be updated and all the flatholders would potentially have to accept more noise, which might not be great for everyone

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 18/06/2022 12:51

I don’t know regionally. I just live in a big university city. He’s looking at first time buyers stuff and has just lost his 6th house to a cash buyer.

IncessantNameChanger · 18/06/2022 10:36

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/06/2022 21:03

That’s not how my ds or dss did it,

They graduated, got job, came home, saved for deposit, and now can’t get anything because of landlords and investors.

But that's not case regionally surely? In Kent my home town was cheap as some places up north. Until the rent cap came in and people moved out of London. Prices first increased due to rent cap, then due to covid exodus from London, now because terrace homes are being converted to bed sits.

If every landlord sold in my town then the void would be filled by Londoners. Everyone has to live somewhere. Not all the renters in London can afford to buy but lots did as it's so much cheaper in comparison.

Petallergysufferer · 18/06/2022 09:56

As OP herself is only interested in renting.

I'd really like you to show me where I said that? For most people, buying is not a choice in our current housing market. It's out of touch to think otherwise.

To whoever said this, I don't get disability benefits and don't think I should. If I avoid allergens, other than some infection related flare ups, increasing my sickness rate and meaning that I can't cook, clean, shop at those times, I live a normal life. That's what life is like when you avoid allergens. Having 2 weeks of the year (estimate of worst case in recent years) unable to do basic things is not reason to claim benefits and I always live in preparation for that (i.e. have enough food in and clean clothes to be able to survive a week without being able to do these things). This does not make me entitled to benefits.

Saying 'ask landlord to change carpets' suggests you are out of touch with the rental market. There is a glut of renters. Why would LL do that for me when they can avoid the cost by renting to someone else?

It sounds like the way forward is something like:


  1. Some but not all properties should be designated pet-free for renters benefit. Not sure what proportion but I guess looking at allergy stats someone clever could work out what might be a reasonably required percentage?

  2. People with pets should not rent those properties

  3. Anyone living in a designated pet-free property should take some civic responsibility and not bring in a pet to that property - they should understand that this is a dangerous and selfish decision. This will be easier if there are more available properties to rent which allow pets.

  4. LL should be encouraged (or required?) to have hard floors in properties

  5. There should be a fund for people with serious allergies to claim for the cost of a deep clean when they move in if they're unable to fund that themselves (don't underestimate how much this would cost and don't confuse this with a normal end of lease clean). This sits alongside disability benefits as will be needed by many people who appropriately aren't entitled to usual disability benefits.

  6. There should be better recognition of what a serious pet allergy actually is - there are a lot of dangerous myths being pedalled on this thread

  7. Generally the housing market needs an overhaul so that those who want to buy can much more easily do so and housing can stop being seen primarily as an investment opportunity - this benefits both pet owners and non-pet owners.

OP posts:
onthefencesitter · 17/06/2022 22:33

dollybird · 17/06/2022 21:36

When we were looking at flats, most of them were no forward chain, and most of those were BTL landlords selling up.

its true, i bought my flat from an ex landlord.Looking at a (bigger) flat now that is being sold by an ex landlord who is being crippled by debt.

But the key thing is we don't have kids and when we bought, we had a pretty average london income and i know professionals who have similar income who have rented but also managed to buy (albeit a few years later). Without these things, we would not have managed to buy with or without increased supply of homes. we have an earnings crisis, not just a housing crisis. But an incredibly number of well paid people and rich people (I have friends whose parents bought flats and houses for them; they are neither investors or BTL landlords, but there are quite a lot of them).

Cosmos123 · 17/06/2022 21:51

Petallergysufferer · 16/06/2022 07:36

Carpet cleaning does not work as I said in the OP.

Look for places without carpet. Or ask landlord to replace carpet.

dollybird · 17/06/2022 21:36

When we were looking at flats, most of them were no forward chain, and most of those were BTL landlords selling up.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/06/2022 21:03

That’s not how my ds or dss did it,

They graduated, got job, came home, saved for deposit, and now can’t get anything because of landlords and investors.

onthefencesitter · 17/06/2022 20:56

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/06/2022 16:56

The problem is that if Landlords sold, where would people rent from

More people would be able to
buy their own house rather than be stuck renting. It would be much better for first time buyers.

The problem is that the model in this country is not graduate, get first job, live with family (or move in with partner's family) and then buy a flat/small house (which is what I did)..the model in this country is graduate, get first job, get flatshare, rent first flat with partner, save for first home with partner, buy first home (preferably house with garden/maisonette big enough for a baby)- so not the cheapest type of property. The latter model means a fair amount of time spent in rental regardless of income levels.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/06/2022 16:56

The problem is that if Landlords sold, where would people rent from

More people would be able to
buy their own house rather than be stuck renting. It would be much better for first time buyers.

changeornot · 17/06/2022 16:15

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 17/06/2022 14:46

@changeornot just interested, who would be your ideal sort of tenant, or is there just no such thing? I can see why all those scenarios are a potential hassle. I have rented before and always wonder whether I come across as a good tenant or potential disaster!

@Alltheleavesaregreen1

I'm not a landlord , but a private renter.

I was trying to illustrate that there is no such thing as perfect tenant.

All the scenarios are all examples I've witnessed, and also heard similar stories landlords have
complained about
on forums such as these and friends that I know that are also landlords etc..

It's too subjective and nearly everyone would/could be at fault.

But that is my point within reason you should not need to be the perfect tenant.

Because who is the perfect tenant?

You do not need to be a perfect home owner to own property, you do need to be a perfect landlord to let property, so you should not need to be a perfect tenant to rent property.

Good enough... should be good enough.

Landlords should stick to the basics. Safe homes, good quality flooring. reasonable rents.
And expect tenants to do the same..

Pays rent on time, and does not deliberately destroy the property. Paying for any real damage through their deposit.

Not wear and tear caused by putting down cheap carpets. Or badly put down flooring. Expecting the cheapest kitchen/bathroom from wickes to last 20 years...
Although landlord should also consider alterations, garden work that may have added value to the property. Length of time they have lived at the property- accidents do happen.

If the unlikely event a tenant does really damage a property -Severe damage fire/ water would be covered by landlords insurance.

Landlords are not employing the tenant. The tenant is paying for a service for the use of their building to live in for private enjoyment of their home.

It really is not the business of the landlord to make decisions on how the tenant chooses to live their life. If they lose their job but can still pay there rent through UC, if they have children, and need to claim UC for childcare. If they want to purchase a cat. How they want to decorate or furnish their flat- it really is no business of the landlord as long as their rent is coming in, on time.

Kennykenkencat · 17/06/2022 15:57

antelopevalley · 16/06/2022 11:27

People need a home, not simply to have a roof over their head provided by an investor.
This is a good policy.
Landlords are running a business. That comes with some challenges like any business. You don't like the laws, then sell up.

The problem is that if Landlords sold, where would people rent from.

I am in rented because I wanted a rental for 1 year whilst between houses.
Where would I go.

Landlords are being driven out of the btl market but not selling. They are turning to short term let’s which just make rents for a family home a lot higher and the landlord gets the money upfront, can get the police to remove anyone who outstays their contract and they can claim tax back from their mortgage interest payments on these type of mortgages.

All legislation brought in by governments to penalise landlords has just ended up penalising the tenants instead.

Kennykenkencat · 17/06/2022 15:41

Dexy007 · 17/06/2022 13:24

OP I’m a landlord. If I don’t want to let to people with pets trust me, I won’t. I’ll reject a pet application on some other basis. It’s a landlord’s market - sad but true. I’m a tenant myself and I’d love a dog but I also know we are more attractive tenants without. So until we buy a place no pooch!

I have been a landlord in the past and I would always say yes to pets (apart from when it went against a lease on a flat)

I have pets and would do a house up with pets in mind. (Good laminate and tiles everywhere and base plates on doors so no scratched wood etc) Usually because it was so hard to find a landlord to say yes to pets they would stay for a few years.
Usually after 1 year my non pet owning tenants would be moving on so I always seemed to have a void period of a couple of weeks-1 month each year.
Never got that in my pet friendly places. Even if pet owner decided to move on I could have the place tenanted then next day.

Alltheleavesaregreen1 · 17/06/2022 14:46

@changeornot just interested, who would be your ideal sort of tenant, or is there just no such thing? I can see why all those scenarios are a potential hassle. I have rented before and always wonder whether I come across as a good tenant or potential disaster!

changeornot · 17/06/2022 13:35

@Dexy007

Third of renters, don't disclose pets ownership.....

Because of LL attitude- this actually makes the OP more unsafe.

What if you knew you would be renting forever..........for the rest of your life......

What makes the status of renting / owning so different?

So you're punishing yourself by not getting a dog and also punishing your tenant- bizarre......

Why don't you sell your rented property and buy your own place.

Dexy007 · 17/06/2022 13:24

OP I’m a landlord. If I don’t want to let to people with pets trust me, I won’t. I’ll reject a pet application on some other basis. It’s a landlord’s market - sad but true. I’m a tenant myself and I’d love a dog but I also know we are more attractive tenants without. So until we buy a place no pooch!

changeornot · 17/06/2022 13:05

dreamingofsun · 17/06/2022 11:53

I think a lot of the rants above that are aimed at landlords should actually be aimed at bad tenants and the legal system that allows them to remain in properties for months with no financial comeback. I would happily allow tenants to decorate my properties if I knew they were going to make a half decent job of it. Once you have had a tenant trash a place it makes you much more wary as you have to fork out loads to put things right.....if you owned a place you would put dust sheets down first to protect carpets and you wouldnt allow your 5 year old to paint (thats what it looked like).

I agree bad decorating is not great- but again that is why (if possible) no carpet is really sensible.

All tenants could cause you problems, consider these 3 common scenarios---

Family with a 4 and 2 year old.....

Family wants to decorate as toddler has grubby fingers and draws on walls. does the job not to your standard
Not great

Professional Couple mid twenties.....
Have high standards, want you to remove the carpet, redecorate, complain about damp but do not open windows to allow circulation and will not use tumble dryer. Complain about simple things that they should do themselves, minor blocked toilet, light bulb change etc...After all the decoration/ adjustments. Want to move out after 7 months. Not happy for people to view the flat. Find they have a cat.
Not great

Couple, mid 50s one has long term disability, the other working (10 years plus) never moves out, looks after property doesn't complain but you feel guilty about putting the rent up to market rates as housing allowance may not cover. No they would find it difficult to find another property
Not great

I don't think you can tell who will ruin your property, or be an annoying tenant.

The truth is that most tenants will cause you some sort of annoyance somewhere down the line.

I think all you can hope for is one that will pay the rent on time....

A kitchen/ bathroom should be replaced every 10/15 years, depending on condition .
I would actually favour european style rents where the tenant can put in their own kitchen/ bathroom.....

Also I stated the reason why a lot of tenants get an enormous bad rep.....

As mentioned earlier by a housing soilicitor....

Standard advice will be for a tenant is to stay past an eviction .....

Apologies this may of changed.. but as I understand it .....The council will not house you if you move before being evicted as you would be intentionally homeless.

Blame the courts for taking so long. Blame the government for not building enough council houses and shouldering the responsibility on to you (private landlords) to house 20% and rising of the UK population. Blame all governments in the past 15 years that millions of mid earners are now blocked from home ownership.

Also, surely if landlords rented to people who could pay the rent and allow part benefits, children, and pets than less people would be forced to declare being homeless in the first place...........So you would less likely have the scenario where you have a tenant not paying rent for months at a time.....

DixonD · 17/06/2022 12:56

RincewindsHat · 16/06/2022 07:53

Even though there can't be a clause specifically banning pets, landlords will be able to pick and choose whether they rent to someone with pets or not, so I don't see much changing to be honest. Some landlords will never allow pets in any case and a change in rent clauses won't affect that.

Well, a prospective tenant can simply not announce the fact they have pets. I wouldn’t. I’d just move them in if it’s not written in the contract.

Thankfully, I’m allowed pets because I own my home. It’s ridiculous that renters are unable to treat the house they live in as a home. They are not second class citizens.

changeornot · 17/06/2022 12:42

antelopevalley · 17/06/2022 12:00

It is very easy to say the place has to be returned to a reasonable condition before leaving.
Although normally tenants want to decorate because landlords are failing to. A lot wait until a new tenancy until they do anything.

Yes agree-

Most landlords will not decorate until you move out- which if you renting for years is frustrating. Punishing long term renters

IMO Landlords should let tenants (or at least give the option) to decorate themselves.....

antelopevalley · 17/06/2022 12:00

It is very easy to say the place has to be returned to a reasonable condition before leaving.
Although normally tenants want to decorate because landlords are failing to. A lot wait until a new tenancy until they do anything.

dreamingofsun · 17/06/2022 11:53

I think a lot of the rants above that are aimed at landlords should actually be aimed at bad tenants and the legal system that allows them to remain in properties for months with no financial comeback. I would happily allow tenants to decorate my properties if I knew they were going to make a half decent job of it. Once you have had a tenant trash a place it makes you much more wary as you have to fork out loads to put things right.....if you owned a place you would put dust sheets down first to protect carpets and you wouldnt allow your 5 year old to paint (thats what it looked like).

changeornot · 17/06/2022 11:49

@MrsDThomas

Third of renters won't tell you about pets anyway........

From what I've seen the "nice" middle class professionals are more likely to do this.

So don't think you can sense this from a tenant.......

As they don't give a stuff about being evicted.... As saving up deposit, or/and know they can move into a flat share, mum and dad etc......

And will also more likely to be super demanding, and leave after a year leaving gaps in your income.

You have to realise as a Landlord:

You own the Capital but when you rent it out you do not own their home.

That is what the tenant is paying for.....

The use of your building, for the use of their home.

Seriously if you cannot allow people the quiet use and enjoyment of their own home, you are entirely unsuited to being a landlord.

Mitigate risk- Provide good quality flooring. Hard if possible. Wool carpet- (no beige please) in sensible colour.

Do not let furnished, unless short term

Professionally deep clean after tenancy, as standard.

Garden, lawn- please do no put concrete/ paving - very poor for the environment.

Shed with lawn mower, garden tools as standard.

You could as a goodwill provide Instructions on what plants are in the garden, bulbs etc and basic instructions on how to maintain a garden.

Some people would never of used a garden before.

thereisonlyoneofme · 17/06/2022 11:35

Having seen the state of my neighbours rented house and garden who have five animals Im with landlords being able to ban animals,when they will have to clear up the place when the tenants leave

onthefencesitter · 17/06/2022 10:26

changeornot · 17/06/2022 09:39

Hi- felt your reply was quite rude and patronising........(hope you don't speak to people accessing your help like this). Who like me (unlike yourself) will be stuck renting forever.

Replying as it really annoys me, that you can ignore the powerless situation, and stresses of renting longterm with a family as "rubbish".
Yes you are right I was given a Section 21 and technically 2 months notice.

However, in effect (as you should know). 2 months notice would not make much difference, as it's nearly impossible to find a property available in 2 months time. Rented properties are advertised as available in 2 weeks or available now. Sorry I could not afford to pay 2 lots of private rent over 2 months.
So I actually had one month to look for a property available at the end (or near enough) at the end of that month.

Also I appreciate this is the legal advice you are giving out--- and it is entirely correct. That if you go pass your notice, the landlord has to follow legal procedures to evict you.

And (correct me if this has changed), as I understand it, the advice from the council was that you MUST not move out at that time, as you would make yourself intentionally homeless, and the council can relinquish their statuary duty to rehouse.

The problem with this approach, is that it is a nuclear option. If I stayed my relationship with my landlord would of broken down, I would NOT of got a reference. Making it nearly impossible (with children and a small amount of top up housing benefit) to find another property, in the given timescale.

I would run the risk of being locked out of private rented accommodation forever.

If I stayed waiting to be evicted, I would definitely of burned all bridges with my landlord.

Sure, the council may of rehoused me in a bed sit and temporary accommodation for several years, and I may or may not be in the long term be in a better position.

But as me and my partner are actually on ok wages, ( but not high enough to buy or even rent without top up benefits) and ( we most likely would of been homeowners if housing hadn't of skyrocketed from 2013). I wasn't willing to put my children through that.

If we are going to have ever increasing house prices, and move to a model where some people will be renting forever, we need to make it more like the european model.
More autonomy for the renter in decoration, having children, pets

This things really matter to people's mental health.

And more long term rental agreements.

If we lose amateur landlords, I think that is great.

Renting out property should be taken seriously.

I agree with amateur landlords being discouraged from entering the sector. We live in north London and in our friendship group, we know a couple where the boyfriend and girlfriend are living together in the boyfriend's flat. Now the girlfriend has bought the flat downstairs (it's a period conversion) and the freehold. So they will be moving into the girlfriend's flat and renting out 2 rooms upstairs (including the lounge, it's a 2 bedroom flat). The boyfriend is keeping one room for himself upstairs (to keep his stuff); he told me that it's because the people who rent the rooms would be lodgers and hence a lot of the new standards around renting (including pet keeping) would not apply! I mean, on one level, it sounds reasonable cos it's his girlfriend's flat and its quite common for a lot of unmarried couples to want their own space away. But I know them and they are talking about babies and they are very much a couple i.e. live together full time. Anyway it doesn't matter what their personal reasons are- the people he rents the room to are going to be lodgers with significantly less rights. They had a little dog in that flat upstairs (boyfriend's flat) but you can bet that the lodgers would not be allowed pets.

changeornot · 17/06/2022 09:39

Lineala · 16/06/2022 16:27

There is no eviction at a months notice, and if this is what happened to you, read up on the law so you can prevent a landlord attempting this. The statutory law is already in place that states a requirement for two months notice. If you choose not to leave which is your right, the ll must apply to court for a possession order and if you still won't leave, a warrant of possession. Claims for costs would also be made and these are fixed at around £400. Peddling your sort of crap doesn't help anyone and is misleading other tenants who may believe you and not realise statutory protections are in place.

In my experience as a housing solicitor of some years, illegal eviction carries such huge penalties, very few dodgy landlords will try it. They're more likely these days to offer you money to leave.

Hi- felt your reply was quite rude and patronising........(hope you don't speak to people accessing your help like this). Who like me (unlike yourself) will be stuck renting forever.

Replying as it really annoys me, that you can ignore the powerless situation, and stresses of renting longterm with a family as "rubbish".
Yes you are right I was given a Section 21 and technically 2 months notice.

However, in effect (as you should know). 2 months notice would not make much difference, as it's nearly impossible to find a property available in 2 months time. Rented properties are advertised as available in 2 weeks or available now. Sorry I could not afford to pay 2 lots of private rent over 2 months.
So I actually had one month to look for a property available at the end (or near enough) at the end of that month.

Also I appreciate this is the legal advice you are giving out--- and it is entirely correct. That if you go pass your notice, the landlord has to follow legal procedures to evict you.

And (correct me if this has changed), as I understand it, the advice from the council was that you MUST not move out at that time, as you would make yourself intentionally homeless, and the council can relinquish their statuary duty to rehouse.

The problem with this approach, is that it is a nuclear option. If I stayed my relationship with my landlord would of broken down, I would NOT of got a reference. Making it nearly impossible (with children and a small amount of top up housing benefit) to find another property, in the given timescale.

I would run the risk of being locked out of private rented accommodation forever.

If I stayed waiting to be evicted, I would definitely of burned all bridges with my landlord.

Sure, the council may of rehoused me in a bed sit and temporary accommodation for several years, and I may or may not be in the long term be in a better position.

But as me and my partner are actually on ok wages, ( but not high enough to buy or even rent without top up benefits) and ( we most likely would of been homeowners if housing hadn't of skyrocketed from 2013). I wasn't willing to put my children through that.

If we are going to have ever increasing house prices, and move to a model where some people will be renting forever, we need to make it more like the european model.
More autonomy for the renter in decoration, having children, pets

This things really matter to people's mental health.

And more long term rental agreements.

If we lose amateur landlords, I think that is great.

Renting out property should be taken seriously.